Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Will Finn go bad? Will he and Elly get it on? Will Robert get Paul? Will Harlow get a make over and snog Hendrix? Did Karl put that sex toy back in the box... Neighbours...

999 replies

SleepingStandingUp · 23/01/2020 19:10

No spoilers, by order of Lou and Harold

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
SpanishFly · 24/07/2020 10:37

Agreed. And I still dont think her dad was particularly unreasonable in being uncomfortable with having lost a son and gained a daughter.

SpanishFly · 24/07/2020 10:39

@BluePajamas

No she def said Lance!
No. She said "Ned's". The subtitles are wrong. Remember the person editing the subtitles is literally typing/respeaking what they hear too. Just because the subtitles say it doesnt mean it's correct.
Stellaris22 · 24/07/2020 10:44

Mackenzie isn't doing this 'just because she can' though, you can't compare it to things done on a whim.

I do think Neighbours could have gone more in depth with this story, the counselling and showing the genuine desire and why the character wants to do this.

Of course the character is excited, this is her becoming who they truly see them self as.

I'm actually glad the other characters haven't been negative, it would be deeply unpleasant to watch.

I don't see it as 'pushing an agenda' either, it's one of many storylines. Soaps are used to discuss current issues, if you are offended then just stop watching.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 10:49

My ears heard Lance, I reckon the Neds amongst you heard what you thought it should be 😂
I think Shane and her dad's reactions have been quite true whereas no one else even questioning extensive surgery within days of turning 18, half way through an important school year, is a little disingenuous

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 10:56

I'm actually glad the other characters haven't been negative, it would be deeply unpleasant to watch. but thry could do it without it being nasty. No one is suggesting that. But even having her and Harlow having a conversation about some people's normal fears. Mackenzie is Charly here to educate and inform so don't good over it. They've done a good job so far but this feels quite rushed imo

OP posts:
SpanishFly · 24/07/2020 15:34

I've listened to it a few times. Besides the fact that she gestures to Ned as she says it, and besides the fact that there is NO Lance in existence, it sounds nothing like Lance 😅
Maybe I've just got a better quality TV 😜 (I don't)

WitchSharkadder · 24/07/2020 16:00

I agree with Sleeping. My personal opinions regarding under 18s beginning hormone treatments aside, I think Neighbours are doing a bad job of portraying this storyline. There's been no mention of counselling, no discussion about the negatives (physical, social or emotional) and for any young person questioning their identity, it's all been too 'easy' which is hardly an accurate portrayal.

I know Neighbours aren't particularly known for their realism, but with very sensitive plots I do think there is some responsibility to accurately reflect people's actual experience.

Samcro · 24/07/2020 16:10

why was the party so naff? there were only a few people there.
I hate the mackenzie story. making out like having life altering surgery is nothing.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 16:16

@WitchSharkadder

I agree with Sleeping. My personal opinions regarding under 18s beginning hormone treatments aside, I think Neighbours are doing a bad job of portraying this storyline. There's been no mention of counselling, no discussion about the negatives (physical, social or emotional) and for any young person questioning their identity, it's all been too 'easy' which is hardly an accurate portrayal.

I know Neighbours aren't particularly known for their realism, but with very sensitive plots I do think there is some responsibility to accurately reflect people's actual experience.

And the actress has been such a driving force behind so this isn't like a baby on prison where clearly no one has a frigging clue, she knows not everyone is so easily won over, she knows there's a harder battle. They've put lots of work in, got to the surgery and suddenly it's all easy peezy She did tell Shane and Dip she'd be in for a week. But even that was like yeah ill totally keep on top of my work, I won't need much support as you both have full time jobs and I told my aunt not to bother. There won't be tons of hospital scenes so thry could have pretended her aunt was there. Awks convo with Richie about sex (if we can do threesomes and Harlow having sex I think we can cope with an Awks teenage sex chat, or even the lads ribbing him. I do wish we could keep Ritchie full time, I like him. I'd def pick him over Hendrix if I was 17
OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 16:17

@SpanishFly

I've listened to it a few times. Besides the fact that she gestures to Ned as she says it, and besides the fact that there is NO Lance in existence, it sounds nothing like Lance 😅 Maybe I've just got a better quality TV 😜 (I don't)
You're wrong, hth 😂😂😂😂 Lance is a random wrong name for several of us Inc the subtitler to hear,
OP posts:
MiddleClassProblem · 24/07/2020 16:20

Lance should come back. What ever happened to that actor?

happilybemused · 24/07/2020 17:31

Loved Paul's reaction to Harlow already hiring Toadie as a lawyer.

To be fair he's got a point ... not a great track record 😂

SpanishFly · 24/07/2020 19:37

Yes it is very random. And also wrong 🤦‍♀️

SpanishFly · 24/07/2020 19:38

Oops that was in reply to it being a random name for viewers and the subtitler to hear.

It's clearly not Lance, even if it sounds a bit like it.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 22:15

I agree it's wrong, she def said the wrong name 😂😂😂😂

OP posts:
woodhill · 24/07/2020 22:21

@SleepingStandingUp

I just think they're completely skipping over how people react to this in real life. When Shane wasn't 100% excited at the start she was trans he was the worst person ever for even questioning it. Harlow would be asking about her fertility and zjendrix her sexual pleasure. Her Aunt would absolutely come over rather than just being ah k, it's just a little op. There's been no talk about whether she's had therapy or really discussed this with anyone. I think they covered the issues with her Dad quite well, the bad kid at school but that lasted 5 minutes, no one has ribbed Richie for being with a "guy" and I don't think all kids are so cool that wouldn't happen. It isn't that they shouldn't show her going through it, it's that if they're going to feature it quite heavily I'd expect a little bit more challenge and discourse
Totally agree and Dipi was particularly annoying and harsh towards the dad, it's not your child Dipi having the operation.

Richie was the one blackmailing and snooping on Ellie I think and suddenly he's all tolerant. Most boys would run a mile from this situation

SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 22:51

I caught up today, OK Dips expressed kild concern and that dick was mean to Ritchie so that's a couple of the points I complained at the lack of.

Also think it's weird Shane and Dips are with her not her ACTUAL FAMILY.

I can't remember Ritchie being a bad kid, and agree it's a suprise that he's been so cool with it all but I think to a degree this generation is a it less suprised by it all

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/07/2020 22:58

Dean is the bad one who blackmailed her first, Ritchie tried it in but he's def redeemed himself with Mac

OP posts:
AGnu · 25/07/2020 03:19

I know why there's the Lance/Ned confusion, both characters are equally wet & boring - easy to mix them up!

The pre-op scenes were ridiculous - it was clearly written from a teen's fantasy of how everything should go POV. Everyone's oh so supportive, the adoring family members are prepared to fly across the country but nobel Mackenzie is so brave & doesn't need any more support than some random locals - the hand-picked ideal "family." There's a minor miscommunication with the attractive, mature, supportive boyfriend which is resolved when he turns up just in the nick of time & the people wheeling the bed towards the operating theatre stop & melt into the background so he can profess his love. Once the romantic moment is over, the nurses/porters spontaneously reappear to continue wheeling the triumphant Mackenzie towards destiny & a perfect future.

I'm still Hmm about Susan's earnest "we'll work around whatever you want" speech. As if she wouldn't have encouraged Mackenzie to wait until the holidays. I'm assuming they do have a long school holiday at some point? Isn't Mackenzie due to do the HSC this year? Seems irresponsible for all the adults to be such yes-men & not suggesting getting exams out the way before undergoing major, elective surgery!

Also, Elly spilling her guts to women she'd just met - as if! She'd be a lot more guarded, especially after the whole Karl/Olivia thing. And sleeping with Shaun in the garden... Who lives next door? As if the neighbours wouldn't all be peering over & gossiping about it! Nice of Aster to stay asleep while they were getting it on. For a baby whose mother complains about her sleeping patterns, I'm more concerned with how much she sleeps! Oh, and that fade-out kiss - hilarious! Grin

I'm glad Koxy have sorted things out but I'm already bored of the Sheila/Levi secret. I can see it now - she finally confesses when he's already feeling dodgy & it pushes him over the edge & he has another seizure in front of her but it'll be a bad one that hospitalises him & she'll be wringing her hands at his side.

How did Therese think telling a police officer that they'd be "in his debt" if he got her step-granddaughter off a drug charge was anything other than an outright bribe?! Tbh, I think she's lucky he was a dodgy cop - Mark would've arrested her for that, unless he wanted to sleep with her. Then he'd have finished what Harlow started & had a bumbag BBQ. Still not sure why she didn't just drop the whole thing in the fire when she found it. The evidence would've been destroyed before the police arrived!

Sorry, I binged the week this evening & can't sleep - bad combination! Blush Did I miss any storylines? I know Kirshy turned up for 5 seconds but, let's face it, no-one cares about that! Oh - I missed the bit where Lance quit his job for his art. Any reason why he couldn't go part time, or just ask for the job back since he doesn't seem to have any art stuff lined up? Maybe EH are looking for a new art teacher to replace that one who's never been mentioned before but has suddenly had to rush off to tend to a sick relative leaving poor Susan in the lurch. He could connect with Emmett over their shared love of art & before we know it, Emmett will be heading off on a full scholarship to an art school in Outer Mongolia without any parental supervision. Probably waved off by his social worker, if anyone remembers he's fostered & thinks to inform them.

MiddleClassProblem · 25/07/2020 08:08

Yes the two socially distanced kisses have been funny. Elly and Shaun’s was filmed before lockdown but they were already being cautious so they could lean in but Roxy’s and Kyle’s was after. That must have been so awkward to film!

Clawdy · 25/07/2020 08:14

AGnu don't think you missed a thing! Perfect summing up of the Mackenzie story.

SpanishFly · 25/07/2020 08:54

I was only half watching- when was Kyle and Roxy's distant kiss?

MiddleClassProblem · 25/07/2020 09:03

When they decided to give it ago. I think it was Friday last week but might be wrong.

SpanishFly · 25/07/2020 09:33

Thanks. I didnt even notice. I must pay more attention 🙈

SleepingStandingUp · 25/07/2020 16:26

a teen's fantasy of how everything should go POV.
yes thats exactly whats wrong with it

And sleeping with Shaun in the garden
sheila: ooh did you hear some shouting yesterday afternoon?
levi: i did have some report of suspected coyotes...

why she didn't just drop the whole thing in the fire when she found it
well id have opened it and upended it, not slowly go through it waiting for the owner to notice

a new art teacher../. connect with Emmett
perfect

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread