Please or to access all these features

The royal family

Duke of Sussex & Others vs ANL: thread 6

967 replies

bluegreygreen · 15/08/2026 09:37

This is the sixth thread discussing the case Prince Harry (and 6 others) brought against the Daily Mail (Associated Newspapers Limited; ANL) for alleged unlawful information gathering (UIG).
The claimants were: Prince Harry (PH); Doreen Lawrence (DL); Liz Hurley (EH/LH); Elton John (EJ); David Furnish (DF); Simon Hughes (SH); Sadie Frost (SF). They were represented by David Sherborne (DS).
The defendant (ANL) was represented by Anthony White (AW).

Judgement was handed down by Judge Nicklin on 7th July 2026.
All claims were dismissed.
Links to the summary and full judgement are below.
We are currently awaiting decisions around costs, following the Consequentials hearing on 29-30th July.

The threads to date were thorough discussions of the evidence (so far as we were able to obtain it), with posters giving links and explaining their views.
Following the judgement, we discussed the judgement itself, the reaction, statements made by different parties and ongoing relevant issues.

We have mostly kept things civil by avoiding more general discussion on Royal Family members, which can become partisan, and trying not to be derailed from the main topic of the thread.

We have occasionally included (when things slowed with the title case) other cases or discussions with a specific theme of free speech/press freedom, particularly when related to those with money or power preventing others from speaking.

Links to previous threads
Thread 1
Thread 2
Thread 3
Thread 4
Thread 5

There was limited direct reporting from court after the celebrities gave evidence; what there we followed on this link, which also includes reaction to the judgement
Sky news link to court case

Summary judgement

Full judgement

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Mylovelygreendress · 06/11/2026 18:25

@Serenster and other legal experts , what happens about the costs already incurred before this application? I know they had to make an interim payment but what about the balance ?
Apologies if this has already been covered .

Puzzledandpissedoff · 06/11/2026 18:38

MauveLibrary · 06/11/2026 18:02

Either a Lord or Lady Justice will have a look at the application under 52.6 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Permission to appeal will only be granted if the claimants can evidence that an appeal would have a real prospect of success or there is some other compelling reason involving a novel point of law.

There will be an initial review by the judge entirely based on the paper application and s/he will have a detailed look at the application and the basis on which the claimants are appealing weighed against the Nicklin judgement. The judge then either refuses or grants the application.

If permission is refused they can still ask for a hearing where they present oral arguments. If the judge still chucks the case out then that is the end of the case.

The Supreme Court wont hear an appeal against a refusal of permission to appeal in the CA

Thank you for that excellent explanatrion, MauveLibrary

I suppose all we can hope is that - apart from the possibility of giving "oral evidence" - this really might be the end of it, because frankly it seems about time

Wonder if Harry and Doreen will release any more offensive statements if it doesn't go their way? Confused

Serenster · 06/11/2026 18:41

Mylovelygreendress · 06/11/2026 18:25

@Serenster and other legal experts , what happens about the costs already incurred before this application? I know they had to make an interim payment but what about the balance ?
Apologies if this has already been covered .

Generally the costs discussions will be put to one side while the appeal is being progressed. ANL won’t have to repay the costs paid on an interim basis - although if ultimately the appeal is successful they will.

Mylovelygreendress · 06/11/2026 18:48

Serenster · 06/11/2026 18:41

Generally the costs discussions will be put to one side while the appeal is being progressed. ANL won’t have to repay the costs paid on an interim basis - although if ultimately the appeal is successful they will.

Thank you !

RecoIIectionsMayVary · 06/11/2026 18:59

who's paying

A pertinent question @Puzzledandpissedoff

Unless they think they already owe ruinous amounts so what harm is a bit more.

RecoIIectionsMayVary · 06/11/2026 18:59

When are they (we) likely to hear the decision?

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 19:05

Hello all.

The Sky News page reporting it is here, and is still labelled as 'Breaking', so I haven't archived it: Sky News

One interesting point: anywhere I have looked (Sky, ITV and the Independent so far) hasn't included Simon Hughes' name. The same statement appears to have been given to the outlets I've read.

From Sky:

On Friday, a spokesperson representing him, as well as Baroness Doreen Lawrence, Sir Elton John, David Furnish, Liz Hurley, and Sadie Frost confirmed they would appeal.
Their statement said: "We confirm that the claimants have today filed applications with the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal the judgments of Mr Justice Nicklin in respect of his dismissal of their claims and the indemnity costs order.
"The claimants respectfully disagree with those unprecedented decisions, which they consider to be legally and factually flawed."

OP posts:
MauveLibrary · 06/11/2026 19:23

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 19:05

Hello all.

The Sky News page reporting it is here, and is still labelled as 'Breaking', so I haven't archived it: Sky News

One interesting point: anywhere I have looked (Sky, ITV and the Independent so far) hasn't included Simon Hughes' name. The same statement appears to have been given to the outlets I've read.

