Please or to access all these features

Politics

Social services failed to protect traveller children from being abused because they were afraid of being seen as racist

88 replies

newacct · 11/11/2026 17:02

Bit of a heavy subject, I thought politics would be the best section to put this under.

While doing a bit of research, I stumbled on this analysis of reviews into cases where social services have failed traveller children. I feel like this should be a huge scandal and people need to know what happened to these poor babies.

https://academic.oup.com/bjsw/article/56/3/1364/8467095

The most damning part for me is this: "practitioners did not challenge parenting practices due to a fear of being viewed as discriminatory, perhaps even racist"

So basically, social workers ignored massive red flags because they saw it as normal for travellers and so it would be racist to treat them as the warning signs that they were eg. a man claiming to homeschool his 7 children even though he was functionally illiterate and social services didn't bother taking a closer look, meanwhile those 7 kids were being sexually abused.

There's more detail under the heading Consideration of culture and ethnicity

In four of the CSPRs [R1, R2, R3, R4], responses from professionals were said to be grounded in stereotypical understandings of Gypsy and Traveller culture, leading to potentially harmful behaviour towards children being perceived as a cultural norm.

In R7, it is noted that social workers failed to visit the family home and readily accepted that the children were being home-schooled, despite knowledge that their father did not have the skills himself to educate the children.

In more than half of the CSPRs [R1, R3, R4, R7] professionals, including social workers, health visitors, and schools, were evidenced as possessing cultural knowledge or were reported by the CSPR to have made attempts to approach their work with cultural sensitivity.

However, attempts to work in a culturally sensitive manner did not always equate to more effective safeguarding practice, and could be suggested to have had repercussions for the safety of the children concerned.

In R7, it is recorded that children’s services had tried to keep the children within the family due to their cultural needs despite knowing it was not in their best interest.

For reference, these are the details of those R-numbered cases:

[R1] Child C suffered a serious and life-threatening knife injury from a younger sibling. [age 7]

[R2] Child AG was presented at hospital and was found to be malnourished and neglected. X-rays found bone fractures of varying ages and long-term malnutrition. [age 2 and a half]

[R3] Child G died in the care of the of his mother’s partner, The cause of death was unable to identify the cause of death, but seven fractures were identified which predated his death. [age under 1 year]

[R4] Holly was admitted to hospital with a range of health issues which were attributed to neglect, one of the health issues was deemed to be life threatening. [age 3]

[R7] The children were in the sole care of their father and suffered sexual abuse, physical abuse and neglect emerged. [Seven siblings between the ages of
6 and 14]

OP posts:
Minasama · 12/11/2026 18:58

It’s so sad.
Those poor kids.
The problem here is the travellers not the social workers.
I am guessing the social workers need some additional support when dealing with these families.

ThePerfectStormBird · 12/11/2026 19:01

Sounds awfully like two tier policing doesn’t it?

Truinio · 12/11/2026 19:02

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 18:45

A culture doesn't mean they don't have to abide by the laws of the land which need to apply to everyone!

It kind of does. We are ruled and policed mostly by consent. If an entire community rejects those rules, then in reality there is very little the state can do about it.

A good example is a site near us where there were repeated firearms offences, mostly intimidation, poaching, and security cameras on farms being shot out before a burglary. Eventually the police went in, with firearms officers, to seize the firearms and arrest the owners.

The firearms were found hidden in a trailer that was mostly used as a crèche. Every single person on the site denied any knowledge. The owner of the trailer could not be determined so no-one was arrested.

That’s what you’re dealing with with some communities who have decided that the law simply doesn’t apply to them.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 19:05

ThePerfectStormBird · 12/11/2026 19:01

Sounds awfully like two tier policing doesn’t it?

It always has been. When I was in the police in the 1980s we were told not to bother with Irish "Travellers" unless the crime was the most serious, i.e. GBH upwards. Told to ignore minor offences like traffic related, drunkeness, burglaries, shoplifting, etc., even drink driving was to be ignored unless it was related to an injury RTA. Specifically prohibited from going near traveller sites without prior authority of an inspector ranked officer or above.

Truinio · 12/11/2026 19:21

JohnofWessex · 12/11/2026 17:45

I wonder if there was 'assertive' enforcement it might bring about long lasting change

ie let the Social Worker/Beat Copper/whatever in and play nicely or the Riot Squad will turn up with armed back up and deal with absolutely everything they can find at the same time eg untaxed vehicles, stolen property etc?

