How do I decide?

[Tobermory]

So... I ordered myself a present in the Coach sale. I ordered a couple cps I wasn’t sure about colours. They arrived a few days ago but the problem... I 💕 them both!!
The ‘berry’ is lovely. Exactly my kind of colour. Fantastic colour. I get it out of the box and think perfect bag for me.
But then I get the pale pink one out-no idea of the name- it’s just gorgeous. So pretty. Beautiful. Love it. Too summery?
So wise fashionistas of mumsnet, what are your thoughts.

The berry is lovely and looks expensive. I don’t really like the pale pink - plus I imagine it would provably get a bit grubby looking eventually.

The berry is really lovely - I am trying not to look at their website. I am on a no spend 2019 and it is only the 14th January and already I am lusting over a handbag!