Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!

635 replies

GetSetFake · 09/10/2026 11:51

Three weeks in, we've reached Thread Two and so far, mostly agreed to disagree on all things baking and non baking related including:

Diversity casting
Throuples
Nigella's Big Bites
A clutch of dead nans and a couple of live ones
Several dead pets
And...the first ever - maybe last ever?- Audience Choice week.

Join us to sail through the rest of the series on a soothing cloud of icing sugar, hoping for cosy Tuesday nights curled up on the sofa with a packet of (not just an old people thing) biscuits and the ever dwindling ranks of (maybe) Britain's Best Amateur Bakers.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 11:45

FuzzySlippers · 13/10/2026 12:29

I have no idea what you’re talking about now. I don’t think anyone else on here had said anything like that, even in the previous thread, but I certainly haven’t, ever.

You said 'The kids know from the playground that trios and upwards is trouble (Why only three? Why not four? Or five, six, or thirty?)'

There are comments on the other BO threads about how Gabe being on telly baking some cakes might encourage polygamous people to come out of the woodwork and start lobbying/agitating for the right to marry.

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 11:46

Thegirlwhowent · 13/10/2026 19:15

I love bread week. Years ago, I bought James Morton's book, 'Brilliant Bread', and tried the 'no-knead' method. I'd always hated getting doughy hands and this method transformed my life. I've made all my own bread ever since. It's easy, makes fabulous bread and saves money. Thanks to James and GBBO.

Is it soda bread that method makes, or 'normal' bread but you get to avoid the kneading?

EmptyCan · 15/10/2026 12:06

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 11:45

You said 'The kids know from the playground that trios and upwards is trouble (Why only three? Why not four? Or five, six, or thirty?)'

There are comments on the other BO threads about how Gabe being on telly baking some cakes might encourage polygamous people to come out of the woodwork and start lobbying/agitating for the right to marry.

Yes, there are some insane ‘Civilisation ends here, if there’s a throuple on GBBO!’ type posts.

What I do think the production and casting team will have definitely been sitting down together about is the casting of this season in teams of seemingly much poorer quality/more inexperienced bakers — Ruby Tandoh from season 4 writes about how much she practiced (and was encouraged to practice by the production team) before filming started, to fill in weak areas, and says that if her cohort could have been considered in any way ‘expert’ bakers, it was after they got cast rather than before. She also describes detailed phone interviews in advance of being cast about baking techniques like getting a good crust on a loaf and making meringue. If that’s still happening, then the team would have cast someone who’s been upfront about never making bread.

Because it feels slightly to me that, while they have always cast people you know will go out in early rounds, this year it was disproportionately people at that level.

AND that bread week was a bit of a disaster in that no one did particularly well at any of the challenges, and when it’s clear this is an issue with the time allotted, it’s not much fun watching the judges repeatedly poking raw dough and Baker of the Week being ‘slightly less shit than the others’ . It sounds to me as if they need to rethink both casting and what people can realistically do in the time.

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 12:08

EmptyCan · 15/10/2026 12:06

Yes, there are some insane ‘Civilisation ends here, if there’s a throuple on GBBO!’ type posts.

What I do think the production and casting team will have definitely been sitting down together about is the casting of this season in teams of seemingly much poorer quality/more inexperienced bakers — Ruby Tandoh from season 4 writes about how much she practiced (and was encouraged to practice by the production team) before filming started, to fill in weak areas, and says that if her cohort could have been considered in any way ‘expert’ bakers, it was after they got cast rather than before. She also describes detailed phone interviews in advance of being cast about baking techniques like getting a good crust on a loaf and making meringue. If that’s still happening, then the team would have cast someone who’s been upfront about never making bread.

Because it feels slightly to me that, while they have always cast people you know will go out in early rounds, this year it was disproportionately people at that level.

AND that bread week was a bit of a disaster in that no one did particularly well at any of the challenges, and when it’s clear this is an issue with the time allotted, it’s not much fun watching the judges repeatedly poking raw dough and Baker of the Week being ‘slightly less shit than the others’ . It sounds to me as if they need to rethink both casting and what people can realistically do in the time.

I can't remember old seasons enough to comment on the standards, but I should think they still have skills criteria that people have to fulfil.
Haven't seen this week's so can't comment on that.

MoltenLasagne · 15/10/2026 12:43

I got through to reserve on Sewing Bee about 10 years back which is another Love Productions show. They had quite a few qualification rounds but the questions were very much "tricky for a beginner" rather than technical sewing questions.

What I think must significantly restrict the contestant pool is the filming schedule. I was childfree and living in Yorkshire at the time and despite having a very supportive manager, ended up dropping out because of the sheer travelling time. (Entertainingly there was a woman on that season who everyone said I was the sub for because we both had similar looks and sewing styles...)

It would be exceedingly difficult to do it with:

  • young kids
  • any other caring requirements
  • a serious job that doesnt allow you to take unpaid leave
  • unstable finances or being unable to afford unpaid leave
  • living far from the filming location without the ability to temporarily move down

Also Love Productions were pretty stingy with their reimbursement for all the travel.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 15/10/2026 12:59

@MoltenLasagne

That's very interesting - I had never thought of the logisitics of such shows.

My Vet was on it, series 8 2022.

When I phoned one day for an appointment, the receptionist merely said she was away on a training course. It was some time later that it came out where she actually had been.

GetSetFake · 15/10/2026 13:14

MoltenLasagne · 15/10/2026 12:43

I got through to reserve on Sewing Bee about 10 years back which is another Love Productions show. They had quite a few qualification rounds but the questions were very much "tricky for a beginner" rather than technical sewing questions.

What I think must significantly restrict the contestant pool is the filming schedule. I was childfree and living in Yorkshire at the time and despite having a very supportive manager, ended up dropping out because of the sheer travelling time. (Entertainingly there was a woman on that season who everyone said I was the sub for because we both had similar looks and sewing styles...)

It would be exceedingly difficult to do it with:

  • young kids
  • any other caring requirements
  • a serious job that doesnt allow you to take unpaid leave
  • unstable finances or being unable to afford unpaid leave
  • living far from the filming location without the ability to temporarily move down

Also Love Productions were pretty stingy with their reimbursement for all the travel.

I got quite a long way in the Bake Off process a few times, twice while I was working full time in a very demanding job.

At that point, filming was pretty much 10 consecutive weekends, so in theory would fit around a full time job. Looking back, in practice it would have been utterly exhausting and I would probably have crashed out through sheer exhaustion quite early in the process.

You can sometimes see it, I think, some bakers lose their sparkle and are ready to go home. I thought the teacher who got about half way through the sewing bee had that kind of air about her, just ran out of steam.

I guess it might explain why there is a dearth of middle age group contestants, too busy bringing up kids and working their butts off. They have found quite a few prepared to put themselves through it in the past though.

OP posts:
GetSetFake · 15/10/2026 13:30

This just popped up on my feed, I reckon 2 hours is more like it.

Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!
OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 15/10/2026 13:44

They often say the technical "will be tricky to do in thr time" and I have thought before that its almost setting them up to fail.
I have to admit I didnt see the full episode but I saw most of the technical (critically I didnt see what the finished item was meant to look) I have made flat breads but never with a filling.

To have an oven hot enough to roast anything presumably it would need to preheat for 15 min, thats a quarter of the time gone already!

Agree its on the judges that it was impossible, even more so that the recipe in the book suggests much longer. But also think bread levels were not up to previous standards.

Fwiw I made caramel to a Delia recipe once. She said 7 minutes, it took me 3 goes, 1 extra trip to the supermarket and about 2 hours. 🤣Even the successful attempt took about 20 -30 min! Ive never attempted it again and found different recipe/methods that are a lot quicker and easier

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 13:52

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 15/10/2026 12:59

@MoltenLasagne

That's very interesting - I had never thought of the logisitics of such shows.

My Vet was on it, series 8 2022.

When I phoned one day for an appointment, the receptionist merely said she was away on a training course. It was some time later that it came out where she actually had been.

Was that the woman who said she didn’t like working on rabbits because ‘they just want to die’? She really made me laugh.

EmptyCan · 15/10/2026 13:55

MoltenLasagne · 15/10/2026 12:43

I got through to reserve on Sewing Bee about 10 years back which is another Love Productions show. They had quite a few qualification rounds but the questions were very much "tricky for a beginner" rather than technical sewing questions.

What I think must significantly restrict the contestant pool is the filming schedule. I was childfree and living in Yorkshire at the time and despite having a very supportive manager, ended up dropping out because of the sheer travelling time. (Entertainingly there was a woman on that season who everyone said I was the sub for because we both had similar looks and sewing styles...)

