Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What sports don't distinguish men from women?

132 replies

Manxexile · 15/11/2026 15:35

I didn't want to derail the current thread about a transwoman suing one of the pool organisations for alleged discrimination on grounds of gender recognition, so thought I'd start this thread as I'm particularly interested in how different sporting bodies deal with this issue - and how they view the aspects of fair competition and physical safety.

So far as I can tell the only internationally recognised sport which doesn't appear to distinguish at all between men and women competitors and has them competing on an equal footing (ie open competition as opposed to having entirely separate mixed-sex events) is equestrianism: ie horse jumping and three-day eventing, plus I suppose flat racing and jump racing.

Are there any other open sports?

I had supposed that events like shooting, curling and archery might be open, but the Olympics has separate men's and women's plus mixed events for all three of those

NB1 - I'm a bit surprised that equestrian events are open at all, as I'd have thought that the greater strength of men would be an obvious competitive advantage - but I'm not a horsey event person so what do i know. Men might possibly aso have a strength advantage in archery, but shooting and curling?

NB2 - I see in the pool thread there seems to be some suggestion that if a sport is a "precision" sport, then men cannot have a competitive advantage over women. But i thought - perhaps mistakenly - that it was generally accepted that men had better visual spatial perception than women. Isn't this an inbuilt advantage in any sport involving positioning and 3d (or even 2d) space?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CurlewKate · 16/11/2026 08:11

Octavia64 · 15/11/2026 15:38

not sure if you are talking about professionals or not but marathons are usually open. I used to do triathlons and they were mixed as well.

Events are open-results are gendered.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/11/2026 08:40

Manxexile · 15/11/2026 17:02

Perhaps i haven't made it clear enough - I'm not looking for "mixed" sports at all.

"mixed" sports are those which have a separate mixed category in addition to single sex categories.

I'm looking for sports that only have an open category where men and women compete directly against each other

So an example would be equestrianism, three-day eventing, show jumping and horse racing

Do you know any others? (hint: I don't mean events where men and women happen to compete coincidentally at the same time but in separate sex categories)

Horse racing - mares and fillies receive a weight allowance, or a preferential handicap rating.

So even that doesn’t count as a truly mixed sport at the sex difference between the horses is recognised.

ItalianoSl · 16/11/2026 08:46

Manxexile · 15/11/2026 15:58

Perhaps I didn't express my question very well...

Marathons and triathlons still have separate men's and women's competitons...

Don't they?!?!

Yes. Thank goodness - being last out of 150 is not as bad as last out of 400!
#NotATriathlete #StickToRunning

Shortshriftandlethal · 16/11/2026 09:18

To be able to distinguish one thing from another is to be able to tell things apart; to recognise characteristics which differentiate one thing from another. I don't think anyone is really unable to distinguish men from women, male from female. In some circumstances the differences may matter less though.

Shortshriftandlethal · 16/11/2026 09:20

The main reason we make distinctions between males and females in sports is to provide a platform for females that offers a fair playing field upon which female skill and excellence can be measured, and then rewarded.

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · 16/11/2026 11:59

Interestingly in horse racing, where horses are handicapped by weight, women jockeys have a significant physical advantage over men. It’s because, although no one is stronger that a horse, building strength will benefit all riders and it’s easier for women, having generally smaller frames, to do that without adding excess muscle mass and therefore weight. The only reason there aren’t more women jockeys in the top flight is the inherent sexism in the sport and rides on the best horses being given to men. IIRC one of the reasons for there being more women in the sport now is it used to be much easier to recruit boys and young men who had grown up in relative poverty and were therefore short and slight owing to poor nutrition.

Toddlersarehardwork · 16/11/2026 17:22

In England, artistic swimming (synchronised swimming) is an open sport, except for the mixed duet category which must have 1 male and 1 female swimmer in each duet. In all other categories: figures, solo, duet and teams, males and females compete together, separated, where necessary, by age group.
I compete at national level and have competed against men.
At international level, there are male and female competition categories. At the last Olympics each team could include, for the first time, a maximum of 2 men, however, none of the countries competing chose to include any men.

LakieLady · 16/11/2026 18:12

Motorcycle racing has women competing against men in several of its formats. Women have raced in MotoGP, Superbikes, Supersport, Isle of Man TT and something called "flat track" that they have in the US.

JustAnotherMinionForAMerchantOfDeath · 17/11/2026 15:50

Agility (with dogs) is mixed at all levels.

