Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

One week in. Major puppy blues triggering depression

112 replies

bibbityboo2 · 24/10/2026 06:46

Please help. And please no judgement.
our family has always wanted a dog - I grew up with them but not had one of my own since a child. Thought we could do it. Did all the research, waited until the right time. It's not good at all. I'm ill I'm tired I have barely slept since we had him. Husband is no longer on board with the whole thing. Kids are tired and ratty but also love him . I feel claustrophobic and want the life I had just a week ago . It's bringing back that sad sad feeling I had when I was depressed and with post natal anxiety. I just want to rewind time and not get the pup. I feel so sad so guilty and completely devastated. I started to feel attached to him but now don't feel anything.

OP posts:
MaeshoweDragon · 24/10/2026 08:53

We got a puppy because the kids and DH wanted one. Guess who did everything... for fifteen years. They loved him to bits. I kind of resented the lack of freedom. For fifteen years.

Would suggest you speak to the breeder about returning or rehoming.

estrogone · 24/10/2026 09:03

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 24/10/2026 07:34

@estrogone honestly, no.

But a puppy is still going to chew, and need toilet breaks and cry. How you manage them is key, but ultimately they do need to be managed and some breeds are going to be far worse than others and not everyone is cut out for it.

Tbh, it sounds like OP's puppy is not capable of being left alone or crate trained - based on her OP and her comments about sleep - so really the play pen and crate training for sleep isn't going to work anyway.

Even if it can be...

A puppy will never have been alone a night in its life until it goes to its new home. Not all puppies can, or should, be crate trained for sleep. Crate training for worst case scenario (long term injury that requires bed rest) is one thing, but I wouldn't be impressed with someone putting a giant breed in a crate for extended periods i.e. 12 hours. Tbh I wouldn't be impressed with anyone putting any puppy in a crate for an extended period just to give themselves some rest.

Crates and play pens also aren't completely safe and I disagree that young puppies should be left in them. I know puppies that have broken their legs climbing out of their play pen to get to their human, and I know one puppy - whose knowledgable owner left it for 10 minutes - who dislocated his jaw trying to bite through his crate when it got it stuck and panicked. And chances are, if you're there with the puppy but not inside, it'll cry and cry and cry. Which won't help it.

And on lick matts & kongs...

Lick matts, Kongs and various other things are like the dog ownership equivalent of sticking a toddler in front of an i-pad. It doesn't do anything except give you peace for what 30 minutes? If that? So unless OP is going to be one of those owners whos solution to everything is 'Kong' and she has a steady supply of them...and really its nothing something a dog owner should aspire toward. It doesn't teach your dog anything useful, it doesn't teach them not to bite or mouth, and it doesn't build any relationship with you. Fine if that's what you want in a dog, and fine for OP, but it's not going to solve the underlying biting issue that OP has. The best way to manage teething is to engage constructively with your dog - not fill them up with energy in the form of frozen food in kongs or lickmatts. If you're going to do that, better to use a frozen tea-towel. They are, ultimately, a management tool. 15+ years ago, no one used them and by and large we had happier dogs that settled more easily. I have no idea why they're a 'thing' now as all they seem to do is create problems through being badly used.

And then there's adolescence which will be even harder if OP doesn't have that bond or indeed has still not found anything positive in dog ownership.

But whether or not OP does all those things, there is absolutely no way a puppy should be bringing on emotions that OP had when she had PMD.

And its really unfair on the puppy to be in a home where the only people who seem to want him are the children (which depending on their ages might be teaching him even worse habits - children are little shits for making biting/mouthing worse because of the way they react, for example - and making things so much harder for OP).

Okey dokey then. You are talking to me like I have no idea.

I have a border collie and know a thing or two. Your post was very judgemental and I disagreed with a lot of what you say. My dog sleeps well in her crate from 7am till 6.30ish. I didnt enforce this its just what she wants and needs.

I do not crate her for my needs, I respect her need for downtime and have carefully researched puppy behaviour and needs as a dog, not a human baby.

It makes life happier for everybody, mostly the dog.

Thanks for the lecture though.

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 09:40

If neither of you has the commitment after just one week in, then I agree with others that you need to contact the breeder. You need to have commitment and both be willing to share the load. Because this will get worse before it gets better. You haven't started with full on teething or lead training yet, and adolescence is a long way off.

We're three weeks in with our puppy and still getting little sleep. We thought we knew exactly what we getting into, we've done it several times before and we never crate. But we are struggling more than we expected to, because we have a particularly strong willed and vocal puppy. We're both determined to make it work but right now I have puppy blues, which I had not anticipated.

Some puppies are harder than others. They're like kids. Some don't sleep well or settle easily, no matter what you do. Even with a lifetime's experience it can still be hard. So no judgement from me. I know how you feel. You love the pup to start with, but then they kick into the "witching hour", life feels disrupted and you almost start to hate and resent them. You just want your life to be back how it was.

