Please or to access all these features

Odd AI-generated thread title options in Site Stuff

8 replies

AmIAComplete · 04/10/2026 19:33

AIBU Response Schema v1.0: Structured adjudication for interpersonal reasonableness posts about family support during a child’s serious illness, with special handling for ND context and empathy calibration. Use this schema to produce concise, practical verdicts and communication guidance without escalating stigma or family conflict unnecessarily. The assistant should assess whether the poster is being unreasonable, acknowledge the child’s medical context, weigh the brother’s expectations and possible ND-related rigidity, and give a clear, forum-style ruling plus brief actionable advice. Definitions: 'AIBU' = 'Am I Being Unreasonable?'; 'ND' = neurodivergent/neurodivergence; 'DD' = dear daughter. Safety/quality constraints: do not diagnose anyone; do not demean ND people; do not imply a sick child owes social performance; do not overstate certainty about motives; distinguish the child nephew’s needs from the adult brother’s message; prioritize compassion, boundaries, and de-escalation. Output should be parseable JSON matching this schema exactly, with no extra keys, comments, or prose outside JSON. In verdict, choose one of the enumerated values. In confidence, give 0..1. In core<span class="underline">judgment, give a short forum-style judgment. In reasoning, briefly explain balancing factors, including that serious illness and treatment commonly affect energy/mood; the brother may be stressed but his complaint is misplaced; ND can explain disappointment but not obligate the ill child to perform. In advice, include immediate emotional validation and one or two practical next steps (e.g., do not engage tonight, send a calm boundary later, loop in parents only if needed). In suggested</span>reply, provide a short message the poster could send to the brother, neutral but firm, avoiding argument. In tone<span class="underline">flags, indicate whether the response should emphasize empathy, boundaries, de-escalation, and whether to avoid legal/medical advice. In risk</span>notes, note any caution about the poster’s acute stress and potential family fallout. minor<span class="underline">child</span>considerations should explicitly state that children’s wellbeing takes priority over adult expectations in family gatherings when a child is newly seriously ill. nd_sensitivity should acknowledge ND respectfully while rejecting its use as a trump card over another child’s health needs. Keep outputs concise but humane, roughly the level of a supportive forum reply translated into JSON fields.

Weird shit on AI title options

But the AI worked on this post

KatyMumsnet · 05/10/2026 08:37

Hi everyone, thanks for flagging this, and sorry for the confusion.

I can confirm that we’re not using AI to write threads or replies.

The issue raised by the OP is an issue with our thread title suggestion tool, which uses AI to suggest a title when you’re writing a new thread. It’s entirely up to the thread creator whether to use that suggestion. The tool doesn’t post anything on anyone’s behalf.

We’ll look into what’s going wrong and get it fixed as soon as we can.

KatyMumsnet · 05/10/2026 08:56

It uses the opening post draft and the topic selected to suggest a relevant title.

The prompt may look complicated, but that’s all it’s asking the AI to do.

KatyMumsnet · 05/10/2026 10:15

Hi all. A bit more detail on this, as my earlier reply didn't really cover it.

To be completely clear: we don't use AI to write threads or replies on Mumsnet. Not OPs, not replies, not to bump threads, not for anything else.

We do use AI to suggest a thread title when you're writing a new thread. You don't have to use it. This is the full prompt it runs on:

You are generating title options for a Mumsnet thread.

Return exactly 1 candidate title.

Requirements:

* 8 to 14 words each.
* Clear and neutral tone.
* Avoid clickbait or sensational language.
* Avoid personally identifying details.
* Keep UK spelling and style. Don't use em dashes.
Output as plain text containing only the title.

As you can see, that's nothing like the text AmIAComplete got. Our tech team have checked the tool and its logs, and they're confident it didn't come from us. Our best guess is that something else was running on the device while the post was being written, such as a browser extension, keyboard app or writing assistant.

@AmIAComplete, if you can tell us which device and browser you were using, and whether you have anything like that installed, it would help us get to the bottom of it. We're not doubting what you saw.

JustineMumsnet · 05/10/2026 11:52

Hi everyone, Justine here. I wanted to come on myself, because things have got a bit confused on this thread and I want to be completely clear about what happened.

We've now got to the bottom of it, and AmIAComplete, you were absolutely right: this did come from our thread title suggestion tool. Thank you for flagging it, and I'm sorry, both that it happened and that our earlier post suggested it might have come from your device.

The tool works by sending your draft to OpenAI, which is meant to send back a single suggested title. On this occasion, instead of a title, it sent back a long set of notes describing how someone might reply to the post. That's what appeared in the title box. We can't see inside OpenAI's model, so we can't say exactly why it did this, but it looks like an error on their side. It's still our tool, though, and what shows up on Mumsnet is our responsibility.

Our first check of the logs wasn't thorough enough, which is why we told you it hadn't come from us. That was our mistake, and not Katy's, who was passing on what she'd been told.

To be really clear, we don't use AI to write threads or replies on Mumsnet. But I completely understand why people are wary of AI on forums. So if someone who knows about these things would like to examine our code to confirm that, I'd be very happy to arrange it.

Later today we're adding a check so that if the AI ever sends back anything that isn't a short, sensible title, it's thrown away and you won't see a suggestion.

Thank you again for raising it.

JustineMumsnet · 05/10/2026 12:08

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 05/10/2026 11:59

@JustineMumsnet , with respect, this is the third different explanation that we have been offered by MNHQ this morning.

Are your moderators, or those who are guiding them, not trained to investigate matters thoroughly before posting spurious explanations on the site which don't stand up to scrutiny?

Do you recognise that this kind of issue seriously damages trust in the Mumsnet brand, and that the dodgy attempts to explain it away merely undermine the credibility of the site even further?

Yes I certainly recognise that posting too quickly without really getting to the bottom of things can be a mistake (i've done it enough times myself!) but equally you'll know that not responding promptly often leads to wild speculation and people thinking the worst, particularly where Ai is concerned. So it's a bit of a balancing act. Nonetheless we weren't thorough enough this morning and I'm sorry about that. I want to assure people though it wasn't because we've anything to hide - more cock up rather than conspiracy!

SueMumsnet · 05/10/2026 17:20

Hi all - thanks for your feedback. We're going to look at what we can do to make the thread suggestion tool more obvious and opt-in. In the meantime, whilst we figure that out, we've turned it off for now.

JustineMumsnet · 06/10/2026 16:29

Hi everyone,
Thanks for continuing to raise questions. I understand why this has unsettled people, particularly the discovery that draft text was being sent to OpenAI while you were writing. I also understand why our incorrect initial explanation has made the subsequent one harder to trust.

Here are some direct answers to questions that have come up on this thread.
We have never tested AI-generated responses to threads on Mumsnet. We do not use AI to write threads or replies.

The draft text sent to OpenAI for a title suggestion is not used to train its models. There is an opt-out from using that data for training, which we obviously chose. We receive no payment for sending draft text to OpenAI.

We introduced title suggestions to help avoid duplicate thread titles and make starting a thread easier. We recognise that removing friction can benefit users, and we approached this as a tool to help people start threads. But I understand that people feel differently about unpublished drafts, which may contain things they ultimately decide not to share. We should have made it clearer how the tool works and given people the option to opt out. As Sue said, the tool is switched off while we look at making it clearer and opt-in.

On moderation, we use AI to help flag potentially problematic posts for our team to review. A human always makes the moderation decision.

Finally, as said previously, we should have investigated more thoroughly before suggesting that something on the OP’s device might be responsible. I’m sorry for that, and for the understandable frustration it caused.

Thank you to the OP for flagging it and to everyone who has taken the time to explain their concerns.

JustineMumsnet · 09/10/2026 13:01

Hi all,
Some answers to the questions that have come up since my last post.

First, on the prompt tool to be clear we’re no longer sending any draft text to OpenAI. When we switched title suggestions off, we stopped sending anything, not just stopped showing the suggestion.

When the tool was operational, all that was sent was the text of the draft and the topic, to generate a title. No usernames, email addresses or account details were included, and OpenAI doesn’t use this data to train its models.

When I previously said 'We have never tested AI-generated responses” I should have also said that we haven’t built one, haven’t tested one and have no plans to. Mumsnet doesn’t use AI to write any posts or replies on the site. We understand how important it is to keep Mumsnet human.

On name changes, which are a crucial part of feeling comfortable posting here: I want to reassure you that AI can't link people’s posts across usernames.

When we say posts used in research are anonymised, we mean we don't share any personally identifiable information and we don’t join anonymised posts together using an account identifier. Partners get trends and themes, and occasionally an anonymised quote from a public post, not anything that identifies the individual wrote it.

Our moderation and tech teams can see posts alongside registration details, because that’s needed to moderate and run the site. As our privacy policy explains, we keep that access to a minimum and review it regularly. If you deregister, your posts stay up, but your email address and other registration details are deleted, so they’re no longer connected to your posts. The one exception is the IP address you registered with, which we keep for moderation purposes.

I hope that’s helpful. The point of our insights work is to show what parents in general think and care about, not to profile anyone. We take individual privacy very seriously, and we know anonymity is fundamental to Mumsnet. People speak frankly here because they can, and it’s the people, not the technology, that make Mumsnet what it is.

Thank you for all the questions. It’s been useful to set this out clearly, and we’ll look at adding something to our guidelines and policies that spells it out for everyone.

Justine

Privacy Policy | Mumsnet

This policy explains the way that we collect, use and protect your data to support Mumsnet, Gransnet and other Mumsnet products (we will refer to this range of products under the name ‘Mumsnet’ throughout this policy), as well as your choices with rega...

https://www.mumsnet.com/i/privacy-policy

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread