Please or to access all these features

30 days only

I’ve changed my mind about Lindsay Clancy, anyone else?

51 replies

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 16:56

Awhile ago I posted a Thread about Lindsay Clancy and I was defending her. I have, however, changed my mind a little. To me, the crime was so horrific and (I thought) rare. Then I learnt that 50-59% of filicide cases (where a parent kills their own kid) are committed by women. This is frankly startling, but it raised a few questions for me:

  • Is Lindsay Clancy really the exception to these other women who have been prosecuted for their crimes?
  • Granted, she had mental health problems, but don’t most people (men and women) who are in the prison system?
  • What is going on to make so many women resort to this?
  • Would the sympathy for her case be the same if she was a man experiencing mental health issues or anyone other than an attractive white middles class woman?
Interested to know what others think.
OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 09/11/2026 09:26

PurpleBrocadePeacock · 09/11/2026 05:30

I think you are correct to question if PPP and PPD tells the whole story in this case but imho the DA used her mental health history against her and failed to investigate properly. This means the first trial as presented by the prosecution does not hang together in a satisfying way and is causing polarising views as the evidence isn’t fitting the narrative.

Here’s one example, the prosecution initially charged her with an offence related to endangering children due to drug use. In the initial weeks of the trial, they brought forth several witnesses to testify she was addicted to her psych meds. Only the toxicology for her on the night had no alcohol, illegal drugs or toxic doses of her prescribed drugs in her system. So where did the drug charge come from? Was it because she appeared so out of it when first responders attended that paramedics administered narcan?

Note: this charge was quietly dropped by the time sentencing came round, but if they got this so obviously wrong after three years what else have they got wrong?

That’s interesting. I didn’t know that. I agree the trial left me with more questions than answers. The prosecution introduced selfies taken from a hospital room in the week prior to the killings. This could either point to Clancy not being in the right state of mind or show that she did have awareness (which they argued). It was surprising to me to see Clancy do this as try to figure out what her intention was. And Patrick seemed really shocked to see the selfies.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page