It’s great to see this happening from the WRN and others.
Long post to try and answer a few questions!
I have campaigned for years to:
retain the door gaps in non domestic toilet provision for health and safety. That’s it.
In design terms this means toilets should be single sex leading out on to a single sex environment. You can do that in several ways. You can have a longer walkway to the toilets that doesn’t need a door, or you can have a washroom door.
You can’t have a toilet opening on to a mixed sex area or a toilet opening on to an arbitrary single sex open area overlooked by the opposite sex because no one is comfortable with this - the designs will go private.
The rules, regulations and legislation in schools are particularly complex because they change to which country you are in in the U.K., but mainly they are exempt from certain legislation like the HS&W at work 1992. It means designers have had ‘free rein’ and architects have been justifying their designs by saying they are great because they are ‘gender-neutral’. There is no regulated design that is gender-neutral. The DfE justified a 5mm gap as standard because of privacy due to boys voyeurism and mobile phones, which is an understandable but they can’t provide me with any evidence risk assessments were ever done to justify the reduction in safety. As yet no one has ever done this properly (except me) to my knowledge.
My campaign started in schools as I am an ex-teacher and could see what was going on in design.
The only regulated design that is allowed to permit men and women is the universal design. It has to have the sink and dryer in and be floor to ceiling in privacy.
Unfortunately universal designs with female pictograms and then universal designs with male pictograms would satisfy much of the regulation and legislation in most places.
The universal design is the ‘sophisticated’ design the Good Law Project wanted in their KTSiE with the only material difference it having a unisex pictogram on the door and sanitary bins in all rooms.
What is the issue, ours are all mixed sex but are open to the corridors. This helps prevent bullying and vandalism in the toilets. They have been a vast improvement since they changed them at our school.
How do you know it prevents it? You can’t see it. I know it doesn’t in general due to the research I have done.
What are the risks of completely private toilets? Regulations do state that you have to be able to unlock doors from the outside and have doors that open outwards or be taken off so you can reach a child that has collapsed against a door. That should give a heads-up. This means boys open up the toilets on girls who can’t see what’s happening, but at worst children have died in these private designs undetected. CPR can’t be done successfully as it’s too late. For the families of children who have medical conditions, it’s really worrying.
There are also sexual assaults and rapes in British schools that go undetected. It is incredibly hard to get figures but from various sources an estimate is 3-5 rapes a week. Where are these happening? I certainly didn’t know this was going on. Looking at Everyone’s Invited the disabled toilet (the original private mixed sex toilet) and store cupboards feature.
In society it’s the disabled toilet, unisex toilets and toilets that are private in design that are targeted for sex. Manufacturers say as much, marketing smart alarms that activate on ‘help me’ or ‘stop it’ to school gender neutral designs (with or without sinks).
This is what Approved Document T (2024) says about what non domestic toilets can lead out to. It is for England and it’s easy to look up. I believe that, since schools are open to public groups, their toilets should be told to conform to Approved Document T too :
1.22 The layout when entering, exiting and using a toilet room or cubicle should cater for the safety, privacy and dignity of users. Cubicle doors should only open into single-sex toilet accommodation.
You shouldn’t have universal toilets in enclosed spaces as that’s doubling the enclosing.
For the lobby within lobbies this should be avoided for safety reasons:
2.8 Universal toilets and single-sex toilet accommodation should open onto a well-lit corridor or circulation space. Direct sight lines from a corridor to the WC and washbasin should be avoided, while reducing the number of lobbies where possible (as this restricts access).
One thing that is useful to bear in mind are definitions. Facilities means the washbasin too. ‘Convenience’ is the toilet.
For Approved Document T
Toilet facilities: Sanitary accommodation that
contains water-closets (WCs) and/or urinals, along with washbasins and hand-drying facilities.
It’s complicated by historical reasons that many older buildings weren’t even build with toilets, then workplaces just added toilets for men. But what really has caused new problems is ‘gender neutrality’.
This is why FWS was so monumental for toilet provision. It’s brought this all out to focus.