Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

How did you end up with clothes you don’t like?

109 replies

Flomasterina · 20/09/2026 23:13

I am curious to learn from others’ mistakes. What have you bought that you look at now and think - WTF was I thinking?

I am not talking about clothes that don’t fit you anymore or that have gone out of fashion like skinny jeans.

Over and after pandemic I had a bit of style reset and focussed on buying better, not chase sales and learning about good fit and composition. I have consumed a lot of content about capsule wardrobes and French women style rules, which appealed to my minimalist mindset, I get easily overwhelmed by variety.

Where I went wrong big time was buying too many expensive black items (worst colour on me), thinking they will be my forever pieces. I have kept my black coats (I can break up the colour with tops and scarves) and leather skirt, but sold on silk shirt, satin skirt and jumper. Same with camel / tan, it’s just not me.

My other mistake is compromising on something because I just loved the idea, or felt desperate to close the gap and kept it when I should have returned. This is mainly shoes too painful to wear, or a navy blazer that fitted perfectly but looked like something from 6th Form, or a great cropped jacket but in the wrong colour.

OP posts:
LimeShaker · 21/09/2026 22:51

Beebumble2 · 21/09/2026 09:16

Panic buying to match something I’ve already got. Examples - yet another white top because the others aren’t the right style. Sparkly ‘somethings’ to look Christmassy. Summer dresses to look ‘romantic’ for an evening stroll on holiday.
All of which end up in the charity shop, but I know I’ll do it again!

all of this!and buying things in a few colours because I like them….never works for me!

Megamegablahblah · 21/09/2026 22:56

This makes me feel better! I got my colours done in the pandemic but didn't address style, so ended up with a lot of coloured items.

I find merino wool just to hot to wear too.

MissyB1 · 22/09/2026 08:52

genuineflexor · 21/09/2026 19:46

Buying things that look beautiful on skinny, tall, tanned models but not on a middle aged overweight not model . I bought a very very expensive beige trench coat on the basis I would look elegant and expensive but it made me look like Frank Spencer.

Frank Spencer 🤣🤣

I bought a dark navy trench coat and dh asked me if I had joined the Police force 😂

dayslikethese1 · 05/10/2026 09:27

Yes to buying things for a life you're not living; my wardrobe clearly thinks I'll be invited to a fancy bohemian garden party....tbh I've started just wearing stuff and not worrying about being 'overdressed'.

dayslikethese1 · 05/10/2026 09:29

My main mistake is buying white; I like it but can never seem to make it stay that way.

DeafLeppard · 05/10/2026 09:51

HardStopAt4 · 21/09/2026 09:13

I went through a phase of trying to buy classic 'forever' pieces as wardrobe staples instead of fast fashion. I spent quite a lot on some of them but then tbh I just got bored of them all. I seem to change taste every few years - not really following fashion but just wanting to try out a totally new style.

This. I think "forever" pieces are a bit of a misnomer. I also don't suit camel at all. I find it better to buy middle of the road or cheap stuff as I know i'll get bored of it or it will get dated over a couple of years. So i have £5 gold fine hoops from Sainsbury's, not the £100 ones from Missoma becuase i can guarentee you thatn by 2028, large fine gold hoops will look dated and I won't want to wear them.

I'm much better at returning stuff, and have a higher bar of entry into my wardrobe. Or at least try stuff from Vinted before spending $$$.

dayslikethese1 · 05/10/2026 10:09

I never like the things on those classic/capsule lists; I don't want to wear a crisp white shirt or a smart blazer or some brown brogues😄 It's just not me.

AdeleRochester · 05/10/2026 10:29

dayslikethese1 · 05/10/2026 10:09

I never like the things on those classic/capsule lists; I don't want to wear a crisp white shirt or a smart blazer or some brown brogues😄 It's just not me.

Well then build a capsule of things you do like and wear regularly. You don’t have to follow someone else’s rules!

mcmuffin22 · 05/10/2026 10:34

I mostly really like what I buy... but the stuff that I end up not wearing is either not warm or cool enough. Eg. A summer dress in a slightly too heavy fabric so would always need another layer that makes it look odd. Or eg. A short sleeved jumper - cold arms even though wearing a jumper. I try to find work arounds and then wonder why I just didn't but something more useful to suit the fact that I want to feel the right temperature. My best recent buys are lovely lightweight wool scarves from vinted in colours that suit me. I wear them constantly (and easy to stick in my bag if it's too warm).

italianlondongirl · 05/10/2026 10:39

NestaVipaz · 21/09/2026 08:47

I buy clothes for versions of me which are never going to manifest. The version who works in a city office (I’m retired in a country town). The version who has regular cocktail/lunch dates with the girls (you’ll find me down the pub with my OH on a Friday night). The version who dines at high-end restaurants on holiday in the South of France (pizza in a back alley). The version who delivers academic papers at international conferences (pub quiz anyone?). Like pp, the version who is regularly invited to glamorous parties (neighbourhood barbecue once a summer maybe). I just can’t stop styling all the lives I never have and never will live. Some sort of wish fulfilment I suppose.

Haha. You’re spot on… But you should try to go out more in those clothes… you sound great fun!!

boredsmored · 05/10/2026 10:40

These are my rules

Do not buy items that are impractical as I wont wear them.
Do not buy a top or bottom without having something to wear with it already otherwise you never wear it.
Do not buy things that aren’t me, they have to be my style & fit my life.

tobee · 19/10/2026 15:27

Being too slow to send an item back in the returns window. Usually because I have dithered

minnowonthesay · 19/10/2026 17:44

I just buy too many clothes, mostly high street, and the law of averages says some won’t work - I call it my hobby 😬 as I don’t really have any others and I’m quite good with a sewing machine so can alter things too.
I used to buy far too many handbags, now I’m quite good and buy better bags as I think they can make a high street/supermarket outfit look better.
I have got so much better at selling stuff on Vinted that I’ve worn once and thought nope, not for me.
I also try to do the if it’s not worn in two weeks then take it back thing, but that doesn’t always work for me if I buy summer clothes in March and winter clothes in August.

TwoGingerEars · 19/10/2026 18:51

I'm seduced by the colour. I had my colours done aeons ago and I know what suits me. So I zoom in on the navys, the blues, the dusty pinks. Lovely.
Except that I seem to be blind to the effect of the colour/style combo. So I don't see that the full skirted dress in cornflower blue is giving an Alice in Wonderland vibe. And the navy pleated skirt looks like school uniform. And the pink jumper isn't 'granny chic' on me, just granny.

MakemineaGandT · 19/10/2026 19:05

This is such a good thread!

I’ve spent the last two years slowly clearing my wardrobe of anything that no longer suits me/feels weird nowadays/is a poor version of something I already own in a better version. This process has been quite revealing and I’ve thought a lot about how I decided to buy the things I have, and what decision-making process I’ll go through in adding to my wardrobe in future. Some thoughts!:

I’m totally guilty of the ‘sucker in the sales’ phenomenon! I now try to think ‘would I have wanted this at full price?’ and proceed accordingly!

im also guilty of buying for a ‘fantasy life’ (especially buying too many summer clothes!). Realistically most of the year im in jeans and some sort of top.

I no longer buy knitwear with acrylic in it. I know it bobbles and looks rubbish. I now only wear wool, cashmere, cotton etc (and these are things I look for in the sales).

I no longer buy handbags made of faux leather. Like acrylic knitwear, it’s a waste of money. I have just bought a new leather clutch from Vinted - fraction of its original price and nothing wrong with it.

I now listen to that inner voice with its first reaction when trying something on. If it feels ‘off’ somehow, I no longer compromise, no matter how much of a ‘bargain it is’.

I too spent too long buying things I thought I ought to have - the ‘classic/capsule wardrobe’ ideal. I’ve realised I feel very frumpy if things look too prim/perfect. I’m much better at knowing what really suits me - I’d describe my ideal look as classic with a twist - simple colours/interesting shapes/bold jewellery. I think most of my ‘mistakes’ have been in this regard, and I’ve sold a lot of my more predictable/‘safe classics’ on Vinted. I now don’t bother looking at Hobbs, Phase Eight, Jigsaw etc as I have wasted so much money there in the past!

I’m in my early 50s and it has taken me a very long time to get to this point where I feel confident about what suits me and what to buy. It feels great, and I hope I will stay on this path now!

mtobrokeme · 19/10/2026 19:13

I’m 43 and I have settled on my style. Think ‘This is England’, ‘Stone Roses’ and ‘adidas Originals’ and I’m an amalgamation of all three. It suits me, I’m comfortable and I’m happy to look a bit ‘different’! However, I have friends who are very much ‘in fashion’, and on occasion, when my defences have been low and I’ve wanted to fit in, I have been known to venture into the realms of high street fashion. I look a pillock and I feel like a pillock! Even my friends will say ‘you don’t look like you’! And I take that as a compliment now! Stick to what I know and style it like I want and in my personal opinion I look fucking brilliant!!

tomorrowfollowstoday · 19/10/2026 19:15

I don't think I own anything I don't like. I've got two tops that are slightly dodgy colours but they're fine under a jumper.
I don't have many things, and if I love something I buy a second one.

Vegetablespringrolls · 19/10/2026 19:17

I have 2 polyester monstrosities that the inlaws bought me for Christmas in the back of my cupboard. One is black and the other is leopard print. I would literally rather wear a bin bag.

MakemineaGandT · 19/10/2026 19:21

Vegetablespringrolls · 19/10/2026 19:17

I have 2 polyester monstrosities that the inlaws bought me for Christmas in the back of my cupboard. One is black and the other is leopard print. I would literally rather wear a bin bag.

Sell them on Vinted and buy something else with the money! Some people love polyester monstrosities and will snap them up 😁

catteabook · 19/10/2026 20:51

I was terrible for buying things that I think look nice as an individual item, whilst ignoring the fact that it wasn’t my style, wouldn’t go with anything in my wardrobe and/or maybe required some ‘high fashion’ styling that as a wfh school mum in a northern town was never going to get worn.

so when hanging in my wardrobe said item just looked stupid in isolation, and I didn’t like wearing if, even though stand alone it was a ‘nice’ item of clothing.

not sure I’m explaining this very well!!

anyway I have made a conscious effort to stop doing this now, and although I am drawn to certain pretty, or avant garde or beautiful fabric items I’m better at going but I wouldn’t actually ~like~ to wear this myself and let it be.

Huckleberries · 19/10/2026 21:03

I just go off stuff for no reason

Then of course, if I give it away, I end up thinking I should’ve kept it

I think being able to see so much online hasn’t been good for me. I bought a load of stuff a few years back that I thought would comfortably form the basis of my wardrobe for a long time. It was good quality so it could’ve done, but I got bored within two years.

Then I try and go for neutral colours and I miss colour

Then I see people wearing neutrals and I think oh that’s brilliant

Now I’m faced with the reality of living much more quietly, I see tons of stuff that just wouldn’t fit in my life!

@catteabook I know exactly what you mean. And then if you do buy that one item you actually need to buy other stuff to fit with it. I think if you enjoy putting together outfits and you have unlimited budget, then it’s fine. But otherwise no.

I love the idea of a capsule wardrobe, but in reality, I would just be too bored with it

LikeABell · 19/10/2026 21:11

I’ve been stung more than once by all the capsule wardrobe, must-have key pieces nonsense.

White shirts.
Trench coats.
Expensive knitwear.
(*See also ‘summer edition’ - white jeans, ‘throw on’ denim jacket)

It’s taken me almost 50 years to work out what suits me and I will never again be duped by the above!

FKAT · 19/10/2026 21:22

Big fluffy jumpers, usually pink - buy a load every winter and then remember that you can't fit them under a coat AND they make me look like 80s era Sharon Watts

Cardigans - I look like Miss Trunchball. Luckily I stopped buying them years ago but my mother still knits them for me.

Crisp men's style blue shirts - these WOULD suit me if I ever got them tailored OR could be arsed to iron.

Sensible basic neutrals - such as a grey Whistles work skirt I never wear because it's so boring it makes me want to slit my throat. Still cant get rid of it because it's Whistles and it's the kind of thing a professional middle aged woman SHOULD have.

I have the opposite problem to PPs in that I have the wardrobe of a woman who would ideally spend her time walking the dog in the woods but actually do go to theatre / restaurants / fancy offices. If only I could just wear Nike leggings, a fleece and DMs to them.

Thecows · 19/10/2026 22:19

Whenever I buy something it looks utterly fantastic on me, I then cut the label off and it all goes Cinderella like and the clothes (and me) just turn into mice and pumpkins. Literally the minute I snip the label poof, I look completely rubbish but now can't return said item !

Puppylucky · 23/10/2026 07:49

Thecows · 19/10/2026 22:19

Whenever I buy something it looks utterly fantastic on me, I then cut the label off and it all goes Cinderella like and the clothes (and me) just turn into mice and pumpkins. Literally the minute I snip the label poof, I look completely rubbish but now can't return said item !

Are you me? Before Vinted I wasted so much money on mysteriously shape shifting clothes that waited until I was out in public to reveal exactly how awful they looked. At least now I can get some money back.