You can’t get a search warrant for a fishing trip. They are only issued if you provide evidence that a specific item or intelligence is located on the premises. And you would need a separate warrant for every home on a site.

IronEverything · 12/11/2026 19:48

I have first hand experience of this.

I was a gypsy child who was pulled out of school at 11. I can recall only twice being visited by the people who were meant to check that we were being educated (and we had a fixed address). Both times they were shown the pile of random school work I had accumulated during primary school. This was clearly sufficient in their eyes as no further questions were asked.

likelysuspect · 12/11/2026 19:56

teaandtoastwouldbenice · 11/11/2026 17:26

It’s infuriating.

I would also add that homeschooling is a safeguarding minefield - the actual education home school teams barely, if ever see the children. The acceptable level of ‘education’ is appalling. I would personally ban home education, it can be very dangerous but instead, cases just get pushed back to the home ed teams and children are left unseen or professionals dare not question a parents view on teaching.

Theres no law mandating parents to prove what is being provided.

I dont really agree with homeschooling for this reason.

Nextweektoo · 12/11/2026 20:20

teaandtoastwouldbenice · 11/11/2026 17:26

It’s infuriating.

I would also add that homeschooling is a safeguarding minefield - the actual education home school teams barely, if ever see the children. The acceptable level of ‘education’ is appalling. I would personally ban home education, it can be very dangerous but instead, cases just get pushed back to the home ed teams and children are left unseen or professionals dare not question a parents view on teaching.

I agree and despair with the legislation around EHE! It should be easier for CSC to get children on plans into mainstream education.

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 20:57

notthesebeesknees · 12/11/2026 18:36

It’s a legal responsibility to ensure children have an education.

And yet, education authorities across the country abdicate this responsibility for thousands of children and nobody seems to care, and those are the ones enrolled in school.

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 21:00

ThePerfectStormBird · 12/11/2026 19:01

Sounds awfully like two tier policing doesn’t it?

It’s nothing of the sort. That doesn’t exist in the way you want to claim it does.

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 21:06

notthesebeesknees · 12/11/2026 18:35

I disagree. Eight year olds playing together in a park near their home is not an issue, but children of that age being clearly and quite extremely underdressed for the weather is. That is a sign that parents are not coping. A child in a thin vest in the snow for what is presumably a prolonged period, rather than a quick scoot in the snow in the garden. That’s not normal parenting behaviour. A social workers job is based on being able to spot what is normal and what is not. SWs who take a relativist approach of ‘what is normal anyway’ should not be social workers.

I imagine the SW was not interested as they are overwhelmed and can only deal with more severe cases.

This is a long-standing issue that SWs want to dismiss signs that most everyone else would see as ‘not coping’ or ‘of concern’ as ‘lifestyle choices’. Their job is to discern what is normal and what is not.

Not necessarily. You’ve presumed a long period, that’s not confirmed. It all hinges on how the children were behaving. Kids don’t hang about playing in the snow if they are close to hypothermia. Frankly, if I saw it and was worried I’d nip over and speak to them before insisting social services come out.

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:14

PillsBox · 11/11/2026 17:31

This is what I was going to say.

There's an awful lot of fear of violence and reprecussions even if the police do attend.

I agree. I think it's more fear of violent backlash rather than fear of being called racist. I won't go into detail but I had to report a traveler family and you could see the police were even too frightened to take action.

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:19

rosydreams · 11/11/2026 18:16

not just the traveller community but even to mention said other groups would be considered racist .There are multiple groups that are hard for social workers because they fear racism .Good lord what happens behind closed doors

If anything research shows many social workers overlook things in middle class white families more so i'm not sure where you're going with this. I used to work in social services and if anything minority families were overrepresented. We did have one young white middle class woman who told us we couldn't touch her (ie/ remove her child) because she was 'white and posh'. Her words.😁 Reader: the child was moved to a foster home.

But her arrogance was interesting and while it was uncomfortable I think she had touched on something.

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:21

ThePerfectStormBird · 12/11/2026 19:01

Sounds awfully like two tier policing doesn’t it?

What is two tier policing? Could you explain backed by statistics and facts?

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:26

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:26

I’m saying that focusing on that part of it and making it the headline dismisses the actual problem. It’s reductive and ignores a whole lot of context.

We hear the same argument about the grooming gangs, that they were never reported because of a fear of racism. That is such a tiny part of a tiny part of what happened. People did report it, people did raise concerns, police were involved, social services did investigate. What happened was, the system was so disjointed that cross agency reviews didn’t look at the whole picture. And the biggest issue wasn’t the fear of racism, it was that the girls involved were vulnerable, and were deemed as trouble, labeled as prostitutes, teenage girls who liked what was happening, were looking for attention, were just being promiscuous. But there have never been headlines anywhere about that, instead we have the “fear of racism” plastered all over it - because that a far more palatable excuse. And still, the type of vulnerable teenagers who were groomed, are treated as the problem today, because nobody has done anything about that.

This! I saw plenty of white working class girls abused by mainly white men in the area I worked in. Also black and mixed race working class girls.

Had they been middle class girls swifter action would've been taken. The issue wasn't that they were white, it was they were working class /underclass.

I don't know the full details but i'm hearing a lot of the young women and girls Walliams allegedly targeted were working class too.

likelysuspect · 12/11/2026 21:28

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:14

I agree. I think it's more fear of violent backlash rather than fear of being called racist. I won't go into detail but I had to report a traveler family and you could see the police were even too frightened to take action.

SWs dont have security to go on visits. Going with police is not an option because they're not there to be your private body guard.

It absolutely is about risk to the worker rather than fear of being called racist. We get called all the names under the sun and complaints made all the time, its irrelevant.

Its about safety.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 12/11/2026 21:29

Ice worked with plenty of settled traveller families as a social worker and the cultural issues never stopped me from intervening properly. However that's just not really possible for children who live in caravans. No sooner than you had a call about them and gone to try to visit they have gone and left the area.

Bringemout · 12/11/2026 21:29

I really miss the days when we talked about having universal values and universal rights. The thread was that regardless of your colour, ethnicity, sex, sexual orientation, class etc that your rights were the same as anyone else's.

It’s becoming increasingly clear that it’s not true.

We need to start saying clearly, this is the standard, everyone must meet the minimum standard otherwise there will be consequences.

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:31

likelysuspect · 12/11/2026 21:28

SWs dont have security to go on visits. Going with police is not an option because they're not there to be your private body guard.

It absolutely is about risk to the worker rather than fear of being called racist. We get called all the names under the sun and complaints made all the time, its irrelevant.

Its about safety.

Yes, exactly.

Creedymcreedy · 12/11/2026 21:39

I can’t imagine it would ever be possible to tackle the huge problems associated with traveller sites without a government task force

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:48

Whatashamewhatapity · 12/11/2026 21:31

Yes, exactly.

Oh and to add - the whole 'people are too scared to act for fear of being called racist' is a narrative often pushed by racists IME.

They never give a shit about actual systemic or even casual racism but pipe up to claim no-one can do anything for fear of those 'wokies'.

So while I do believe some authorities such as social workers have issues with engaging with traveler families, I think it's a red herring and a dog whistle to say it's about them being scared of being labelled racist. Not for the most part.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 12/11/2026 21:56

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 17:29

I think this is quite harsh to lay this on SWs. Where I live you would be hard pressed to get police to attend a traveller site. I don't know what social workers are expected to do to eg. Enforce school attendance/ attend a multi-agency meeting.

Agreed.

They'd be facing having their cars torched or worse ....and be getting terrorised in their homes... etc.

The police are terrified fgs.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 13/11/2026 08:08

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 12/11/2026 21:29

Ice worked with plenty of settled traveller families as a social worker and the cultural issues never stopped me from intervening properly. However that's just not really possible for children who live in caravans. No sooner than you had a call about them and gone to try to visit they have gone and left the area.

Also - fear of being called racist? Absolutely not. The last traveller family I worked with their whole response to everything was to accuse us of discrimination and racism. It didn't stop me from doing anything at all. So what if I get accused of being called racist when I'm not being? Ridiculous argument

MalateOxaloacetate · 13/11/2026 09:05

I don’t blame the SWs tbh. Part of the work of SS works because the majority of the population would back them and believes children should be removed and wouldn’t help their neighbours if they decided to get violent or cause issues if their children were being taken for their own safety.

On a site, that’s the opposite. You don’t have the support of the majority and the population in place doesn’t see you as part of their society but as an invading, oppressive force. And they would fight back.

Blueseaurchin · 13/11/2026 09:14

Indeed.

It is ridiculous that in the UK children being taken out of school, women and girls being treated like second class citizen and the general opaque work/income tax practices are ignored due to so called 'culture'.

Time to forget about political correctness and apply laws and safeguarding to all communities.