Please or to access all these features

The litter tray

Join our community of cat lovers on the Mumsnet Cat forum for kitten advice and help with cat behaviour.

Is pet insurance really worth it?

71 replies

RaspberryBeret1999 · 07/11/2026 21:18

I have two cats, insured since I have had them. I pay approx £90 per month for their insurance, plus I have pet health plan with my vet at £44 per month, so £1600pa in total. I’m actually shocked now I’ve worked this out!

I am in the process of putting in a claim for dental work for my older cat for £700. Looking through my documents, I’ve noticed as he’s over 10 years old, I have an excess of £115 plus 20% of the bill, so I’ll be lucky if I get back £500.

It’s really not worth it, is it?

I am thinking of not renewing and just putting away some money each month, just in case.

OP posts:
needtohotobed · 08/11/2026 23:03

I think yes you should shop around. However, once the animal gets old it’s not worth it as they take off what they will cover.

I had a horse insured with Petplan for nearly 20 years when we needed the insurance they wouldn’t pay and the contact was worthless as the horse was too old. We never claimed once and on the top level to cover everything so that was a rip off spent tens of thousands however I was always worried about falling off / the horse bolting into the road / multi collision etc (the nightmares which never happened).

However, current cat wasn’t insured initially my husband said it wasn’t worth it. The first “illness” within the first 5 months cost £1600 and he prob just had poison from somewhere outside and no broken bones. So now insured with Asda for around £19 per month 🤣 as I would be very worried about vets costs of a broken bone if a tummy problem costs over £1500 for sedation / bloods / scans etc.

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 23:07

Yesreallyitsme · 08/11/2026 12:55

Worth it in my opinion. Our 10 year old cat has always had insurance, and we’ve used it 3 times (twice for cat bites, once for gastro issues). Her gastro issues were this year - in only 4 days of treatment, the bill got to almost £5K. I did have to pay £100 excess and 10%, but it’s a lot better than £5K. Oh, and it turned out to be a hair ball 🫠

£5k for a hairball ?? How?

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 08/11/2026 23:49

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 23:07

£5k for a hairball ?? How?

In days gone by it was five bob for a dose of liquid paraffin - but I'm sure it was £5k well spent.

WaynesWhirled · 09/11/2026 00:01

I’ve never had it- just made sure I have enough accessible cash in case it’s needed. Saved an absolute fortune, thousands of pounds.

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 09/11/2026 03:39

How much something is worth and how much something costs are two different things.

I go to a fairly standard chain vet. I've had some of the procedures/issues listed above and I've paid nowhere near the prices some people are saying they paid for with insurance. My previous cat sustained a cat bite, it was less than £100 at the vet.

I fully agree with the comments about quality of life too. Unfortunately, (and I understand why), some vets are reluctant to have the hard conversations required and there is Very Online Pet Owner mentality that you should do everything possible, which completely overlooks the daily quality of life of the pet themselves.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 09/11/2026 03:41

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 23:07

£5k for a hairball ?? How?

Bad hairballs can cause intestinal obstruction.
Google trichobezoar.

Allergictoironing · 09/11/2026 06:57

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 23:07

£5k for a hairball ?? How?

It was finding out that it was a hairball I'm guessing. If something doesn't present as normal then your mind won't go to that as the problem. Plus how DO you diagnose a hairball? If it doesn't shift with the standard medications then you need to have x-rays done to look for obstructions in the gut & try to work out what they are & where, then if it's really massive and firmly wedged you may have to operate to get it out.

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 09/11/2026 10:10

Yes. My late girls ran up
bills of 30k. Penelope had to go to the emergency vet and was put to sleep on the day her new insurance policy with a new provider started, so she was still in the exclusion period. It cost £700. That the day before would have been covered by insurance!

Leeds157 · 09/11/2026 10:21

Tesco is a lot cheaper and you can upload the invoices yourself on their portal to make a claim, shop around a bit, I’d always say it’s worth it, vet bills are so expensive, a scan, and an overnight stay alone can be in the region of £1k each

Nodirectionhome · 09/11/2026 10:33

Londersand · 07/11/2026 22:59

Petplan keep it low-ish till 10yrs old then they massively hoik it every year as over 10 many insurers won’t take on a new pet. Mine was £20 until just after 10 and now it’s suddenly £66 and I can’t move. Will never go with Petplan again

I had the same with Petplan. My cat was insured with them over 10 years until this September. Never had a claim. The monthly premium jumped from £30 to £68 this year. I knew it would probably double again next year.
So I moved to John Lewis pet insurance. £24 per month for exactly the same cover, excess and the 20% co-payment. I was surprised they would take her on now she is over 10 years old, but so glad they did.

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 09/11/2026 12:19

Leeds157 · 09/11/2026 10:21

Tesco is a lot cheaper and you can upload the invoices yourself on their portal to make a claim, shop around a bit, I’d always say it’s worth it, vet bills are so expensive, a scan, and an overnight stay alone can be in the region of £1k each

I had been with Tesco for 10 years. And liked them. Until Penelope’s premium doubled despite no claims that year. I went with Animal friends.

Yesreallyitsme · 09/11/2026 13:18

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 23:07

£5k for a hairball ?? How?

We didn’t know it was a hairball at first. She got admitted with anorexia after not eating for 3 days. She had blood tests and a scan under sedation, which showed a mass. 3 nights at the vets in total. They wanted to do another specialist scan at the approximate cost of another £5-7k as they assumed cancer or blockage. We said no and bought her home, continued nasal feeding whilst we considered what to do. After a couple of days she pulled out the tube, vommed up a big hairball ball and has been fine ever since.

She never had a hairball before or since, assume she saved up 10 years worth of fur…….

Is pet insurance really worth it?
aodirjjd · 09/11/2026 13:36

Yesreallyitsme · 09/11/2026 13:18

We didn’t know it was a hairball at first. She got admitted with anorexia after not eating for 3 days. She had blood tests and a scan under sedation, which showed a mass. 3 nights at the vets in total. They wanted to do another specialist scan at the approximate cost of another £5-7k as they assumed cancer or blockage. We said no and bought her home, continued nasal feeding whilst we considered what to do. After a couple of days she pulled out the tube, vommed up a big hairball ball and has been fine ever since.

She never had a hairball before or since, assume she saved up 10 years worth of fur…….

Aww her poor little face!

ours had similar at start of year, and I was quite worried as she tends to eat things she shouldn’t. But when I said we didn’t have insurance they told us to try smelly foods, then gave her an anti sickness jab after she still wasn’t eating and then she was ok. I think it was about £150 for two visits, a jab and some cat electrolytes. Maybe yours was presenting as iller than ours but I do wonder if we would have had similar treatment plan/bill as you if we’d said we’d had insurance. Which is what I was getting at with my earlier posts.

our last cat had cancer. Suspected when she started to lose weight and then about 6 months later a suspicious lump appeared. I didn’t really see the point in getting it biopsied/confirmed as she was 13 or so at the time. We just pampered her until it was clear she wasn’t happy anymore then pts.

Yesreallyitsme · 09/11/2026 18:25

@aodirjjdthats interesting- if we ever need the vet again perhaps I will say I have no insurance to see if it changes their care plan! Sorry you lost your cat to cancer, that must be hard - but I’m sure they had a good life being pampered whilst they could.

CatMother2026 · 09/11/2026 20:44

Just posted about tooth resorption which isn't covered by insurance and will cost us around £1000 (!) so from a dental perspective it's not worth it unless paying for highest insurance where this is included. However, in the past we have claimed £3000 for a broken leg for one cat and heart scan in another so it was worth it then. You never know what's around the corner so it depends how much you have in savings I guess!

mondaytosunday · 09/11/2026 21:29

For my two dogs it wasn’t and I stopped after it got to £70/month for one without one claim. I never insured the other one nor do I insure my two cats. My oldest dog had mast cell cancer (£1200) and my younger dog went through a bad day just before she died (£1400). One of the cats needed eye operation for entropion (£1200). All still cheaper than if of been paying 15 years of insurance. (Or five years as the cat was 5 at the time).
But maybe I’ve been lucky? Though my cousin pays £1500/month for her dogs as they’ve needed a few operations. Still, it seems £18,000 a year would cover quite a bit….

CheeseWisely · 09/11/2026 21:32

It was worth it for us when our older cat was on daily medication and monthly blood tests, we paid £50 per month for the policy and they covered 80% of the medication and bloods, nearly £200 per month.

Allergictoironing · 10/11/2026 07:00

I think it depends to a degree on what your general financial status is. If you're a higher earner, have plenty of savings etc then it probably isn't worth it. For a lower income person it's much easier to budget however much per month than find a big lump sum in one go. I wouldn't have been able to afford that big chunk of money for faecal tests, bloods, X-ray, scan, multiple vet visits etc in a month when Tobias was first being diagnosed.

Dozycuntlaters · 10/11/2026 10:37

Completely dependent on whether you can afford a massive vet bill if god forbid something should happen. I can't so both my cats are insured. I use the insurance emporium (was equine and leisure first I think) and it costs me £18 a month for my 12 year old and £13 for my 8 year old.

chathammassive · 10/11/2026 11:02

Londersand · 07/11/2026 22:52

Cat arthritis jabs are just a money making endeavour that lowers the cat’s standard of life if they don’t enjoy being hoiked to a vet in a carrier to be jabbed with a sharp implement once a month. Pretty traumatic for them.

Genuine question, why are you so disparaging about arthritis jabs for cats? My cat has been transformed since having them - she doesn’t limp as significantly and is much more mobile and brighter. I agree about the monthly trip to the vets being distressing, which is why my vet taught me to self administer the jab at home, and issues me with a prescription to source them more cheaply online

elijahm · 10/11/2026 13:11

Ours definitely is. Our old cat got diagnosed with a rare heart condition, spent over £7000 which we got back through insurance. Our new cat has a urinary condition which we would’ve spent £5000 on so far if he hadn’t been insured. My outlook is that if I never claim again i’ll have had my value for money based on those two alone.

However, if your policy doesn’t cover much and your excess is big, then possibly not worth it. I suppose it also depends what treatments you’d be willing to give to your cat (I.e. if the treatment were more expensive would you want to do it anyway?) if they’re older.

May be worth shopping around but then you have to consider that anything pre existing won’t be covered!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page