ItalianoSl · 17/11/2026 16:16

JustAnotherMinionForAMerchantOfDeath · 17/11/2026 15:50

Agility (with dogs) is mixed at all levels.

Is that because the handlers are not being measured on anything that would differ between the sexes? It's a canine rather than human sport, isn't it?

Manxexile · Yesterday 00:25

LakieLady · 16/11/2026 18:12

Motorcycle racing has women competing against men in several of its formats. Women have raced in MotoGP, Superbikes, Supersport, Isle of Man TT and something called "flat track" that they have in the US.

Thanks. Coming from the Isle of Man I'm well aware of women competing on equal terms with men

OP posts:
Manxexile · Yesterday 00:32

Shortshriftandlethal · 16/11/2026 09:20

The main reason we make distinctions between males and females in sports is to provide a platform for females that offers a fair playing field upon which female skill and excellence can be measured, and then rewarded.

Edited

I'm not questioning why we have a separate category for women's sports. To me, as a man, it's obvious why there is a separate category.

What I'm interested in is sports where the governing body has decided it isn't necessary to have a separate category for women.

OP posts:
Manxexile · Yesterday 00:38

tewi · 15/11/2026 21:07

I’m saying that there is no inbuilt advantage.

So are you saying either (1) that men do not have better visual spatial perception than women, or (2) that if if they do, then it provides no advantage in sports that require a perception of 2d or 3d space?

Having played both men and women at pool, snooker and tennis, I'd suggest otherwise.

OP posts:
Manxexile · Yesterday 00:45

My wife is a sculler. Mostly recreational but some low level competition.

She was involved in a discussion with a female NHS physiotherapist who had qualified at out local university.

The physio was of the opinion that the only reason that male athletes were quicker than, and were stronger than, female athletes was because of the "patriarchy".

As a retired NHS manager and having been involved in the commisioning of the physio school at the university on behalf of the NHS I couldn't believe it.

But then. thinking about the NHS and universities...

OP posts:
Manxexile · Yesterday 00:55

Apart from the various "horsey" events the only other mainstream recognised sport seems to be variations on motor racing.

Surprisingly I missed one of my favourite sports - rally driving - and one of the finest exponents in her day was Michele Mouton who was world champion runner up in 1982

And let's not forget Pat Moss, Louise Aitken-Walker and many other female rally aces

OP posts:
Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 08:27

Manxexile · Yesterday 00:32

I'm not questioning why we have a separate category for women's sports. To me, as a man, it's obvious why there is a separate category.

What I'm interested in is sports where the governing body has decided it isn't necessary to have a separate category for women.

It was the words " don't distinguish" which prompted my response. Even if a sport is genuinely mixed sex with no differentiation at all, everyone can still distinguish the men from the women, the girls from the boys. So, it made news when the first female jockey won the Grand National, for example.

oldtiredcyclist · Yesterday 08:51

Manxexile · Yesterday 00:45

My wife is a sculler. Mostly recreational but some low level competition.

She was involved in a discussion with a female NHS physiotherapist who had qualified at out local university.

The physio was of the opinion that the only reason that male athletes were quicker than, and were stronger than, female athletes was because of the "patriarchy".

As a retired NHS manager and having been involved in the commisioning of the physio school at the university on behalf of the NHS I couldn't believe it.

But then. thinking about the NHS and universities...

That is ridiculous, the physiological differences between men and women are huge, even at the elite level.

The difference in times is very obvious.

https://worldrowing.com/athletes/best-times/

Best Times - World Rowing

Discover the Best Times of World Rowing Athletes. Look through the records and statistics of Athletes' Best Times.

https://worldrowing.com/athletes/best-times

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 08:54

Manxexile · Yesterday 00:45

My wife is a sculler. Mostly recreational but some low level competition.

She was involved in a discussion with a female NHS physiotherapist who had qualified at out local university.

The physio was of the opinion that the only reason that male athletes were quicker than, and were stronger than, female athletes was because of the "patriarchy".

As a retired NHS manager and having been involved in the commisioning of the physio school at the university on behalf of the NHS I couldn't believe it.

But then. thinking about the NHS and universities...

A physio not undetstanding the dicfetences between the musclo-skeletal system of men and women is actually quite concerning!

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 09:06

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · 16/11/2026 11:59

Interestingly in horse racing, where horses are handicapped by weight, women jockeys have a significant physical advantage over men. It’s because, although no one is stronger that a horse, building strength will benefit all riders and it’s easier for women, having generally smaller frames, to do that without adding excess muscle mass and therefore weight. The only reason there aren’t more women jockeys in the top flight is the inherent sexism in the sport and rides on the best horses being given to men. IIRC one of the reasons for there being more women in the sport now is it used to be much easier to recruit boys and young men who had grown up in relative poverty and were therefore short and slight owing to poor nutrition.

There's a big problem with eating disorders amongst male jockeys, including anorexia and bulimia as they struggle to 'make weight'.

I'm often struck by how slim and slight sportsmen look in old photos/films - scrawny by today's standards, in fact, so it was probably easier to find male apprentice jockeys who were below the lower average weight for men.

Less so today, so maybe women jockeys are a more attractive prospect because they can be, as HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear says, stronger and healthier at the required weights.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · Yesterday 10:05

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 08:27

It was the words " don't distinguish" which prompted my response. Even if a sport is genuinely mixed sex with no differentiation at all, everyone can still distinguish the men from the women, the girls from the boys. So, it made news when the first female jockey won the Grand National, for example.

Edited

Individuals distinguishing (observing) is not the same as the sport distinguishing (making rules for separate categories). For example sports don't distinguish by race, but people might note the first black winner of Wimbledon or the first Asian to captain a Premier league football team.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:24

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · Yesterday 10:05

Individuals distinguishing (observing) is not the same as the sport distinguishing (making rules for separate categories). For example sports don't distinguish by race, but people might note the first black winner of Wimbledon or the first Asian to captain a Premier league football team.

The use of the word 'distinguishing' was incorrect in the context. To distinguish is to be able to tell one thing apart from another. 'Differentiate' would have been more appropriate.

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:40

Shortshriftandlethal · Yesterday 10:24

The use of the word 'distinguishing' was incorrect in the context. To distinguish is to be able to tell one thing apart from another. 'Differentiate' would have been more appropriate.

Edited

As an ex English teacher I understand how important it can be to find the correct word for what it is you are trying to describe or convey. Words have meanings.

ElizaSchuyler · Yesterday 11:12

Motor Racing. Yes, we have F1 Academy but that is purely a standalone series to try and increase the number of female participants. F1Academy winners generally move onto mixed sex series such as Abbi Pulling in GB3 and Alisha Palmowski going into FRECA.

However on of the biggest disafvantages for women in strength. There is no power steering in the junior formulae which ironically isn't the case in F1. But you have to progress through the junior formulae to get to F1.

There has been a woman Formula E driver and several as rseve/developent drivers so hopefully we will see better representation soon.

SwirlyGates · Yesterday 11:59

Re equestrianism - yes, women compete with men, and often win. But when you look at the figures it's not at all clear that competitions ought to be mixed.

FEI figures published in 2023 show that over the past 10 years, the ratio of female to male rider registrations has swung towards an increase of females – rising from around 56% to 63%. But in contrast, the gap at the top of the sport is widening – particularly in the Olympic disciplines, and especially in showjumping.
Figures show that female athletes represent around a third of ranked riders in showjumping, but that in the top 100 this falls to 16%, and 6% in the top 30. Eventing has a wider disparity overall but is more balanced at the top, as females make up 72% of the overall rankings and 53% of the top 30.

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/how-to-keep-boys-riding-and-why-the-gender-gap-widens-at-the-top-in-horse-sport-859394

Or from Horse Network:

Equestrian is the only Olympic sport where men and women compete on equal footing. But you’d never know it from the show jumping world rankings.
Only one female rider, Meredith Michaels-Beerbaum, has ever reached the elusive world number 1 spot—and that was over 20 years ago in 2004.

Basically, girls way outnumber boys as riders, whether casual or competitive, but as you move up the ranks the boys win more. It's not clear why - I've seen sponsorship, family responsibilities and other reasons put forward, but I don't think anyone knows.

Jessica-Kürten-2P7JPPM.jpg

How to keep boys riding and why the gender gap widens at the top in horse sport

Equestrianism leads the way for gender parity in sport – but even though men and women compete on equal terms, pockets of imbalance remain within the industry. Discussion on equity in equestrian sport

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/how-to-keep-boys-riding-and-why-the-gender-gap-widens-at-the-top-in-horse-sport-859394

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · Yesterday 12:21

@SwirlyGates that is really interesting (and a bit depressing!). A showjumper I follow on YouTube made the point recently that a horse she bought that had been produced by a man (and produced well and carefully) was used to responding to much stronger aids than how she likes to ride, so I wonder if strength does play a part in showjumping more than in other disciplines? And weight is much less of a problem within reason because the horses are so much bigger and more mature than flat racehorses.

Swipe left for the next trending thread