Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Anyone else get annoyed by the phrase ‘not all men, but always a man’?

398 replies

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:15

I’ve seen countless comments saying ‘not all men, but always a man’ underneath news articles and videos detailing a murder, child abuse, stalking or rape case. I guess what annoys me about it is that none of these crimes are just committed by men. If they were, then fair enough.
Over the last week I’ve seen an article about a woman who sexually assaulted a male taxi driver after groping his genitals and exposing herself (the comments were not kind to the man and he was called ‘gay’ for rejecting her, many of which were wrote by women). I’ve seen several articles about women who have killed or harmed young children. I’ve seen two news articles on female teachers who sexually abused/raped their male students, etc. I do wonder what sort of message these types of comments send out to young boys (who are being taught that they are the problem) and girls (who are being taught that only men can commit these crimes).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Truinio · 02/11/2026 22:23

Rape is always committed by men OP.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:22

Truinio · 02/11/2026 22:23

Rape is always committed by men OP.

No it’s not and that’s why there have been women convicted of rape

OP posts:
LivelyAquaPoster · 03/11/2026 07:24

Enterthewolves · 02/11/2026 21:15

Merriam Webster is American - nowt to do with British law

We weren't talking about the law here.

But in Britain, a woman can be convicted of rape if she acts as an accomplice. If a woman aids, abets, procures, or assists a man in raping someone else, she can be charged and convicted of rape under joint enterprise.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:25

HobnobsChoice · 02/11/2026 21:14

Just in case anyone else was curious about the link to the Zimbabwe case in 2011 that was given as proof that women are rapists too. I decided to look it up as KellyKs other "evidence" was quite lacking or didn't reflect the claims being made.

Neither did this one. .

The women were charged with indecent assault (as Zimbabwean law didn't allow women to be charged with rape). The charges were dropped after DNA cleared them but two were charged with prostitution. The women had said they were prostitutes and hadn't disposed of the used condoms from the Johns
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-17939542

I did find it two other cases in Zimbabwe where men state that they were raped by women. One in 2015 and one in 2024. I also found that about 22 women a day are raped in Zimbabwe. That's ones reported and recorded by the police. I can't find an equivalent of the British Crime Survey or any self reporting which usually has higher figures.

So not always a man but almost always.

There’s other cases, you know.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:27

BellesAndGraces · 02/11/2026 21:16

The fact you could laugh about any of this is horrendous tbh.

I’ve only read your posts and it’s very apparent that you are failing to respond in full to a lot of the posts you are quoting, probably because you do not have robust answers to support your own position. And before you ask me to point to a specific circumstance, do us both a favour and check your own responses first.

You refused to say whether you would prefer your own daughter to be picked up by a man or a woman because apparently hypotheticals are not helpful. How convenient. I can confidently say that if my DD is stranded, I would rather she get in a car with a woman than a man. That’s not because ALL WOMEN are safe - take Rose West for example - but men are overwhelmingly a more dangerous prospect than women.

Of course Im not going to response to everyone. If people keep regurgitating the same point why would I respond to each person individually? Yet none of you can answer the question of how the phrase benefits either women or men.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:31

MJEBinAthens · 02/11/2026 21:37

As mother of four adult kids (three of which are male) I have always instilled in my kids what is considered to be unacceptable behaviour. All these men who are committing crimes against women were born from (and presumably brought up by) women. Isn’t it our place to try to nip this in the bud?

Do you realistically think mothers can ‘nip this in the bud’? Did you watch the Manosphere
documentary? The one thing all those men had in common was an absent father. It didn’t matter if their mother was great.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:32

Enterthewolves · 02/11/2026 21:28

Nobody on this thread has said that a VERY small percentage of women don’t commit abhorrent crimes, they have said that those crimes are overwhelmingly committed by men and obscuring that is hugely unhelpful to looking to system and societal responses.

Everyone knows that those crimes are committed mostly by men. So the phrase isn’t drawing attention to anything other then falsely implying that women don’t also commit them.

OP posts:
WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:34

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:27

Of course Im not going to response to everyone. If people keep regurgitating the same point why would I respond to each person individually? Yet none of you can answer the question of how the phrase benefits either women or men.

It benefits everyone, except perpetrators and apologists for male violence, because it identifies what the main problem is: male violence. Naming and identifying the problem enables us to begin to tackle it. As I said, it would be fine to make the phrase more accurate by changing it to 'not all men, but 98% of the time it's a man' but despite your purported commitment to facts and victims, you didn't seem keen on this. It does seem that your actual motivation here is to obscure male culpability amd nothing more than that.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:34

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 02/11/2026 22:18

nearly every single women I know have been assaulted by a man, at the very least been cat called or walked home terrified with their keys in their hands worried for their safety, do I know many men who have experienced this on a routine basis. No, I do not. Have I been raped. Yes. Do I know many men who have been no. Are you a bot? Probably.

You don’t know many men who have been sexually assaulted by a woman? I know
plenty.

OP posts:
Emilesgran · 03/11/2026 07:37

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:34

You don’t know many men who have been sexually assaulted by a woman? I know
plenty.

So on the one hand you say that men don’t report sexual assault by women - but on the other hand they all confide in you?
Amazing.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:40

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:34

It benefits everyone, except perpetrators and apologists for male violence, because it identifies what the main problem is: male violence. Naming and identifying the problem enables us to begin to tackle it. As I said, it would be fine to make the phrase more accurate by changing it to 'not all men, but 98% of the time it's a man' but despite your purported commitment to facts and victims, you didn't seem keen on this. It does seem that your actual motivation here is to obscure male culpability amd nothing more than that.

Lots of feminists don’t think it’s a helpful
phrase. Many people belonging to the LGBTQ+ community don’t think it’s a helpful phrase. Almost 80% of violent male committed crime is done by men who grew up with an absent father (that’s a fact). But would you feel comfortable shouting ‘not everyone without a dad, but always someone without a dad?’. Or what about gang violence in the US (since the majority of gangsters are Black, how about ‘not all Black people, but always a Black person’. Does that sit comfortably with you? It wouldn’t with me. Why? Because it’s taking a complex issue and making it about one part of that person. It ignores reality and doesn’t fix anything whilst giving people a false perception that they are doing something new. It’s bizarre and not helpful. Feminism has always been about tackling structural inequalities, not blaming an entire demographic and making themselves seem helpless.

OP posts:
MJEBinAthens · 03/11/2026 07:40

I haven’t seen the documentary… maybe I should.

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:40

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:34

You don’t know many men who have been sexually assaulted by a woman? I know
plenty.

No you don't. Nor can you find a gender-flipped version of the Pelicot case and all the other similar cases now coming to court. There simply are not networks of women online sharing tips on how to rape men and arranging with each other to come and assault one another's husbands. There is not a widespread campus issue of male students fearing to enter sorority houses and being gang-raped by the sisters who high five each other and send text messages advertising their crimes and inviting other girls to join in. When men walk home alone, it's not the threat of female violence that they fear. We know, and you know, the reality of the world we live in. You can't come on forums, piss on women's heads and convince them it's raining. We can see what you're doing and it doesn't work. No one denies the existence of female violence; everyone knows it is overwhelmingly dwarfed by male violence. Not all men, but 98% of the time it's a man.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:41

Emilesgran · 03/11/2026 07:37

So on the one hand you say that men don’t report sexual assault by women - but on the other hand they all confide in you?
Amazing.

Talking to a friend about it isn’t the same as going to the police to report it. I’m surprised I have to explain that.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:43

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:40

No you don't. Nor can you find a gender-flipped version of the Pelicot case and all the other similar cases now coming to court. There simply are not networks of women online sharing tips on how to rape men and arranging with each other to come and assault one another's husbands. There is not a widespread campus issue of male students fearing to enter sorority houses and being gang-raped by the sisters who high five each other and send text messages advertising their crimes and inviting other girls to join in. When men walk home alone, it's not the threat of female violence that they fear. We know, and you know, the reality of the world we live in. You can't come on forums, piss on women's heads and convince them it's raining. We can see what you're doing and it doesn't work. No one denies the existence of female violence; everyone knows it is overwhelmingly dwarfed by male violence. Not all men, but 98% of the time it's a man.

