Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

One week in. Major puppy blues triggering depression

112 replies

bibbityboo2 · 24/10/2026 06:46

Please help. And please no judgement.
our family has always wanted a dog - I grew up with them but not had one of my own since a child. Thought we could do it. Did all the research, waited until the right time. It's not good at all. I'm ill I'm tired I have barely slept since we had him. Husband is no longer on board with the whole thing. Kids are tired and ratty but also love him . I feel claustrophobic and want the life I had just a week ago . It's bringing back that sad sad feeling I had when I was depressed and with post natal anxiety. I just want to rewind time and not get the pup. I feel so sad so guilty and completely devastated. I started to feel attached to him but now don't feel anything.

OP posts:
Onlyme7575 · 24/10/2026 12:47

Please don’t get another dog ever again.if your mental health is that bad,there are always obstacles in life which you will have to face.

grinandslothit · 24/10/2026 12:55

I would return him to the breeder. I don't know why people think that getting a puppy when they already are slammed with small children, work, and other responsibilities is a good idea. It's good in theory when you're thinking about sweet puppy hugs but it's usually the woman that ends up doing everything. it becomes another household chore because nobody else is going to do anything other than when they feel like it. You will be the one responsible for training it, feeding it, walking it, taking it to the vet while the rest of the family will occasionally pet it and say oh nice doggie and that's about it.

LouisFuton · 24/10/2026 12:57

Oh give over @Onlyme7575 you wouldn't say to a woman who's suffering baby blues don't ever have another baby would you?

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 13:02

Onlyme7575 · 24/10/2026 12:47

Please don’t get another dog ever again.if your mental health is that bad,there are always obstacles in life which you will have to face.

That's a very sweeping statement to make. Sometimes a dog can be the antidote to mental health issues.

estrogone · 24/10/2026 13:15

Rainbowchicken · 24/10/2026 12:23

That is so cruel, even more so with a collie. No one should have a dog if they are going to be out for 12 hours a day but keeping them in a cage for that length of time is quite frankly disgusting.

Did you read that she takes herself to bed and is never left awake and unattended.

What do you suggest we do? Keep her awake? You really have no idea about managing a working breed.

She gets up in the morning, premium raw food.
We get ready and she goes with me to wkrk. We train on the walk.

At work she sees the other dogs - its dog friendly.
She has a little.play
Snooze
Wakes and has a puzzle feeder or a lick mat
Outside into sunshine for a play - variety of toys
Another 5 minutes of clicker training (food = lunch)
On home days she plays in the garden / her sandpit or paddling pool (we live in hot climate).
Another snooze
Walk to the shops and practice obedience in the supermarket/chemist/post office.
Home for some time on the sofa
A bit of ball and fetch
A last sleep late afternoon
Lots of family time - they get home and dote on her.

Around 7 she toddles off to her crate and goes to sleep. She gets up at around 6.30. We have a baby monitor next to her crate.

She is 20 weeks and has done this since 12 weeks- when she slept right beside me for the first four weeks.

Oh and on Saturdays she goes to obedience and on Sundays to the beach.

Not sure what is cruel about that. Mumsnetters seem incapable of assuming positive intent.

E: ,SP

GoldenTobes · 24/10/2026 13:21

It’s only been a week. If you’ve not done the puppy stage before it is a shock to the system and it is very normal to have regrets. But in the grand scheme of things it is a fairly short amount of time out of their life and before you know it you’ll be enjoying them and these weeks will feel like a long way in the past. I think you should push through, join some support threads and get some specific advice where needed. We had previous rescue dogs that were older, then along came our first pup and it was hard but it wasn’t long before things started getting better and eventually ended up with a lovely adult dog.

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 13:22

Because @estrogone you haven't stated anywhere whether the crate is open. If it is unfastened, fine, no problem. If not, that is a barbaric way to rear an energetic pastoral breed.

estrogone · 24/10/2026 13:26

So sorry OP - for derailing your thread. I hope you find a solution that works for you, your pup and your family.

I thought you might want advice from.somebody else in the thick of things,

Best of luck.

E: Sp

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 15:19

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 10:57

I hear you @Twiglets1 If crating is not enforced and is the dog's choice then fine. Maybe I misinterpreted what was said about the dog being crated... 🤔

On the other hand, given that a border collie is a pastoral breed, it wouldn't be normal for it to remain in the crate for lengthy periods. The pastoral group of dogs are the ones that move around a lot at night and rarely stay in one spot for long, so it seems unusual that it would choose to lie in its crate for almost 12 hours at a stretch. I would worry about the joints and muscles long term if that was the case for a breed that is known for being extremely active.

Yup I agree. Breed is important too. Labs are notoriously lazy at home, while being high energy outside the home. I have no experience of other breeds.

Tbh I'm just guessing that mine stays in the crate all night because he puts himself in there about 9pm and we hear him coming out of it as one of us walks down the stairs about 6am. When it's very hot or cold, I certainly am happier with the idea that he can move around more if he wants to find a cosier or cooler spot to sleep in. Or just wants a good stretch.

AudiSQ6 · 24/10/2026 15:27

Gosh, no judgement! I returned a rescue animal once after a couple of weeks -partly due to health issues we hadn't been told about but also it just wasn't working for our family.
Do not make yourself miserable over an animal OP!!

GreengrocersApostrophe · 24/10/2026 15:29

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 24/10/2026 07:34

@estrogone honestly, no.

But a puppy is still going to chew, and need toilet breaks and cry. How you manage them is key, but ultimately they do need to be managed and some breeds are going to be far worse than others and not everyone is cut out for it.

Tbh, it sounds like OP's puppy is not capable of being left alone or crate trained - based on her OP and her comments about sleep - so really the play pen and crate training for sleep isn't going to work anyway.

Even if it can be...

A puppy will never have been alone a night in its life until it goes to its new home. Not all puppies can, or should, be crate trained for sleep. Crate training for worst case scenario (long term injury that requires bed rest) is one thing, but I wouldn't be impressed with someone putting a giant breed in a crate for extended periods i.e. 12 hours. Tbh I wouldn't be impressed with anyone putting any puppy in a crate for an extended period just to give themselves some rest.

Crates and play pens also aren't completely safe and I disagree that young puppies should be left in them. I know puppies that have broken their legs climbing out of their play pen to get to their human, and I know one puppy - whose knowledgable owner left it for 10 minutes - who dislocated his jaw trying to bite through his crate when it got it stuck and panicked. And chances are, if you're there with the puppy but not inside, it'll cry and cry and cry. Which won't help it.

And on lick matts & kongs...

Lick matts, Kongs and various other things are like the dog ownership equivalent of sticking a toddler in front of an i-pad. It doesn't do anything except give you peace for what 30 minutes? If that? So unless OP is going to be one of those owners whos solution to everything is 'Kong' and she has a steady supply of them...and really its nothing something a dog owner should aspire toward. It doesn't teach your dog anything useful, it doesn't teach them not to bite or mouth, and it doesn't build any relationship with you. Fine if that's what you want in a dog, and fine for OP, but it's not going to solve the underlying biting issue that OP has. The best way to manage teething is to engage constructively with your dog - not fill them up with energy in the form of frozen food in kongs or lickmatts. If you're going to do that, better to use a frozen tea-towel. They are, ultimately, a management tool. 15+ years ago, no one used them and by and large we had happier dogs that settled more easily. I have no idea why they're a 'thing' now as all they seem to do is create problems through being badly used.

And then there's adolescence which will be even harder if OP doesn't have that bond or indeed has still not found anything positive in dog ownership.

But whether or not OP does all those things, there is absolutely no way a puppy should be bringing on emotions that OP had when she had PMD.

And its really unfair on the puppy to be in a home where the only people who seem to want him are the children (which depending on their ages might be teaching him even worse habits - children are little shits for making biting/mouthing worse because of the way they react, for example - and making things so much harder for OP).

Tldr; dog police has arrived

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 15:31

GreengrocersApostrophe · 24/10/2026 15:29

Tldr; dog police has arrived

Aka the most knowledgeable dog person in The Doghouse.

