Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would you consider this cheating?

121 replies

KellyK2026 · 15/11/2026 19:25

Posting for a friend because I’m crap at relationship advice and really don’t know where I stand on this one.

His wife goes out with friends, gets drunk, starts talking to an attractive young man, gets his number and then later messages him asking him to contact her if he ever needs anything. She doesn’t tell her husband and he just discovers the texts. More embarrassing for him as he knows this bloke.

I can see it’s a breach of trust, but would you class this as cheating?

OP posts:
Bandbros · Yesterday 19:06

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:01

No, because I’m like family. His wife doesn’t have an issue with me at all. It’s weird that people are trying to reframe this as him trying to cheat for opening up to a close friend.

I wouldn't care who he was confiding in or how close they were, I'd see it as a far bigger betrayal than a drunken offer of help that would likely never be taken up anyway.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:07

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:06

I wouldn't care who he was confiding in or how close they were, I'd see it as a far bigger betrayal than a drunken offer of help that would likely never be taken up anyway.

Is it a bigger betrayal because I’m female and he’s a male? I’m sure you wouldn’t say that if I was male.

OP posts:
Bandbros · Yesterday 19:11

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:07

Is it a bigger betrayal because I’m female and he’s a male? I’m sure you wouldn’t say that if I was male.

I'd be very unhappy if he was analysing our marriage with anyone, but yes, it makes a difference that you're female, in the same way that I don't suppose he'd have an issue with her offering to help a female aquaintance.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:12

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:11

I'd be very unhappy if he was analysing our marriage with anyone, but yes, it makes a difference that you're female, in the same way that I don't suppose he'd have an issue with her offering to help a female aquaintance.

Then that’s sexist.

OP posts:
Bandbros · Yesterday 19:12

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:11

I'd be very unhappy if he was analysing our marriage with anyone, but yes, it makes a difference that you're female, in the same way that I don't suppose he'd have an issue with her offering to help a female aquaintance.

I also really can't imagine any male friend being so invested they'd go on line for help in supporting their friend.

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:13

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:07

Is it a bigger betrayal because I’m female and he’s a male? I’m sure you wouldn’t say that if I was male.

Could you not say the same about the messages?
His wife got talking to a young woman who injured her hand and she felt sorry for her so took her number and text her saying let me know if you need anything.
Next day wife thinks silly me offering help to a stranger when I was drunk. I'm glad she didn't take me up on it.
Sounds very innocent when you put it that way.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:14

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:13

Could you not say the same about the messages?
His wife got talking to a young woman who injured her hand and she felt sorry for her so took her number and text her saying let me know if you need anything.
Next day wife thinks silly me offering help to a stranger when I was drunk. I'm glad she didn't take me up on it.
Sounds very innocent when you put it that way.

Not the same thing at all

OP posts:
Bandbros · Yesterday 19:14

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:12

Then that’s sexist.

Lol. I said I'd object to him discussing it with anyone. If it's sexist to say it makes a difference you're female, would he have the same problem if she'd been talking to a woman. Does that make him sexist too?

Plus you are far far too invested.

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:15

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:14

Not the same thing at all

Because it's not you and your bestie?

Step back and talk to yourself honestly.

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:15

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:14

Not the same thing at all

Why not?
Why does gender matter in that situation but not yours?
I don't think there's clear betrayal from husband or wife in this situation.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:15

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:14

Lol. I said I'd object to him discussing it with anyone. If it's sexist to say it makes a difference you're female, would he have the same problem if she'd been talking to a woman. Does that make him sexist too?

Plus you are far far too invested.

It’s sexist to presume a man and a woman who have been friends for years have a sexual interest in each other when there’s no indication of that. I’m not some woman he met on a night out when he was drunk.

OP posts:
KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:16

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:15

Why not?
Why does gender matter in that situation but not yours?
I don't think there's clear betrayal from husband or wife in this situation.

Because I’m not some random woman lol

OP posts:
JLou08 · Yesterday 19:17

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:16

Because I’m not some random woman lol

Affair partners usually aren't some random. They start off as friends or colleagues.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:18

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:17

Affair partners usually aren't some random. They start off as friends or colleagues.

Sigh. If you genuinely think a man and a woman can’t be friends then that’s really sad for you.

OP posts:
YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:20

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:18

Sigh. If you genuinely think a man and a woman can’t be friends then that’s really sad for you.

So why doesn't that apply to your very good friends wife and her friend?

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:23

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:20

So why doesn't that apply to your very good friends wife and her friend?

Simply put, if I was a random woman who he asked for my number when he was drunk I would assume he had a sexual interest in me. It’s different because it is entirely different.

OP posts:
Bandbros · Yesterday 19:23

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:15

It’s sexist to presume a man and a woman who have been friends for years have a sexual interest in each other when there’s no indication of that. I’m not some woman he met on a night out when he was drunk.

I didn't say there was a sexual interest - you're the only one who's gone there. I would hate DP to discuss our realtionship with anyone and it would feel worse if that were a woman.

That's far more personal, and yes more of a betrayal, than chatting on a drunken night out.

He's checked her phone and then talked about the messages with someone outside the relationship, I'd be furious and if you can't see that crosses a line then maybe there is a problem.

What were you hoping to hear here OP?

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:25

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:18

Sigh. If you genuinely think a man and a woman can’t be friends then that’s really sad for you.

No one's said a man and woman can't be friends, only that he shouldn't be discussing his marriage with her.

Again, you've gone there.

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:26

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:18

Sigh. If you genuinely think a man and a woman can’t be friends then that’s really sad for you.

Can you friend's wife not be friends with someone she met in the pub then?

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:26

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:23

Simply put, if I was a random woman who he asked for my number when he was drunk I would assume he had a sexual interest in me. It’s different because it is entirely different.

Ahhh so your intentions are pure? How did you meet this woman's husband? Do you find it hard to hide your disdain for her? You are giving pick me energy with a side of misplaced superiority. Just my opinion of course.

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:29

Anyway, as you asked the advice you should be giving your friend is to go home and talk to his wife, privately without involving anyone else.

That's not what you wanted to hear though, is it?

YourLoftyCyanZebra · Yesterday 19:32

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:29

Anyway, as you asked the advice you should be giving your friend is to go home and talk to his wife, privately without involving anyone else.

That's not what you wanted to hear though, is it?

Nope OP wants us to say her very good friends wife is an absolute hussy and he should totally continue confide in her. 🤣

SatansFavourite · Yesterday 19:35

She's trying to cheat, unsuccessfully, which is both cheating and utterly embarrassing and tragic for her.

JLou08 · Yesterday 19:53

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:18

Sigh. If you genuinely think a man and a woman can’t be friends then that’s really sad for you.

I think they can. Which is why I said I don't think it's clear husband or wife have betrayed anyone.

KellyK2026 · Yesterday 19:54

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:23

I didn't say there was a sexual interest - you're the only one who's gone there. I would hate DP to discuss our realtionship with anyone and it would feel worse if that were a woman.

That's far more personal, and yes more of a betrayal, than chatting on a drunken night out.

He's checked her phone and then talked about the messages with someone outside the relationship, I'd be furious and if you can't see that crosses a line then maybe there is a problem.

What were you hoping to hear here OP?

At least you admit that you’re projecting your own insecurities on the matter. This post isn’t about you and your husband.

OP posts: