Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Which coat is nicer?

35 replies

Christmasinnewyork · Today 17:31

I want a smart, long, slightly oversized coat.

First one is Zara, it’s lovely on as I tried it in the shop. No belt though, but does that matter. It comes in 4 colours, which colour is the nicest?

https://www.zara.com/gb/en/soft-oversize-coat-p03046329.html?v1=559627833&utm_campaign=productShare&utm_medium=mobile_sharing_iOS&utm_source=red_social_movil

Second is this one, again a nice coat, it has a tie waist belt. I’m just not sure which o prefer can you help me choose 🙏

https://www.asos.com/stradivarius/stradivarius-long-high-neck-soft-touch-coat-in-brown/prd/211766193?affid=29144&freelisting=yes

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Doggymummar · Today 17:43

I like a brightly coloured coat to make a statement so I'm no use on this one. Sorry

garlicandgherkins · Today 17:45

No 1 looks much more stylish but I don't like coats with belts like number 2. Remind me of dressing gowns.

Greenwriter76 · Today 17:49

I’ve got an F&F coat like number one in colour and material which was roughly the same price. I also like the style of number 2 but think number 1 looks better quality?

Wishimaywishimight · Today 17:52

Much prefer the first one. I hate coats with belts, i always think of my mother saying they look "like a featherbed tied in the middle" 😁

parrap · Today 17:53

Zara is No.1 for me definitely. It seems to fit and sit much better than ASOS one. And I don't like belts either BTW so there's that!

TheFlyingPenguin · Today 17:53

Zara coat - I hate belts on coats, never have them. Colour wise not the black or grey.

CharlotteSometimes1 · Today 17:55

The Zara coat looks mega cheap

parrap · Today 18:03

CharlotteSometimes1 · Today 17:55

The Zara coat looks mega cheap

It looks fine to me.

Have you seen any ultra expensive looking alternatives in the same price range?

desperatemum1234 · Today 18:04

Zara in gray

Whatsthemoneyfor · Today 18:06

Two looks warmer 1 am I giving my age away here? 😄, but I prefer the Zara one style wise.

Christmasinnewyork · Today 18:13

I tried the Zara one on today and it is actually gorgeous, it’s nicer in real life in my opinion.

It’s longer in me as I’m 5”5 so it’s quite long and oversized. I tried it on in cream and brown.

’ also not sure about coats with belts, but I possibly prefer the colour of the Asos one and it has the funnel neck.

OP posts:
Dulcima · Today 18:16

Love the Asos one - a bit different and looks classy

ItsmeMargo · Today 18:21

I prefer the ASOS coat.

luckylavender · Today 18:23

I can’t bear coats with belts. But I don’t think the Zara one has enough buttons to be warm

FindingMeno · Today 19:27

The Zara one.
I'm loving cream at the moment in jackets, but I love brown and practicality dictates that I'd go for brown in a coat.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 19:30

The ASOS one is a more classic shape. Both look very polyester though.

Fast800goingforit · Today 19:38

ItsmeMargo · Today 18:21

I prefer the ASOS coat.

Me too. It's more current with the funnel neck and I like the wrist detail and the belt.

PerfectPaula · Today 19:41

The ASOS one by a country mile.

EleanorMc67 · Today 20:08

Wait for the sales & buy this instead. Or keep an eye out on Vinted/eBay. It was on eBay the other day for £56 & had one bid!

Or go try on wool or at least wool-mix coats in various shops, so that you know what suits & fits you in various brands & styles, & set up searches on eBay/Vinted. You will get lucky with one, & have a good-quality coat that will keep you warm & still look great next winter & beyond.

Both those coats might look fine from a distance but are 100% polyester & will look it up close. They're microplastic-tastic & won't wear well either.

https://www.whistles.com/product/morgana-wool-funnel-wrap-coat-41602.html

Taupe Morgana Wool Funnel Wrap Coat | WHISTLES | Whistles UK |

Shop the Taupe Morgana Wool Funnel Wrap Coat at Whistles. Order now.

https://www.whistles.com/product/morgana-wool-funnel-wrap-coat-41602.html

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · Today 20:13

I like the first one best but both are nice.

unlike lots on here, I do like coats with belts

EleanorMc67 · Today 20:15

52% wool from Mango, & the beige & grey are reduced to under £100.

https://shop.mango.com/gb/en/p/women/coats/coats/handmade-oversized-wool-coat/37006332/96/00

Which coat is nicer?
Which coat is nicer?
HardShoulders · Today 20:15

The Zara in brown.

Ruthietuthie · Today 20:18

Both are 100% polyester. Plastic. Neither will keep you warm and both will looks shoddy and misshapen after just a few wears.
They are rubbish - rubbish to wear, rubbish looking very soon, and rubbish for the planet.
Don't buy either. In the long term, you would be throwing money away.