From Sky:

On Friday, a spokesperson representing him, as well as Baroness Doreen Lawrence, Sir Elton John, David Furnish, Liz Hurley, and Sadie Frost confirmed they would appeal.
Their statement said: "We confirm that the claimants have today filed applications with the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal the judgments of Mr Justice Nicklin in respect of his dismissal of their claims and the indemnity costs order.
"The claimants respectfully disagree with those unprecedented decisions, which they consider to be legally and factually flawed."

It will be interesting to see what they are basing the appeal on given the meticulous judgement from Nicklin. They are going to have a very hard time persuading the court of appeal that the judgement was flawed or that the judge failed to apply the law correctly.

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 19:25

I agree.

I wonder if Simon Hughes, being a barrister, has realised that there is no basis for appeal and hence has not joined his fellow claimants.

OP posts:
IAmATorturedPoet · 06/11/2026 20:07

What madness.

Is this an indication that the ATE insurance providers have said they aren’t going to be paying out?

It’s highly unlikely they can get any insurance cover going forward on this case (that will require a new policy and further risk assessment to gauge likelihood of success, which it won’t pass) so costs from their own pockets are going to keep on increasing.

I hope the CoA judge sees fit to put it to bed once and for all.

BasiliskStare · 06/11/2026 20:14

Thanks for that transcript @bluegreygreen .

I personally count the ANL case as separate from general H&M PR because there are a lot more facts involved, and it is very specific. I would be very interested to follow the case / request for appeal so if you are up for it , I'd be interested in a thread. But I would understand if you couldn't be bothered - you've done so much with the original case. 💐

I also wonder if Simon Hughes is also thinking discretion is the better part of valour.

AgileRobin · 06/11/2026 20:28

Serenster · 06/11/2026 17:36

Well, that is interesting. Harry, Liz and Elton will need new solicitors I guess given the failure of Thomson Heath - I wonder who is acting for them now?

I have a good idea but obviously it’s not appropriate to say on here until it is in the public domain. I am very surprised: Nicklin is an excellent Judge. Factual and thorough. I also find it somewhat distasteful if not disturbing that one of the claimants acknowledged ANL had done nothing wrong and had a secret meeting in a car park on Christmas Eve. The lawyer for this claimant said she would withdraw the claim for a tidy sum. This does not sit well.

You will know that the bar for an appeal is set very high. I am interested to know the precise grounds of the appeal and any new evidence they may submit, if any. I think however, their argument will rest on what they perceive to be ‘legal & factual’ flaws.

The behaviour during the trial was astounding at times. I guess we will just have to wait and see!

KatherineParr · 06/11/2026 20:29

IAmATorturedPoet · 06/11/2026 20:07

What madness.

Is this an indication that the ATE insurance providers have said they aren’t going to be paying out?

It’s highly unlikely they can get any insurance cover going forward on this case (that will require a new policy and further risk assessment to gauge likelihood of success, which it won’t pass) so costs from their own pockets are going to keep on increasing.

I hope the CoA judge sees fit to put it to bed once and for all.

I also wondered whether it was a sign that the insurers wouldn't pay out.

AutumnCrowOfTheBailey · 06/11/2026 20:51

AgileRobin · 06/11/2026 20:28

I have a good idea but obviously it’s not appropriate to say on here until it is in the public domain. I am very surprised: Nicklin is an excellent Judge. Factual and thorough. I also find it somewhat distasteful if not disturbing that one of the claimants acknowledged ANL had done nothing wrong and had a secret meeting in a car park on Christmas Eve. The lawyer for this claimant said she would withdraw the claim for a tidy sum. This does not sit well.

You will know that the bar for an appeal is set very high. I am interested to know the precise grounds of the appeal and any new evidence they may submit, if any. I think however, their argument will rest on what they perceive to be ‘legal & factual’ flaws.

The behaviour during the trial was astounding at times. I guess we will just have to wait and see!

I am interested to know the precise grounds of the appeal and any new evidence they may submit, if any.

They can’t introduce new evidence now, I understand.

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 20:51

Thanks, @BasiliskStare.

Yes, I'll be happy to start a new thread if we need one.

OP posts:
AutumnCrowOfTheBailey · 06/11/2026 20:55

I’d noticed Simon Hughes was ‘out’ a while ago. The only former barrister, MP and ‘thinker’ among the whole celeb rabble had indicated he would not be appealing.

But the media is saying ‘all’ the claimants are appealing. Laziness from the press?

AgileRobin · 06/11/2026 20:57

AutumnCrowOfTheBailey · 06/11/2026 20:51

I am interested to know the precise grounds of the appeal and any new evidence they may submit, if any.

They can’t introduce new evidence now, I understand.

It’s extremely difficult to do so, agreed, it’s unlikely the claimants would come even close to meeting the criteria, but it’s not entirely impossible. Their focus will be on the applied law.

GwendolineFairfax8 · 06/11/2026 20:59

AI - might be incorrect

The Appeal Challenge: The claimants are arguing that the trial judge's evaluation of the evidence, application of the burden of proof, and treatment of inferences/propensity evidence were legally or factually incorrect.

Inferences (The "Connecting the Dots" Argument)
Bullet What it means: An inference is a logical conclusion drawn from surrounding facts. Because many of the alleged privacy breaches happened years ago, direct, smoking-gun evidence (like an internal memo admitting to hacking a specific phone for a specific story) was often missing. The claimants relied on inferences—arguing that given the secretive nature of the press, the timing of articles, and the publisher's known methods, the court should infer that unlawful methods were used.
Bullet The High Court's Stance: The judge ruled that suspicion and logical inferences cannot bridge an "evidential gap." He found that without direct, article-by-article proof connecting the publisher's conduct to the specific claims, general inferences weren't enough to meet the legal standard.
Why this is part of the appeal:
The claimants' legal team argues that the trial judge erred in law by being far too rigid. They are contending that the judge dismissed valid patterns of behavior and logical inferences, setting an impossibly high evidentiary bar for victims of historic press intrusion who are trying to prove secrets that newspapers actively tried to hide.

AgileRobin · 06/11/2026 21:10

GwendolineFairfax8 · 06/11/2026 20:59

AI - might be incorrect

The Appeal Challenge: The claimants are arguing that the trial judge's evaluation of the evidence, application of the burden of proof, and treatment of inferences/propensity evidence were legally or factually incorrect.

Inferences (The "Connecting the Dots" Argument)
Bullet What it means: An inference is a logical conclusion drawn from surrounding facts. Because many of the alleged privacy breaches happened years ago, direct, smoking-gun evidence (like an internal memo admitting to hacking a specific phone for a specific story) was often missing. The claimants relied on inferences—arguing that given the secretive nature of the press, the timing of articles, and the publisher's known methods, the court should infer that unlawful methods were used.
Bullet The High Court's Stance: The judge ruled that suspicion and logical inferences cannot bridge an "evidential gap." He found that without direct, article-by-article proof connecting the publisher's conduct to the specific claims, general inferences weren't enough to meet the legal standard.
Why this is part of the appeal:
The claimants' legal team argues that the trial judge erred in law by being far too rigid. They are contending that the judge dismissed valid patterns of behavior and logical inferences, setting an impossibly high evidentiary bar for victims of historic press intrusion who are trying to prove secrets that newspapers actively tried to hide.

One of their arguments will most likely centre around the star witness (or not in this case). They will reiterate that they were not solely reliant on the witness and that there is other evidence. Personally I think it’s a high risk manoeuvre and I cannot see how they will succeed. Inference is simply not enough.

BasiliskStare · 06/11/2026 21:14

From what I recall @GwendolineFairfax8 and others ( and no expert me ) - wasn't part of the point (as you explained thank you ) - my layman's terms - ANL weren't found guilty of phone tapping etc. So "inferences / patterns of behaviour " weren't applicable in the same way. The claimants were subject to a higher bar of evidence than against eg NOTW , Mirror etc.

I'll be really interested to see what they have now compared to the case at the time.

Lifestooshort71 · 06/11/2026 21:32

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 20:51

Thanks, @BasiliskStare.

Yes, I'll be happy to start a new thread if we need one.

Thank you @bluegreygreen , this thread has been a pleasure to read with all the well-informed posters and reasoned discussions. A little oasis in a turbulent sandstorm!

GwendolineFairfax8 · 06/11/2026 21:35

As I recall, Sherborne was trying to argue if ANL didn’t unlawfully gather information, ANL must say who did - and was (rightly) told by Judge Nicklin that the burden of proof rested with the complainants.

bluegreygreen · 06/11/2026 21:36

BasiliskStare · 06/11/2026 21:14

From what I recall @GwendolineFairfax8 and others ( and no expert me ) - wasn't part of the point (as you explained thank you ) - my layman's terms - ANL weren't found guilty of phone tapping etc. So "inferences / patterns of behaviour " weren't applicable in the same way. The claimants were subject to a higher bar of evidence than against eg NOTW , Mirror etc.

I'll be really interested to see what they have now compared to the case at the time.

Yes, they had to start from the beginning and make their case, whereas with the other media groups the basic case was already made, and the claimant simply had to show that they were also involved.

OP posts:
GwendolineFairfax8 · 06/11/2026 21:42

News of the World - Glenn Mulcaire and Andy Coulson convicted

Mirror Group - Graham Johnson convicted

ANL - no evidence of UIG despite the best efforts of unscrupulous individuals

Puzzledandpissedoff · 07/11/2026 10:32

I also find it somewhat distasteful if not disturbing that one of the claimants acknowledged ANL had done nothing wrong and had a secret meeting in a car park on Christmas Eve. The lawyer for this claimant said she would withdraw the claim for a tidy sum. This does not sit well

I find that the more Doreen is looked into the less savoury some of her choices become, @AgileRobin, but she's got her secular sainthood now and will doubtless keep using it