Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Which coat is nicer?

34 replies

Christmasinnewyork · Today 17:31

I want a smart, long, slightly oversized coat.

First one is Zara, it’s lovely on as I tried it in the shop. No belt though, but does that matter. It comes in 4 colours, which colour is the nicest?

https://www.zara.com/gb/en/soft-oversize-coat-p03046329.html?v1=559627833&utm_campaign=productShare&utm_medium=mobile_sharing_iOS&utm_source=red_social_movil

Second is this one, again a nice coat, it has a tie waist belt. I’m just not sure which o prefer can you help me choose 🙏

https://www.asos.com/stradivarius/stradivarius-long-high-neck-soft-touch-coat-in-brown/prd/211766193?affid=29144&freelisting=yes

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Blanketwaffle · Today 20:23

I'd try and get one with a fair bit of wool in it, you will be much warmer.

EleanorMc67 · Today 20:28

Just an example of a 100% wool grey herringbone oversized wrap coat from Jigsaw on eBay - this is a 10 & £83 - or nearest offer so potentially much less. Mightn't be your size or the colour you want, but it's just an example of the vastly better quality (& warmth & longevity) you can find for the same sort of price from Vinted/eBay or in the sales.

As said above, why throw your money away on polyester?

https://ebay.io/m/zmhXgJ

EleanorMc67 · Today 20:28

Forgot photo.

Which coat is nicer?
PrettyLittleRose · Today 20:37

Christmasinnewyork · Today 17:31

I want a smart, long, slightly oversized coat.

First one is Zara, it’s lovely on as I tried it in the shop. No belt though, but does that matter. It comes in 4 colours, which colour is the nicest?

https://www.zara.com/gb/en/soft-oversize-coat-p03046329.html?v1=559627833&utm_campaign=productShare&utm_medium=mobile_sharing_iOS&utm_source=red_social_movil

Second is this one, again a nice coat, it has a tie waist belt. I’m just not sure which o prefer can you help me choose 🙏

https://www.asos.com/stradivarius/stradivarius-long-high-neck-soft-touch-coat-in-brown/prd/211766193?affid=29144&freelisting=yes

The first one definitely (from Zara.) The other one looks frumpy and awkward. And I don't like the neck. (The collar.)

.

HugoThatway · Today 20:42

Neither. I don't like the asos one at all. The Zara one looks ok.

greenheetah · Today 20:44

Zara is much better.

Christmasinnewyork · Today 20:59

This is the Zara coat on of or makes any difference to opinions.

Which coat is nicer?
OP posts:
EleanorMc67 · Today 21:04

No - as it's not the shape as such that's the issue.

Why waste money on something 100% polyester pretending to be wool, when you can get at least a decent wool-blend for the same amount new, or 100% wool on Vinted/eBay?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread