Thank you! I'm still figuring out what I like, even the basics. It's as if 'sweet does not equal sweet', as there are so many nuances to even sweet scents. I would love to smell a really nice vanilla (took some notes from this thread), which is sweet, but apparently there are sold differences amomg vanilla scents.
I agree with your memories of Oilily. I still have a bottle of the original and just sprayed it. Unfortunately it's changed too much over the past 30+ years and has developed an unpleasant dominant note. I don't understand why they discontinued it. I had the shower gel too and it was blissful.
As for Chanel No. 19, are you describing the EdT or EdP? Or Poudré?
Today I was in a local drug store, with low expectations. If anything, my expectation was met that I dislike most scents. The only ones I found pleasant enough were Betty Barclay Wild Flower and Elizabeth Arden Green Tea (I remembered @paristotokyo mentioned it), which actually smells like tea to me. The store didn't carry Chanel which I would have liked to try, and TBH I generally also go by the packaging, which usually implies to me I would not like the scent (female body shapes, lace, big 3D flower sculptures, ribbons, ots of gold...).
The only ones I sprayed on my wrists were by Korres: Vanilla Freesia (a bit dark and pungent for me) and Black Vanilla (smokey and dark, could imagine this on an attractive guy). Sorry for rambling...