Please or to access all these features

30 days only

I’ve changed my mind about Lindsay Clancy, anyone else?

51 replies

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 16:56

Awhile ago I posted a Thread about Lindsay Clancy and I was defending her. I have, however, changed my mind a little. To me, the crime was so horrific and (I thought) rare. Then I learnt that 50-59% of filicide cases (where a parent kills their own kid) are committed by women. This is frankly startling, but it raised a few questions for me:

  • Is Lindsay Clancy really the exception to these other women who have been prosecuted for their crimes?
  • Granted, she had mental health problems, but don’t most people (men and women) who are in the prison system?
  • What is going on to make so many women resort to this?
  • Would the sympathy for her case be the same if she was a man experiencing mental health issues or anyone other than an attractive white middles class woman?
Interested to know what others think.
OP posts:
Keanuwilldo · 08/11/2026 20:02

Apotofrealcoffee · 08/11/2026 19:46

Can it really be postpartum psychosis when the baby is 8 months old?

Absolutely yes.

Sugargliderwombat · 08/11/2026 20:03

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:01

If I’m correct, PPP can officially last until the first two years after giving birth. Not sure it can be classed as PPO after that.

It leads to longer term issues. For example, a schizophrenia or BPD diagnosis, even in cases where there were no prior mental health issues.

MommaMia26 · 08/11/2026 20:04

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 19:35

Benoit had significant brain damage from his career as a wrestler. No, it’s not the same as postpartum psychosis but both will make you act out of character. He was successful in killing himself.

If we say Clancy definitely had postpartum psychosis then I think we would need to review all women and men committed of similar acts to see if they too had some brain condition.

I don’t really understand your point. If Benoit hadn’t died by suicide after killing his partner and child then his defense team would definitely have brought up his traumatic brain injury at trial.
There would almost certainly have been expert testimony about the extent of his brain injury and the impact it had on his mental capacity when the crimes were committed (just like in the Lindsay Clancy case).

There are plenty of other cases where people have claimed to be not guilty by reason of insanity (or claimed diminished responsibility etc).

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:06

MommaMia26 · 08/11/2026 20:04

I don’t really understand your point. If Benoit hadn’t died by suicide after killing his partner and child then his defense team would definitely have brought up his traumatic brain injury at trial.
There would almost certainly have been expert testimony about the extent of his brain injury and the impact it had on his mental capacity when the crimes were committed (just like in the Lindsay Clancy case).

There are plenty of other cases where people have claimed to be not guilty by reason of insanity (or claimed diminished responsibility etc).

Perhaps, but do think he would’ve got the same support? I’m not sure. The same way I’m not sure an African American woman would have gained the same support (most of Clancy’s support seemed to come from white middle class women like herself). There’s many cases where women suffering from mental illness have killed their children, but not received the same support.

OP posts:
Jk987 · 08/11/2026 20:11

I don’t it’s a case of whether she had post partum psychosis or not, I don’t think she did it full stop. I think Patrick did. There are far too many inconsistencies and a totally inadequate investigation.

I followed the case closely and I assumed she was guilty but my has been changed completely.

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:13

Jk987 · 08/11/2026 20:11

I don’t it’s a case of whether she had post partum psychosis or not, I don’t think she did it full stop. I think Patrick did. There are far too many inconsistencies and a totally inadequate investigation.

I followed the case closely and I assumed she was guilty but my has been changed completely.

I think there is inconsistencies but I certainly think she did it. I haven’t seen any convincing evidence to say that she didn’t. Plus she seemed quite controlling over her children (or at least that’s how I interpreted it).

OP posts:
ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:21

Stats on filicide are stacked against women because far more children (especially if SN) spend time alone with their mothers, more than with fathers, and there are far more single parents who are mothers. Funnily enough men’s rights activists rarely like this being pointed out to them because it doesn’t fit their creepy agenda.

Mothers are also the only ones who can have postpartum psychosis. Which these men also don’t like.

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:24

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:13

I think there is inconsistencies but I certainly think she did it. I haven’t seen any convincing evidence to say that she didn’t. Plus she seemed quite controlling over her children (or at least that’s how I interpreted it).

My interpretation was that she was basically a single parent with a disengaged husband who had zero interest in his children. A scenario that kinda makes you have to take control.

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:26

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:21

Stats on filicide are stacked against women because far more children (especially if SN) spend time alone with their mothers, more than with fathers, and there are far more single parents who are mothers. Funnily enough men’s rights activists rarely like this being pointed out to them because it doesn’t fit their creepy agenda.

Mothers are also the only ones who can have postpartum psychosis. Which these men also don’t like.

I did look up documented reasons why mothers commit filicide and, you’re right, postpartum depression does account for some of it, but there is still neglect/abuse, general depressive disorders (not just PPP), unwanted pregnancy, poverty, and doing it as an act of control. I was actually expecting the numbers to be much lower, so it was shocking to me to see that women worldwide account for 50-59% of perpetrators. It is worldwide, so it would be interesting to compare countries with fewer single mothers and those with higher rates to see if there is a difference.

OP posts:
Strangerthanfictions · 08/11/2026 20:30

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 19:27

Hang on, my initial thread was in defence of Lindsay Clancy. If you don’t like the Threads I start you don’t have to read them or participate.

Edited

But don't object to them or voice disagreement? It seems a lot like you are saying only comment if you agree with me

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:31

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:24

My interpretation was that she was basically a single parent with a disengaged husband who had zero interest in his children. A scenario that kinda makes you have to take control.

Well I kinda got that vibe from comments that were made about her spiralling just before she returned to work each time after she had a child. I know it’s not uncommon for mothers to feel anxious once their MAT leave ends, but her mental state seemed especially troubling. Like she felt like she needed to be there for her children. This is just speculation, but it felt like perhaps she didn’t want to live and didn’t think her children could live without her (which can be a motive in these cases). It just made me think slightly differently.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:31

Strangerthanfictions · 08/11/2026 20:30

But don't object to them or voice disagreement? It seems a lot like you are saying only comment if you agree with me

Where have I done that on this Thread? I’m happily having a conversation with people. I find comments like yours strange.

OP posts:
ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:37

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:26

I did look up documented reasons why mothers commit filicide and, you’re right, postpartum depression does account for some of it, but there is still neglect/abuse, general depressive disorders (not just PPP), unwanted pregnancy, poverty, and doing it as an act of control. I was actually expecting the numbers to be much lower, so it was shocking to me to see that women worldwide account for 50-59% of perpetrators. It is worldwide, so it would be interesting to compare countries with fewer single mothers and those with higher rates to see if there is a difference.

So look for those stats instead of starting dramatic posts with skewed stats on a forum created for mothers.

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:40

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:37

So look for those stats instead of starting dramatic posts with skewed stats on a forum created for mothers.

It’s not skewed stats at all. You’re the one who mentioned the rate of single motherhood and its connection to filicide so I assumed you had the stats on it? Clancy was in a relationship though.

OP posts:
ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:45

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:40

It’s not skewed stats at all. You’re the one who mentioned the rate of single motherhood and its connection to filicide so I assumed you had the stats on it? Clancy was in a relationship though.

They are skewed because they’re not adjusted to take into account the very high number of children alone with their mothers as opposed to alone with fathers.

Men and women kill for very different reasons, not that that excuses it, but patterns of violent behaviour are far more unlikely in women than men. So presenting stats like this as a bald statement is lacking a very important part of the story. But you know that.

KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:46

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:37

So look for those stats instead of starting dramatic posts with skewed stats on a forum created for mothers.

There isn’t any reasonable data to suggest a link (yet). So that’s speculation. I just looked it up.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 08/11/2026 20:47

ErmWhatNow · 08/11/2026 20:45

They are skewed because they’re not adjusted to take into account the very high number of children alone with their mothers as opposed to alone with fathers.

Men and women kill for very different reasons, not that that excuses it, but patterns of violent behaviour are far more unlikely in women than men. So presenting stats like this as a bald statement is lacking a very important part of the story. But you know that.

And I’ve just commented that I looked it up and data is limited, so that’s speculation at the moment. There’s no reliable data that shows single mothers are much more likely to commit filicide.

OP posts:
Horses7 · 08/11/2026 21:29

I don’t know much about this case but I know of one colleague (40 years ago) and one friend (20 years ago) who both had PPP and it was absolutely horrifying.
As the name suggests it’s not a bit (or even a lot) of post natal depression - it turns perfectly mild, ‘normal’ women into women capable of anything.
Fortunately both were still in hospital as it began immediately after the birth of their babies and they were moved to facilities where they could get the help they needed.

Icecreamisthebest · 08/11/2026 21:56

I think its more likely that all the other women who also killed their children also had some kind of mental illness that was undiagnosed than that Clancy is the exception

KellyK2026 · 09/11/2026 04:07

Icecreamisthebest · 08/11/2026 21:56

I think its more likely that all the other women who also killed their children also had some kind of mental illness that was undiagnosed than that Clancy is the exception

Well I agree, and it’s been proven that the vast majority of both men and women in the prison system have some form of mental illness. But the line of when that mitigates responsibility isn’t clear.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 09/11/2026 04:33

St0rmF0rce · 08/11/2026 19:39

I just want to make sure that anyone who might get drawn into a debate with you thinking you want a genuine discussion is aware that this thread is just part of your wider agenda.

FYI your post has been deleted by MN. Perhaps have a think about whether you’re the right person to be telling people what they can and can’t post on MN because clearly MN doesn’t agree with you.

OP posts:
SpinelessBastardsAll · 09/11/2026 04:59

So if she didnt do it, does she think she did? Wouldnt she be protesting her innocence to anyone who would listen?

PurpleBrocadePeacock · 09/11/2026 05:30

I think you are correct to question if PPP and PPD tells the whole story in this case but imho the DA used her mental health history against her and failed to investigate properly. This means the first trial as presented by the prosecution does not hang together in a satisfying way and is causing polarising views as the evidence isn’t fitting the narrative.

Here’s one example, the prosecution initially charged her with an offence related to endangering children due to drug use. In the initial weeks of the trial, they brought forth several witnesses to testify she was addicted to her psych meds. Only the toxicology for her on the night had no alcohol, illegal drugs or toxic doses of her prescribed drugs in her system. So where did the drug charge come from? Was it because she appeared so out of it when first responders attended that paramedics administered narcan?

Note: this charge was quietly dropped by the time sentencing came round, but if they got this so obviously wrong after three years what else have they got wrong?

Lhori · 09/11/2026 05:58

When I looked up the figures for the UK, most filicide is carried out by men. In the rare cases where mothers kill their children, there is usually a history of mental illness.

KellyK2026 · 09/11/2026 09:20

Lhori · 09/11/2026 05:58

When I looked up the figures for the UK, most filicide is carried out by men. In the rare cases where mothers kill their children, there is usually a history of mental illness.

in the UK about 57% of filicide is carried out by men. Worldwide about 50-59% is carried out by the mother. Since this isn’t a UK case, I went with the worldwide stats. Either way it’s an almost 50/50 split.

OP posts: