Please or to access all these features

The litter tray

Join our community of cat lovers on the Mumsnet Cat forum for kitten advice and help with cat behaviour.

Is pet insurance really worth it?

71 replies

RaspberryBeret1999 · 07/11/2026 21:18

I have two cats, insured since I have had them. I pay approx £90 per month for their insurance, plus I have pet health plan with my vet at £44 per month, so £1600pa in total. I’m actually shocked now I’ve worked this out!

I am in the process of putting in a claim for dental work for my older cat for £700. Looking through my documents, I’ve noticed as he’s over 10 years old, I have an excess of £115 plus 20% of the bill, so I’ll be lucky if I get back £500.

It’s really not worth it, is it?

I am thinking of not renewing and just putting away some money each month, just in case.

OP posts:
keepincool · 07/11/2026 22:57

Londersand · 07/11/2026 22:55

Who do you have that insurance with as my 14yr old cat’s plan is £65 a month with Petplan. Every year they hike it without fail. I’ve never claimed

Mines with Animal Friends.

Edited to add that I always shop around each year.

Londersand · 07/11/2026 22:59

RaspberryBeret1999 · 07/11/2026 21:52

Is it worth shopping around? I’m with petplan at the moment.

Petplan keep it low-ish till 10yrs old then they massively hoik it every year as over 10 many insurers won’t take on a new pet. Mine was £20 until just after 10 and now it’s suddenly £66 and I can’t move. Will never go with Petplan again

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 07/11/2026 23:05

I agree with @Grumpyoldpersonwithcats that insurance does seem to encourage treatment options because you can and not because you necessarily should. We were offered chemo for our girl which would have prolonged her life, but not cured her. It would have been incredibly distressing for her to be hauled back and forth to a specialist facility (not our own vet) for weekly infusions, and we opted to let her go gracefully.

On the day of her final appointment I tearfully asked our vet, what would she do if it was her cat, would she do the chemo? She said no, absolutely not. I wonder if it would have even been offered to us if we’d been paying out of pocket.

pinneddownbytabbies · 07/11/2026 23:10

I completely agree with @Grumpyoldpersonwithcats about vets viewing us as cash cows now.

This happened to my friend this week - she took her cat to the vet for a very minor issue, and the vet recommended a raft of blood tests which would have cost hundreds.

Londersand · 07/11/2026 23:10

pinneddownbytabbies · 07/11/2026 23:10

I completely agree with @Grumpyoldpersonwithcats about vets viewing us as cash cows now.

This happened to my friend this week - she took her cat to the vet for a very minor issue, and the vet recommended a raft of blood tests which would have cost hundreds.

Hence the arthritis injections on a monthly basis

Douglasmummy · 07/11/2026 23:24

I've been paying out insurance for my dog but they annoyingly don't cover his teeth as he had a history of gingivitis. The only thing he's had wrong with him is bloody teeth being taken out. It's so annoying but I'm scared of stopping and putting money into a savings account instead. He is insured up to £6k a year for £30:pm so if he got a bad illness or accident we wouldn't have raised anywhere near £6k . I did look into accident only insurance which is far cheaper but it's only up to £2k. TBH the insurance and vet bills is putting me off getting another pet. When my dog goes I may foster but won't get another dog.

pinneddownbytabbies · 07/11/2026 23:33

Londersand · 07/11/2026 23:10

Hence the arthritis injections on a monthly basis

My friend was just annoyed that she'd taken the cat to the vet about a scratch on its ear and they'd told her that expensive blood tests were necessary, just to check for something the cat might not have anyway.

Ladybird69 · 07/11/2026 23:53

My petplan cat insurance has just jumped to £45 for my 🤞 healthy 7 year old ragdoll and I’ve never claimed. It’s more than double my car insurance and it’s got an excess payable. I’d love to get her a little playmate but I couldn’t afford it. Since when could a person not be able to afford to own a cat! It’s extortion.

Londersand · 08/11/2026 00:10

Ladybird69 · 07/11/2026 23:53

My petplan cat insurance has just jumped to £45 for my 🤞 healthy 7 year old ragdoll and I’ve never claimed. It’s more than double my car insurance and it’s got an excess payable. I’d love to get her a little playmate but I couldn’t afford it. Since when could a person not be able to afford to own a cat! It’s extortion.

Petplan are the worst. And their awful smug comms they keep sending it about how they’re my BFFs. They can fuck off

icecreamscreams · 08/11/2026 00:41

It’s been worth it for me. My old boy clocked up some vet bills, my current cat is on about 5k - investigations for recurrent cystitis that started with a simple UTI

ThoughtsOnLife · 08/11/2026 00:45

Happily my vet is not part of a large group and so far I am more that happy, I would always look out for a highly recommended individual practice.
With regards to insuring older pets I believe agria pet & some others do not have an age limit ( although pre-existing conditions are unlikely to be covered). I would compare on a service like money supermarket or other similar site.

Allergictoironing · 08/11/2026 08:03

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 07/11/2026 23:05

I agree with @Grumpyoldpersonwithcats that insurance does seem to encourage treatment options because you can and not because you necessarily should. We were offered chemo for our girl which would have prolonged her life, but not cured her. It would have been incredibly distressing for her to be hauled back and forth to a specialist facility (not our own vet) for weekly infusions, and we opted to let her go gracefully.

On the day of her final appointment I tearfully asked our vet, what would she do if it was her cat, would she do the chemo? She said no, absolutely not. I wonder if it would have even been offered to us if we’d been paying out of pocket.

Vets are obliged to inform you of all possible treatments for a condition. I've sadly gone through this with 2 cats one now long gone, the other is still with me. In each case the vets have made it clear that they are giving me every option available rather than recommending them; they've answered every question I've put to them openly and always taken into consideration the mental welfare of the cat not just the physical. I've even had the vet saying that though a certain treatment would prolong life, they wouldn't want to recommend it as it would distress the cat and quality of life was more important than length.

This vets were independent when I joined them, but have since become part of one of the chains. I've seen absolutely no change in their care or attitude.

Though I've never had to claim for my girl to date, Boycat would have cost me about 3 years premiums in 5 months. Tobias would have cost me £3-4k the last couple of insurance years and another £500 so far this year, instead he's cost a total of £265 in 3 years excess for the first appointment each year.

DSis didn't have a previous cat insured. He developed a number of conditions including epilepsy which resulted in him having stress related issues as well, and was costing her typically around £50 a month in meds apart from all the vet visits and tests for a few years. When she got her current 2, first thing she did was get them insured!

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 08/11/2026 08:31

Allergictoironing · 08/11/2026 08:03

Vets are obliged to inform you of all possible treatments for a condition. I've sadly gone through this with 2 cats one now long gone, the other is still with me. In each case the vets have made it clear that they are giving me every option available rather than recommending them; they've answered every question I've put to them openly and always taken into consideration the mental welfare of the cat not just the physical. I've even had the vet saying that though a certain treatment would prolong life, they wouldn't want to recommend it as it would distress the cat and quality of life was more important than length.

This vets were independent when I joined them, but have since become part of one of the chains. I've seen absolutely no change in their care or attitude.

Though I've never had to claim for my girl to date, Boycat would have cost me about 3 years premiums in 5 months. Tobias would have cost me £3-4k the last couple of insurance years and another £500 so far this year, instead he's cost a total of £265 in 3 years excess for the first appointment each year.

DSis didn't have a previous cat insured. He developed a number of conditions including epilepsy which resulted in him having stress related issues as well, and was costing her typically around £50 a month in meds apart from all the vet visits and tests for a few years. When she got her current 2, first thing she did was get them insured!

Good vets will undoubtedly follow those best practices. However there is plenty of evidence that the private equity owners of many practices enforce targets to push expensive treatments and drugs over simpler cheaper options.
The real issue with all of this is that vets as a group are losing the trust of many pet owners.

The most distressing example I have was when one of my previous cats was very clearly at end of life with kidney failure. We took her into the vet to be put down and the vet persuaded Mrs G (against my better judgement) to keep the cat on a drip that night for monitoring.
Our cat died alone attached to the drip that night. The fucking vet when we went in in the morning had added to the bill a charge for euthanasia - presumably thinking that we'd be too upset to read the bill properly. He was wrong.

I've had some great vets - I've also had some complete shysters. Sadly I regularly take a second opinion now because vets as a group have lost my trust.

aodirjjd · 08/11/2026 08:35

Logically pet insurance at population level isn’t worth it or insurance companies wouldn’t make profit. Obviously individual level it will vary. Person on this thread who paid 1 month and then the cat got hit by a car is a good example of that.

I strongly agree with earlier post that pet insurance is driving inflated pricing and over treating animals. I think this skews people’s perception as to whether it’s “worth” it. But I feel very uncomfortable with some stories of what I think are over treated animals

I think quality of life really has to be considered more than it currently is, especially with older cats who hate being taken to vets. Chemo for pets is an awful concept. Our last cat had hyperthyroidism, the first suggestion cost thousands and had risks around teeth, second suggestion involved frequent vet’s visits and daily meds and third suggestion was we change her food. The food was expensive but she was fine on that until her end 5 years later.

We put £50 a month in a savings account for our current cat. I could pay up more if I needed but if the bill was more than £3k and I had a cat over 10 I’d have serious conversations with myself on what was fair to the cat.

