Liberty Beauty Drop Spoiler (from the despatch date!) Part 9

[Unpaidviewer]

I hope no one minds me starting a new thread. I couldn't see one.

There's a new GWP for beauty purchases over £200.

• Ultimate Gift with Purchase includes:
• Maria Nila Head & Hair Heal Shampoo 100ml
• Maria Nila Head & Hair Heal Conditioner 100ml
• Skin Rocks Retinoid 2 30ml
• Sunday Riley C.E.O Afterglow Brightening Vitamin C Cream 8g
• Hourglass Caution Deluxe Mascara 3.8g
• Suqqu Aqufons Hydrating Lotion 30ml
• Philip Kingsley Daily Damage Defence Leave in Conditioner 60ml
• Bamford Geranium Body Wash 50ml
• Sisley Paris Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream 10ml
• Zelens Daily Defence Sunscreen SPF30 OR SPF50 OR Daily Defence Mineral Sunscreen SPF30 50ml
• Sunday Riley C.E.O. 15% Vitamin C Brightening Serum 5ml
• Fugazzi PASSIONFROUDH Eau de Parfum 8ml
• MALIN+GOETZ Grapefruit Face Cleanser 30ml
• Skincycles Silk Bio-Cellulose Sheet Mask 25ml
• Liberty LBTY. Fragrance Wild Rosinda Eau de Parfum 8ml
• L:a Brucket Hand Cream 30ml in Lemongrass OR Bergamot/Patchouli OR Sage/Rosemary/Lavendar OR Hinoki OR Grapefruit Leaf OR Elder OR Spruce OR Angelica OR Wild Rose
• Vilhelm Parfumerie Moon Carnival Eau de Parfum 10ml
• Contents worth over £387
• Housed in a Liberty Phoebe print wash bag

I can't justify spending £200 at the moment, it's a nice mix but small sizes and so many repeats!

As usual they’ve over estimated the value by £200. The bag it comes with is very pretty but not practical for me.

They say Moon Carnival is 10ml, but in the photo it's definitely a 1.5/2ml sample in the picture!

More Bamford and Philip Kingsley 🙄

The two perfumes are both very nice - but I don’t need anything. Self imposed buying ban for a few months.

That’s not a great GWP for a £200 spend, particularly if it’s a tiny Moon Carnival rather than the 10ml. Too many things we’ve seen time and time again, and didn’t go wild for first time round.

That's a deal breaker for me. 10ml and I'd be interested

I’m on the fence about this. I’ve been waiting for a GWP, as the April/May one is usually good. There are many repeats and stuff I’m not interested in with this GWP though. Do we think there’ll be a better GWP along? That bag suggests it’s the main GWP they’ll be doing.

I actually think it’s not bad at all - much better than the previous one. The skin rocks and zelens look to be full size, if the Moon Carnival is 10ml that would be three travel sized perfumes, which is pretty good. While they’re small, I really like the Sunday Riley and Sisley products. The shampoo and conditioner are 100ml each, which is a decent travel size too. So overall, I think if you were waiting to buy stuff you wanted anyway, this would be a good opportunity to do so.

I don't think it's that bad, just too many repeats for me which has made it an easy decision not to go for it.

Disappointing for me, I have £120 credit plus a £10 voucher burning a hole in my pocket but there’s not a lot in this I fancy, especially as I will have to add my own money to meet the threshold spend.

I’ll hang on till they do a decent edit and then I’m cancelling.

I also have £100 or so in credit and a £10 voucher but I don't think I fancy this. What I want is an amazing kit.

@wheresmyshoe I’ve just checked with Liberty and the moon carnival is only 2ml. Like you I would have got the kit if it was 10ml

Thanks very much for checking @MyCatsSlave

My disappointment at the moon carnival only being 2ml has put me off getting it - they have missed a trick there. Liberty used to do such good GWPs/boxes/kits but have really gone down hill lately. Too many minis in this. The only thing that slightly appeals is the Wild Rosinda, and I'm sure they will be on ebay at less than £20 following the release of the GWP so maybe I'll just wait for that.

I've ordered as it means I can use up my Beauty Drop credit and a loyalty voucher. I'd have preferred a good kit but there you go. There are a few things that will be handy for trips away, I like the Suqqu lotion and I've been surprisingly impressed with the Skin Rocks retinoid 1. Some of the rest and probably the wash bag will be hitting Vinted as part of my pre-move declutter.

The thing about my beauty drop credit is that it doesn't feel like real money so I don't feel guilty about the big bottle of Dyptique hand lotion I ordered for my desk...

Ooh I was already thinking what to buy as I read the product list but confirmation for the Moon Carnival being only 2ml has made me pause now.

I would have dived in even though I actually bought Moon Carnival in 50ml recently but I really do love it and a travel size would be great. Now, I have time to think and not jump into spending £200 on impulse and I know I won't be too disappointed if it sells out while I decide.

I really do like Wild Rosinda though, and it's an obscene price to buy on its own so ....hmmm

Oh no!! I was really looking forward to a new GWP as there are some things I need and have credit. Bamford and PK is not luxury to me and it’s in everything - I must have 20 in my wardrobe. I can’t get rid of the skin rocks stuff, and I wasn’t impressed with that shampoo last time they stuck it in a GWP. It would be really nice to have some new stuff, and luxury items, even if there were less of them.

Agreed, I really don't want any more Bamford or PK. I am planning a bit of a birthday splurge (my presents to me are always the best ones ) but this isn't enticing me to spend a chunk at liberty

Am exactly the same @WindsurfingDreams My birthday in two weeks and I always get something lovely from Diptyque to me but this bag doesn't tempt me at all. I thought, with the 3 monthly beauty boxes especially, it was a chance to try new products but Bamford and Zelens have been in almost everything.

Or maybe I am just all beautied out...

I've been waiting for a GWP - but so many repeat items in this one, again! Maybe they only want to attract new customers, people who haven't had Beauty Box or GWP before.

It's an okay GWP but a lot of repeats for BD members. I'd get it if I was planning to buy something but I'm not. I guess my advent calendar fund is safe once again.

Too many repeats for me too. I do need some basics but will just get my usual from Beauty pie. Hoping the advent calendar is good this year as am racking up credit

I was away till last night. Agree that the Bamford stuff never feels particularly luxurious, but I’m going away for a few days next week so it will come in handy. Ditto small face creams.

I like it as a treat and I’m storing credit for the advent calendar so I’m sticking with it for now. But I get as much fun from the Look Fantastic box which is substantially cheaper!

Has anyone actually caved and got the GWP?
I'm curious about the Fugazzi eau de parfum.