Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationship imbalance

52 replies

Gnoney03 · Today 19:13

Context & Background:
Ages & Duration: 17M and 17F. Dating for under 4 months (talking for 3 months prior).
Emotional Dynamic: I am more emotionally expressive and tend to overthink. She is much more stoic. She was the first to say "I love you."
Past History: About 2 months ago, we had a brief talk about effort, and she stepped up and fixed it. However, I generally feel like I put in more overall effort (around a 70/30 or 65/35 split).
The Breakdown & Current Situation:
Recently, I was dealing with a lot of anxiety, stress, and overthinking that I didn't know how to handle. I started venting to my girlfriend a lot—probably too much. A few days ago, after breaking down crying at our homecoming after-party, we had a very long, heavy conversation the next morning explaining everything.
Two days after that, she communicated a boundary with me: she said my situation was taking a heavy mental toll on her because she kept trying to "fix" the problem. She also said she felt like I expected or wanted something from her that she didn't know how to give.
I took this to heart and have been working a ton on my mental health over the last two weeks, and I'm genuinely doing much better now. However, ever since that heavy talk, a major effort imbalance and distance has set in:
I'm always the one asking to hang out and planning things.
She is not initiating conversations anymore (though when we do talk, her texting style is fine).
Recent example: Yesterday I texted her good morning, but she didn't reply until after practice ("didn't see this, good afternoon"). We talked briefly about our runs that day, and I sent the last text. We had our senior night later, but she didn't text me after we got back. We won't see each other today, are both busy tomorrow until a shared party in the evening, and have vague plans for Sunday that aren't locked in yet.
Where I'm At Right Now:
About a day ago, I realized I was overcompensating for her lack of effort, so I decided to step back—no double-texting, not planning hangouts until she does, and waiting for her to initiate. She hasn't stepped up yet, and because I stopped initiating, we barely have any emotional connection right now.
I know she loves and cares about me, but this dynamic is exhausting. I just want our efforts to be closer to 50/50.
My Questions for Advice:

  1. At what point do I communicate my needs and boundaries about this effort imbalance, and how can I expect that conversation to go?
  2. Is there any chance I can avoid having another heavy conversation and just trust that she will step up on her own once she decompresses? (She has proven in the past that she can initiate and plan when asked).
  3. Was her telling me about the pressure a fair boundary, or does it sound like she is using it as an excuse to block me out emotionally?
  4. How should I handle texting over the next couple of days? We barely talked yesterday despite being in the same places, won't see each other today, and only see each other briefly tomorrow night.
OP posts:
BleedinglyObvious · Today 19:28

Walk away. You're not compatible.

tanstaafl · Today 19:29

Was this a Dawson's Creek episode?

Actually it was all the episodes wasn't it?

Gnoney03 · Today 19:32

What do you mean straight up not compatible? There is no way to work through this?

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · Today 19:37

There’s no way to put this gently I don’t think. - I could not be arsed with any of this nonsense. I would have advised my 17yo dd to run a mile months ago, and she would have. You are putting ‘your intense emotional labour’ in as if it’s a good thing, and berating her for a ‘lack of emotional connection’ when actually it is you who is far far too intense.

Billy47 · Today 19:55

You need to relax. This isn't loves young dream. You've been together 4 month and you've already had a talk about lack of effort at 2 months. Instead of focusing on relationships you'd be better off on focusing on your own future. Put your energy into studying, volunteering and working towards a positive future.

If you do get involved in relationships and girls remember never put the responsibility of contraception on anyone else. You protect yourself from unplanned pregnancy and STIs. Don't rely on anyone else to do it. You take control of your health and future.

Finally, dont use ChatGPT as much. Its lazy and not a good look.

Tryingtothinkofausername · Today 20:01

I'm much, much older and couldn't handle your intensity.

I'd tell my 17 year old daughter to stop messaging you and to concentrate on having fun in group situations. You're both too young to be caught up in this type of drama.

ScorpionLioness79 · Today 20:08

When you say this dynamic is exhausting, it sounds like you're the cause of that. If we spoke to her, I have a feeling she'd say if she gives you inch, you'd take a mile. Likely why she's reigning in the communication and get-togethers, because you're expecting too much.

What is your ideal for getting together during the week and how much and what type of communication when apart? I know when I was your age, I'd see my bf twice a week on average, and we'd have a nightly phone call (no cell phones back then).

Always remember that even if you have a gf, you should keep up with your friendships, spending time with buddies and on hobbies/interests so that you're not just relying on your gf for all your social needs.

