Best high street mascara that isn’t Benefit They’re Real?

[BumboBaggins]

I flip flop between different brands - looking for one I love that I come back to time and again. That used to be Max factor masterpiece max - maybe I should revisit it?

They’re Real didn’t do it for me sadly (which actually I’m not disappointed about as it’s fairly ££). Nothing too spendy.... More interested in lengthening and curling than fullness. Thanks in advance!

Tried lots of mascaras for curling. Found best to be Benefit Roller Lash.

I've tried just about everything and have bought Maybelline Collosal in the yellow tube the last 5x. I buy the one with the purple writing on it as I have sensitive eyes and it comes off with water so I don't need to use makeup remover. Stays put though ,doesn't shift.

I love max factor. I recently revisited the the 2000 calorie one from my youth in black brown and found it actually is fab! The natural feeling wand is great for separating lashes compared to the plasticky spikey ones with other brands.

Lancome hypnose is the best ever.

Rimmel Extra Long Lash. I have used this for years and have never needed or wanted to change. Its £5.99.

Maybelline lash sensational

Max factor 2000 calarie waterproof is better than the expensive brands I've tried (have naturally long lashes so hatenit when they go clumpy or spiky)

I really like the waterproof version of Lancôme's Monsieur Big. It has great staying power!

Nyx doll eyes is excellent for lengthening and curling, it's a tubing mascara and it's only around £8. That and my cheapo eyelash curler gives me better eyelashes than the diorshow one i used for years.

No7 stay perfect (gold tube). The biggest issue I have with mascaras, no matter how much I spend, is it giving me panda eyes - this one doesn’t!

Nyx Doll Eyes.

Best I’ve ever used especially fir staying out and not smudging.

• for staying put.

The purple maybelline one, lash sensational

I love L'oreal Telescopic (I have tiny stubby blonde lashes and it's the best I've found for me)

Lash sensational (plus ideally the primer which makes a massive difference and is super easy to use) here too.

My absolute favourite is lan come hypnose. Best value though is maybelline lash sensational

Im quite interested in reading these responses, because I’m absolutely certain that the ‘they're Real’ mascara made my eyelashes snap off! Before using this mascara I had naturally long curly lashes, and this reduced them to little stumpy things?
I’m tempted to try roller lash as I’ve heard it being raved about, but don’t know if I trust the benefit ones now

@PreseaCombatir roller lash was ok for me but that's it, for the price tag you would expect very good or great, not just ok. I found that I would still layer lash sensational over it

I love Rimmel Scandal Eyes Reloaded. It's a tubing mascara and really lengthening. It's the one in the orange packaging. £5.99.

Rimmel day 2 night is amazing and I’ve tried loads

Splash out: Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme

Budget:
L'Oréal Miss Manga

I just got winky lux so extra mascara. It’s amazing! £14 and so worth it!

L'oreal Telescopic

The best mascara I've ever used is also one of the cheapest - I Need A Miracle by Essence. It's about £3 and it doesn't clump, adds volume and length and actually tints your lashes gradually with every application. You can buy it at Wilkinson's but if you don't have one nearby, justmylook.com sell it and it's free postage on all orders.

Here you go