It would be exceedingly difficult to do it with:

  • young kids
  • any other caring requirements
  • a serious job that doesnt allow you to take unpaid leave
  • unstable finances or being unable to afford unpaid leave
  • living far from the filming location without the ability to temporarily move down

Also Love Productions were pretty stingy with their reimbursement for all the travel.

Yes, from what I understand, they only pay you for the ingredients you use while in the tent, not anything you use to practice, and the travel allowance only kicks in once you've been cast and are travelling to film, and isn't generous. And Danny the medic from season three of GBBO was eloquent in her blog about the slog of having to submit all recipes before filming (and them having to be original, so you had to do sufficient tweaking to a Nigella cake, for instance, because it would be appearing on the GBBO website and/or book and other people's recipes are copyrighted), and that she was going to bed at 1.30 am and getting up at 5 am, even before filming started, and chose savoury things to bake whenever she could because she still needed to feed her family and the stuff she was practicing had to be dinner a lot of the time. And that at least some of your success would come down to an ability to clear your schedule.

She said she saw it as an expense she went to for a hobby, like an expensive set of golf clubs!

ChaosandCwtches · 15/10/2026 14:00

Interesting what Ruby says, it makes sense that the are very much amateurs when applying (or maybe very good at one skill set) and then would just practice like madbefore the show.

Also makes sense that the time needed for practice and also the travelling and filming itself is just too prohibitive for a hell of a lot. I would love to apply but realistically can’t see how I would have the time money or energy to do a good job of it. As has been said it might be why we have less middle aged (gah is 30s middle aged!) but also maybe the producers are aware of that and have tried to lower the expectations a bit? Nobody gasped or told Mo off when he said he’d never made bread or really biscuits…

Thegirlwhowent · 15/10/2026 15:18

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 11:46

Is it soda bread that method makes, or 'normal' bread but you get to avoid the kneading?

It's normal bread! You mix the flour, yeast and water (500g flour, 350ml tepid water, 1 sachet dried yeast) cover the bowl with a damp cloth (or cling film) and leave it in a warm place for about 40 mins. (I put it on a shelf in the oven with a tray of boiling water on the bottom of the oven, which creates a lovely damp, warm atmosphere.) This bit gets the yeast working so you don't have to! Then you use a spatula to form the dough into a ball and put in back in the warm place for another 40 minutes or so. Use a spatula to scoop it out onto a floured surface and shape it, then bake it. This is honestly a lot simpler than it looks here! You don't need to be around. You don't need a warm place. You can even prove it in the fridge overnight. His book explains it better than I can!

Trotula · 15/10/2026 15:41

Enjoying all your comments on the show and agree with so many, not loving the contestants, feels very contrived!
Havent been commenting as I’m on catch up!
I remember the contestants of years gone by like Fran, Rahul and Briony May Williams who seems to have done really well post GBBO, she’s often on the telly these days.
Just turned it on to see her presenting Escape to the Country and last week in Tesco How do they do it?
Good on her!

TallagallaPenguin · 15/10/2026 15:50

GetSetFake · 15/10/2026 13:30

This just popped up on my feed, I reckon 2 hours is more like it.

Interesting!

I searched and found a YouTube video of him actually making them
1min 26s in is when the recipe starts.

Interestingly in this version he doesn’t roast the grapes - maybe that was added in to make the gbbo task more “interesting”. And although the headline says 2 hours prep, it doesn’t seem like it when you watch the video - he says to rest the dough for 10-30 mins, then fills each with filling and fries them up straight away. I can’t find an image of the actual full recipe anywhere.

This recipe has them frying for twice the time the gbbo one says, as you mention - the dough is a little different but wonder why that is? (Unless 3 mins per flatbread is patently unrealistic…). And the book recipe makes about 12 which would take longer - that would be over 1hr 10 of just frying by their timings.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/dVrZQjQwM1s?is=4WLKObPDoojyFLqY

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 15:51

Thegirlwhowent · 15/10/2026 15:18

It's normal bread! You mix the flour, yeast and water (500g flour, 350ml tepid water, 1 sachet dried yeast) cover the bowl with a damp cloth (or cling film) and leave it in a warm place for about 40 mins. (I put it on a shelf in the oven with a tray of boiling water on the bottom of the oven, which creates a lovely damp, warm atmosphere.) This bit gets the yeast working so you don't have to! Then you use a spatula to form the dough into a ball and put in back in the warm place for another 40 minutes or so. Use a spatula to scoop it out onto a floured surface and shape it, then bake it. This is honestly a lot simpler than it looks here! You don't need to be around. You don't need a warm place. You can even prove it in the fridge overnight. His book explains it better than I can!

That sounds miraculous Grin Thank you.

Tiredofitallagain · 15/10/2026 15:54

@GetSetFake Would you try again?
Sounds like I need to get onto watching the sewing bee...

Nuttyrubble · 15/10/2026 17:02

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 13:52

Was that the woman who said she didn’t like working on rabbits because ‘they just want to die’? She really made me laugh.

She was called Rosie the vet I think, made me chuckle that did.

AlwaysExtraHot · 15/10/2026 17:10

Nuttyrubble · 15/10/2026 17:02

She was called Rosie the vet I think, made me chuckle that did.

Rosie rings a bell, yes. I didn't expect her to say that Grin It was very funny.

ChaosandCwtches · 15/10/2026 18:12

I made the flatbread! Took me 40 minutes and I only made 3 but I was also making and plating our dinner the same time (the rest of the dough is going in the freezer) I also mixed up the order (should have been proving during the grapes not mixing) I rewatched the episode as well so I’ve softened my thoughts somewhat!

To give credit, I did spend longer mixing and proving than I thought I would. It also wasn’t easy rolling very thin with all the filling (paper thin Paul said!) and they did puff up quite a bit in the pan. I do wonder that if I heard “filled flatbreads” under pressure in the tent I may have had them a bit thicker. Also more credit to be given that they didn’t have a proper recipe and they deserve one now 4 episodes in!

However, if I was worried about timing I would have cut the mixing and proving time considerably, yes maybe Paul would have commented “they could have done with a longer prove” but they would have at least been edible and probably still pretty tasty let’s be honest.

I standby that the challenge was not that difficult, mine were not paper thin but they were very clearly flatbreads. The filling may have confused them but even Alison said “I think they need to be more flat!” - she was ignored completely. I would have a lot more baking respect had they made 6 edible flatbreads and not had time to make the last 2!

By the way, I used feta instead of blue cheese and they were delicious! Highly recommend having a go ! (They’re easy! 😂)

GetSetFake · 15/10/2026 19:04

@ChaosandCwtches Fabulous! Can we see a picture?

I've bought the grapes and cheese for mine but got in too late to make them tonight, so that'll be tomorrow's tea.

I think it's always going to be far harder than it looks to do the technicals blind under the pressure of the tent, but I guess having a go at home gives us an idea of whether it's even theoretically possible in the time.

Interesting you saying the order should be mix/prove/do grapes. How long did it take for the grapes to cool down? My instinct would be get the grapes going and cool them while the dough proved. But do you think I should try in the recommended order?

OP posts:
LindorDoubleChoc · 15/10/2026 20:24

Another side note from me: I saw a really striking looking young woman when out and about on my local High Street recently. I saw her twice infact, second time in the M&S Food Hall. She was instantly recognisable to me, she had quite unusual looks and stood out from the crowd, but I couldn't think where I knew her from.

It suddenly hit me when I got home - Ruby from Bake Off! She was a great contestant. She and Nadiyah (and latterly Nancy Birtwhistle) are definitely the only ones I would recognise but I haven't been a faithful viewer of all series.

Cookingdoesntgettougher · 15/10/2026 23:22

I think to go on Bake Off you’d need to start off a pretty good baker then add techniques before applying- that means learning little by little and less expensive and not in just a few weeks at the end. Also money o practice and travel - narrowing the field.

I can’t do the baking anyway, but It’s the creativity of coming up with things like hats and handbags that would stump me. Know just how far to push things. Also I’m sure there will be other criteria - must have a chocolate element when you know you’ll likely be a tent that will be hot to do a good job.

DrBlackbird · 15/10/2026 23:33

So, watched the replacement show for Second Slice and lasted no more than 5 minutes. I won’t be watching it again. But does anyone else watch and like it? What happened to Jo and Tom? Fair enough if they chose to go, but was that it or were they pushed out?

Mooselove · 16/10/2026 07:28

DrBlackbird · 15/10/2026 23:33

So, watched the replacement show for Second Slice and lasted no more than 5 minutes. I won’t be watching it again. But does anyone else watch and like it? What happened to Jo and Tom? Fair enough if they chose to go, but was that it or were they pushed out?

I have watched bits of them but thought it awful. I don't really like Judi Love and don't get the point of the interviews she is doing on them with actors.

Swipe left for the next trending thread