It's okay to occasionally express what you're going through with mental issues to your gf, but save most of that for a therapist, through journaling, with your parents and counselors, etc.

Consider that you're over the top in your expectations and that it's you who needs to tone it down for the good of your relationship. Good luck and let us know if there are any improvements if you try that.

.

Gnoney03 · Today 20:09

The AI was used to just organize all completely my thoughts lol

OP posts:
BleedinglyObvious · Today 20:12

You're 17 and been dating a few weeks. You're not right for each other. Nothing more to it. I'm surprised she hasn't dumped you already.

Boredofprivateschoolbashing · Today 20:16

Gnoney03 · Today 19:13

Context & Background:
Ages & Duration: 17M and 17F. Dating for under 4 months (talking for 3 months prior).
Emotional Dynamic: I am more emotionally expressive and tend to overthink. She is much more stoic. She was the first to say "I love you."
Past History: About 2 months ago, we had a brief talk about effort, and she stepped up and fixed it. However, I generally feel like I put in more overall effort (around a 70/30 or 65/35 split).
The Breakdown & Current Situation:
Recently, I was dealing with a lot of anxiety, stress, and overthinking that I didn't know how to handle. I started venting to my girlfriend a lot—probably too much. A few days ago, after breaking down crying at our homecoming after-party, we had a very long, heavy conversation the next morning explaining everything.
Two days after that, she communicated a boundary with me: she said my situation was taking a heavy mental toll on her because she kept trying to "fix" the problem. She also said she felt like I expected or wanted something from her that she didn't know how to give.
I took this to heart and have been working a ton on my mental health over the last two weeks, and I'm genuinely doing much better now. However, ever since that heavy talk, a major effort imbalance and distance has set in:
I'm always the one asking to hang out and planning things.
She is not initiating conversations anymore (though when we do talk, her texting style is fine).
Recent example: Yesterday I texted her good morning, but she didn't reply until after practice ("didn't see this, good afternoon"). We talked briefly about our runs that day, and I sent the last text. We had our senior night later, but she didn't text me after we got back. We won't see each other today, are both busy tomorrow until a shared party in the evening, and have vague plans for Sunday that aren't locked in yet.
Where I'm At Right Now:
About a day ago, I realized I was overcompensating for her lack of effort, so I decided to step back—no double-texting, not planning hangouts until she does, and waiting for her to initiate. She hasn't stepped up yet, and because I stopped initiating, we barely have any emotional connection right now.
I know she loves and cares about me, but this dynamic is exhausting. I just want our efforts to be closer to 50/50.
My Questions for Advice:

  1. At what point do I communicate my needs and boundaries about this effort imbalance, and how can I expect that conversation to go?
  2. Is there any chance I can avoid having another heavy conversation and just trust that she will step up on her own once she decompresses? (She has proven in the past that she can initiate and plan when asked).
  3. Was her telling me about the pressure a fair boundary, or does it sound like she is using it as an excuse to block me out emotionally?
  4. How should I handle texting over the next couple of days? We barely talked yesterday despite being in the same places, won't see each other today, and only see each other briefly tomorrow night.

I think you should write your own posts, OP...

Notmycircusnotmyotter · Today 20:17

You're 17 love. Let it go.

YourWinter · Today 20:17

I’d have hoped my daughters would recognise the absolute madness of dealing with such an intense boyfriend at 17. Just back off, neither of you will grow and thrive in this mess. She surely recognises it’s run its course and so will you. Don’t make it awkward. Needy, possessive and intense men are truly not nice to be around, so try working on relaxing while you grow up and grow out of this.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:19

Gnoney03 · Today 19:32

What do you mean straight up not compatible? There is no way to work through this?

Dude.
You're 17.

Just move on.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Today 20:19

I don't think I subjected the reasons for my marriage break up to this much analysis, never mind a relationship of a few months,

Poor girl must be exhausted with it all. It sounds like it's all laid out on an Excel Spreadsheet that keeps being updated.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:44

It sounds like it's all laid out on an Excel Spreadsheet that keeps being updated.

🤣🤣🤣

Gnoney03 · Today 20:46

Look all I’m trying to receive constructive advice on myself and this situation. Not saying you would tell your daughter to leave. Yall clearly haven’t experienced anxiety and I don’t fault you for that. And what comes with that is I love extremely deeply. I’m actively working on the intensity as I stated in my message. Yall do not know who I am, my ambitions or goals, and how I treat her (meaning very very good and thought out in what I do) so stop attacking my character it’s not fair

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · Today 20:51

You aren’t ’loving extremely deeply’. You are on route 1 to being controlling. You are allowed to put in the effort you want in to a relationship, and she, as a different person, is allowed to put in the effort she wants. You don’t get to decide her effort. She does. You only get to decide if her effort is enough for you. If it’s not, you break up, you’re not compatible

Gnoney03 · Today 20:52

ScorpionLioness79 · Today 20:08

When you say this dynamic is exhausting, it sounds like you're the cause of that. If we spoke to her, I have a feeling she'd say if she gives you inch, you'd take a mile. Likely why she's reigning in the communication and get-togethers, because you're expecting too much.

What is your ideal for getting together during the week and how much and what type of communication when apart? I know when I was your age, I'd see my bf twice a week on average, and we'd have a nightly phone call (no cell phones back then).

Always remember that even if you have a gf, you should keep up with your friendships, spending time with buddies and on hobbies/interests so that you're not just relying on your gf for all your social needs.

It's okay to occasionally express what you're going through with mental issues to your gf, but save most of that for a therapist, through journaling, with your parents and counselors, etc.

Consider that you're over the top in your expectations and that it's you who needs to tone it down for the good of your relationship. Good luck and let us know if there are any improvements if you try that.

.

Yes I’m actively working on the venting to her it was very un fair to put that on her. Sometime my support system lacks. Ideally like once a week and once on the weekend. I just meant more her asking me to hangout instead of vice versa. The texting is more I just want to hear about each others days. And for her to reach out first some of the time

OP posts:
TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:53

Gnoney03 · Today 20:46

Look all I’m trying to receive constructive advice on myself and this situation. Not saying you would tell your daughter to leave. Yall clearly haven’t experienced anxiety and I don’t fault you for that. And what comes with that is I love extremely deeply. I’m actively working on the intensity as I stated in my message. Yall do not know who I am, my ambitions or goals, and how I treat her (meaning very very good and thought out in what I do) so stop attacking my character it’s not fair

OMG dude, calm down.
You're waaaay too intense about this.
You're 17.

17!

I spent less time analysing why my husband of 26 years left me a year ago than you've spent writing your l'il spreadsheet.

You asked for advice. Most of us are mothers, a great many are mothers of teenagers, or remember what it was like when their older DC were young.

Our advice was for you to move on. Stop with the angst and the analysis.

You'll find another girlfriend and hopefully you won't scare her off with your intensity like you did this one

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Today 20:54

Yall clearly haven’t experienced anxiety and I don’t fault you for that.

Don't make assumptions, thanks.

Gnoney03 · Today 20:55

arethereanyleftatall · Today 20:51

You aren’t ’loving extremely deeply’. You are on route 1 to being controlling. You are allowed to put in the effort you want in to a relationship, and she, as a different person, is allowed to put in the effort she wants. You don’t get to decide her effort. She does. You only get to decide if her effort is enough for you. If it’s not, you break up, you’re not compatible

Thank you for this advice. When I say effort I mean just literally reaching out to me first. Is that not something that can be worked on?

OP posts:
TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:55

Y'all clearly haven’t experienced anxiety and I don’t fault you for that

How do you know what we've experienced?
How presumptuous.

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:57

Gnoney03 · Today 20:55

Thank you for this advice. When I say effort I mean just literally reaching out to me first. Is that not something that can be worked on?

No.
She's afraid of you.
She's had enough.
And I don't blame her.

I'd be so interested to hear her side of the story.

Gnoney03 · Today 20:57

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:53

OMG dude, calm down.
You're waaaay too intense about this.
You're 17.

17!

I spent less time analysing why my husband of 26 years left me a year ago than you've spent writing your l'il spreadsheet.

You asked for advice. Most of us are mothers, a great many are mothers of teenagers, or remember what it was like when their older DC were young.

Our advice was for you to move on. Stop with the angst and the analysis.

You'll find another girlfriend and hopefully you won't scare her off with your intensity like you did this one

The relationship isn’t lost. I’m asking on how myself and her can work towards something healthy at this age. I not sure why I’m being attacked

OP posts:
Gnoney03 · Today 20:59

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · Today 20:57

No.
She's afraid of you.
She's had enough.
And I don't blame her.

I'd be so interested to hear her side of the story.

you don’t even have proof of that. Your telling me my mental health struggles made her afraid of me. They were never about anything related to us they were about trying to figure out how to manage anxiety

OP posts: