Please or to access all these features

30 days only

AIBU not to let my son’s father meet our 6 year old son

357 replies

BeWaryBeaker · 08/11/2026 21:33

I have a six year old son. His father and I were never in a relationship; we knew each other casually and slept together a few times. We always used protection, but the last time, he removed it without my consent. I wasn’t happy about it, but I didn’t want to argue, so I cut contact completely.

About a month later, I found out I was pregnant. I initially planned to have an abortion, but I couldn’t go through with it and became attached to the pregnancy.
Before I found out I was pregnant, I’d bought a three bedroom house in a fairly nice area of Surrey, commutable to London because of work. My parents helped me with the deposit because they were fed up with me living in house shares and complaining about my two housemates! I’d been saving, but their help made it possible. I have a good job and salary, and at 35 I can support my son without help from his father. I earn around £140k.I’m now in a relationship. We’ve been together for two years but haven’t moved in together yet; we hope to in the future. He doesn’t have children.

I never removed my son’s father from Facebook, but we’d had no contact for years. After I changed my profile picture to one of me and my son for his birthday, his father messaged to ask if the child in the picture was mine. My son looks very much like him. I didn’t reply at first, but then he called. I confirmed that it was my son and told him I didn’t want him involved in our lives. I feel we’ve managed perfectly well as the two of us, and I don’t want someone who broke my trust back in my life.

He asked what would happen if our son wanted to know about him. I said we’ve talked about it and will talk more when he’s older. I’m struggling to know what to do. Should I consider letting his father make contact, or am I right to keep that door closed for now. My son and I are very happy, he has positive male figures in his life, I have 4 brothers, they have children, one has a son a few weeks older than my son and they’re very close. He has a community, his father hurt me and I don’t know how I feel about it. I forgot he even existed I got used to being a single mother it’s all I’ve ever known.

OP posts:
Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:00

Read the changes to the children's act that came into effect October 2025 and you'll find that you are wrong
The 'would be lawyers' on this forum is staggering! And the confidence that they know what they are talking about is frightening!

Interpreting the law to fit one's narrative is a very dangerous activity.

Happyjoe · 09/11/2026 10:01

Sorry @BeWaryBeaker for some of the shitty posters and comments. You sound strong and totally on the ball so I hope none of those will get you down.

Good luck with the fight and hope you will be ok. MN hugs.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 10:01

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:56

I think the new laws state that if there was any form of abuse to the mother that mean they are a danger to the child. Abuse isn't just one thing.

I can’t speak for other people here, but I have been basing my responses on realistic expectations, not what is right and wrong. Of course in real life, an abusive man is a danger, it’s just that historically courts have not recognised this fact. Also, abuse and for some reason especially r*pe have been very hard to convict. So courts basically just shrug their shoulders, say “the child seems fine” (even where there is significant evidence of trauma in the child) and grant full, unsupervised access.

So I have been assuming the court would grant access. But given your update I think you would have a very strong case. Let him take you to family court, and then present your defence. He may even go to prison in these circumstances.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 10:03

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:54

That information about a record being available with an admission wasn't available at the time I wrote my post.

But I still don't believe this would be enough reason for the law to order no contact with the child in this case.

Read the new rules because it is

cupfinalchaos · 09/11/2026 10:05

70sgal · 08/11/2026 22:05

I don’t think any child would want a relationship with a rapist.

That’s for them to decide.

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 10:05

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 10:01

I can’t speak for other people here, but I have been basing my responses on realistic expectations, not what is right and wrong. Of course in real life, an abusive man is a danger, it’s just that historically courts have not recognised this fact. Also, abuse and for some reason especially r*pe have been very hard to convict. So courts basically just shrug their shoulders, say “the child seems fine” (even where there is significant evidence of trauma in the child) and grant full, unsupervised access.

So I have been assuming the court would grant access. But given your update I think you would have a very strong case. Let him take you to family court, and then present your defence. He may even go to prison in these circumstances.

Yeah that is a shame. We will have to see how it goes, he hasn't yet said he will get legal advice but my father worked in family law for many years and I have had other legal advice since he got in contact. Only saving grace is that I did keep the text messages and did seek support when it happened. Based on the text messages he sent me that I did not respond to he could be doing worse to others. My son has had 6 years without him even my dad said he won't really make a difference in his life, sending me an aggressive message 6 years later doesn't really show a nice man anyway.

OP posts:
cupfinalchaos · 09/11/2026 10:07

Themaghag · 08/11/2026 22:16

No child should ever be forced to have any relationship with a man who raped his mother.

No one should be forced to do anything but knowing who your parent is I believe a fundamental right.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 10:07

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:51

I wasn't saying it isn't legally rape, I was asked my opinion what I thought the line should be and I gave it.

The law is what it is.

Unless you have another account, you weren’t asked. I was speaking to someone else. And you said “finding out he took off a condom is sexual assault” - it is not, it is r*pe. Saying “in my opinion it should be classed as sexual assault”, would be giving your opinion.

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 10:07

cupfinalchaos · 09/11/2026 10:05

That’s for them to decide.

He is 6, he doesn't understand what that is and I will not be explaining what stealthing is.

Anyway he has offered money, I don't want his money, we are fine, I have said he can put it in a savings account for him. If he wants to support him he can do that or go to court and we will see how that goes.

OP posts:
Happyjoe · 09/11/2026 10:07

cupfinalchaos · 09/11/2026 10:05

That’s for them to decide.

Not while they are young children it's not and certainly not when dad is a rapist.

Hellohelga · 09/11/2026 10:08

Mulledjuice · 08/11/2026 21:50

I'm curious as to how your house in Surrey and £140k income is relevant.

That she’s financially independent and doesn’t need support from him.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:08

I think the new laws state that if there was any form of abuse to the mother that mean they are a danger to the child. Abuse isn't just one thing
No it doesn't! Firstly, the law is not yet being enacted.

Secondly, what it means is that the abuse towards the mother has to be CONSIDERED as a POTENTIAL risk to the child.

It is not the significant change to family law that women think it is. Judges always had a duty to consider the welfare of the children. The difference now is that proven abuse towards the mother will have more weight in assessing risks to the children. The principle that children's needs is the most important factor remains at the forefront.

The law is not a mean for mothers who don't want the biological parent as part of their child life to take control of the outcome as some posters think it applies here.

In OPs instance, if the father went to court and requested a DNA, it would be granted.

If he proves he was the biological father and requested PR, it would be granted unless he was accused of such a serious crime, it would be deemed a danger for them to face PR.

If he requested contact, it would almost inevitably be granted, unless cafcass assessed, through evidence, that he was a danger to the child.

Of course, it would be a very gradual introduction.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 10:09

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 10:05

Yeah that is a shame. We will have to see how it goes, he hasn't yet said he will get legal advice but my father worked in family law for many years and I have had other legal advice since he got in contact. Only saving grace is that I did keep the text messages and did seek support when it happened. Based on the text messages he sent me that I did not respond to he could be doing worse to others. My son has had 6 years without him even my dad said he won't really make a difference in his life, sending me an aggressive message 6 years later doesn't really show a nice man anyway.

I would absolutely contact women’s aid. Good luck OP. You’re in an extraordinarily difficult and complicated position, but you sound like you have good support and a strong case.

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 10:14

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:08

I think the new laws state that if there was any form of abuse to the mother that mean they are a danger to the child. Abuse isn't just one thing
No it doesn't! Firstly, the law is not yet being enacted.

Secondly, what it means is that the abuse towards the mother has to be CONSIDERED as a POTENTIAL risk to the child.

It is not the significant change to family law that women think it is. Judges always had a duty to consider the welfare of the children. The difference now is that proven abuse towards the mother will have more weight in assessing risks to the children. The principle that children's needs is the most important factor remains at the forefront.

The law is not a mean for mothers who don't want the biological parent as part of their child life to take control of the outcome as some posters think it applies here.

In OPs instance, if the father went to court and requested a DNA, it would be granted.

If he proves he was the biological father and requested PR, it would be granted unless he was accused of such a serious crime, it would be deemed a danger for them to face PR.

If he requested contact, it would almost inevitably be granted, unless cafcass assessed, through evidence, that he was a danger to the child.

Of course, it would be a very gradual introduction.

He messed up there by sending me an aggressive message 6 years later. He isn't going to add much to his son's life anyway and I count aggressive messages as abuse plus text messages from 6 years ago weren't very nice either. He hasn't changed.

My dad who worked in the legal field for 40 years said if he requested access right now he wouldn't get it anyway. I have a case, we will have to see how it goes but anyone silly enough to admit to what they did over text message and laugh about it, isn't really going to think ahead, I doubt he has even had legal advice since he got in contact.

OP posts:
slugjelly · 09/11/2026 10:16

I never understand why people amplify and reply to the annoying voices on threads like these— the troll like people who just want to quibble immovable facts and usually want to blame the OP.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:25

My son has had 6 years without him even my dad said he won't really make a difference in his life, sending me an aggressive message 6 years later doesn't
Your father isn't biased at all!

