Please or to access all these features

Politics
ImthatBoleyngirl · 12/11/2026 09:55

Climate change is a genuine issue but there's a difference between acknowledging it and catastrophising about the future as though our children have no hope. Modern life is very resource-intensive, and we all contribute far more than we probably realise. Cheap food available all year round, online shopping with free returns, constantly upgrading mobile phones, cloud storage, streaming, data centres, fast fashion, supermarkets with enormous refrigeration requirements, washing machines, tumble dryers, fridge freezers, air conditioning, cheap furniture, constant home improvements, concrete and construction, international shipping, car tyres and brake wear. The list goes on.

Yet we seem to focus on individual cars, plastic bags and whether someone has a gas boiler, while conveniently overlooking thing that most people wouldn't even consider giving up.

We need some perspective. The UK contributes less than 1% of current global greenhouse gas emissions. Of course we should play our part, but our children deserve to inherit a world where we tackle problems realistically, not one where they're constantly being told they have no future.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:55

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:52

Exactly! and I've been genuinely shocked by just how much more expensive some of these products are

True. And tbh I'm not convinced that it makes a big difference.

QueenGizzard · 12/11/2026 10:41

Some of us actually driven ourselves a bit mad doing everything possible to help. Reducing plastic, recycling, shopping ethically, checking labels, spending more etc.

In the end it cost us our mental health, family harmony, financially etc.

Then you realise it's just not a massive priority when you weigh it all up.

Pp are right. Individually why should we sacrifice our own happiness and wellbeing on some unachievable dream?

I'm sorry but it really has to come from the top. And I don't even mean our govt here in the UK because I think China/India/USA/Middle East have to step up before it's even worth any smaller countries bothering.

We are cooked tbh. All I can do is make my family's life as good as it can be while we are all still here.

Sorry to those who work in the sector. Perhaps you have more power than me to instigate bigger change.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 12/11/2026 11:05

I do think individuals could help by avoiding using AI, having fewer children and not buying cheap disposable plastic shite but it would require a large majority of the populations of all countries to do it and that is never going to happen. In the UK we need all the consumerism to keep the economy going.

I think we're screwed really, I just hope I'm dead before it completely kicks off.

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 13:39

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:39

The population debate is a red herring the average Brazilian produces about 3 tonnes of Carbon a year and the average American produces 17 tonnes.

When people say, oh well lots of people will just die, they are referring to people like those in India, who's average carbon production is 2 tonnes....

Population is not the issue. The way we live is.

And yet many people in 'developing' countries see the lifestyle of 'developed' countries and want it, mass movement of people ensues. Birth rates are dropping in most 'developed' countries and some people think that's a problem. It's not. Exponential human population growth is, it's unsustainable, unless you expect 'undeveloped' countries not to level up.

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 13:52

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 13:39

And yet many people in 'developing' countries see the lifestyle of 'developed' countries and want it, mass movement of people ensues. Birth rates are dropping in most 'developed' countries and some people think that's a problem. It's not. Exponential human population growth is, it's unsustainable, unless you expect 'undeveloped' countries not to level up.

Yes, I don't expect developing countries to level up. I expect that material living standards in developed countries will decline, regardless of whether their populations decide to or not.
There are already signs of this happening, as we can't keep up the rate of raw material extraction and energy production to continue to achieve expected growth in GDP. Many economies are now running huge deficits to try to keep the fun going. The French are not exactly convincing the bond markets that all is well, so it will probably start there as France is too big to bail out.

Monty36 · 12/11/2026 14:50

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:39

The population debate is a red herring the average Brazilian produces about 3 tonnes of Carbon a year and the average American produces 17 tonnes.

When people say, oh well lots of people will just die, they are referring to people like those in India, who's average carbon production is 2 tonnes....

Population is not the issue. The way we live is.

It is both. If there were fewer people on the planet it would help. There would be less need for land for food, less housing, less planes travelling everywhere, less raw materials used. Fewer factories, less pollution.
India is increasing emissions not reducing them sadly. I doubt that trajectory will change.
You cannot have a serious conversation about climate change and ignore the ever increasing global population. More people equals more abuse of the planet. Our inability to manage the population growth is dire for the planet.

And the planet has had enough. I think it is too late personally. And we will have to get used to whatever Mother Nature wants to dish up to us.

LlynTegid · 12/11/2026 14:54

I don't think it is lack of care. Part of it is that why make changes if China and the US don't (without thinking of energy security or air quality), and part as noted is the cost of living crisis.

chucklebrother · 12/11/2026 14:57

I recycle as much as I can, buy second hand, take soft plastics to the shop to recycle. Then I go to work and see people can't even put the correct recycling in the correct bin or food waste into the right place 🙈 I give up

TheSnappyBluePoster · 12/11/2026 14:57

What have you done about it op? Have you given up your car? Have you given up all your creature?Comforts, and all your electronic gadgets do you live off grid in a forest?

Most people jump up and down and demand to know what we're doing about it without looking in their own backyard.

The fact is, the matter is, human beings are too selfish, and they are not going to give up their creature.Comforts, one look on the christmas present threads will show you that eleven year olds are being bought, laptops, tablets and phones. One woman is considering buying her tweenage son a £300 3D printer, just so he can print plastic junk off it and run it several hours a day. They are ruinous for the environment, but people are just too selfish to deny themselves or their children anything.

How about your pets? All of you know, surely that the carbon footprint of pet food is massive? Give up your dogs and cats? Of course you won't.

PetiteParakeet · 12/11/2026 15:07

Well, this is a depressing thread, as the overwhelming consensus seems to be: yes, we're doomed but there's nothing we can do.

I know people's capacity to do stuff varies and a lot of people are just struggling with day to day lives. Personally I do have some ability to put energy towards this and I feel that when the shit really starts to hit the fan in a decade or two I'll feel better if I at least tried to do something useful to stop it rather than just watching.

I recognise that a lot of MPs are crap and just give standard responses to letters, but they do look at the total volume of correspondence they receive and if they get a more personal approach, e.g. inviting them to a National Emergency Briefing film screening.

The government is currently deciding whether to approve drilling of a massive great oilfield which would do fuck all for the UK's energy security (as the oil will be exported) but would produce huge amounts of greenhouse gases. So writing to your MP about that is something to do https://www.stopcambo.org.uk/rosebank-mp-actions

Likewise there's the plan to massively increase emissions through a third runway at Heathrow Airport (on top of Gatwick expansion) but there might be the chance of pushing the government back on that now Rachel Reeves has gone, who was the biggest cheerleader of a third runway.

And there's lots of campaigning going on at the moment about hyperscale data centres and their massive carbon footprints.

It's all difficult and depressing, but it helps to get involved with a wider campaign, people who are actually actively doing stuff. And you know, better to light one small candle than curse the darkness and all that...

Inextremis · 12/11/2026 15:35

I still care.

There is something we can do about it, as individuals. Stop flying unless it's an emergency (relative in hospital etc.). Just stop. It may not make a significant difference in emissions worldwide, but it would certainly affect the aviation industry and the companies that produce aviation fuel. It would be headline news if a significant proportion of the population stopped flying for recreational purposes (eg holidays).

People won't, though, because their 2 weeks in Tenerife or whatever are what they deserve, and feel entitled to. They work hard for the money, after all. So it won't happen.

It's about instant (well, sort of) gratification, rather than taking a long-term view of what is best for us collectively and as individuals.

Of course, it's not all about flying - it's about enough people changing their behaviour for 'big business' to recognise it's in their best interests to reduce emissions.

You may call me a dreamer - but I'm not the only one!

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 15:49

I used to really care and do a lot but like others, I just think we are doomed.

I think the fact we have become the 'top animal' is because we are ultimately so selfish that we will climb over the dead bodies of everyone and everything else for our own comfort (and ultimately, for more cash).

Capitalism has won, the Earth has lost. It's just where our genes are taking us.

QueenGizzard · 12/11/2026 15:51

@Inextremis we do deserve our holiday in Tenerife (or wherever) though.

Maybe if the bigger problem countries start to make some kind of an effort, then people here might too.

Until then, there really is no point punishing ourselves.

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 15:52

Monty36 · 12/11/2026 14:50

It is both. If there were fewer people on the planet it would help. There would be less need for land for food, less housing, less planes travelling everywhere, less raw materials used. Fewer factories, less pollution.
India is increasing emissions not reducing them sadly. I doubt that trajectory will change.
You cannot have a serious conversation about climate change and ignore the ever increasing global population. More people equals more abuse of the planet. Our inability to manage the population growth is dire for the planet.

And the planet has had enough. I think it is too late personally. And we will have to get used to whatever Mother Nature wants to dish up to us.

Indeed.
I have read that female education and emancipation can help reduce population growth.
Another article I read in the 80s (when population control was on the green party agenda) noted the correlation between lifestyle envy of soap opera families and lowering birth rates in Brazil. (Children or a luxury lifestyle..)

I wonder how many real environmentally concerned bods would need to join the green party to reclaim it from the recent cuckooing entryists. Our local green counciller is very effective but I couldn't vote for them at a national level, their party is a disgrace.

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 15:55

Inextremis · 12/11/2026 15:35

I still care.

There is something we can do about it, as individuals. Stop flying unless it's an emergency (relative in hospital etc.). Just stop. It may not make a significant difference in emissions worldwide, but it would certainly affect the aviation industry and the companies that produce aviation fuel. It would be headline news if a significant proportion of the population stopped flying for recreational purposes (eg holidays).

People won't, though, because their 2 weeks in Tenerife or whatever are what they deserve, and feel entitled to. They work hard for the money, after all. So it won't happen.

It's about instant (well, sort of) gratification, rather than taking a long-term view of what is best for us collectively and as individuals.

Of course, it's not all about flying - it's about enough people changing their behaviour for 'big business' to recognise it's in their best interests to reduce emissions.

You may call me a dreamer - but I'm not the only one!

The internet tells me that aviation fuel is still leaded. Even more reason to fly less.

Inextremis · 12/11/2026 16:02

QueenGizzard · 12/11/2026 15:51

@Inextremis we do deserve our holiday in Tenerife (or wherever) though.

Maybe if the bigger problem countries start to make some kind of an effort, then people here might too.

Until then, there really is no point punishing ourselves.

It's always this - someone else's problem, no point me changing my behaviour. This is why we're not going to stop anthropogenic climate change. People underestimate the effect of collective behaviour.

Carry on enjoying your holidays until your destinations sink into the oceans. After all, you're only there for a couple of weeks, unlike the people who live there, and you can always decide to go somewhere else.

QueenGizzard · 12/11/2026 16:04

It's called the bigger picture @Inextremis . Read my earlier post too.

Boomer55 · 12/11/2026 16:07

People are just trying to get on with the here and now. Not what might happen in the future.

larrap · 12/11/2026 16:12

Until there are severe sanctions for all polluters and those who contribute to climate change without a thought, nothing will change. And maybe incentives for those that do their bit. How to assess and monitor this though?

Same applies to corporate polluters, sanction or incentivise.

You may say well there are such things in progress. Well I don't know about them and I'd say millions of others don't either.

Say I do everything possible to reduce my carbon footprint etc., but next door neighbour and every other house on the road couldn't care less. What's the sanction or incentive to do more?

Powerless and feeling like a mug when you do try is dead right. I often feel others are laughing at our efforts, both corporate and individual. Because they KNOW it's beyond us now.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 16:17

It's always this - someone else's problem, no point me changing my behaviour.

And you know why? because whatever we do - recycling, not flying, not using plastic, buying electric cars, not buying throw away clothes - we're always being told it's not enough, you need to do more, we're all doomed.

While the rainforest gets destroyed so people can fly to COP in their private jets.
I mean, talk about mixed messages

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9vy191rgn1o

Little people, you have to do more. I'm telling you for your own good while I sit here in my Learjet pissing off to Turkey while telling you to holiday at home.

HotGrapefruit · 12/11/2026 16:42

larrap · 12/11/2026 16:12

Until there are severe sanctions for all polluters and those who contribute to climate change without a thought, nothing will change. And maybe incentives for those that do their bit. How to assess and monitor this though?

Same applies to corporate polluters, sanction or incentivise.

You may say well there are such things in progress. Well I don't know about them and I'd say millions of others don't either.

Say I do everything possible to reduce my carbon footprint etc., but next door neighbour and every other house on the road couldn't care less. What's the sanction or incentive to do more?

Powerless and feeling like a mug when you do try is dead right. I often feel others are laughing at our efforts, both corporate and individual. Because they KNOW it's beyond us now.

Yes, when I was younger I thought we'd have it in hand by now: carbon budgets per household was suggested, sanctions etc. and massive global change. That could have changed things.

Instead we are actually making things worse and worse, even as the planet is obviously heating. It's extraordinary really. We will just end up defending our island from massive migration, climate wars and food rations I suppose.

I suppose it's like the change from nice Roman towns back to the dark ages...

1dayatatime · 12/11/2026 16:50

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 15:55

The internet tells me that aviation fuel is still leaded. Even more reason to fly less.

Only for small piston engine light planes. Jet planes use jet fuel which is not leaded.

1dayatatime · 12/11/2026 16:55

quantumbutterfly · 12/11/2026 15:52

Indeed.
I have read that female education and emancipation can help reduce population growth.
Another article I read in the 80s (when population control was on the green party agenda) noted the correlation between lifestyle envy of soap opera families and lowering birth rates in Brazil. (Children or a luxury lifestyle..)

I wonder how many real environmentally concerned bods would need to join the green party to reclaim it from the recent cuckooing entryists. Our local green counciller is very effective but I couldn't vote for them at a national level, their party is a disgrace.

This is spot on. The most effective means of combatting not just climate change but environmental damage in its entirety is a lower global population, as well as improving the quality of life of those that do exist.

And the most effective means of reducing global population is female education.

The problem with pushing this message is cultural sensitivities in countries where women do not have equal rights to men and there is no way that they are going to allow that to change.

I see so many posters claiming that we need to increase the UK population because we have an ageing population when from an environmental and economic perspective we should be doing the exact opposite.

Waitingfordoggo · 12/11/2026 16:58

I still try quite hard- environment and waste is usually the first thing I think about when I’m making a purchase or using a service. But a lot of people don’t give a stuff, I’ve noticed. It’s not that people have stopped caring, I don’t think, it’s that they didn’t care in the first place, or are so accustomed to putting their wants before anything else. You see it all the time on MN re buying shite off Temu, taking multiple flights, wasting water etc. It always comes back to ‘I want’. (Or people say there’s no point doing anything until China does something, without thinking about how much of the stuff they buy comes from China). And then stuff that’s less damaging to the environment is often more expensive, so that’s a legitimate problem for many. But almost everyone should buy much less stuff anyway so 🤷🏼‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread