Please or to access all these features

30 days only

AIBU not to let my son’s father meet our 6 year old son

357 replies

BeWaryBeaker · 08/11/2026 21:33

I have a six year old son. His father and I were never in a relationship; we knew each other casually and slept together a few times. We always used protection, but the last time, he removed it without my consent. I wasn’t happy about it, but I didn’t want to argue, so I cut contact completely.

About a month later, I found out I was pregnant. I initially planned to have an abortion, but I couldn’t go through with it and became attached to the pregnancy.
Before I found out I was pregnant, I’d bought a three bedroom house in a fairly nice area of Surrey, commutable to London because of work. My parents helped me with the deposit because they were fed up with me living in house shares and complaining about my two housemates! I’d been saving, but their help made it possible. I have a good job and salary, and at 35 I can support my son without help from his father. I earn around £140k.I’m now in a relationship. We’ve been together for two years but haven’t moved in together yet; we hope to in the future. He doesn’t have children.

I never removed my son’s father from Facebook, but we’d had no contact for years. After I changed my profile picture to one of me and my son for his birthday, his father messaged to ask if the child in the picture was mine. My son looks very much like him. I didn’t reply at first, but then he called. I confirmed that it was my son and told him I didn’t want him involved in our lives. I feel we’ve managed perfectly well as the two of us, and I don’t want someone who broke my trust back in my life.

He asked what would happen if our son wanted to know about him. I said we’ve talked about it and will talk more when he’s older. I’m struggling to know what to do. Should I consider letting his father make contact, or am I right to keep that door closed for now. My son and I are very happy, he has positive male figures in his life, I have 4 brothers, they have children, one has a son a few weeks older than my son and they’re very close. He has a community, his father hurt me and I don’t know how I feel about it. I forgot he even existed I got used to being a single mother it’s all I’ve ever known.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:40

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:35

Yes, I agree, but they will also look at when I initially reported the rape to SARC and others, along with all the information and evidence that has been retained from that time to support victims. This isn't something I've suddenly decided because he has got back in contact. I actually have messages from him being incredibly blasé about what happened, which was one of the reasons I cut contact with him in the first place. 6/7 years isn't a long time ago, I still have access to our contact and him even saying in messages what he did, he admitted to it face to face and text, its not really my word against him, its just what he did but I am not interested in pursuing it further unless he wants to.

I don't know whether he has a history of treating other women this way or doing worse but I would imagine most would take a very dim view of a man who has committed rape, I wouldn't personally want my son near a man who did raped me and was so blasé about it just because it wasn't aggressive doesn't mean Its not rape. Ultimately, though, we'll have to see how things unfold. My father was a family lawyer so at least I have that background to draw on. I've also sought legal advice somewhere else since he got in contact and will see how it goes.

Well that changes things if you have written evidence.

Yes you could now hold that over him to make him go away.

Your son still has a right to know his father and you need to consider very carefully what will happen if they contact each other when he is older.

I'm very sorry this happened to you, it is a bad situation to find yourself in.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 09:43

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:50

Which rules are these?

The children act 1989 was updated and came into effect October 2025. The new rules removed the presumption of contact and recognised that abuse against the mother is considered child abuse and that the ongoing harm towards the mother by having to have contact wither rapist or abuser must be considered as ongoing harm to the children.

Its taken decades of campaigning and so much harm to women and children but we finally got the law changed

C8H10N4O2 · 09/11/2026 09:43

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:37

I have not disputed the law and I'm frankly astonished by anyone who doesn't feel that forced penetration against your will at the time is different than penetration you find out later you would not have wanted, just as there is a difference between giving someone a black eye and smashing their eye socket to pieces.

So non consensual forms of penetration are not rape because there were not enough bruises??

I'm astonished that you don't see how non consential impregnation is rape not just something you have second thoughts about later.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 09:44

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:35

Yes, I agree, but they will also look at when I initially reported the rape to SARC and others, along with all the information and evidence that has been retained from that time to support victims. This isn't something I've suddenly decided because he has got back in contact. I actually have messages from him being incredibly blasé about what happened, which was one of the reasons I cut contact with him in the first place. 6/7 years isn't a long time ago, I still have access to our contact and him even saying in messages what he did, he admitted to it face to face and text, its not really my word against him, its just what he did but I am not interested in pursuing it further unless he wants to.

I don't know whether he has a history of treating other women this way or doing worse but I would imagine most would take a very dim view of a man who has committed rape, I wouldn't personally want my son near a man who did raped me and was so blasé about it just because it wasn't aggressive doesn't mean Its not rape. Ultimately, though, we'll have to see how things unfold. My father was a family lawyer so at least I have that background to draw on. I've also sought legal advice somewhere else since he got in contact and will see how it goes.

You could definitely threaten him with pressing charges, if you have his own admittance on record. Maybe that would be enough to make him back off. And as I said before, I wouldn’t be facilitating contact until there was a court order forcing me to do so. The “unreasonable” argument that may apply to a mother in a similar situation (having never told the father) wouldn’t apply to you I wouldn’t have thought as you did in fact have a good reason for not wanting to have contact with him.

Contact women’s aid as they can advocate for you in court and that would help your case too.

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:46

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:17

There don't seem to be any separate statistics for this form of rape but the convictions reported have all been of men who admitted what they had done. Unless the OP has some form of evidence she needs to be very careful of accusing a man of raping her.

It has to be unprovable, not untrue, for him to accuse her of libel or defamation.

Luckily, I have texts from the of him admitting to stealthing, because 'it feels better', I did not respond to those texts because he couldn't comprehend why I was annoyed. He said so himself over text.

I did get support the next day, and that's what the charities are for and lots of them keep evidence for you, till you need it or want to report. Its not just one word against the other, its also not just text messages that is evidence. He did contact my friend at the time to ask her why I was upset and won't respond and even went on a rant to her about the situation and 'only taking the condom off'. He wouldn't really be a good role model for my son anyway, I don't know if he has done that to other women since me or even other women before me.

You can go on to say its my responsibility etc, contraception etc, this is someone I trusted, I learnt my lesson anyway.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:47

C8H10N4O2 · 09/11/2026 09:43

So non consensual forms of penetration are not rape because there were not enough bruises??

I'm astonished that you don't see how non consential impregnation is rape not just something you have second thoughts about later.

I might agree with you if pregnancy was not an everyday result of consensual sex with a condom as the only method of contraception. Yes, it's against her will to increase the risks so dramatically, but it's not introducing a risk that wasn't there at all when a woman consents to penetration.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 09/11/2026 09:49

PenelopeFlipFlop · 08/11/2026 23:30

I can't believe how many people are blaming you for being raped!

Between this thread, the ones about Russell Brand being a convicted rapist and the one about Noel Fielding joking about rape it's been an enlightening few days regarding how some women unfortunately choose to think about this topic.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 09:49

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:10

You draw the line at whether there was agreement for that one man to penetrate you at that time.

Finding out it was someone else is rape. Finding out he had HIV is assault, potentially ABH or GBH if infected by him, and in the past might have been attempted murder. Finding out he took off a condom is a sexual assault.

I'm puzzled that women don't think there is a huge difference between being penetrated against your will at the moment of penetration and finding out later that you would have refused if you had known other information.

If finding other information retrospectively turns consensual sex into rape, then where is the line drawn about what information passes that threshold?

And I think if these sort of events are going to be rolled into the "reported rape" statistics it will affect the way rape is viewed.

If the information was not present at the time of the consent, then informed consent was not present was it? This is the point which is recognised by law. You can disagree that this should be the law, but you can’t say “it’s not r*pe” because legally it is.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:49

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:46

Luckily, I have texts from the of him admitting to stealthing, because 'it feels better', I did not respond to those texts because he couldn't comprehend why I was annoyed. He said so himself over text.

I did get support the next day, and that's what the charities are for and lots of them keep evidence for you, till you need it or want to report. Its not just one word against the other, its also not just text messages that is evidence. He did contact my friend at the time to ask her why I was upset and won't respond and even went on a rant to her about the situation and 'only taking the condom off'. He wouldn't really be a good role model for my son anyway, I don't know if he has done that to other women since me or even other women before me.

You can go on to say its my responsibility etc, contraception etc, this is someone I trusted, I learnt my lesson anyway.

I'm pleased for you you've got everything on record. I hope you can find some way through this it must be a nightmare for you.

LongDarkTeatime · 09/11/2026 09:50

No advise. Just wanted to comment on how strong you sound @BeWaryBeaker
After your experience with the father, to have built a strong and healthy life for you and your son, good on you!
Whatever you decide, remember you are doing from a strong foundation which you have built for yourself.

FaceIt · 09/11/2026 09:51

Sorry but your DS has absolutely every right to know who his father is.

I don’t think there’s any question about that unless he’s a completely unsavoury character/criminal etc.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 09:51

No we don't and neither does the law
Wrong! One falls under criminal acts, the other under family law.

Whether he would be convicted of rape (and ultimately, why hasn't he yet?), and whether this would mean he wouldn't be entitled to contact with his child is two different matters.

The latter is ONLY concerned with the best interests of the child. The criminal act, which would need to be evidenced, which alone is far from a given, does not in itself ascertains that this man would be a danger to the child.

The world doesn't just revolve around the rights and needs of women. The rights and needs of children will ALWAYS come first in court.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:51

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 09:49

If the information was not present at the time of the consent, then informed consent was not present was it? This is the point which is recognised by law. You can disagree that this should be the law, but you can’t say “it’s not r*pe” because legally it is.

I wasn't saying it isn't legally rape, I was asked my opinion what I thought the line should be and I gave it.

The law is what it is.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 09:51

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:57

On what basis do you think he will fail a risk assessment for custody of a 6 year old child?

Domestic violence against a mother is abuse of the children who exist at the time. It cannot be abuse against a child who doesn't yet exist. He has not abused any children.

He has been convicted of nothing. His mother is extremely unlikely to be able to get the CPS to prosecute in a case with no witnesses where she was not using a backup contraceptive (knowing that condoms can and do fail) and where she chose to keep the child and then voluntarily put his face on the internet under her name.

And even if she did, he isn't a paedophile, in company with a huge number of men he prefers naked sex and selfishly chose to take that without permission. He's no danger to a 6 year old boy who has a right to know his father, however painful his mother finds that.

She's in a right bind, but she needs to do what's right for that boy and for her future relationship with him.

Read the changes to the children's act that came into effect October 2025 and you'll find that you are wrong.
The op has both temperainious records and texts that document the rape so the cps would be hard pressed to explain why they wouldn't go forward with a rape prosecution.
Also family crt is a civil crt so its a lower threshold of proof than the criminal crt and she has more than enough evidence to prove rape in the family crt. Oh and conception by rape is specifically mentioned in the update as a reason to deny all contact

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 09:52

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:46

Luckily, I have texts from the of him admitting to stealthing, because 'it feels better', I did not respond to those texts because he couldn't comprehend why I was annoyed. He said so himself over text.

I did get support the next day, and that's what the charities are for and lots of them keep evidence for you, till you need it or want to report. Its not just one word against the other, its also not just text messages that is evidence. He did contact my friend at the time to ask her why I was upset and won't respond and even went on a rant to her about the situation and 'only taking the condom off'. He wouldn't really be a good role model for my son anyway, I don't know if he has done that to other women since me or even other women before me.

You can go on to say its my responsibility etc, contraception etc, this is someone I trusted, I learnt my lesson anyway.

You agreed to a particular form of contraception and he took that away without informing you. That is not your fault. You should be able to trust that the agreed protection is in place and you should not have to use a separate form of contraception on the basis that your partner can’t be trusted.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:54

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 09:51

Read the changes to the children's act that came into effect October 2025 and you'll find that you are wrong.
The op has both temperainious records and texts that document the rape so the cps would be hard pressed to explain why they wouldn't go forward with a rape prosecution.
Also family crt is a civil crt so its a lower threshold of proof than the criminal crt and she has more than enough evidence to prove rape in the family crt. Oh and conception by rape is specifically mentioned in the update as a reason to deny all contact

That information about a record being available with an admission wasn't available at the time I wrote my post.

But I still don't believe this would be enough reason for the law to order no contact with the child in this case.

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:55

FaceIt · 09/11/2026 09:51

Sorry but your DS has absolutely every right to know who his father is.

I don’t think there’s any question about that unless he’s a completely unsavoury character/criminal etc.

I mean I did not consent to what he did, I told him even at the time even when I noticed so I don't think that is a man that should be around my son. All I wanted was a 'you know what I am sorry' not a 'its feels better that way' 'not even a, sorry I should have asked you' I don't know if he has done that to other women before me or after me, or even worse.

OP posts:
squarecrow · 09/11/2026 09:55

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 09:51

Read the changes to the children's act that came into effect October 2025 and you'll find that you are wrong.
The op has both temperainious records and texts that document the rape so the cps would be hard pressed to explain why they wouldn't go forward with a rape prosecution.
Also family crt is a civil crt so its a lower threshold of proof than the criminal crt and she has more than enough evidence to prove rape in the family crt. Oh and conception by rape is specifically mentioned in the update as a reason to deny all contact

Now that OP has said she has multiple messages from the time, I am a lot more hopeful that this will be enforced.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 09:55

The OP is under no obligation to foster anything with a man who behaved in such a way and then fucked off and has shown no interest in her since. Not really the great role model we want for our sons
So should all mothers who tricked a man into become a father see their parental right removed? Does this act automatically make them a dangerous parent!

He didn't fuck off! OP terminated the relationship (rightly so) and never told him about the pregnancy. She took this entitlement from him and her son for her own interests.

Parents don't have to be good role models in the eye of the law!

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 09/11/2026 09:55

FaceIt · 09/11/2026 09:51

Sorry but your DS has absolutely every right to know who his father is.

I don’t think there’s any question about that unless he’s a completely unsavoury character/criminal etc.

I tend to view people who rape as being quite unsavoury characters, don't you?

BeWaryBeaker · 09/11/2026 09:56

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 09:51

No we don't and neither does the law
Wrong! One falls under criminal acts, the other under family law.

Whether he would be convicted of rape (and ultimately, why hasn't he yet?), and whether this would mean he wouldn't be entitled to contact with his child is two different matters.

The latter is ONLY concerned with the best interests of the child. The criminal act, which would need to be evidenced, which alone is far from a given, does not in itself ascertains that this man would be a danger to the child.

The world doesn't just revolve around the rights and needs of women. The rights and needs of children will ALWAYS come first in court.

I think the new laws state that if there was any form of abuse to the mother that mean they are a danger to the child. Abuse isn't just one thing.

OP posts:
Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 09:57

And FFS what has these fictional women putting holes in condoms got to do with the OP. I have novwords for how disgraceful your post is. Jog on
Sadly your posts are all emotional drivel. I talk about the law, which ultimately has the final day in these situations. The fact that women don't like family laws it is completely irrelevant.

Momon45 · 09/11/2026 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Happyjoe · 09/11/2026 09:57

FaceIt · 09/11/2026 09:51

Sorry but your DS has absolutely every right to know who his father is.

I don’t think there’s any question about that unless he’s a completely unsavoury character/criminal etc.

It may be wise to read the OP's posts.
Would you class rape as unsavoury character? Rape criminal?

Happyjoe · 09/11/2026 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OMG !!

Honestly, lost for words that you wrote that.