Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would you consider this cheating?

121 replies

KellyK2026 · 15/11/2026 19:25

Posting for a friend because I’m crap at relationship advice and really don’t know where I stand on this one.

His wife goes out with friends, gets drunk, starts talking to an attractive young man, gets his number and then later messages him asking him to contact her if he ever needs anything. She doesn’t tell her husband and he just discovers the texts. More embarrassing for him as he knows this bloke.

I can see it’s a breach of trust, but would you class this as cheating?

OP posts:
JLou08 · Yesterday 21:55

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 21:24

Please quote me where I said she was cheating? I clearly state at the start that I didn’t know what to think of it. I’m fairly sure if I wanted to go out of my way to break them up I would’ve just told him that I think it’s cheating rather than asking for other people’s opinions. My opinion at the beginning was that I wasn’t sure it was cheating (still not) but I can clearly see that it broke a boundary as he had kicked her out and was still upset about it. People have different ideas of what cheating is, which is why I asked different people the question.

"Simply put, if I was a random woman who he asked for my number when he was drunk I would assume he had a sexual interest in me" That's implies the wife had a sexual interest in the man.

"Most people have said they’d consider it cheating so you’re in the minority." Pointing out that the majority think it's cheating, that implies you think so too.

My previous post: Could you not say the same about the messages?
His wife got talking to a young woman who injured her hand and she felt sorry for her so took her number and text her saying let me know if you need anything.
Next day wife thinks silly me offering help to a stranger when I was drunk. I'm glad she didn't take me up on it.
Sounds very innocent when you put it that way.

Your response:
"Not the same thing at all" Implies that the wife was in the wrong but you are not. Why do you feel the need to argue that you are so different? Why can't you accept that a woman can form a friendship or offer help to a man she felt sorry for when she met him, unless you think that is cheating.

So you may not have said it outright but your comments do imply that, or at the very least that you think she had intent.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 21:55

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 21:48

And if she is she’s more than free to talk to a close friend about it. In fact I think that would be great if she talked to a close friend about it.

I'm sure she doesn't need you permission.Are there any children involved? Did you ever date her husband? What does he think about you airing his marital issues?

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 21:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:01

JLou08 · Yesterday 21:55

"Simply put, if I was a random woman who he asked for my number when he was drunk I would assume he had a sexual interest in me" That's implies the wife had a sexual interest in the man.

"Most people have said they’d consider it cheating so you’re in the minority." Pointing out that the majority think it's cheating, that implies you think so too.

My previous post: Could you not say the same about the messages?
His wife got talking to a young woman who injured her hand and she felt sorry for her so took her number and text her saying let me know if you need anything.
Next day wife thinks silly me offering help to a stranger when I was drunk. I'm glad she didn't take me up on it.
Sounds very innocent when you put it that way.

Your response:
"Not the same thing at all" Implies that the wife was in the wrong but you are not. Why do you feel the need to argue that you are so different? Why can't you accept that a woman can form a friendship or offer help to a man she felt sorry for when she met him, unless you think that is cheating.

So you may not have said it outright but your comments do imply that, or at the very least that you think she had intent.

Yes, from experience when a drunk man has approached me in a bar to ask for my number it has always been with the intention of something else happening.

And pointing out what the majority have said does not mean that I think it too. Frankly, I think if he’s decided to take her back he needs to get on with it and move on instead of arguing about it with her. If he’s going to continue to argue with her then they probably would be better to break up as that’s not particularly nice for the kids.

OP posts:
YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:06

I think this is good advise to your friend OP, either he is fully into his wife and forgives or he gets on with it and drops you. You should tell him that.

GumyBand · Yesterday 22:07

JLou08 · Yesterday 21:55

"Simply put, if I was a random woman who he asked for my number when he was drunk I would assume he had a sexual interest in me" That's implies the wife had a sexual interest in the man.

"Most people have said they’d consider it cheating so you’re in the minority." Pointing out that the majority think it's cheating, that implies you think so too.

My previous post: Could you not say the same about the messages?
His wife got talking to a young woman who injured her hand and she felt sorry for her so took her number and text her saying let me know if you need anything.
Next day wife thinks silly me offering help to a stranger when I was drunk. I'm glad she didn't take me up on it.
Sounds very innocent when you put it that way.

Your response:
"Not the same thing at all" Implies that the wife was in the wrong but you are not. Why do you feel the need to argue that you are so different? Why can't you accept that a woman can form a friendship or offer help to a man she felt sorry for when she met him, unless you think that is cheating.

So you may not have said it outright but your comments do imply that, or at the very least that you think she had intent.

How would we all be feeling if the husband had got the number of a 19 year old girl and was texting her the same thing? After drinking. In a club?

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:08

GumyBand · Yesterday 22:07

How would we all be feeling if the husband had got the number of a 19 year old girl and was texting her the same thing? After drinking. In a club?

I've got a funny feeling thats exactly how OP met her close friend 🤣 either its all cool or it's not.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:09

GumyBand · Yesterday 22:07

How would we all be feeling if the husband had got the number of a 19 year old girl and was texting her the same thing? After drinking. In a club?

That’s my thoughts. Comparing someone getting pissed and them asking a stranger for their details and then messaging them and not telling their partner is NOT the same as someone opening up to a decades old friend (who they have zero sexual history with) about what happened.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:13

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:09

That’s my thoughts. Comparing someone getting pissed and them asking a stranger for their details and then messaging them and not telling their partner is NOT the same as someone opening up to a decades old friend (who they have zero sexual history with) about what happened.

Edited

If those are your thoughts you should tell him that. You seem quite sure of your friendship with him is much more appropriate than what his wife has done. Do you like her? What about her children? Do you have many close friends that happen to be other women's spouse?

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Another personal attack. I'm sorry that you feel this way.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:15

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:13

If those are your thoughts you should tell him that. You seem quite sure of your friendship with him is much more appropriate than what his wife has done. Do you like her? What about her children? Do you have many close friends that happen to be other women's spouse?

Look, you’ve seemed to create a scenario in your mind where I’m into my friend and am actively trying to break them up. If it makes you feel better to think that, then go for it. But I don’t see what you’re achieving by constantly commenting fairy tales about my life. I accept you think that so now it’s probably time for you to move onto pastures green.

OP posts:
YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:19

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:15

Look, you’ve seemed to create a scenario in your mind where I’m into my friend and am actively trying to break them up. If it makes you feel better to think that, then go for it. But I don’t see what you’re achieving by constantly commenting fairy tales about my life. I accept you think that so now it’s probably time for you to move onto pastures green.

Edited

You know what, asking questions that you've ignored and saying my opinion isn't creating a scenario anymore than the one you've made about his wife.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:23

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:19

You know what, asking questions that you've ignored and saying my opinion isn't creating a scenario anymore than the one you've made about his wife.

To be completely honest, I’m ignoring your questions because you seem completely off your trolley. You don’t know me at all and you’ve implied that I fancy my friend, that I met him pissed at a bar, etc. it’s weird. You’re reporting my comments every time I say something that you don’t like and claim it’s a ‘personal attack’ when that’s all you’ve done on this Thread (I’m mature enough not to report your fanciful comments). As others have pointed out, it’s childish.

OP posts:
YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:30

Yeah, trying to doxx isn't in the spirit. If mumsnet have deleted your comments its because they agree. But you know that don't you?

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:32

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:30

Yeah, trying to doxx isn't in the spirit. If mumsnet have deleted your comments its because they agree. But you know that don't you?

I somehow very much doubt that as you seem like someone who can dish it out but not take it. As I said, I accept you think that I’m into my friend and that I’m trying to break him and his wife up, so unless there’s anything else you’d like to add I don’t see the point in continuing this conversation, do you?

OP posts:
YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:39

Nope, peace out OP.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:40

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 22:39

Nope, peace out OP.

Grand

OP posts:
BillieWiper · Yesterday 22:44

Needs anything?! Unless they discussed a potential professional relationship and she was contacting him about a product or service she sells (hopefully not sex on the sly?!)- it's definitely shifty and attempting to cheat?

What does she give as the explanation for it? And does he respond to the text?

It's not looking good for her at all!

WaryCyanStork · Yesterday 22:45

I don't think it's cheating. Being overly helpful to someone with an injury sounds very much like something I'd have done in my younger/drunker days.

I do think it's a sign she could be interested in cheating. I'm not denying that. I still don't think it's proof.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 22:48

BillieWiper · Yesterday 22:44

Needs anything?! Unless they discussed a potential professional relationship and she was contacting him about a product or service she sells (hopefully not sex on the sly?!)- it's definitely shifty and attempting to cheat?

What does she give as the explanation for it? And does he respond to the text?

It's not looking good for her at all!

Nope. Apparently he has a slight injury to his hand and she felt sorry for him (she doesn’t have a medical background). She didn’t know why she offered help and said she just didn’t handle her drink well. My friend isn’t particularly jealous (that I know of) and was more upset that she just didn’t mention it to him. The young man in question didn’t respond and my friend has absolutely nothing against him as he wasn’t to know and he much younger.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page