The court will see that you didn't file a case at the time nor any time in the 6 years.

The court will see that you never made any attempts to inform him that he was a father, hence denying him that chance.

If your father has any genuine experience of the law, he would tell you that solicitors fight on both side, so however much would try to make a case that his act (to be proven) means he would be a danger to your son, you can bet that his solicitors will fight just as hard to evidence that you tried to prevent your child from developing a strong relationship with an outstanding man because it suited you not to have a father in his life. For a starter, they could say that if you cared about your child's best interest, you would have applied for child maintenance.

SaySomethingMan · 09/11/2026 10:28

@BeWaryBeaker ignore everyone asking why you didn’t take the MAF pill blah blah. What’s that going to help with now? He isnt a trustworthy person. You sound like you have a brilliant family around you and your boy is in good hands.
Sure children need to know both parents but what is the point of introducing him to a person who will only cause him harm, potentially ? He’s not a good role model for your son.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:30

He messed up there by sending me an aggressive message 6 years later. He isn't going to add much to his son's life anyway and I count aggressive messages as abuse plus text messages from 6 years ago weren't very nice either. He hasn't changed
You are so naive OP if this is what you believe and you'll have a shock to the system if he decides to proceed with a court application.

A message that expresses anger because you've denied him knowledge of his fatherhood is going to more in his favour than yours.

How do you know he won't add much to his life? You don't know what person he is now. Such statement will strengthen his case that you just don't want him in his son's life because it doesn't suit you.

And no, an aggressive email does not count as abuse, much less than purposely withdrawing knowledge of parenthood.

Good luck, you're going to need it.

SaySomethingMan · 09/11/2026 10:30

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:25

My son has had 6 years without him even my dad said he won't really make a difference in his life, sending me an aggressive message 6 years later doesn't
Your father isn't biased at all!

The court will see that you didn't file a case at the time nor any time in the 6 years.

The court will see that you never made any attempts to inform him that he was a father, hence denying him that chance.

If your father has any genuine experience of the law, he would tell you that solicitors fight on both side, so however much would try to make a case that his act (to be proven) means he would be a danger to your son, you can bet that his solicitors will fight just as hard to evidence that you tried to prevent your child from developing a strong relationship with an outstanding man because it suited you not to have a father in his life. For a starter, they could say that if you cared about your child's best interest, you would have applied for child maintenance.

Why would someone on higher than the combined income of many households not care about their son’s best interest because they didn’t apply for maintenance?!

3peassuit · 09/11/2026 10:31

The man’s a rapist. Why should a woman let her rapist into her life?

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:32

My dad who worked in the legal field for 40 years said if he requested access right now he wouldn't get it anyway
I treating you say worked in the field rather than saying he's a solicitor or judge. He is either isn't he? Because a legally trained person would never make such a statement in these circumstances, unless he is just trying to reassure you.

Mulledjuice · 09/11/2026 10:33

Keepingthingsinteresting · 08/11/2026 23:02

Are you curious, or just being unpleasant piece of work?

She is showing she has made a good life for herself and her son and he is not losing out by not having the rapist in his life. Does that satisfy your curiosity? 🙄

yes I was curious. I found them jarringly specific given the heart of the matter.
"we have no need for financial support from him" would have been sufficient. I was suspicious, like others, that this type of detail reads like AI.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 10:33

Why would someone on higher than the combined income of many households not care about their son’s best interest because they didn’t apply for maintenance?!
Because that's what THE CHILD is entitled too, and even if OP could meet his needs without it, it's money that could have been saved in a trust for him.

So it is not in his best interest to deny what he is entitled to and would benefit him.

hypnovic · 09/11/2026 10:38

What he did was rape.
You owe him nothing
If he wants contact he can persue it via the court system

Mulledjuice · 09/11/2026 10:43

BeWaryBeaker · 08/11/2026 23:02

More so to say that I’ve done it on my own for 6 years apart from the help with the house deposit. I’ve looked after my son on my own I’m used to that I don’t need his help. He’s offered to pay I’ve said no he can just put it in a savings account for him if he’d like to. Of course it would have been nice for my son to have a father.

I can absolutely understand how you would feel conflicted about this. Realistically your son is going to ask about his father as he grows up. You won't be able to avoid the conversation. There will come a time when you cant control your son's contact with this man. You will have feelings about it.
I agree with PP that it sounds as though you have a bit more working through to do on this one. I can imagine it's frustrating to think he needs to take up any more airtime in your life.