Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!

635 replies

GetSetFake · 09/10/2026 11:51

Three weeks in, we've reached Thread Two and so far, mostly agreed to disagree on all things baking and non baking related including:

Diversity casting
Throuples
Nigella's Big Bites
A clutch of dead nans and a couple of live ones
Several dead pets
And...the first ever - maybe last ever?- Audience Choice week.

Join us to sail through the rest of the series on a soothing cloud of icing sugar, hoping for cosy Tuesday nights curled up on the sofa with a packet of (not just an old people thing) biscuits and the ever dwindling ranks of (maybe) Britain's Best Amateur Bakers.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
GetSetFake · 16/10/2026 07:42

@LindorDoubleChoc which Ruby? They were both stunning in their own way.

Just watched Second Helpings and Paul said they were all cheating - one person made the chunky muffin shapes and everyone behind them copied. Molly said she was at the front and it might have been her. But Connie said they were trying to roll them thinner and they wouldn't go.

@DrBlackbird I quite like it but it is mostly just people wittering on about baking. Which is right up my street but I'd think quite a small potential audience. The famous person interview is pretty pointless.

I liked Extra Slice but was better shorter, it didn't have enough material for an hour and the games were super cringey. I suspect Jo and Tom were pushed out.

OP posts:
TheSmellOfSea · 16/10/2026 09:12

That flatbread challenge was an absolute joke. I don't believe you can roast the grapes and cool them in that time. Heat oven, put grapes in, roast then cool. Yeah right! PH will have them done already. It was an embarrassment.

ChaosandCwtches · 16/10/2026 15:10

Am I just the outlier that I honestly didn’t think twice about cooling the grapes? They’re only small so they cooled a bit pretty fast and then they’re going in the pan straight anyway…

I think bung things in mixer then chop grapes, check on mix, grapes in oven and leave dough to prove.

GetSetFake · 16/10/2026 21:35

Well, I have to report - that was absolutely doable in the time. I didn't expect it to be but it was quite manageable.

I started at 5pm. Whacked the grapes in at a high temperature for 20 minutes, then started the dough. While the dough rested I was messing about with the curry to go with them.

Took the grapes out, put them on a cold plate and started shaping straight away. Had the heat under the pan as high as it would go. Made the next flatbread while the previous one was cooking. All done by 5.55.

The grapes did want to squish out of the dough but I got better at keeping them in the flatbread. Not perfectly shaped but fully cooked through and a very tasty bread.

Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!
Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!
Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!
OP posts:
AlwaysRightISwear · 19/10/2026 17:48

Yours look good!

GetSetFake · 19/10/2026 20:02

AlwaysRightISwear · 19/10/2026 17:48

Yours look good!

There are loads now on the Reddit Bake Along thread, all looking pretty good and most saying they did it pretty much in the time. I reckon Paul was right when he said panic set in and they all copied the first person who made them like muffins.

OP posts:
ChaosandCwtches · 19/10/2026 20:05

GetSetFake · 19/10/2026 20:02

There are loads now on the Reddit Bake Along thread, all looking pretty good and most saying they did it pretty much in the time. I reckon Paul was right when he said panic set in and they all copied the first person who made them like muffins.

They look so good! Were they tasty? I’m still dreaming about the feta versions I made!

Ye I think they must have copied someone and was too scared to be the outlier where sense went out the window! Saw Paul on extra helpings say they honestly are good bakers!!

TheSmellOfSea · 20/10/2026 08:00

1.5 hours would have been better in that environment.

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 08:25

TheSmellOfSea · 20/10/2026 08:00

1.5 hours would have been better in that environment.

That's generally true for technicals, they give enough time for someone who knows what they they are doing but not enough time for someone to learn as they go along. So usually you get a range from good to terrible. Because no-one succeeded this time, it looked as if they might not be physically possible in the hour. I was surprised that they definitely were.

OP posts:
Tvci5 · 20/10/2026 09:10

For everyone saying it is possible or they have managed to do it in an hour, how do you think you would do if you also had judges and presenters stopping by for a chat?

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 09:15

Tvci5 · 20/10/2026 09:10

For everyone saying it is possible or they have managed to do it in an hour, how do you think you would do if you also had judges and presenters stopping by for a chat?

I agree with you, baking in the tent with cameras and judges is a whole different ball game to baking at home. That's why I'm often very defensive of the bakers when people say they are crap.

The difference is, this challenge looked like it might be physically impossible in the time. Baking along just showed it wasn't impossible. Not that we would do better.

OP posts:
Nuttyrubble · 20/10/2026 10:01

I just found it odd that no one appeared to know what a flat bread was supposed to look like....I mean the clue is in the name. I assumed people were finding it difficult to flatten them out / make them big enough but even then small flat ones would have at least cooked and been edible and you clearly managed it in the time @GetSetFake. Was odd

AlwaysExtraHot · 20/10/2026 11:59

Nuttyrubble · 20/10/2026 10:01

I just found it odd that no one appeared to know what a flat bread was supposed to look like....I mean the clue is in the name. I assumed people were finding it difficult to flatten them out / make them big enough but even then small flat ones would have at least cooked and been edible and you clearly managed it in the time @GetSetFake. Was odd

Edited

I just found it odd that no one appeared to know what a flat bread was supposed to look like
Me too! Had no one honestly ever had or seen a naan, or a pita, tortilla, chapati, matzo...
I liked Molly but I think it was her time to go. Yannis is next if he doesn't raise his game IMO. I liked the look and sound of Gabe's showstopper, and Clara's. I think Tom was the right choice for Star Baker. Gary being Paul in the judging when Paul walked away was pretty funny. I'm enjoying this bunch; they seem fun and kind.
So sad for Nikki. I wonder if she comes back.

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 12:09

AlwaysExtraHot · 20/10/2026 11:59

I just found it odd that no one appeared to know what a flat bread was supposed to look like
Me too! Had no one honestly ever had or seen a naan, or a pita, tortilla, chapati, matzo...
I liked Molly but I think it was her time to go. Yannis is next if he doesn't raise his game IMO. I liked the look and sound of Gabe's showstopper, and Clara's. I think Tom was the right choice for Star Baker. Gary being Paul in the judging when Paul walked away was pretty funny. I'm enjoying this bunch; they seem fun and kind.
So sad for Nikki. I wonder if she comes back.

I think she probably doesn't, GBBO have posted her "goodbye letter"on social media today and they wouldn't do that if she was coming back. Really sad, but not surprising she wanted to be with her family at such a sad time.

It's an interesting point about them not knowing what a flatbread looks like, because of course they will. But when I made them, I had to add extra water because the recipe amount was not enough. Someone else on Reddit said the same thing.

So I wonder if none of them were experienced enough to go by the feel of the dough, and they all used the exact quantity in the recipe. Then had a tough dough that wouldn't roll out. That's my current theory!

OP posts:
AlwaysExtraHot · 20/10/2026 12:13

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 12:09

I think she probably doesn't, GBBO have posted her "goodbye letter"on social media today and they wouldn't do that if she was coming back. Really sad, but not surprising she wanted to be with her family at such a sad time.

It's an interesting point about them not knowing what a flatbread looks like, because of course they will. But when I made them, I had to add extra water because the recipe amount was not enough. Someone else on Reddit said the same thing.

So I wonder if none of them were experienced enough to go by the feel of the dough, and they all used the exact quantity in the recipe. Then had a tough dough that wouldn't roll out. That's my current theory!

I think she probably doesn't, GBBO have posted her "goodbye letter"on social media today and they wouldn't do that if she was coming back. Oh, sounds like she doesn't then. I will miss her bakes. She was so much fun.
I see what you mean by your theory, but I'm not sure we saw any of them trying to roll it out and saying it was too tough. They all just seemed to deliberately make those fat little muffin-style things.

Nuttyrubble · 20/10/2026 12:20

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 12:09

I think she probably doesn't, GBBO have posted her "goodbye letter"on social media today and they wouldn't do that if she was coming back. Really sad, but not surprising she wanted to be with her family at such a sad time.

It's an interesting point about them not knowing what a flatbread looks like, because of course they will. But when I made them, I had to add extra water because the recipe amount was not enough. Someone else on Reddit said the same thing.

So I wonder if none of them were experienced enough to go by the feel of the dough, and they all used the exact quantity in the recipe. Then had a tough dough that wouldn't roll out. That's my current theory!

Yes of course they must know, one of them even mentioned naan bread I think. I just found it odd that they all ended up
with odd crumpety looking things and no one did a tiny flat bread. I once made pizza dough that for some reason just wouldn't stretch / roll properly kept springing back so I just made small pizzas! Think you are probably right about the dough needing more water.

Nuttyrubble · 20/10/2026 12:24

It's a real shame about Nikki, her poor family. I really liked her. Maybe they'll let her come back in another series.

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 12:59

AlwaysExtraHot · 20/10/2026 12:13

I think she probably doesn't, GBBO have posted her "goodbye letter"on social media today and they wouldn't do that if she was coming back. Oh, sounds like she doesn't then. I will miss her bakes. She was so much fun.
I see what you mean by your theory, but I'm not sure we saw any of them trying to roll it out and saying it was too tough. They all just seemed to deliberately make those fat little muffin-style things.

It wouldn't have occurred to me but Connie said on Second Helpings they were all desperately trying to roll them thinner and they couldn't - that, plus me needing to add more water than the recipe said, made me think it might be an explanation. Or maybe they just lost their collective mind!

OP posts:
AlwaysExtraHot · 20/10/2026 13:01

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 12:59

It wouldn't have occurred to me but Connie said on Second Helpings they were all desperately trying to roll them thinner and they couldn't - that, plus me needing to add more water than the recipe said, made me think it might be an explanation. Or maybe they just lost their collective mind!

Connie said on Second Helpings they were all desperately trying to roll them thinner and they couldn't
Oh, I see. I can't remember; did they actually get a recipe? Or was it just a 'make your flatbreads' job? Surely the latter, unless Paul got his water quantities wrong and there's about to be a national scandal Grin

murasaki · 20/10/2026 14:19

What is this water madness, I make mine with self raising flour and Greek yoghurt!

CrushingOnRubies · 20/10/2026 20:05

Evening all! Was expecting to watch live this evening but here I am

GetSetFake · 20/10/2026 20:13

Only two women left? And no men gone home at all? So hard to believe they didn't have stronger women bakers to choose from.

Harsh having to hang around for over an hour waiting for your turn on this one. When they've done these in the past they've been out of the tent while they wait. This seems harder.

Can't see how Gary can achieve a saucy centre and a saucy base. I can't see how the little bit of sponge in the middle can cook. But always willing to be proved wrong.

OP posts:
littlbrowndog · 20/10/2026 20:14

I do like a lemon surprise pudding

littlbrowndog · 20/10/2026 20:15

Gary’s are lovely

bungobungobungo · 20/10/2026 20:17

Bit disappointed there’s no Sussex Pond pud but you’d need a bigger bowl for that I suppose.