Please or to access all these features

Radio/podcast addicts

Discuss your favourite podcast, radio show or The Archers episode.

Archers thread #204: Is Vince mince? Discuss The Archers here.

1000 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/10/2026 11:51

Thank you, @PseudoBadger, for kicking off this long, long series of Archers threads.

Archers All views on The Archers welcome here! New blood welcomed, and of course we are always delighted to welcome back former or occasional listeners/posters. We don't all agree on all points, although we do mostly try to be civil about it. Most of us are posting tongue in cheek a lot of the time, so don't worry about revealing that you'd have liked to hear more of Pip's and Stella's wedding vows, or other unusual views. Grin

Archers Spoilers: not on this thread, please! We don't wait for the omnibus to discuss the weeknight episodes, but we do try our best to avoid cross-contamination from https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/radio_addicts/4636789-the-archers-spoilers-thread-12-cant-wait-for-702pm-join-us-here, where spoilers are positively welcomed!

Archers For newer listeners, lurkers or those who just have no idea what we're talking about, @DadDadDad has created this useful thread: www.mumsnet.com/Talk/radio_addicts/3557323-For-Archers-fans-a-guide-to-acronyms-on-the-long-running-discussion-threads-and-any-other-meta-thread-questions-you-may-have - BOOP point for him! (See thread for explanation.)

Several people on the previous thread, and probably the spoilers thread, have rhymed Vince with mince, so credit to all of you! As I start this thread, we don't know what's going to happen to Vince, and it's looking as if Sunday night is going to last all week, or a good chunk of it. Ah well. We have to put up with this kind of thing every few years. I cling to my belief that the SWs aren't going to kill off another of Elizabeth's partners in a horrific accident - but of course they could be toying with us!

Josh has returned from Patagonia sounding strangely changed by his time abroad. Hmm (Angus Imrie is presumably too busy, or perhaps fed up with the limited storylines given to Josh up to now, so the part has been re-cast.)

Will the Brookfield inheritance row start up again now? I do hope so. Josh has been very badly short-changed by his parents' decision to leave the farm to Pip (and Stella). Surely they could have taken the same approach as Pat and Tony and involved both children (with separate provision for Ben, who's not interested in a farming career)?

Over to you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AgentKim · 31/10/2026 06:02

Every1ElseInKnowsley · 30/10/2026 13:09

A friend gets stopped every time he goes through customs. He's British Asian.
He's probably the least likely person to be up to no good.
I went through a phase of being stopped by the police in my car and can be a bit chopsy. They don't like being asked why they stopped you. (In my case, it was probably because I was driving a tatty little hatchback home from work late at night.)

Oh why couldn't they let Kirsty have a happy pregnancy and a relaxed maternity leave with her lovely job to return to?
Where's the drama in that?

What's going on with Keira?
She's annoying and very dull.

I wonder if it’s an exit route for Kirsty?
NOOOOOO!! I ❤Kirsty.

I get stopped everytime I go through customs because mt double knee replacements set the alarms off, its so annoying so I stopped going abroad.
Ive since had a screw in my ankle to fuse it. I have RA. I get stopped because of this not because of my skin colour. It must be so demeaning and hurtful to have to go through that and scary.
My late DBIL who is of Indian decent shaved his beard off when they had the London Bombings because he didnt want to be stopped incase he was a terrorist.

Feel very sorry for Alan, those Terrgoran women where trouble from the first time I heard them.( not that long ago).I hope he gets a better lawyer than his wifey poo.

WitcheryDivine · 31/10/2026 06:33

CarlaH · 30/10/2026 07:38

This really is daft. If they did want to run this storyline then surely it would make more sense if the tree check had been due in September or something like that. At the moment there isn't an issue since it wasn't due until November.

Don't the cast ever question the nonsense they are required to speak.

Thank goodness for the sanity of MN on this. I’m exhausted at the moment and was starting to wonder what on Earth I’d missed with this “a tree fell down that was due to be checked in future” story. I’ve experience of anxiety and even at my most anxious being taken to court for this wouldn’t have been on my list of worries.

LaMarschallin · 31/10/2026 07:15

Gonners · 30/10/2026 22:32

@LaMarschallin ... Neither of the above, as it happens. But feel free to judge us. After all, that's what the CofE is all about.

OK - thank you.

BeatriceBatchelor · 31/10/2026 07:24

I have also impressed upon all my (white) children from a young age to be polite and cooperate fully with police officers and never ever do anything in their presence that could be misinterpreted as non compliance or evasion. Seems like common sense to me.

Do you have a daughter? Have you advised her to get into his car if a lone male police officer ordered her to?

I feel sympathetic towards Alan. Anna was vile to him when he was nothing but kind to her awful mum. Then the pompous prick of an archdeacon turns up unannounced and speaks to him in a patronising tone.

LaMarschallin · 31/10/2026 07:31

BeatriceBatchelor

I feel sympathetic towards Alan. Anna was vile to him when he was nothing but kind to her awful mum. Then the pompous prick of an archdeacon turns up unannounced and speaks to him in a patronising tone.

I agree.
The archdeacon was, I assume, trying to sound impartial but ended up sounding rather aggressive.
I was wincing a bit though at Alan getting so angry, however understandably. It really won't help his case.

Prestissimo · 31/10/2026 08:12

I wonder if Alan’s response to all sorts of things recently are designed to demonstrate that he is burning out. He must be getting older, he’s supporting several parishes single-handed (we don’t ever hear about a deacon or even lay-readers) and now his kindness to a cantankerous old woman and her demanding daughter, to whom he only showed kindness and probably thought of as friends on some level, has been questioned and accusations made. Those accusations actually hit to the core of his character and vocation so I can understand him feeling deeply hurt and distressed by them. Then the Archdeacon or whatever he was turns up and speaks as though he’s never met him before and has no knowledge of Alan’s work or his character.

Obviously there is procedure and guidance that needs to be followed but in my experience of difficult conversations like this (patient complaints mainly) it would not be this acrimonious: investigative and challenging, yes, but with a significant level of support for the professional who may or may not have made a mistake.

The rewilding tree business is so ridiculous I can’t even give it headspace. I hope that there will be a straightforward resolution once Kirsty is eventually told what’s going on - “oh yes, it’s in my diary to call Ed next month” - but the SWs do persist in these stupid faux-peril storylines where everyone refuses to say anything to the person who holds the key to the issue.

Teddleshon1 · 31/10/2026 09:51

@BeatriceBatchelor obviously I’ve told all my children not to rely simply on a warrant car and get in a non marked police car with a lone person wearing civilian clothing. It is highly unusual for officers to operate alone in this scenario and anyone should insist a second officer is called.

I can’t understand how the arch deacon could turn up unannounced, surely this is totally against their procedures. Alan was ambushed.

WitcheryDivine · 31/10/2026 10:28

I’m due around the same time as Kirsty and if I were off long term sick as she is and then found myself berated for not booking something BACK IN ABOUT APRIL I would take a dim view tbh. When someone is off sick the business is supposed to ensure things still get done and they’ve not covered her role at all as far as I can see. Presumably even if she had booked it in the spring someone would still need to be in touch to reconfirm access dates etc and ensure the right areas are fenced off etc.

Also if Ed and Emma are that booked up WHY a) is Ed still working for Brian b) aren’t we seeing a strong uptick in their standard of living? Any idea what a full time income for two tree surgeons would be?

TottersBlankly · 31/10/2026 10:56

Anyone can google an answer to How much would Ed and Emma earn as tree surgeons in The Archers and - after five minutes correcting Google AI’s insulting and misogynistic assumptions - arrive at a figure that sounds reasonable.

And which definitely would, if they’re working say four days a week, pull them out of generational Grundy poverty. It’s not as if they have high housing or childcare costs.

So I too have wondered why we haven’t seen any shift in the Grundy narrative. Yes, they have to factor in Will’s share of the business, but I’d be surprised if they still genuinely need little side jobs that pay almost nothing and keep them under someone else’s thumb.

I suspect it’s another area where the producers and creative team just haven’t got round to having a meeting and moving the story on.

Emilesgran · 31/10/2026 12:15

Brefugee · 30/10/2026 11:49

No I mean the "always do exactly what the police tell you and make sure you don't backchat or be anything other than extremely compliant and reasonable and never ever let them provoke you"

I have never been raped, i am not a young muslim man who has been beaten up by skinheads, and i am not a young black man who gets stopped for "existing as black" but i can empathise with the victims of that and understand that the world works differently for them.

My experience as a nationalist in Northern Ireland during the troubles was that a LOT of young men (and many young women) quite enjoyed provoking the army and police while carefully remaining just within the legal limits, because of course they “knew their rights” - so for instance when the police asked you your age, legally you could say “Over 18”, or where you were coming from/going to, you could answer as vaguely as possible etc. And of course even without refusing to reply, there’s still a hostile tone that isn’t illegal but gets a certain message across too.

TBH I have to admit to having done it myself. There’s something of a thrill in being defiant to armed men while knowing they can’t really do much to you. The same people wouldn’t be nearly as defiant towards the local paramilitaries- even those supposedly on the same side.

And if you think young black men in England aren’t just as well informed as to their rights, and don’t make it equally clear to the cops that they consider them to be their enemy, then you are very naive.

But I still don’t see what relevance any of this has to Zainab joining (or not) the police service herself. Unless Azra was telling her the police are her enemy and that she shouldn’t “collaborate”. That’s how it came across to me anyway. Which, as I say, coming from the socially successful Maliks, is a bizarre message.

Every1ElseInKnowsley · 31/10/2026 14:27

I thought Azra was pointing out some things in a way that a parent should. The police force is predominantly white and male.

WitcheryDivine · 31/10/2026 15:42

TottersBlankly · 31/10/2026 10:56

Anyone can google an answer to How much would Ed and Emma earn as tree surgeons in The Archers and - after five minutes correcting Google AI’s insulting and misogynistic assumptions - arrive at a figure that sounds reasonable.

And which definitely would, if they’re working say four days a week, pull them out of generational Grundy poverty. It’s not as if they have high housing or childcare costs.

So I too have wondered why we haven’t seen any shift in the Grundy narrative. Yes, they have to factor in Will’s share of the business, but I’d be surprised if they still genuinely need little side jobs that pay almost nothing and keep them under someone else’s thumb.

I suspect it’s another area where the producers and creative team just haven’t got round to having a meeting and moving the story on.

My toddler is at an incredibly clingy stage so I haven’t had that five mins but I’m pleased to hear it. You’re probably right about the meeting. It’s just disappointing when they make a good decision and it’s not seen to make any difference to them at all.

TottersBlankly · 31/10/2026 16:13

Sorry, @WitcheryDivine - if I quote Google AI everyone would be up in arms. (First it stated that Ed and Emma were working untrained with no qualifications or equipment. Then it decided that Ed was the real tree surgeon and Emma was just support. 😡) Eventually it estimated they’d each earn about £40k per annum. I have no idea but that doesn’t sound unreasonable.

DeanElderberry · 31/10/2026 17:21

Yes, tree surgeons charge a lot, and although I'm sure they have high insurance premiums and need to pay for equipment and regular refresher training, they should be doing well.

MeadowPumpkin · 31/10/2026 21:27

Tree surgeons are not particularly well off - their operating expenses (equipment, fuel, insurance) are enormous. In many areas (and I would expect Borsetshire to be the same) they will be competing with each other for work and so pushing their rates down. Often a job will need at least three people so Ed and Emma would have to pay for a third person (e.g. like Will) to be a groundsman which will cut into their profits.

I believe there would be a potential conflict of interest for BL to hire E&E to do both the tree surveying and the felling work so I think in reality they would be done separately by two distinct contractors.

It is also fairly implausible for E&E to be acting as tree assessors so soon into their arb careers. They would both have had to have done tons of training - more than what was portrayed.

LillianGish · 31/10/2026 22:40

I feel sympathetic towards Alan. Anna was vile to him when he was nothing but kind to her awful mum. Then the pompous prick of an archdeacon turns up unannounced and speaks to him in a patronising tone. I also feel very sorry for Alan, especially as we saw/heard what happened - how kind and patient Alan was with Carole and Anna when Anna was always so irritated with her mum. How Alan was trying to do a kind thing for Anna by helping Carole by the flowers. We know he hasn’t done anything wrong - Carole and the Archdeacon are extrapolating and assuming the worst. We are Alan’s witnesses but we are totally helpless - as is he. This is the opposite to what is happening in the Keira story where we have no idea what has happened to her and whether or not she is over reacting - she might eventually tell us, but we will be like Carole and the Archdeacon, we won’t know if that’s the whole story.

JudyCoolibar · 01/11/2026 01:07

MeadowPumpkin · 31/10/2026 21:27

Tree surgeons are not particularly well off - their operating expenses (equipment, fuel, insurance) are enormous. In many areas (and I would expect Borsetshire to be the same) they will be competing with each other for work and so pushing their rates down. Often a job will need at least three people so Ed and Emma would have to pay for a third person (e.g. like Will) to be a groundsman which will cut into their profits.

I believe there would be a potential conflict of interest for BL to hire E&E to do both the tree surveying and the felling work so I think in reality they would be done separately by two distinct contractors.

It is also fairly implausible for E&E to be acting as tree assessors so soon into their arb careers. They would both have had to have done tons of training - more than what was portrayed.

If they're so busy that they have to be booked several months in advance, surely they would at the very least be earning well above whatever they were previously making with a patchwork of minimum and low wage jobs?

BeatriceBatchelor · 01/11/2026 08:43

Does Emma still work at the Terum?

TottersBlankly · 01/11/2026 11:50

Finding it hard to believe that Azra - who spent years as a student and training for her medical career, as well as navigating her son’s illness - would be relying on a village shop for cardamom. Surely the Maliks as a family would have online grocery ordering organised to the nth degree? And keep a well stocked larder. They cannot possibly have time to be constantly checking for odd things running out.

HewasH2O · 01/11/2026 12:01

Catching up. Honestly, the tree surgery storyline is massive overkill. Why on earth is nobody stating the obvious that the next visit was pending. Nobody books an MoT a couple of months earlier than necessary.

Bettyfromlondon · 01/11/2026 12:04

I hope Tracy and Jazzer do not feel obliged to reimburse Helen for the broken terracotta pots. She should have put them in safe storage when she heard all the many advance warnings of the storm.

JudyCoolibar · 01/11/2026 12:35

Bettyfromlondon · 01/11/2026 12:04

I hope Tracy and Jazzer do not feel obliged to reimburse Helen for the broken terracotta pots. She should have put them in safe storage when she heard all the many advance warnings of the storm.

Typical bloody Helen grabbing Tracy and Jazzer as soon as they got back and insisting that they inspect the damage to try to guilt-trip them. All she needed to do was get the address of the landlords and take it up with them.

JudyCoolibar · 01/11/2026 12:48

Obviously there is procedure and guidance that needs to be followed but in my experience of difficult conversations like this (patient complaints mainly) it would not be this acrimonious: investigative and challenging, yes, but with a significant level of support for the professional who may or may not have made a mistake.

Ideally yes, but not all professions manage this, and I can believe that senior people in the church are not great at it. I remember when a complaint about me was made.by someone essentially based on the fact that I had had to give advice he didn't want to hear. The reality was in part that, during the course of dealing with him, it became clear that he had learning difficulties including a major problem in processing language and remembering what was said to him. I tried to explain my advice carefully both on the phone and in person, I gave him plenty of time to ask questions, I went over anything he didn't seem to understand and simplified my language, and he seemed to understand and accept what I said, but would come back the next day with questions about exactly the same things. I put it in writing with simplified language, suggested he go through it with a trusted adviser, said I was very happy to talk to the adviser etc etc, and thought that ultimately he went away satisfied that I had looked into it very carefully and unfortunately could not advise any differently. But still he complained.

I remember when the investigator phoned me about it all. She could not point to anything wrong in my advice, the way I'd dealt with this man, or my efforts to explain to him. When I commented that he a language processing problem, however, she leapt on that with glee and asked why I hadn't got an interpreter. She was a bit stumped, though, when I asked her what sort of interpreter she envisaged given that this man only spoke English. Ultimately the complaint went away but I got the distinct impression that the investigator was quite disappointed that she couldn't find something to beat me up about.

What was annoying about the discussion with Alan was that Alan was doing that annoying Archers thing of leaping in and interrupting rather than listening to what was being said to him. Do people really behave like that in RL? I suspect that most people in that situation instinctively go quiet and decide to keep their heads down rather than acting all outraged that the complaint hasn't been thrown out without any sensible investigation.

beigetriangle · 01/11/2026 13:13

Bettyfromlondon · 01/11/2026 12:04

I hope Tracy and Jazzer do not feel obliged to reimburse Helen for the broken terracotta pots. She should have put them in safe storage when she heard all the many advance warnings of the storm.

...there was a thread here about exactly this just after the last gaggle of storms...

TottersBlankly · 01/11/2026 13:24

At the moment Helen seems to have no other purpose than squeezing money out of Horrobins.

It’s … weird. The SWs are making her look obsessed.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.