Please or to access all these features

Politics
MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:10

The argument around climate change has been lost. Part of the reason for this was the tone of the messaging adopted by the climate movement a few decades ago. This has led to people feeling utterly helpless about it.
A good portion of the movement is now focused on how to mitigate the impacts of the extreme weather events that are now effectively baked in. Mostly the focus is on local action and preparedness, which is much more helpful and less distressing for people.
In my personal opinion, COP is pointless. The time for that is over and people should now turn to building local resilience.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:18

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:10

It's not even about disengaging. I already recycle, try to be conscious of my consumption and do the things we're routinely told to do. What exactly is it you expect us to do beyond that?

I could never get on another plane, never go on holiday again, give up every conceivable convenience (or enjoyable experience) and recycle until the cows come home, and it would make no measurable difference to global emissions.

I'm sick and bloody tired of the implication that ordinary people simply need to care more, try harder and make yet more personal sacrifices.

This isn't a problem that can be solved by individual lifestyle choices. It requires global political and industrial intervention.

So rather than telling people to channel their anger into caring more, perhaps direct some of your energy towards holding the corporations, industries and governments with the actual power to change things accountable.

I'm not disengaged. I'm simply questioning what more you realistically expect an ordinary individual to do when the responsibility for meaningful change lies so far beyond their control.

In a few minutes I am disengaged being lectured about the topic doing the things we are supposed or told to. Appently still I am more responsible and to blame than the big players on this issue.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:18

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:10

It's not even about disengaging. I already recycle, try to be conscious of my consumption and do the things we're routinely told to do. What exactly is it you expect us to do beyond that?

I could never get on another plane, never go on holiday again, give up every conceivable convenience (or enjoyable experience) and recycle until the cows come home, and it would make no measurable difference to global emissions.

I'm sick and bloody tired of the implication that ordinary people simply need to care more, try harder and make yet more personal sacrifices.

This isn't a problem that can be solved by individual lifestyle choices. It requires global political and industrial intervention.

So rather than telling people to channel their anger into caring more, perhaps direct some of your energy towards holding the corporations, industries and governments with the actual power to change things accountable.

I'm not disengaged. I'm simply questioning what more you realistically expect an ordinary individual to do when the responsibility for meaningful change lies so far beyond their control.

But what you say here is exactly what I mean when I talk about channelling that anger into caring more: holding the corporations, industries and governments with the actual power to change things accountable.

I don’t mean making more personal sacrifices. But - like you - I think there are political parties, and big corporations who think people are too climate fatigued to care, and I think showing them that’s not the case - through the way we use our purchasing power, and through lobbying our elected politicians - is the most significant thing we can do.

Fushia123 · 12/11/2026 09:19

I agree with @FlipFlopPipPop.
Have you been to one of the screenings of the National Emergency Briefing Film about climate change? After seeing it for the first time, myself and 3others have arranged more screenings locally. We have arranged a follow up workshop to share, discuss and decide what we can do next. It will focus on our local community and will prob only be able to support one or two local projects. (One similar group worked to get grants and funding for a whole street to have solar panels.)
We are all busy people, and can only do what we can do. We are well aware that the problem is huge, but if everyone could offer something to move forward, that would be a start.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:19

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:18

But what you say here is exactly what I mean when I talk about channelling that anger into caring more: holding the corporations, industries and governments with the actual power to change things accountable.

I don’t mean making more personal sacrifices. But - like you - I think there are political parties, and big corporations who think people are too climate fatigued to care, and I think showing them that’s not the case - through the way we use our purchasing power, and through lobbying our elected politicians - is the most significant thing we can do.

How?

SwirlyGates · 12/11/2026 09:21

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 08:50

Frankly, I'm getting rather tired of having climate change constantly dumped at the feet of ordinary individuals as though we're the ones holding the levers of power.

I could spend the rest of my life never getting on a plane, never going on holiday, recycling every scrap of rubbish and living like a Victorian, and it would make virtually no measurable difference to global emissions.

Meanwhile, multinational corporations, fossil fuel industries, global supply chains and governments operate on a completely different scale.

I'm not suggesting individuals have no responsibility, but let's stop pretending that the solution rests with consumers making increasingly miserable lifestyle sacrifices while those with the real power to make systemic changes escape the same level of scrutiny.

You cannot solve a systemic global problem by making individuals feel guilty about their shopping bags and holidays.

I am not exactly sure what you are expecting "us" to do about it?

I agree - and I've come to the conclusion that there is pretty much nothing I can do.

It's particularly enraging that humanity is now faced with hyperscale data centres, which nearly everyone agrees will be damaging to the planet (along with the damage to our humanity from AI), but this onslaught is presented as inevitable. Angry

And for all the people I come across who say, "I asked ChatGPT to decorate my front room to see how it would look," or "I got Claude to make me an itinerary for my holiday," have a think about this (a quote I found online):

"Please be mindful with using generative AI. Every time you ask AI (like chat gpt, grok, Claude) to make you a picture or song or business model you’ll never follow through with, you’re creating the demand that will land a data center in your city. The result will be a non-stop horrific buzzing sound, dirty water, dirty air, no bees, birds or wildlife.
So stop and think, ‘do I really need to see myself in a red Christmas dress just for fun? Or make that cheesy video of your cat or dog doing silly things?’ Cause every time you do, that creates demand, and the billionaires of the world will keep supplying you and lining their pockets as they destroy our planet.
Put the phone down friends, go watch your pet do actual silly things!!"

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:24

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:18

But what you say here is exactly what I mean when I talk about channelling that anger into caring more: holding the corporations, industries and governments with the actual power to change things accountable.

I don’t mean making more personal sacrifices. But - like you - I think there are political parties, and big corporations who think people are too climate fatigued to care, and I think showing them that’s not the case - through the way we use our purchasing power, and through lobbying our elected politicians - is the most significant thing we can do.

But how, precisely, do you suggest I hold these corporations accountable? What practical steps have you personally taken to do so?

And here's another consideration: when you're working full time, raising children and looking after elderly parents, where exactly are you supposed to find the time to lobby corporations, organise campaigns and campaign for legislative change?

These are not abstract inconveniences; they're the realities of millions of people's lives.

It's very easy to tell people to channel their anger into action, but considerably harder to explain what that action should look like in practice, or how people with already stretched lives with precious little free time are supposed to find the time and resources to do it.

I'm not climate fatigued because I don't care. I'm fatigued by the constant expectation that ordinary people must take on yet another responsibility for a problem over which they have very little control.

So yes, if I've spent a full working week earning a living, looking after children and caring for ageing parents, and I don't have the energy left to take on another campaigning responsibility, can you bloody blame me?

I'm genuinely asking: what have you personally done to hold these corporations accountable, and what realistically do you expect ordinary people to do beyond the things they're already doing?

user47639820987 · 12/11/2026 09:26

The only thing that will make any difference whatsoever is the human population being dramatically reduced, back to 2 or 3 Billion. But you’re never going to get a politician anywhere to vote for that so basically we are just waiting for Mother Nature to do it for us, and she will.

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:28

It is impossible to hold Western governments to account over climate change and believing you can (and are failing to do so) is causing the feelings of distress I mentioned earlier.
For a Western government to actually meaningful reduce carbon emissions, for example (and by that I don't mean the slight of hand whereby they slip that carbon onto another country's balance sheet), it would require such a decline in average "living standards" that the government would fall/not get voted in.
What would actually need to happen for climate change to be "stopped" is for the average living standards of people in the western world to drop to the level of those in the developing world. We would have to live like the people who grow our coffee and our cocoa.
That's not a vote winner.

Specialneedsnightmare · 12/11/2026 09:29

This may be a very unpopular opinion , but I think people having children should be extremely concerned about it and think twice, especially before having multiple kids.

As a single person who is unwell , I am very concerned and do what I realistically can.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:31

Specialneedsnightmare · 12/11/2026 09:29

This may be a very unpopular opinion , but I think people having children should be extremely concerned about it and think twice, especially before having multiple kids.

As a single person who is unwell , I am very concerned and do what I realistically can.

Why? If people stop having children as in no children born the society will collapse. How is this a solution?

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:33

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:19

How?

That’s a really good question, and I’m not saying it’s easy - but I guess for me it’s about big corporations and politicians being shown that people do care, and that there is money and votes in climate action.

So, it’s stuff like writing to your MP to lobby for regulation - or if that’s not something you have time for, then at least making sure when someone from a political party comes knocking at your door come election time, you let them know their stance on the climate will influence your vote; emailing your pension provider and asking if their fossil-free fund options (so they know there’s demand for that); buying ethically certifiable products (which again proves demand).

Freemefromic · 12/11/2026 09:34

The biggest problem we face is the attitude of several countries towards climate change. Whilst we may do our bit, this is a drop in the ocean compared to the emissions from countries like China and India.

Specialneedsnightmare · 12/11/2026 09:35

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:31

Why? If people stop having children as in no children born the society will collapse. How is this a solution?

Well i ageee but there's no way that literally everyone would stop having children but I do think people planning families now should stop at one or two at the most if they decide to go ahead. I know three women who have five or six children and I just feel it's irresponsible in this climate.

Monty36 · 12/11/2026 09:39

user47639820987 · 12/11/2026 09:26

The only thing that will make any difference whatsoever is the human population being dramatically reduced, back to 2 or 3 Billion. But you’re never going to get a politician anywhere to vote for that so basically we are just waiting for Mother Nature to do it for us, and she will.

Correct. But I think it is too late anyway.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:39

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:33

That’s a really good question, and I’m not saying it’s easy - but I guess for me it’s about big corporations and politicians being shown that people do care, and that there is money and votes in climate action.

So, it’s stuff like writing to your MP to lobby for regulation - or if that’s not something you have time for, then at least making sure when someone from a political party comes knocking at your door come election time, you let them know their stance on the climate will influence your vote; emailing your pension provider and asking if their fossil-free fund options (so they know there’s demand for that); buying ethically certifiable products (which again proves demand).

Edited

MP just writes "Thank you". Same with pension providers. It won't matter at all in the big picture.

Yes you can buy a few ethically certifiable products. Not a lot to buy around here and not a lot which I use anyway - but it a nice thing to do, yes .

Mostly it's just words really.

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:39

The population debate is a red herring the average Brazilian produces about 3 tonnes of Carbon a year and the average American produces 17 tonnes.

When people say, oh well lots of people will just die, they are referring to people like those in India, who's average carbon production is 2 tonnes....

Population is not the issue. The way we live is.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:40

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:24

But how, precisely, do you suggest I hold these corporations accountable? What practical steps have you personally taken to do so?

And here's another consideration: when you're working full time, raising children and looking after elderly parents, where exactly are you supposed to find the time to lobby corporations, organise campaigns and campaign for legislative change?

These are not abstract inconveniences; they're the realities of millions of people's lives.

It's very easy to tell people to channel their anger into action, but considerably harder to explain what that action should look like in practice, or how people with already stretched lives with precious little free time are supposed to find the time and resources to do it.

I'm not climate fatigued because I don't care. I'm fatigued by the constant expectation that ordinary people must take on yet another responsibility for a problem over which they have very little control.

So yes, if I've spent a full working week earning a living, looking after children and caring for ageing parents, and I don't have the energy left to take on another campaigning responsibility, can you bloody blame me?

I'm genuinely asking: what have you personally done to hold these corporations accountable, and what realistically do you expect ordinary people to do beyond the things they're already doing?

I don’t disagree with what you’re saying - but what I also think is that a lot of political parties (all of them, maybe, even) have stopped believing there are any votes in committing to climate action, and alot of companies have stopped believing there is money to be lost if they don’t take climate action seriously enough. So, I do think we can - and should - all use our votes, and our choices about where and how we spend our money, to show them otherwise.

Parky04 · 12/11/2026 09:43

No, I don't care. I only care about the cost of living. Having food on the table and being able to heat my home is far more important.

crunchyvelvet · 12/11/2026 09:45

The article quotes from a couple of prime ministers looking for handouts. What's new?

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:46

MasterGland · 12/11/2026 09:39

The population debate is a red herring the average Brazilian produces about 3 tonnes of Carbon a year and the average American produces 17 tonnes.

When people say, oh well lots of people will just die, they are referring to people like those in India, who's average carbon production is 2 tonnes....

Population is not the issue. The way we live is.

Anerica won't change the next years. That's for sure.

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:46

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 09:40

I don’t disagree with what you’re saying - but what I also think is that a lot of political parties (all of them, maybe, even) have stopped believing there are any votes in committing to climate action, and alot of companies have stopped believing there is money to be lost if they don’t take climate action seriously enough. So, I do think we can - and should - all use our votes, and our choices about where and how we spend our money, to show them otherwise.

Edited

I've previously spoken to my local MP in person about a number of serious issues within social care, including failings that were putting vulnerable people at risk. The response was a rather patronising "yes, isn't it awful", followed by absolutely nothing being done.

Several friends have had very similar experiences. So forgive me if I'm somewhat sceptical about the effectiveness of writing yet another letter.

And regarding ethical and organic products, I think we need to recognise that being able to afford them is a privilege. It's all very well advocating ethical consumerism, but not everyone has the financial freedom to make those choices. For many people, buying what they can afford is the priority.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:48

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:46

I've previously spoken to my local MP in person about a number of serious issues within social care, including failings that were putting vulnerable people at risk. The response was a rather patronising "yes, isn't it awful", followed by absolutely nothing being done.

Several friends have had very similar experiences. So forgive me if I'm somewhat sceptical about the effectiveness of writing yet another letter.

And regarding ethical and organic products, I think we need to recognise that being able to afford them is a privilege. It's all very well advocating ethical consumerism, but not everyone has the financial freedom to make those choices. For many people, buying what they can afford is the priority.

Edited

And these products are very few. Does it make a real difference or is it just mostly words again?

Letsgonowthen · 12/11/2026 09:52

I do care but don't think enough can be done without politicians and countries being willing to make dramatic and unpopular decisions. Like rationing things.

But the depressing responses on the threads about the hosepipe ban make me despair that most people are willing to accept the necessary changes. Loads of people won't even give up using a hose.

Still worth doing the right thing and doing what you can of course.

phoebesplace · 12/11/2026 09:52

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:48

And these products are very few. Does it make a real difference or is it just mostly words again?

Edited

Exactly! and I've been genuinely shocked by just how much more expensive some of these products are