Please or to access all these features

The royal family

Duke of Sussex & Others vs ANL: thread 6

967 replies

bluegreygreen · 15/08/2026 09:37

This is the sixth thread discussing the case Prince Harry (and 6 others) brought against the Daily Mail (Associated Newspapers Limited; ANL) for alleged unlawful information gathering (UIG).
The claimants were: Prince Harry (PH); Doreen Lawrence (DL); Liz Hurley (EH/LH); Elton John (EJ); David Furnish (DF); Simon Hughes (SH); Sadie Frost (SF). They were represented by David Sherborne (DS).
The defendant (ANL) was represented by Anthony White (AW).

Judgement was handed down by Judge Nicklin on 7th July 2026.
All claims were dismissed.
Links to the summary and full judgement are below.
We are currently awaiting decisions around costs, following the Consequentials hearing on 29-30th July.

The threads to date were thorough discussions of the evidence (so far as we were able to obtain it), with posters giving links and explaining their views.
Following the judgement, we discussed the judgement itself, the reaction, statements made by different parties and ongoing relevant issues.

We have mostly kept things civil by avoiding more general discussion on Royal Family members, which can become partisan, and trying not to be derailed from the main topic of the thread.

We have occasionally included (when things slowed with the title case) other cases or discussions with a specific theme of free speech/press freedom, particularly when related to those with money or power preventing others from speaking.

Links to previous threads
Thread 1
Thread 2
Thread 3
Thread 4
Thread 5

There was limited direct reporting from court after the celebrities gave evidence; what there we followed on this link, which also includes reaction to the judgement
Sky news link to court case

Summary judgement

Full judgement

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
bluegreygreen · 07/11/2026 11:10

This is the report in the DM of the application to appeal - it wasn't one of the main headlines, so I had to search for it.
https://archive.is/i1sZr

As you might expect, it is carefully worded and factual. The only part that is new information is this:
The grounds for their application are unknown. The group has not served Associated Newspapers, the publisher of the Mail, with the papers.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 07/11/2026 14:45

News of the World - Glenn Mulcaire and Andy Coulson convicted
Mirror Group - Graham Johnson convicted
ANL - no evidence of UIG despite the best efforts of unscrupulous individuals

So what it boils down to is 'we expected judge to be on our side and hand down a guilty verdict against ANL despite the lack of evidence, because that has happened against papers before, and he didn't. So he's wrong and we are appealing.'

edited for meaning

MFL · 07/11/2026 17:18

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain That’s about it. There was no evidence, according to Nicklin and he was very clear about that. The issue will be about whether the claimants didn’t need hard evidence to prove the alleged wrongdoing, Hopefully, it was and the leave to appeal request fails.

AgileRobin · 07/11/2026 18:52

KatherineParr · 06/11/2026 20:29

I also wondered whether it was a sign that the insurers wouldn't pay out.

This is an excellent point.

HoldMyWine · 07/11/2026 18:55

I read much of Nicklin’s judgement and thought it was watertight with little that could be appealed on, in summary he said the claimants were unable to provide any evidence of UIG.
Interesting that Simon Hughes has dropped out, though he was discredited in Court. Maybe as a barrister he can see the case has reached the end of the road.
As others have said who will represent them as the original solicitors have gone bust.

BasiliskStare · 07/11/2026 19:30

Is there a way ( those legally literate let me know ) that this could be an appeal against the judgment , not to get it overturned , but to reduce the "indemnity" regarding payments by removing the "unreasonable to a high degree" bit. Ie they still lost but cheaper.
I don't know - just a thought.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · 07/11/2026 19:51

BasiliskStare · 07/11/2026 19:30

Is there a way ( those legally literate let me know ) that this could be an appeal against the judgment , not to get it overturned , but to reduce the "indemnity" regarding payments by removing the "unreasonable to a high degree" bit. Ie they still lost but cheaper.
I don't know - just a thought.

Also ignorant, but also wondering if this could in any way be inspired by the insurance.

E.g. "if permitted appeal, x payout, if appeal succeeds, y payout".

MauveLibrary · 07/11/2026 19:57

BasiliskStare · 07/11/2026 19:30

Is there a way ( those legally literate let me know ) that this could be an appeal against the judgment , not to get it overturned , but to reduce the "indemnity" regarding payments by removing the "unreasonable to a high degree" bit. Ie they still lost but cheaper.
I don't know - just a thought.

That might be the angle they are going for...Judge Nicklin was abundantly clear in his judgement though..the case was so egregiously poor both in terms of lack of evidence and the aggressive conduct of the claimants that he felt indemnity costs were appropriate. The CA judge will place a lot of weight on the Nicklin judgement and they will be reluctant to interfere with or make any judgement to the contrary.

The court can sometimes draw adverse inferences from circumstantial evidence but this is limited to situations in which claimants have provided foundational evidence that would point towards a probability of wrongdoing rather than just a possibility of wrongdoing

The Nicklin judgement made extremely clear that no inferences could be drawn here as there was nil foundational evidence.

The claimants cant argue that Nicklin misapplied the law here. The case was based on pure speculation which fails the appropriate legal threshold.

MFL · 07/11/2026 20:11

The grounds for appeal are limited. Serious error in applying the law is a standard reason or a procedural error. Not liking the judgement isn’t grounds for appeal and the decision to grant an appeal also weighs up likely success. It’s quite difficult to see how they will be granted leave to appeal.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 11:52

I honestly can't remember whedre I reasd this, but hasn't it been said that the claimants are insisting that Nicklin applied the guidelines correctly but too rigorously?

As for the insurance, if they really have refused to pay, isn't it one hell of a risk to rack up even more costs on what appears to be little basis?

Mylovelygreendress · 08/11/2026 11:55

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 11:52

I honestly can't remember whedre I reasd this, but hasn't it been said that the claimants are insisting that Nicklin applied the guidelines correctly but too rigorously?

As for the insurance, if they really have refused to pay, isn't it one hell of a risk to rack up even more costs on what appears to be little basis?

That rings a vague bell with me too but also are they not saying that he ruled in favour of claimants in other cases so is being inconsistent in this case ?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2026 11:58

Mylovelygreendress · 08/11/2026 11:55

That rings a vague bell with me too but also are they not saying that he ruled in favour of claimants in other cases so is being inconsistent in this case ?

Yes, I believe that might have come into it too, Lovely

It suggests they don't understand that each case will be judged on its merits, but mostly it just sounds like another "S'not faaaiiirrr"

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2026 12:01

That rings a vague bell with me too but also are they not saying that he ruled in favour of claimants in other cases so is being inconsistent in this case ?

Yes. They're working on the assumption that all the tabloids were hacking so the trial was pretty much a formality and there should have been a guilty verdict on ANL because there was on the others. Hence their shoddy evidence because who needs evidence when the verdict's a foregone conclusion?

The British judicial system. Another thing PH doesn't understand.

edited for typo

MrsLeonFarrell · 08/11/2026 15:26

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2026 12:01

That rings a vague bell with me too but also are they not saying that he ruled in favour of claimants in other cases so is being inconsistent in this case ?

Yes. They're working on the assumption that all the tabloids were hacking so the trial was pretty much a formality and there should have been a guilty verdict on ANL because there was on the others. Hence their shoddy evidence because who needs evidence when the verdict's a foregone conclusion?

The British judicial system. Another thing PH doesn't understand.

edited for typo

Edited

Why aren't their legal teams refusing to take the case if that is their logic? It seems strange that anyone wants to be part of it.

MFL · 08/11/2026 15:38

@MrsLeonFarrell Because they are instructed and they want the payday? Who’s doing the appeal?

The difference between the cases is evidence. Harry et al didn’t have any on any of the 93 cases they cited. There has to be a serious mistake in applying the law for an appeal to be granted so the claimants are basically saying they don’t need evidence. It’s unlikely to succeed as this seems to be clutching at straws and other cases did have evidence of hacking etc. No evidence was presented to Nicklin.

bluegreygreen · 08/11/2026 15:55

I suspect no-one will be offering their services on a no-win no-fee basis this time.

OP posts:
MrsLeonFarrell · 08/11/2026 16:19

bluegreygreen · 08/11/2026 15:55

I suspect no-one will be offering their services on a no-win no-fee basis this time.

It did seem to be a case of No win No fee and No evidence. Now it seems to be No intention of accepting the loss.

MFL · 08/11/2026 17:02

@MrsLeonFarrell So true! It feels like they are just delaying the inevitable costs.

MrsLeonFarrell · 08/11/2026 17:07

MFL · 08/11/2026 17:02

@MrsLeonFarrell So true! It feels like they are just delaying the inevitable costs.

And of course some don't like being told no!

MFL · 08/11/2026 17:15

@bluegreygreen Both solicitors are still
operating (as listed at the hearing)but THJ certainly filed for bankruptcy. Maybe they were sold? However I agree. I’d be a rhino - charge a lot!

AgileRobin · 08/11/2026 19:32

MFL · 08/11/2026 17:02

@MrsLeonFarrell So true! It feels like they are just delaying the inevitable costs.

Yes. I agree with this. However they are also challenging elements of the judgement (as well as costs) stating that it was legally and factually flawed. Interesting to note that Sheridans (Callum Galbraith) is leading this next round and Sherborne is instructed by Sheridans. No massive change in Solicitors. This is in the public domain. We probably won’t know anything till March. Interesting to note that ANL stated they did not know the basis as they had received no paperwork!

MFL · 08/11/2026 20:00

Yes. Just read up it was Sheridans. They say legally and factually flawed. Nothing else I’ve found. It’s difficult to know if their view of facts is assertions and feelings. Can’t comment on the legally flawed bit but it has to be serious flaws.

bluegreygreen · 08/11/2026 20:24

Please can you link to the sources for your updates, if they're in the public domain?

The only information I have seen was the DM article which said that they had no paperwork. I haven't seen anything about the basis of the claimants' application.

OP posts:
AutumnCrowOfTheBailey · 08/11/2026 20:29

bluegreygreen · 07/11/2026 11:10

This is the report in the DM of the application to appeal - it wasn't one of the main headlines, so I had to search for it.
https://archive.is/i1sZr

As you might expect, it is carefully worded and factual. The only part that is new information is this:
The grounds for their application are unknown. The group has not served Associated Newspapers, the publisher of the Mail, with the papers.

Is this secrecy so we don’t see how crap the claimants’ supposed ‘grounds’ really are? And when their appeal request is refused by CoA they can all pretend it’s Yet Another Whitewash And Establishment Stitch-Up Yah, and carry on faking being dragon-slayers?

Just another stupid PR stunt by rich boys and their hangers-on.

MauveLibrary · 08/11/2026 20:32

I honestly dont see this appeal going anywhere....Nicklin was thorough in his judgement. There was nil evidence presented to the court apart from "feelings"