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 24/10/2026 15:33

GreengrocersApostrophe · 24/10/2026 15:29

Tldr; dog police has arrived

I fail to see how wanting the best for dogs (including pointing out it's not fair on a dog to be in a home where no one wants it) makes me the 'dog police.'🤔

Also...if you're going to call me names, at least get it right. I am a 'dictator'...at least according to the last time you insulted me! Hi again!😅

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 24/10/2026 15:35

Don't mind me. Just 'dictating' my way around Doghouse by offering advice to help OP and her dog...

kim jong un GIF
Dozer · 24/10/2026 15:36

Agree with PPs saying that if DH is ‘no longer on board’ and not doing his share, that means the dog needs to go back to where you got it, another home or dog rescue.

Better for the dog. Better for you, once you’ve recovered from the decision not turning out well and experience.

Harsh experience for the DC, but that’s not sufficient reason to keep the pup.

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 15:40

I cannot speak for collies or other herders @Twiglets1 but certainly the pastoral guarding breeds move around a lot at night. I have frequently shared a room with our adult dogs and they'll wander about or relocate several times through the night. This is why I am averse to crating for most large working or pastoral dogs, unless it is necessary for medical reasons.

With apologies for being off topic.

TheRealSmurfette · 24/10/2026 15:49

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 13:02

That's a very sweeping statement to make. Sometimes a dog can be the antidote to mental health issues.

Well CLEARLY in this case it’s not! 🤷‍♀️

TheRealSmurfette · 24/10/2026 15:49

LouisFuton · 24/10/2026 12:57

Oh give over @Onlyme7575 you wouldn't say to a woman who's suffering baby blues don't ever have another baby would you?

Maybe yes.

Nuthatchtreelover · 24/10/2026 15:57

Phone the breeder now and arrange to take the puppy back as soon as possible, before it picks up bad habits. Depression is too big a hurdle to overcome right now and if your husband won’t step up while you all train the puppy etc I think it best if you return it. Don’t ask for your money back though as the breeder is not at fault here; the children will learn a valuable lesson. Take care I hope you feel better soon.

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 16:04

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 15:40

I cannot speak for collies or other herders @Twiglets1 but certainly the pastoral guarding breeds move around a lot at night. I have frequently shared a room with our adult dogs and they'll wander about or relocate several times through the night. This is why I am averse to crating for most large working or pastoral dogs, unless it is necessary for medical reasons.

With apologies for being off topic.

All my dogs have certainly moved around a lot during the day - seeking different surfaces to lie on particularly during hot/cold weather.

That is why I would be uncomfortable with ever locking the crate door - apart from for very small periods of time just to keep the puppy safe for example or to keep the house safe when having to leave small puppies alone in the house for up to an hour.

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 16:06

We digress. I hope you are ok @bibbityboo2 and can take from this thread that most people think you would be doing the right thing if you feel rehoming this puppy is the best thing for your mental health. I can promise you that the puppy can happily resettle with another family at this stage.

Chaarlene · 24/10/2026 16:07

I second/third! returning pup. IME you need someone in the home who is ready to ride or die for that dog. Who is its champion. Who could not live without it and, more importantly, will do something about it. For me, it was my teen DD who swept the puppy up, slept with her, let her out for wees, loved, played and trained her. The result? A super, independent family dog (who sleeps on her own!) and is a stress-free addition to the family. If you don't have someone to do that, you are going to continue to struggle because you are not in the right headspace. It is always hard in the first few weeks, but it shouldn't make you feel ill. Or so alone.

StarDolphins · 24/10/2026 16:09

A week?! Surely as part of your research about getting a puppy you’d know it takes a while before it’s great and calm?! Take him back to tge breeder and please dont get another pet.

FinishedAtFifty · 24/10/2026 16:26

Just out of curiosity, do you get your money back if you return the puppy to the breeder ? Or is buyer beware?

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 16:29

FinishedAtFifty · 24/10/2026 16:26

Just out of curiosity, do you get your money back if you return the puppy to the breeder ? Or is buyer beware?

Normally no you do not nor should you as they have all the worry and responsibility for finding a new home again.

That is the last thing someone should be concerned about who is rehoming a puppy! They are living creatures not something you bought off Amazon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread