I've actually written a few reviews over the last few months which I haven't got round to sharing. Here's one of them,, though it's rather long
Here Where We Live is Our Country by Molly Crabapple
I have heard of the Bund from Jewish socialist friends here in London, and was intrigued by the title of this book and the story of a revolutionary socialist movement, fighting for Jewish workers’ rights, opposing repression and antisemitism from the last Tsars to freedom and dignity in the places where they lived from the end of the 19th century until after the Second World War. The Bund opposed the Tsarist regime and subsequent repressive governments across the region, across borders which frequently changed over more than 50 years. The Bund was a movement in a region of the Russian Empire/Eastern Europe which included Belarus, parts of Ukraine, Poland, Lithuania and other countries. They counterposed a concept of “hereness” to Zionism, of fighting for Jewish people’s rights where they lived rather than a separate Jewish homeland elsewhere.
There is a great deal of tragedy in this story, as many of the Bund were imprisoned and persecuted by their governments even before the Nazis came to power in Germany and then occupied so much of Europe. And then came the Holocaust. But this is also a story of ongoing resistance, of defiance and courage.
Here Where We Live is not an easy read because of the content, but it is beautifully written, with real passion.
Molly Crabapple is an artist and each chapter starts with a black and white illustration of the people/events she writes about. However, the book doesn’t include a list of illustration credits and I would have liked more of an explanation of the pictures - are these drawings by Molly Crabapple? Are her sketches based on older drawings or photographs?
The Bund was an explicitly an organisation of anti Zionist Jews, people who wanted to build a better society where they were where they are, and this book is very critical of Zionism past and present, and of governments who supported Israel rather than the rights of Jewish people to live in Europe or to emigrate to other parts of the world. Molly Crabapple supports Palestinian rights and draws parallels between persecution of Jews in the Russian Empire, Poland, Lithuania and other countries, and current events in Gaza, Israel and the West Bank. I am sure this will be controversial for some people but the stories in this book also offer an important perspective on twentieth century Jewish history (including the Holocaust).
While this is very much a history book for general readers rather than an academic tome, it is also based on extensive research and would be useful to students of Eastern European, Jewish and socialist history, and readers with family origins in this part of the world. There are lots of endnotes and there is also a detailed index, which could also be helpful for forgetful readers who need some help keeping track of the large number of people whose stories are told in these pages.
A definite bold in MN 50 bookers speak for me, and a 5* read, this doesn't mean it's perfect but that I'm really excited about having read it.