If you return your pup now, it will find a home. Prioritising your mental health is better for you and for the dog in the long term.

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 09:41

estrogone · 24/10/2026 09:03

Okey dokey then. You are talking to me like I have no idea.

I have a border collie and know a thing or two. Your post was very judgemental and I disagreed with a lot of what you say. My dog sleeps well in her crate from 7am till 6.30ish. I didnt enforce this its just what she wants and needs.

I do not crate her for my needs, I respect her need for downtime and have carefully researched puppy behaviour and needs as a dog, not a human baby.

It makes life happier for everybody, mostly the dog.

Thanks for the lecture though.

Crated from 7 until 6.30 is inhumane.

throwaway3749574 · 24/10/2026 09:50

Put your MH first OP, returning pup at this point won’t be detrimental to him/her

vjg13 · 24/10/2026 10:12

Definitely return the puppy to the breeder and at some point in the future an older dog may be a better fit for your family.

IzzyLeng · 24/10/2026 10:14

I’m a year in and while things have calmed down I was slightly reminiscing about my old lazy weekends as I was trudging out on an hour walk at 8am this morning in the rain.

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 24/10/2026 10:15

estrogone · 24/10/2026 09:03

Okey dokey then. You are talking to me like I have no idea.

I have a border collie and know a thing or two. Your post was very judgemental and I disagreed with a lot of what you say. My dog sleeps well in her crate from 7am till 6.30ish. I didnt enforce this its just what she wants and needs.

I do not crate her for my needs, I respect her need for downtime and have carefully researched puppy behaviour and needs as a dog, not a human baby.

It makes life happier for everybody, mostly the dog.

Thanks for the lecture though.

Nope. I just said what I think. Wasn’t lecturing - you just seemed to take it that way based off how you are raising your dog - it was just based off experience.

I’ve raised 8 litters but still don’t claim I ‘know a thing or two.’ No one does. That’s the whole point of dog ownership - all dogs are different and different breeds (and even littermates) need different things. We can provide advice based off experience but it may not work as chances are what works for you and your dog won’t work for OP. Just as what worked for my boy won’t work for his sister - despite them having the same parents, raised in the same home and having the exact same upbringing for 8 weeks

If 12 hours in a 24hr day in a crate works for your dog, that’s great. It wouldn’t work for most dogs, and would be incredibly cruel. But I am sure your dog is very happy 😊

But PMD is no joke, and OP shouldn’t muck around with her MH for the sake of a puppy that could easily (and happily) return to its breeder.

sonjadog · 24/10/2026 10:17

Take him back to the breeder. He is still so young and they can find him another family. He won't be damaged by being returned now. This is more than puppy blues - so I would just accept that having a dog isn't for you and give him back. Don't feel bad about it - it isn't uncommon for people to think they want a puppy until one is actually there. It is quite hard to imagine what it will be like if you haven't had previous experience with dogs.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 24/10/2026 10:20

Agree to return but now

MrsUrdd · 24/10/2026 10:21

It's ok to admit it didn't work. Hope you are ok

Balloonhearts · 24/10/2026 10:24

This is normal for the first few months. They are literally babies. They don't come out pretrained and sleeping through the night. Give yourself a shake and a big cup of coffee. This too shall pass and surely you did your research before getting a puppy? You knew the first months would be tough. Get the basic foundations and manners installed now, and 12 months down the line, you will start to see the end result emerging.

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 10:33

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 09:41

Crated from 7 until 6.30 is inhumane.

I agree it’s inhumane if the door is locked. Even just being alone that long is cruel in my opinion.

My Lab puppy now 11 months puts himself in his crate about 9pm to 6am. That sounds awful to say 9 hours crated but the crate door is open and so are all the downstairs room doors open now he is house trained. It’s funny because during the day he naps on an old armchair, but at night it’s the crate he chooses to sleep in.

estrogone · 24/10/2026 10:40

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 10:33

I agree it’s inhumane if the door is locked. Even just being alone that long is cruel in my opinion.

My Lab puppy now 11 months puts himself in his crate about 9pm to 6am. That sounds awful to say 9 hours crated but the crate door is open and so are all the downstairs room doors open now he is house trained. It’s funny because during the day he naps on an old armchair, but at night it’s the crate he chooses to sleep in.

My.pup goes to sleep and stays asleep when in her crate - goes in by herself and we get her up when she wakes. She is never left to even whimper.

Nothing inhumane going on. Lol, our pup is the most adored baby. She just happens to like sleeping in her crate.

Roselilly36 · 24/10/2026 10:40

I would agree with previous posters, perhaps the best thing is to return the pup to the breeder. And get your life go back to normal, you will be upset for a while, but the kids will soon settle and if your DH is no longer onboard with dog ownership it will make life much harder for you for next 13 possibly more. Do what’s right for you OP. Good luck.

gingerbreadandlemonade · 24/10/2026 10:42

Echo the others thoughts. Give the poor puppy back now. Dogs need taking care of - feeding, walking, picking up poo, for their entire lives, not just puppyhood.

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 10:47

estrogone · 24/10/2026 10:40

My.pup goes to sleep and stays asleep when in her crate - goes in by herself and we get her up when she wakes. She is never left to even whimper.

Nothing inhumane going on. Lol, our pup is the most adored baby. She just happens to like sleeping in her crate.

Like I say I have nothing against puppies sleeping in crates. As long as the door is left open so they have the choice to leave the crate.

raisinglittlepeople12 · 24/10/2026 10:50

Take the puppy back and get an adult dog instead

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 24/10/2026 10:57

Twiglets1 · 24/10/2026 10:33

I agree it’s inhumane if the door is locked. Even just being alone that long is cruel in my opinion.

My Lab puppy now 11 months puts himself in his crate about 9pm to 6am. That sounds awful to say 9 hours crated but the crate door is open and so are all the downstairs room doors open now he is house trained. It’s funny because during the day he naps on an old armchair, but at night it’s the crate he chooses to sleep in.

I hear you @Twiglets1 If crating is not enforced and is the dog's choice then fine. Maybe I misinterpreted what was said about the dog being crated... 🤔

On the other hand, given that a border collie is a pastoral breed, it wouldn't be normal for it to remain in the crate for lengthy periods. The pastoral group of dogs are the ones that move around a lot at night and rarely stay in one spot for long, so it seems unusual that it would choose to lie in its crate for almost 12 hours at a stretch. I would worry about the joints and muscles long term if that was the case for a breed that is known for being extremely active.

Petrine · 24/10/2026 11:37

Take him back.

Ylvamoon · 24/10/2026 12:09

estrogone · 24/10/2026 09:03

Okey dokey then. You are talking to me like I have no idea.

I have a border collie and know a thing or two. Your post was very judgemental and I disagreed with a lot of what you say. My dog sleeps well in her crate from 7am till 6.30ish. I didnt enforce this its just what she wants and needs.

I do not crate her for my needs, I respect her need for downtime and have carefully researched puppy behaviour and needs as a dog, not a human baby.

It makes life happier for everybody, mostly the dog.

Thanks for the lecture though.

Apart from being in a crate for nearly 12 hours, what else have you done to shut your dog down?

On a different note, I have raised several puppies, some were easy and others total nightmares- same breed! So it's never one size fits all.

@bibbityboo2 - sit DH down and ask for help. If no help is offered beyond a day or to of guilt tripping, return the puppy. Remember, dogs can be wonderful companions, but puppies just look cute, everything else about them is a bloody nightmare!

LouisFuton · 24/10/2026 12:11

No judgement from me! I seriously considered leaving the front door open accidentally on purpose. Not even joking.

OldieButBaddie · 24/10/2026 12:20

Not read the replies, we have had 3 big dogs from puppies and I can tell you what worked for us. You don't say what breed yours is, we have had hounds who are very lazy but savages when puppies!

First week or two (and as you are only a week in you could try) puppy slept in a big tall sided cardboard box right by our bed so if they woke we could put our hand in and give it some comfort, after a few nights this works IME and they start to settle

During the day have the crate door open and put bed/toys/water in there. Let the puppy go in and out of its own accord and when it falls asleep put it in the bed in there with the door open. Put treats in the bed and reward the puppy for going in and finding them. Once the pup is settling in the bed start closing the door, first for a few seconds and build it up. Give treats so they like going in.

What specifically are you having issues with other than sleep? They are like babies except the sleep bit gets better much faster! Biting? Chewing?

Rainbowchicken · 24/10/2026 12:23

estrogone · 24/10/2026 09:03

Okey dokey then. You are talking to me like I have no idea.

I have a border collie and know a thing or two. Your post was very judgemental and I disagreed with a lot of what you say. My dog sleeps well in her crate from 7am till 6.30ish. I didnt enforce this its just what she wants and needs.

I do not crate her for my needs, I respect her need for downtime and have carefully researched puppy behaviour and needs as a dog, not a human baby.

It makes life happier for everybody, mostly the dog.

Thanks for the lecture though.

That is so cruel, even more so with a collie. No one should have a dog if they are going to be out for 12 hours a day but keeping them in a cage for that length of time is quite frankly disgusting.

Lotsofsnacks · 24/10/2026 12:38

Please return the puppy immediately, it deserves someone who will give it time and love. I have a dog and the puppy stage is hard; a lot of people with young families are naive as to how much hard work is involved.

Return it before it learns any bad habits.