Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Welcome to the castle - we take it day by day | 2026 Celebrity Traitors Thread 3 [TV Pace]

1000 replies

CaveMum · 08/10/2026 21:42

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5584899-welcome-to-the-castle-we-got-fun-and-games-2026-celebrity-traitors-thread-2-tv-pace?page=1

This is a tv pace thread so make sure you’re up to date with the live broadcast and yes, previous series (regular and celeb) will be discussed.

Please no spoilers if you read them online!

The story so far (as of end of episode 3)

Traitors (still active)
Maya Jama
James Acaster (recruited)
Professor Hannah Fry (recruited)

Faithful

Jerry Hall
Joanne McNally
Joe Lycett
Julie Hesmondhalgh
King Kenny
Leigh-Anne Pinnock
Michael Sheen
Miranda Hart
Rob Beckett
Romesh Ranganathan
Ross Kemp
Sharon Rooney

Up for Murder
Bella Ramsey
James Blunt
Sebastian Croft

Murdered
Amol Rajan

Banished
Richard E Grant (Traitor)
Myha’la

Celebrity Traitors S2 | Mumsnet

Well seeing as I did the threads last year I might as well kick things off again for 2026 now that the first teaser trailer has dropped. If you haven...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mixedpeel · 11/10/2026 18:13

murasaki · 11/10/2026 18:09

Hannah also said they when talking about the faithfulamd what they do. Now she could have meant previous series, but it would have been a red flag for me, she can't pretend to identify as one and use we.

Yes, even though she was talking about previous series, she would’ve been a more convincing Faithful to say “look, we’re making the same mistake faithfuls always do: blah blah noisy ones smart ones”

The way she expressed it shows she’s not feeling aligned with the faithfuls any more.

Mimosaandonwards · 11/10/2026 18:45

I don't think the traitors know about the key yet but I expect Claudia will tell them just before they head into the woods. That may wrong foot them as up until then, they will be expecting a free choice from the four faithfuls selected.

mixedpeel · 11/10/2026 19:07

Mimosaandonwards · 11/10/2026 18:45

I don't think the traitors know about the key yet but I expect Claudia will tell them just before they head into the woods. That may wrong foot them as up until then, they will be expecting a free choice from the four faithfuls selected.

Yes, I agree this is how it will be done.

lettingthedaysgoby · 11/10/2026 19:23

mixedpeel · 11/10/2026 19:07

Yes, I agree this is how it will be done.

Bookmarked ready for Thursday when we will actually find out.

PotterHead1985 · 11/10/2026 22:06

I missed on.Friday so catching up right now

newrubylane · 11/10/2026 23:04

GobbolinoAndSootica · 10/10/2026 08:55

Wouldn't have help, it's a know statergy to include a traitorin a shortlist.

I'd have liked them put all three of themselves in, just so we can see how it plays out.😀. Might have been a good tactic for Maya and possibly James A.

On this game it might have helped though - they would have known who had the key - or could have had the key themselves. But I don't think they know about the key, so hard to anticipate. There's definitely a benefit to having a Traitor in any group in one sense - you need eyes and ears everywhere!

newrubylane · 11/10/2026 23:15

WinWhenTheyreSinging · 10/10/2026 09:36

I think it has happened more often than this, but this series Claudia made a comment that it was tradition that the first person to go had theirs thrown on the floor, and Richard’s did get thrown I’m sure?

It's the murder victims who get thrown, not the banished. So, Amol. I think she did throw it.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/10/2026 07:44

murder face to face
and they try leigh anne
she might see them or catch a glimpse

Mimosaandonwards · 12/10/2026 07:57

MrsLargeEmbodied · 12/10/2026 07:44

murder face to face
and they try leigh anne
she might see them or catch a glimpse

The door will be locked so Leigh-Anne won't be able to see them at all. Only the successfully murdered player would have sight of them.

Puppylucky · 12/10/2026 08:13

Lampzade · 11/10/2026 17:04

Maya is very smart .
She is beautiful so people obviously underestimate her , but to me she is one of the smartest of the lot .
She has been a fantastic traitor

See I really don't think she is smart. The choice of recruited traitors - largely driven by her as REG fell apart - has been very poor and she has ended up with two reluctant partners in crime who are clearly very much on edge the whole time. Her choice of murder victims also isn't particularly strategic. Marina Hyde and Richard Osman described her as only ever thinking one move ahead and I think that's an excellent analysis. She hasn't attracted any attention yet as there are more obviously vocal suspects but I don't think she'll last the course. She keeps referencing treating it like any other job but I think it takes more than that.

Boolabus · 12/10/2026 08:24

Confused why they gave Leigh Ann the key, she has a bit of heat on her so the traitors are unlikely to go for her because she is the most likely in the group to get banished. I was with Romesh on that one and now he will likely be the one to get murdered.

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 08:28

Boolabus · 12/10/2026 08:24

Confused why they gave Leigh Ann the key, she has a bit of heat on her so the traitors are unlikely to go for her because she is the most likely in the group to get banished. I was with Romesh on that one and now he will likely be the one to get murdered.

I agree which is a shame as I’d like to see more of Rom.

squashyhat · 12/10/2026 08:31

New to all this so probably a daft question. Don't the four faithfuls selected for the hide and seek game now have an advantage when it comes to the next roundtable because they know not to target each other?

OsfameronTanamoril · 12/10/2026 08:34

squashyhat · 12/10/2026 08:31

New to all this so probably a daft question. Don't the four faithfuls selected for the hide and seek game now have an advantage when it comes to the next roundtable because they know not to target each other?

No. Because one of them could be a Traitor as both Traitors and Faithfuls are allowed to be chosen.

mixedpeel · 12/10/2026 08:49

squashyhat · 12/10/2026 08:31

New to all this so probably a daft question. Don't the four faithfuls selected for the hide and seek game now have an advantage when it comes to the next roundtable because they know not to target each other?

And to add to what @OsfameronTanamoril just said, in fact they have all been put slightly at a disadvantage by being selected at all, because the other Faithful might think it’s likely that at least one of them is in fact a Traitor.

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 08:50

OsfameronTanamoril · 12/10/2026 08:34

No. Because one of them could be a Traitor as both Traitors and Faithfuls are allowed to be chosen.

And also, what with all these tasks, they know that sometimes one is given a shield so having one traitor there means they would know which one has it.

If nobody is murdered, then THAT would indicate that all 4 are faithful because they would have tried to murder Leigh Anne. But if they had thought it though they could have put the Traitor with the most heat on them in, and so they could have pretended to try and murder that Traitor thus proving that they cannot be a traitor.

So if Hannah had gone in and nobody was murdered then Hannah would obviously have been considered a Faithful.

ThatCyanCat · 12/10/2026 08:51

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 08:50

And also, what with all these tasks, they know that sometimes one is given a shield so having one traitor there means they would know which one has it.

If nobody is murdered, then THAT would indicate that all 4 are faithful because they would have tried to murder Leigh Anne. But if they had thought it though they could have put the Traitor with the most heat on them in, and so they could have pretended to try and murder that Traitor thus proving that they cannot be a traitor.

So if Hannah had gone in and nobody was murdered then Hannah would obviously have been considered a Faithful.

Are they allowed to do that? Essentially, to choose not to murder (and not when it's a choice of recruit or murder, just choose to do nothing, effectively) for strategic reasons?

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 08:58

ThatCyanCat · 12/10/2026 08:51

Are they allowed to do that? Essentially, to choose not to murder (and not when it's a choice of recruit or murder, just choose to do nothing, effectively) for strategic reasons?

Nobody knows which door they tried, or maybe only the person with a shield would know which door they tried and Traitors cannot murder Traitors so yes.

As always, there are confusions and confusions. If Hannah hadn't got the key to save herself and the Traitors has tried to murder the person with the key then there is a chance they would think Hannah knew who had the key and were trying to make it look as if she wasn't a Traitor by deliberately attempting to murder the wrong person.

But she didn't go in anyway so it doesn't matter. They don't seem to be thinking 5 steps ahead. And are resting their hopes on everyone thinking that these 4 could be a traitor in the mix.

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 09:00

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 08:50

And also, what with all these tasks, they know that sometimes one is given a shield so having one traitor there means they would know which one has it.

If nobody is murdered, then THAT would indicate that all 4 are faithful because they would have tried to murder Leigh Anne. But if they had thought it though they could have put the Traitor with the most heat on them in, and so they could have pretended to try and murder that Traitor thus proving that they cannot be a traitor.

So if Hannah had gone in and nobody was murdered then Hannah would obviously have been considered a Faithful.

How would that work? They can’t pretend to try to murder someone. The only person who avoids murder is the person with the key and that was gifted by the 4 faithfuls.

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 09:04

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 09:00

How would that work? They can’t pretend to try to murder someone. The only person who avoids murder is the person with the key and that was gifted by the 4 faithfuls.

Ahh, I think I see what you’re saying.
But then the faithfuls could also suspect that that was what they were trying to do, ie fake that Hannah was a faithful.

lettingthedaysgoby · 12/10/2026 09:31

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 09:00

How would that work? They can’t pretend to try to murder someone. The only person who avoids murder is the person with the key and that was gifted by the 4 faithfuls.

But we know they are all Faithful, the four do not - if they have watched previous series they would expect one of the four to be a Traitor, I think this is the first time the Traitors have decided not to put one of their own in the mix in this sort of task. And, as James A (who has obviously studied previous series) said - putting a Traitor in never goes well, so the four will be expecting one of them to be a traitor.

queenceleste · 12/10/2026 09:47

I really fear that the REG debacle triggered so many misssteps. Rajan would have been a more vigorous traitor (although Acaster is growing on me in the role) the first task was messed up by super kemp saving eveyone, Hannah should have refused seduction as lying doesn’t suit her personality, they shouldn’t have killed Bella (I agree with Richard Osman on ‘the rest is entertainment’).

And this hide and seek thing is already not working and will probably lose us one of the three people who
are very entertaining and leave us with some singer who has no apparent entertainment value (no offence love but there are filler contestants aren’t there?) I LOVE Rob, Kemp and Romesh. Romesh is such huge value - if he goes in this stupid task I will be massively disappointed. I feel the format is in danger of getting rid of all the interesting people.

Or maybe it will all start to work as usual despite the REG mess up; his explanation is so ridiculous “I thought everyone would say ‘I’m a traitor!’…” based on what Richard? I think he totally got lost in his own head and had a long brain fart. It’s like he’d won a prize and was so delighted that it wiped everything else from his mind like a child. Nothing else makes sense of the oddness of it.

Shedmistress · 12/10/2026 09:51

Maggiethecat · 12/10/2026 09:00

How would that work? They can’t pretend to try to murder someone. The only person who avoids murder is the person with the key and that was gifted by the 4 faithfuls.

Yes they can.

They can choose the coffin person with the key.

This is all about double and triple bluffing.

RowsOfFlowers · 12/10/2026 09:53

I think they’ll murder Romesh. That’s my gut feeling.

OsfameronTanamoril · 12/10/2026 10:06

queenceleste · 12/10/2026 09:47

I really fear that the REG debacle triggered so many misssteps. Rajan would have been a more vigorous traitor (although Acaster is growing on me in the role) the first task was messed up by super kemp saving eveyone, Hannah should have refused seduction as lying doesn’t suit her personality, they shouldn’t have killed Bella (I agree with Richard Osman on ‘the rest is entertainment’).

And this hide and seek thing is already not working and will probably lose us one of the three people who
are very entertaining and leave us with some singer who has no apparent entertainment value (no offence love but there are filler contestants aren’t there?) I LOVE Rob, Kemp and Romesh. Romesh is such huge value - if he goes in this stupid task I will be massively disappointed. I feel the format is in danger of getting rid of all the interesting people.

Or maybe it will all start to work as usual despite the REG mess up; his explanation is so ridiculous “I thought everyone would say ‘I’m a traitor!’…” based on what Richard? I think he totally got lost in his own head and had a long brain fart. It’s like he’d won a prize and was so delighted that it wiped everything else from his mind like a child. Nothing else makes sense of the oddness of it.

So agree with all you say.I hope Hannah or James A go soon, and they get a willing and fun Traitor like Joe or James Blount.
Sadly Romesh will go.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.