You want the focus to be kept on the UK and its legal definition of rape but now you’re talking about the US college system.

And yes I do know many men who have been sexually assaulted by women, and interestingly you’re exactly proving my point that victims of female perpetrated violence aren’t believed.

OP posts:
WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:47

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:40

Lots of feminists don’t think it’s a helpful
phrase. Many people belonging to the LGBTQ+ community don’t think it’s a helpful phrase. Almost 80% of violent male committed crime is done by men who grew up with an absent father (that’s a fact). But would you feel comfortable shouting ‘not everyone without a dad, but always someone without a dad?’. Or what about gang violence in the US (since the majority of gangsters are Black, how about ‘not all Black people, but always a Black person’. Does that sit comfortably with you? It wouldn’t with me. Why? Because it’s taking a complex issue and making it about one part of that person. It ignores reality and doesn’t fix anything whilst giving people a false perception that they are doing something new. It’s bizarre and not helpful. Feminism has always been about tackling structural inequalities, not blaming an entire demographic and making themselves seem helpless.

Men abandoning families - another problem of male behaviour. I have no problem discussing that.

Race and crime - the US is historically racist just as it is historically misogynistic. So in the case of higher crime stats for the marginalised group that has always been disenfranchised, you do have to take into account the existence of racial bias in the justice system, racist policing and societal disadvantages that people of colour have systemically experienced that can make it more likely that they have factors in their lives that can drive them towards higher rates of offending eg higher rates of poverty and discrimination. Men do not have a history of being marginalised and persecuted and disadvantaged as a group - they are the dominant and powerful group statistically speaking. Therefore we have to analyse higher rates of male offending differently, because the contributing factors arise from dominance not marginalisation. The problem is different, so the analysis and solutions will also be different.

Please don't come into a forum like MN and tell women how to feminist better, thanks!

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:50

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:43

You want the focus to be kept on the UK and its legal definition of rape but now you’re talking about the US college system.

And yes I do know many men who have been sexually assaulted by women, and interestingly you’re exactly proving my point that victims of female perpetrated violence aren’t believed.

I've said nothing about the UK definition of rape and I don't find that part of the conversation interesting. I'm far more interested in wider societal trends and cultural perceptions. I don't care about that particular nitpicking sidetrack into what constitutes rape where because it's yet another technique that posters like you use designed to distract and obfuscate.

I don't disbelieve victims. I do disbelieve posters who come onto forums like this desperate to seed incel and misogynist ideology, and so does everyone else reading.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:52

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:47

Men abandoning families - another problem of male behaviour. I have no problem discussing that.

Race and crime - the US is historically racist just as it is historically misogynistic. So in the case of higher crime stats for the marginalised group that has always been disenfranchised, you do have to take into account the existence of racial bias in the justice system, racist policing and societal disadvantages that people of colour have systemically experienced that can make it more likely that they have factors in their lives that can drive them towards higher rates of offending eg higher rates of poverty and discrimination. Men do not have a history of being marginalised and persecuted and disadvantaged as a group - they are the dominant and powerful group statistically speaking. Therefore we have to analyse higher rates of male offending differently, because the contributing factors arise from dominance not marginalisation. The problem is different, so the analysis and solutions will also be different.

Please don't come into a forum like MN and tell women how to feminist better, thanks!

So you’ll talk about the complexities of race relations in the US (which I agree with) and you even acknowledge that poverty makes males more likely to commit violence (again, I agree with). So how could you possibly think a phrase like ‘AlwaysAMan’ is helpful when you are aware that violent male criminals make up a minority of men and many of them suffer from mental issues and/or have experienced growing up in an unstable environment. The focus should be on prevention, not blaming an entire demographic and making it sound like having a penis is the reason why.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:53

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 07:50

I've said nothing about the UK definition of rape and I don't find that part of the conversation interesting. I'm far more interested in wider societal trends and cultural perceptions. I don't care about that particular nitpicking sidetrack into what constitutes rape where because it's yet another technique that posters like you use designed to distract and obfuscate.

I don't disbelieve victims. I do disbelieve posters who come onto forums like this desperate to seed incel and misogynist ideology, and so does everyone else reading.

Do you believe that I was sexually assaulted by a female? Or is that me being misogynistic?

OP posts:
WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 08:02

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:52

So you’ll talk about the complexities of race relations in the US (which I agree with) and you even acknowledge that poverty makes males more likely to commit violence (again, I agree with). So how could you possibly think a phrase like ‘AlwaysAMan’ is helpful when you are aware that violent male criminals make up a minority of men and many of them suffer from mental issues and/or have experienced growing up in an unstable environment. The focus should be on prevention, not blaming an entire demographic and making it sound like having a penis is the reason why.

Again, dominant group vs marginalised group. That's where the complexities come in, as I explained. I have already conceded we can stop saying AlwaysAMan and start saying 98%ofthetimeitsaman. It's very suspicious that you don't like that one either!

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 08:04

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:53

Do you believe that I was sexually assaulted by a female? Or is that me being misogynistic?

I think I'll keep the discussion on stats, studies, research, information in the public domain, general experience rather than personal except in the case of high-profile incidents that are out there in the court systems and can be subject to public scrutiny. It's not really helpful to the discussion to do otherwise.

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 08:09

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 07:52

So you’ll talk about the complexities of race relations in the US (which I agree with) and you even acknowledge that poverty makes males more likely to commit violence (again, I agree with). So how could you possibly think a phrase like ‘AlwaysAMan’ is helpful when you are aware that violent male criminals make up a minority of men and many of them suffer from mental issues and/or have experienced growing up in an unstable environment. The focus should be on prevention, not blaming an entire demographic and making it sound like having a penis is the reason why.

And just coming back to this, poverty does play a really important role in crime which is why it's interesting to look at cases like the Cornell 7 and Epstein in which power and privilege were such an integral part of the offending. It was being in the powerful group and feeling untouchable that made these men confident that they could abuse their victims. It's another pattern rooted in male dominance, not male victimisation.

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 08:10

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 08:02

Again, dominant group vs marginalised group. That's where the complexities come in, as I explained. I have already conceded we can stop saying AlwaysAMan and start saying 98%ofthetimeitsaman. It's very suspicious that you don't like that one either!

I didn’t say I didn’t like it. But, by the way, bell hooks, Kimberle Crenshaw (prominent intersectional feminists), Judith Butler, etc. are all well known feminists who HATED phrases and arguments that took the complexities out and just saw men as the oppressor. They have argued that man are not a flat universal oppressor and should not be framed as such. Hooks said repeatedly that women are capable of violence through racism, patriarchy and abusive parenting. She is one of many feminists who do not shy away from talking about female perpetrated violence and actually saw it as incredibly important in addressing inequalities. My view is neither incel or anti feminist. I would argue that ‘not all
men, but always a man’ (while catchy on TikTok) is fundamentally anti feminist and even racist. White women have been there alongside men harming marginalised groups. It wasn’t so long along that Black people were lynched because white women knowingly made false allegations against them, and women were right there with the men smiling in the photographs of lynched men and boys.

My stance isn’t actually new at all. It’s been well argued in a lot of feminist literature.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 03/11/2026 08:11

KellyK2026 · 02/11/2026 13:22

Studies show time and again that victims of female perpetrated crime are less likely to report it due to fears of not being taken seriously. So it’s already having huge consequences.

Can you cite the studies?

KellyK2026 · 03/11/2026 08:11

WillowWindWitch · 03/11/2026 08:09

And just coming back to this, poverty does play a really important role in crime which is why it's interesting to look at cases like the Cornell 7 and Epstein in which power and privilege were such an integral part of the offending. It was being in the powerful group and feeling untouchable that made these men confident that they could abuse their victims. It's another pattern rooted in male dominance, not male victimisation.

Interesting, because Virginia Guiffre herself said that Maxwell (a woman) was the brains behind Epstein’s sex trafficking as she was the one who provided the contacts. She also raped Guiffre multiple times.

OP posts: