can I ask you what you think of this garment without entering into discussions about price/ practicality/ lifestyle etc?

[Stargazing]

ta

I think it's gorgeous

Looks like its from a catalouge.

I think it's lovely unless you have broad shoulders. Then it will look odd.

Quite nice but reminds me a little of a Quality Street sweet wrapper.

i don't like it personally, but if you try it on and it suits you, well, go for it.

Don't really like the one shoulder thing myself. Nice colour though.

looks a bit cheap IMO

its really nice - what are you planning to wear it with/
are you really skinny/

naaaaaaasty
imo

not for me

quality street wrapper!!! yes!!! too funny.

Sorry, has that ruined it for you?

I think its a top best suited to skinny minnies.

loosk a bit square shaped

not reeeeeally skinny, am a size 10 and quite tall (5'10")

prob wear with skinny jeans and heels.

Not broad shoulders. Quite bony up top, all my weight is on my bahooty.

Coloring - olive skin (am anglo-portuguese- indian mix) with dark hair.

No JulietBravo, not at all. I wanted honest opinions and yours was more entertaining than most. And i see your point!

it will probably look terrific on you then!

it would look horrible on me.

gross. sorry!

Yeah, now I can see it!

ninah, what do you mean?

It would look vile on me, but great on you - go for it.

I don't like it

agree with Quality Street

I mean same as expat. Terrific on you. I'd look monstrous in it
Are you out somewhere special

not for anything in particular. Am just heading home for the Southern Hemisphere summer (ie, avoiding the English winter) and my mum will be on hand to babysit while I catch up with lots of old friends. So am trying to take advantage of the summer sales here so that I have nice capsule wardrobe for there. It's all quite glam where I'm from and I've fallen into that jeans/ tank top habit over here which I never would've done back home. It's not really me, but I've become a slave to convenience. Trying to get back to my old self, despite having children very close together.