It’s funny you say that @CoubousAndTourmaIet , I was thinking about this recently.
Since our first puppy, we were always told by our puppies’ breeders, 5 min rule was absolutely imperative, including this one.
But this time I started thinking further because I’ve made a real effort to put little slots of training into our walks, eg sit stays, or just stopping and watching, sitting on benches etc. All of which of course take time- a big chunk if your limited by 5min rule with a young puppy. It’s hard to guess when the numbers you’re working with are so small and therefore the likelihood of error is great.
And then I had the incident with the sheep a week or so ago (I can’t remember if I mentioned it on here but I had to turn back as there were sheep blocking the footpath and whilst some of them moved there was a ram that wouldn’t, started stamping and shaking its head and I thought he’d charge at us to I had to turn around and go back the way we came, making the walk ten min longer than intended. It wasn’t ideal but the safest option).
And then I got thinking about what he was doing on these walks- mooching along at a pace of his choosing with lots of stopping to sniff? Or playing games with us (to encourage engagement and focus), where he’s running about? And obviously if playing with other dogs occasionally then that’s even more full on. Common sense says that different levels of exertion will put more or less stress on little joints.
I’ve started tracking our walks on Strava because it shows you actual moving time in addition to your overall time. But unfortunately it only gives the former once you’ve finished your walk.
I saw on the Labrador site that they have distances suggested, in addition to time. Although, like the 5 min rule, it’s probably a sensible guess along the lines of making sure you don’t do too much, rather than anything scientifically tested.
So personally I’m sort of sticking to it, but not freaking out if we accidentally go over by a few min- eg today our walk was 27.5 not 25 min. Aside from the spaniel incident, and the crow chasing, it was generally just us by ourselves mooching and sniffing on soft ground through woodland and field, not really exerting himself. We did that at 10ish, and then at 545 we did a quick loop of lead walking practice around our estate for 9min. I tend to do one offlead/long line walk with lots of sniffing, and a much shorter one practicing lead walking at the other end of the day for ten min. But equally I’m not glued to it- on Saturday we had a training workshop with a gundog trainer 1.5hrs away. He was exhausted afterwards, even tho he hadn’t done much exercise it was a lot of input for his brain! We didn’t go on a proper walk at all that day.
What I have done is be super careful with jumping on and off things- he’s lifted in and out of the car (now he’s 23+kg it’s getting tough but he shows no sign of wanting to be a bit more independent!). No stairs, and trying not to let him get chubby.
I know myself, and I know I’m a massive over thinker. I know that if I didn’t stick more or less to the 5 min rule that (god forbid) we had a problem later on, I’d never forgive myself and always be thinking ‘what if??’.