Doubleskunk · 08/11/2026 08:48

My friends one year old cat got attacked by a dog when it entered the dog’s garden. Had several thousand pounds worth of X-rays, treatment, vet visits, surgeries etc. It’s a gamble.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 08/11/2026 09:56

Logically pet insurance at population level isn’t worth it or insurance companies wouldn’t make profit.
This is absolutely key. Most people will not financially benefit from having pet insurance. Some people will obviously benefit massively from it. It's all about risk appetite.
As an example I've never claimed on my house insurance in the house we've been in for nearly 30 years, however I wouldn't risk being without house insurance because while the likelihood of a disaster is low - the impact could be disastrous. Whereas (put bluntly) if you can't afford £20k for massive reconstructive surgery for your 15 year old cat, you do have a choice to PTS (which sometimes is the kinder option anyway).

Yesreallyitsme · 08/11/2026 12:55

Worth it in my opinion. Our 10 year old cat has always had insurance, and we’ve used it 3 times (twice for cat bites, once for gastro issues). Her gastro issues were this year - in only 4 days of treatment, the bill got to almost £5K. I did have to pay £100 excess and 10%, but it’s a lot better than £5K. Oh, and it turned out to be a hair ball 🫠

Is pet insurance really worth it?
ThisCheeryBee · 08/11/2026 13:14

I’ve started using MyPetCard which is bit of a half way house. It’s a savings plan for pets with some benefits. Makes much more sense for me as have 2 dogs, a cat and too many horses. Insuring them all individually would be insanely expensive!

herbetta · 08/11/2026 13:18

I've never bothered for cats, but I always do for my dogs.

I've never signed up to any of my vet's monthly plan things either.

In regards to insurance I check out the best value / quality etc (excess / annual or claim limit) & get cashback. Always consider moving each year unless they develop an expensive ling-term condition.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 08/11/2026 13:26

Don't get me started on pet plans - another rip off. 😂

MrsCat1 · 08/11/2026 13:47

I work on the basis that insurance is a money making business so the average person will always end up worse off for taking out insurance. So I would say put the money away into a pets account instead. However there is always a risk that you may be way off average and that your animal racks up substantial costs which is a risk you need to consider.

Keanuwilldo · 08/11/2026 19:11

pinneddownbytabbies · 07/11/2026 23:10

I completely agree with @Grumpyoldpersonwithcats about vets viewing us as cash cows now.

This happened to my friend this week - she took her cat to the vet for a very minor issue, and the vet recommended a raft of blood tests which would have cost hundreds.

Vets can't do right for doing wrong !
We offer bloods because that is the gold standard in veterinary care , you as the consumer have every right to decline them , if we offered them for no charge as perceived with an nhs comparison clients wouldn't think twice.
But , if we didn't offer them routinely or tell the client every available option we would get complaints for that too.
It's quite common for us as humans to be offered routine bloods before a minor issue , sometimes things aren't as they appear and blood work gives a bigger picture.
I don't disagree that some vets are immoral , isn't that the case in most industries?
but after working in the veterinary field in an independent practice for decades i know that your accusation is far from the truth.
And yes in many ,many cases insurance is a blessed relief for many clients and is often the difference between fixing a pet or saying goodbye, again with insurance owners need to really shop around and spend time finding whats best for them but always READ THE SMALL PRINT !

pinneddownbytabbies · 08/11/2026 22:41

Keanuwilldo · 08/11/2026 19:11

Vets can't do right for doing wrong !
We offer bloods because that is the gold standard in veterinary care , you as the consumer have every right to decline them , if we offered them for no charge as perceived with an nhs comparison clients wouldn't think twice.
But , if we didn't offer them routinely or tell the client every available option we would get complaints for that too.
It's quite common for us as humans to be offered routine bloods before a minor issue , sometimes things aren't as they appear and blood work gives a bigger picture.
I don't disagree that some vets are immoral , isn't that the case in most industries?
but after working in the veterinary field in an independent practice for decades i know that your accusation is far from the truth.
And yes in many ,many cases insurance is a blessed relief for many clients and is often the difference between fixing a pet or saying goodbye, again with insurance owners need to really shop around and spend time finding whats best for them but always READ THE SMALL PRINT !

You routinely offer blood tests costing ££££ when someone takes their cat to the vet because they've scratched their ear and the owner just wants the vet to check for ear mites?

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 08/11/2026 22:45

Over the years I've had three vet bills over £2,500. If you can pay £3k per cat at any time with no bother then sure, no need for insurance.

Ncagainagainandagain · 08/11/2026 22:56

ThoughtsOnLife · 08/11/2026 00:45

Happily my vet is not part of a large group and so far I am more that happy, I would always look out for a highly recommended individual practice.
With regards to insuring older pets I believe agria pet & some others do not have an age limit ( although pre-existing conditions are unlikely to be covered). I would compare on a service like money supermarket or other similar site.

Completely agree .
Our vet is the local village vet . He has been here for decades and charges are very low ie my 11year old JRT was born without enamel on her teeth so she has regular dental extractions underGA ,full dental clean,clips her nails and the last bill £230 !! Cannot complain. She is insured with Tesco £45 per month but doesn’t cover dental health.