Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Welcome to the castle - we take it day by day | 2026 Celebrity Traitors Thread 3 [TV Pace]

1000 replies

CaveMum · 08/10/2026 21:42

Previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5584899-welcome-to-the-castle-we-got-fun-and-games-2026-celebrity-traitors-thread-2-tv-pace?page=1

This is a tv pace thread so make sure you’re up to date with the live broadcast and yes, previous series (regular and celeb) will be discussed.

Please no spoilers if you read them online!

The story so far (as of end of episode 3)

Traitors (still active)
Maya Jama
James Acaster (recruited)
Professor Hannah Fry (recruited)

Faithful

Jerry Hall
Joanne McNally
Joe Lycett
Julie Hesmondhalgh
King Kenny
Leigh-Anne Pinnock
Michael Sheen
Miranda Hart
Rob Beckett
Romesh Ranganathan
Ross Kemp
Sharon Rooney

Up for Murder
Bella Ramsey
James Blunt
Sebastian Croft

Murdered
Amol Rajan

Banished
Richard E Grant (Traitor)
Myha’la

Celebrity Traitors S2 | Mumsnet

Well seeing as I did the threads last year I might as well kick things off again for 2026 now that the first teaser trailer has dropped. If you haven...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5571945-celebrity-traitors-s2?page=1

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
sweetpickle2 · 10/10/2026 08:56

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/10/2026 08:54

Oh right - I thought that as they can vote for them in the Banishment Round table exercise they could also get rid of them in Murder games?

I stand corrected!!! (Thank you)

Don’t worry I also didn’t realise this till yesterday (my first time watching!)

I guess it makes sense though, if all traitors would have to agree to who is murdered.

StrawberryStreet · 10/10/2026 08:58

'I don't really agree about Miranda being mean. They're supposed to be there to find traitors, pick up on suspicious behaviours, see who is trying to control the game'

Yes exactly but she doesn't like it when others do it.

The teary faces when juiie went you just want them all to embrace it all and have a laugh about it.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 10/10/2026 08:59

MrsMitford3 · 10/10/2026 08:02

I also twigged that-wondered what word she meant to say.

DS (27) said maybe she used that because she meant the opinions were paying off?? Which they weren't but I take his point. Youth speak 😂

I def do not see her as wise and clever as she (and apparently others) think she is. The fawning is silly.

Ah, ten arrogance of youth.

She's hilarious because "they got rid of me because I would have worked it out so easily" is utter nonsense. Dozens of series of traitors world wide shows us that there's absolutely no way to work out who the traitors are.

Thinking, she's so clever for having got REG out...as if it wasn't the easiest traitor discovery in the whole history of this TV show 😂😂😂

StrawberryStreet · 10/10/2026 08:59

Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 10/10/2026 08:38

I think the traitors should have sent Hannah into the woods with three others.

What's interesting so far is that no one seems to suspect Maya at all. Why do you think?

It's just pack mentality isn't it, all it takes is one person to say 'oo she said..' and that's it.

ThatCyanCat · 10/10/2026 09:03

StrawberryStreet · 10/10/2026 08:59

It's just pack mentality isn't it, all it takes is one person to say 'oo she said..' and that's it.

I think it's partly that, and partly because you need to stay in the game to win, so whatever you think, there's benefit to voting and going with the tide.

Brokedownpalace · 10/10/2026 09:04

I'd like to see Hannah go, I don't think she makes a good traitor as she's too transparent/nervous.

Would love to see more of Jerry/Rob & Romesh as they crack me up, such a random threesome but it was so funny when they were impersonating her and she took it in good humour. I really like Jerry - she was the only one who questioned James A and no one took any notice of her.

Sadly I think it will be Rob or Romesh who goes, unless the Traitors knock on Leigh Anne's door which would be the best outcome.

MyFreeOpinion · 10/10/2026 09:04

I think this season is still struggling under the weight of REG's slip up.

The traitors were on the back foot from the start. The decision in relation to the first murder/recruitment was driven by those who were putting the most heat on REG, so we end up with James A. He may survive for a while, but it is not good TV to watch someone who is struggling so much with the psychic cost of being a traitor.

Then Hannah ... another terrible choice, and perhaps even worse than James. A good traitor is not someone who can appreciate intellectually what faithful and traitors do, but someone who can execute traitor behaviour. Where is her cognate experience in being able to think on her feet, strategise, deflect, tell compelling lies, etc? The hut was an example of this - when the bear was giving the clue for the shield, Hannah pointed at the portrait and stepped towards it. Having put herself in the hot seat, she didn't have a plan to follow through.

The upside for Maya is that having such incompetent partners takes the attention off her. I doubt this was intended, but I think she just have to go with it.

hholiday · 10/10/2026 09:05

RoxieLoxy · 09/10/2026 22:50

I wondered if Joe had refused to go along with it as he wasn’t asked about her. I actually found it very confusing in the context of the game as whenever they said ‘they’ I couldn’t always tell if it was the group or a small group of them, or Bella. It was very distracting.

It is so confusing. I had to read this sentence about three times in one of the reviews this morning – who has formed the clique with who? It makes no sense! By opting for the quietly canny Bella Ramsey, the turret trio not only broke up the “investigator clique” they’d formed with Sebastian Croft and Julie Hesmondhalgh

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:05

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/10/2026 08:06

I think that’s the point the poster was making.

It’s not a rule now to ask other people if they’re Traitors straight after that initial Round Table meeting where the Traitor are chosen, but in future series they may make it a rule that people aren’t allowed to question others on whether they are faithful or traitors to prevent similar REG slip-ups.

I think it would be more to the point to make it a rule that the traitors cannot admit they are traitors from the moment Claudia taps them on the shoulder. After all, every traitor bar one so far has managed to work that one out for themselves anyway.

the80sweregreat · 10/10/2026 09:06

The faithfuls are only teary eyed because they have banished a faithful and losing some allies and losing face for not finding out the real culprits!
The ones who are swayed from their original suspicions are the worst at feeling bad. They just end up following the crowd, which is probably easily done.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 10/10/2026 09:07

Maybe they killed Bella so they didn't have to keep remembering the pronouns of choice and confusing everyone by saying "they" and it not being clear of it's a person or a group being spoken about 😂

AlwaysRightISwear · 10/10/2026 09:07

malefields · 10/10/2026 00:15

I wanted Myha’la to stay a bit longer, I really liked her.

The way everyone was fawning over Bella was a bit odd and almost… condescending? Not sure how to explain it, like when adults go overboard when they hear a “mature sounding” kid and suddenly they act like they just met Einstein.

I wish Michael Sheen had more screen time!

Bella isn't a child though, she's 23.

CaveMum · 10/10/2026 09:09

Richard and Marina pointed out on Thursday night that only Faithfuls cry at the round table when defending themselves. They take it so personally because they know they are in the right. Traitors however are much less likely to cry because they’re focussed on the lying.

OP posts:
Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:09

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/10/2026 08:43

In nearly every season of Traitors, middle aged women are voted out first, along with PoC and anyone highly educated.
Good looking young people stay till the end.
That's no shade on Maya. She's brilliant. But people don't seem to realise that book smarts does not make a Traitor. People smarts more important.

Edited

How do you account for Cat, Nick and David in the first Celebrity series then?

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/10/2026 09:15

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:09

How do you account for Cat, Nick and David in the first Celebrity series then?

Niko, Tameka, Clare Balding and Stephen Fry were among the first 5 banished. PoC, middle aged, seen as clever.

It's not my theory alone. Traitor nerds have analysed UK, US, OZ and NZ series. And obviously there are exceptions to the general rule. But if you watch all the series, it generally holds true.

dontgiveafigso · 10/10/2026 09:17

AlwaysRightISwear · 10/10/2026 09:07

Bella isn't a child though, she's 23.

In today’s money, that means she is (unfortunately)

MightyCarrot · 10/10/2026 09:17

StrawberryStreet · 10/10/2026 08:58

'I don't really agree about Miranda being mean. They're supposed to be there to find traitors, pick up on suspicious behaviours, see who is trying to control the game'

Yes exactly but she doesn't like it when others do it.

The teary faces when juiie went you just want them all to embrace it all and have a laugh about it.

I wonder if they're very aware their reactions are being seen by millions and so are acting sympathetically rather than "oh she was faithful, LOL"

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:18

Sartre · 10/10/2026 07:59

I loved Hannah’s face last night when she was called “the smartest one here”. She looked so pleased. She is smart but as with all academics (myself included), in a niche field. It doesn’t mean she’s thee smartest. I actually think she’s shite at the game.

Miranda is brilliant and Maya is doing a phenomenal job so far too. Also really love Ross, he’s just so direct and you know there’s no airs and graces with him.

I don't think Hannah is great as a traitor, but she was very good as a faithful. She should probably have opted to refuse to be recruited.

If the traitors go for Leigh-Anne in the hunt, they will be doing her a favour as she will survive and it will be proof that she can't be a traitor. Unless, of course, they murder her the following night.

MightyCarrot · 10/10/2026 09:20

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:09

How do you account for Cat, Nick and David in the first Celebrity series then?

The theory isn't that every PoC, middle aged woman etc are banished one by one, but are proven across all series to be much more likely to be banished or murdered early on, possibly due to unconscious bias.

LongDarkTeatime · 10/10/2026 09:20

Brokedownpalace · 10/10/2026 09:04

I'd like to see Hannah go, I don't think she makes a good traitor as she's too transparent/nervous.

Would love to see more of Jerry/Rob & Romesh as they crack me up, such a random threesome but it was so funny when they were impersonating her and she took it in good humour. I really like Jerry - she was the only one who questioned James A and no one took any notice of her.

Sadly I think it will be Rob or Romesh who goes, unless the Traitors knock on Leigh Anne's door which would be the best outcome.

I feel for Hannah and hope she goes soon as it looks like she’s hating the Traitor role. At the Round Table when Julie was clearly going to go she looked like she was in pain. Really felt for her.

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/10/2026 09:21

OsfameronTanamoril · 10/10/2026 09:15

Niko, Tameka, Clare Balding and Stephen Fry were among the first 5 banished. PoC, middle aged, seen as clever.

It's not my theory alone. Traitor nerds have analysed UK, US, OZ and NZ series. And obviously there are exceptions to the general rule. But if you watch all the series, it generally holds true.

Update: the first faithfuls to be banished in UK Civilian Traitors S 1- 4 were all either middle aged women, women of colour or both!
The young white women or men tend to last longer as they are seen as trustworthy. Same goes for other series.
Another trend is that a woman of colour has been a Traitor in 4 out of 5 UK series. Hannah should have picked up on that.

the80sweregreat · 10/10/2026 09:21

Jerry also said Hannah too. I suppose they all work their way around everyone tbf! All suspects.

Needtosoundoffandbreathe · 10/10/2026 09:22

ScaredButUnavoidable · 10/10/2026 08:50

Edited as I realised I have quoted the wrong person!!

I was supposed to quote the poster who suggested Hannah should have gone to the crypts!

I think they should have sent Hannah too - and killed her off!

I think Hannah probably realised if she went into one of the Crypts she wouldn’t coming back.

James and Maya would take her out the game in the same way they did REG.

Ruthlessness in the name of self-preservation!

It would have shook everyone to the core if Hannah hadn’t turned up for breakfast seeing as so many of them were adamant she was a Traitor. Everyone would then start second guessing everything.

Sending home Rob, Romesh or Ross won’t really change anything as none of them were suspects anyway so it will just be the same result at the next round table of everyone going for Hannah.

Edited

Ah come on - REG took himself out of the game. James A and Maya's votes made no difference to the outcome of the round table.

ThatCyanCat · 10/10/2026 09:23

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:18

I don't think Hannah is great as a traitor, but she was very good as a faithful. She should probably have opted to refuse to be recruited.

If the traitors go for Leigh-Anne in the hunt, they will be doing her a favour as she will survive and it will be proof that she can't be a traitor. Unless, of course, they murder her the following night.

She knew she'd be murdered if she refused.

But maybe more faithful should make the supreme sacrifice. Wasn't there one once who knew they were trying to recruit her because there was heat on her and she was expected to be banished, and so she refused? Can't remember what happened after that.

augustuss · 10/10/2026 09:25

Fortuity · 10/10/2026 09:18

I don't think Hannah is great as a traitor, but she was very good as a faithful. She should probably have opted to refuse to be recruited.

If the traitors go for Leigh-Anne in the hunt, they will be doing her a favour as she will survive and it will be proof that she can't be a traitor. Unless, of course, they murder her the following night.

Leigh-Ann could be under suspicion for surviving (key or not).
The game is set up in a way that it is impossible to prove you’re not a traitor.

ETA Completely agree re Hannah.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.