Please or to access all these features

Politics

Social services failed to protect traveller children from being abused because they were afraid of being seen as racist

88 replies

newacct · 11/11/2026 17:02

Bit of a heavy subject, I thought politics would be the best section to put this under.

While doing a bit of research, I stumbled on this analysis of reviews into cases where social services have failed traveller children. I feel like this should be a huge scandal and people need to know what happened to these poor babies.

https://academic.oup.com/bjsw/article/56/3/1364/8467095

The most damning part for me is this: "practitioners did not challenge parenting practices due to a fear of being viewed as discriminatory, perhaps even racist"

So basically, social workers ignored massive red flags because they saw it as normal for travellers and so it would be racist to treat them as the warning signs that they were eg. a man claiming to homeschool his 7 children even though he was functionally illiterate and social services didn't bother taking a closer look, meanwhile those 7 kids were being sexually abused.

There's more detail under the heading Consideration of culture and ethnicity

In four of the CSPRs [R1, R2, R3, R4], responses from professionals were said to be grounded in stereotypical understandings of Gypsy and Traveller culture, leading to potentially harmful behaviour towards children being perceived as a cultural norm.

In R7, it is noted that social workers failed to visit the family home and readily accepted that the children were being home-schooled, despite knowledge that their father did not have the skills himself to educate the children.

In more than half of the CSPRs [R1, R3, R4, R7] professionals, including social workers, health visitors, and schools, were evidenced as possessing cultural knowledge or were reported by the CSPR to have made attempts to approach their work with cultural sensitivity.

However, attempts to work in a culturally sensitive manner did not always equate to more effective safeguarding practice, and could be suggested to have had repercussions for the safety of the children concerned.

In R7, it is recorded that children’s services had tried to keep the children within the family due to their cultural needs despite knowing it was not in their best interest.

For reference, these are the details of those R-numbered cases:

[R1] Child C suffered a serious and life-threatening knife injury from a younger sibling. [age 7]

[R2] Child AG was presented at hospital and was found to be malnourished and neglected. X-rays found bone fractures of varying ages and long-term malnutrition. [age 2 and a half]

[R3] Child G died in the care of the of his mother’s partner, The cause of death was unable to identify the cause of death, but seven fractures were identified which predated his death. [age under 1 year]

[R4] Holly was admitted to hospital with a range of health issues which were attributed to neglect, one of the health issues was deemed to be life threatening. [age 3]

[R7] The children were in the sole care of their father and suffered sexual abuse, physical abuse and neglect emerged. [Seven siblings between the ages of
6 and 14]

OP posts:
PillsBox · 12/11/2026 10:08

Weeelokthen · 12/11/2026 10:05

Well people were pointing out how difficult it is to venture on to traveller sites. Should we just leave they're vulnerable offspring to their fate then?

Yes because that's the only solution isn't it?

Honestly, how petulant.

Weeelokthen · 12/11/2026 14:02

PillsBox · 12/11/2026 10:08

Yes because that's the only solution isn't it?

Honestly, how petulant.

Other than physically going to remove abused children, what is ANY other solution then? Please, do tell and then I will stop being "petulant"!!

PillsBox · 12/11/2026 14:07

Weeelokthen · 12/11/2026 14:02

Other than physically going to remove abused children, what is ANY other solution then? Please, do tell and then I will stop being "petulant"!!

No, you crack on if petulance is your thing.

Meanwhile the rest of us adults will continue with the discussion.

No-one here has promised you any solutions.

emptygoosenest · 12/11/2026 14:12

When I worked as a children's social worker we had a lot of contact with local traveler sites, relationships with the community weren't awful but I was threatened with a shotgun once.
The biggest challenge is following dc around the country because they quickly move dc if they think you are getting too involved with them.

Truinio · 12/11/2026 14:15

emptygoosenest · 12/11/2026 14:12

When I worked as a children's social worker we had a lot of contact with local traveler sites, relationships with the community weren't awful but I was threatened with a shotgun once.
The biggest challenge is following dc around the country because they quickly move dc if they think you are getting too involved with them.

Being threatened with a shotgun is getting off lightly.

emptygoosenest · 12/11/2026 14:22

It was unusual at the time, threatening language, threats of physical violence, use of dogs were all quite common. Having an actual firearm waved in my face was a step up in intimidation in the area, and that was with several police officers present. It is a challenging community to work with that requires additional community resources which I suspect are in shorter supply now than they were then.

florasl · 12/11/2026 14:42

I once called the duty social worker as two little girls of maybe 7 or 8 were in our local play area unaccompanied in vests and thin pyjamas trousers, it was snowing. They appeared to be staying in a caravan parked up in the park with two adults in their sixties at least who appeared too old to be their parents.

The duty social worker told me I couldn’t report people for living a lifestyle I didn’t agree with and gave me a real telling off - never mind there were two small children in basically underwear playing unaccompanied in the snow.

Flapjak · 12/11/2026 14:49

With all the technology now it can't be that difficult to track sites when they up and leave. I find it strange that it is accepted that girls generally no longer attend school after primary age, clearly to keep them trapped and lower their aspirations for a life of their own.

JohnofWessex · 12/11/2026 15:05

There is a basic issue of the state having a duty to protect vulnerable individuals and sadly it doesnt have the bottle to do so

emptygoosenest · 12/11/2026 15:07

In our area the sites were often permanently occupied but dc that authorities were trying to keep an eye on were shuffled around them. The way to manage this is to have regular contact with the sites and the matriarchs who run the family aspects of the sites, so as social workers you know who is staying at the site and where they have moved from. This however requires more time and resources than is always available.

TherapyName · 12/11/2026 15:32

I have seen the same issues in so-called diversity training for therapists. Sadly it doesn't therefore surprise me.

Weeelokthen · 12/11/2026 15:55

PillsBox · 12/11/2026 14:07

No, you crack on if petulance is your thing.

Meanwhile the rest of us adults will continue with the discussion.

No-one here has promised you any solutions.

Condescending much!!!! 🙄
What is YOUR "adult" solution then???

Boomer55 · 12/11/2026 16:09

BrilliantBetty · 11/11/2026 17:44

Police don’t even attend traveller sites without ample precaution. SW shouldn’t have to fear going to work anymore than anyone else.
The acceptance of the traveller community in general is an issue. The community is not well functioning and there are so many complications. Children are of course being abused as are women. They found human trafficking of adult (Asian) males on a traveller site near me.
It is no secret to anyone that the traveller community is criminal through and through.

This. I worked in that sector. Attending a traveller site needs protection. They don’t welcome authority figures. 🤷‍♀️

JohnofWessex · 12/11/2026 17:45

I wonder if there was 'assertive' enforcement it might bring about long lasting change

ie let the Social Worker/Beat Copper/whatever in and play nicely or the Riot Squad will turn up with armed back up and deal with absolutely everything they can find at the same time eg untaxed vehicles, stolen property etc?

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:00

newacct · 11/11/2026 18:03

I think its a bigger cultural issue rather than the blame falling on individual social workers. They are trained to be try and be understanding of cultural differences and to respect different parenting practices being normal in different cultures (I've seen some of the training materials for SWs with examples like how it's normal for traveller girls to be left in charge of babies or boys to operate dangerous equipment so those things shouldn't be treated as causes for concern, and also saying that children shouldn't be taken from traveller families and placed with settled families because it's important to keep them within their own culture, which I think it what they were trying to follow in case R7).

I think there is a bigger issue. It’s that we do “training” on these things but the training is written absent any input from anyone within the traveller community. We have very little outreach or community liaison with the community because they are seen as a problem to solve rather than part of the fabric of our society. The institutional and societal stereotyping and racism feeds in to that.

We expect their very distinct way of life to fit in to our very narrow definition of what is right, rather than looking at how children can be protected within their own structures. For example, people will claim (as they have on this thread) that simply refusing to accept homeschooling as an option is the way to deal with this, but actually, homeschooling is far better for many within these communities because the education they value can differ from what is delivered within our school system. Not only that, having to move schools so often is damaging for children, we recognise that with service families and put things in place to ameliorate it, but we don’t for traveller families. Instead, we should be looking at a home schooling system which works, and having safeguarding built in to that. I doubt the vast majority of travellers would say they are fine with these situations and don’t want their kids protected from them. But their fear and mistrust of social services and authorities generally is for good reason, given if most people had their way, the community would disappear entirely.

Reports and posts like this simply add fuel to the fire, using terminology like “afraid to be called racist” feed in to the “everything is woke” right wing tropes. Inviting people to dump their views and feel good about it.

LattePatty · 12/11/2026 18:02

Flapjak · 12/11/2026 14:49

With all the technology now it can't be that difficult to track sites when they up and leave. I find it strange that it is accepted that girls generally no longer attend school after primary age, clearly to keep them trapped and lower their aspirations for a life of their own.

Boys too so they can start work.

it can’t be right to deny children (girls and boys) opportunities for education. Let alone expose them to abuse in the name of cultural sensitivity.

but from this thread it seems it would be a huge challenge to resolve. I don’t know what the answer is :(

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:11

florasl · 12/11/2026 14:42

I once called the duty social worker as two little girls of maybe 7 or 8 were in our local play area unaccompanied in vests and thin pyjamas trousers, it was snowing. They appeared to be staying in a caravan parked up in the park with two adults in their sixties at least who appeared too old to be their parents.

The duty social worker told me I couldn’t report people for living a lifestyle I didn’t agree with and gave me a real telling off - never mind there were two small children in basically underwear playing unaccompanied in the snow.

This is a good example of a very narrow set of rules for what is acceptable. A 7 & 8 year old playing unaccompanied is not necessarily a problem. In fact, I see kids of this age going about on our very “naice” middle class estate. The small park across from my house will often have kids that age playing without their parents. It was about this age I was happy with my child going out with friends round here. Plenty of children live with or are looked after grandparents, maybe that’s what was going on. Should they have been dressed better for the weather? Probably. Were they huddled in the corner freezing? Or were they doing that thing that kids do when they refuse to wear a jacket and yet seem entirely unbothered that it is freezing cold. Is there any parent out there who hasn’t had the “you have to put a jacket on” conversation with their kids?

You made an assumption based on prejudice rather than seeking out the actual facts of the case. The duty social worker wasn’t entirely wrong in this situation.

GeneralPeter · 12/11/2026 18:14

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:00

I think there is a bigger issue. It’s that we do “training” on these things but the training is written absent any input from anyone within the traveller community. We have very little outreach or community liaison with the community because they are seen as a problem to solve rather than part of the fabric of our society. The institutional and societal stereotyping and racism feeds in to that.

We expect their very distinct way of life to fit in to our very narrow definition of what is right, rather than looking at how children can be protected within their own structures. For example, people will claim (as they have on this thread) that simply refusing to accept homeschooling as an option is the way to deal with this, but actually, homeschooling is far better for many within these communities because the education they value can differ from what is delivered within our school system. Not only that, having to move schools so often is damaging for children, we recognise that with service families and put things in place to ameliorate it, but we don’t for traveller families. Instead, we should be looking at a home schooling system which works, and having safeguarding built in to that. I doubt the vast majority of travellers would say they are fine with these situations and don’t want their kids protected from them. But their fear and mistrust of social services and authorities generally is for good reason, given if most people had their way, the community would disappear entirely.

Reports and posts like this simply add fuel to the fire, using terminology like “afraid to be called racist” feed in to the “everything is woke” right wing tropes. Inviting people to dump their views and feel good about it.

Are you saying that fear being considered discriminatory didn’t affect how the professionals dealt with these abuse/neglect cases, or that yes it may have done but it shouldn’t be put in reports?

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:17

LattePatty · 12/11/2026 18:02

Boys too so they can start work.

it can’t be right to deny children (girls and boys) opportunities for education. Let alone expose them to abuse in the name of cultural sensitivity.

but from this thread it seems it would be a huge challenge to resolve. I don’t know what the answer is :(

Children are denied education for all sorts of reasons - many of them state sponsored in the name of budget cuts or inclusion. Those children don’t have a family business or way of life to fall back on. You can’t force any family to educate their children to tertiary level if they don’t want to. Just as with the rest of society, if the younger generations feel they are missing out because of a lack of education, they will change it for the generations who come after them. Or, they might decide they like how they live and continue to do that.

Conflating a way of life with abuse is very dangerous. The abuse should be dealt with, but that doesn’t mean they have to lose their heritage in order to do so.

notthesebeesknees · 12/11/2026 18:22

newacct · 11/11/2026 17:02

Bit of a heavy subject, I thought politics would be the best section to put this under.

While doing a bit of research, I stumbled on this analysis of reviews into cases where social services have failed traveller children. I feel like this should be a huge scandal and people need to know what happened to these poor babies.

https://academic.oup.com/bjsw/article/56/3/1364/8467095

The most damning part for me is this: "practitioners did not challenge parenting practices due to a fear of being viewed as discriminatory, perhaps even racist"

So basically, social workers ignored massive red flags because they saw it as normal for travellers and so it would be racist to treat them as the warning signs that they were eg. a man claiming to homeschool his 7 children even though he was functionally illiterate and social services didn't bother taking a closer look, meanwhile those 7 kids were being sexually abused.

There's more detail under the heading Consideration of culture and ethnicity

In four of the CSPRs [R1, R2, R3, R4], responses from professionals were said to be grounded in stereotypical understandings of Gypsy and Traveller culture, leading to potentially harmful behaviour towards children being perceived as a cultural norm.

In R7, it is noted that social workers failed to visit the family home and readily accepted that the children were being home-schooled, despite knowledge that their father did not have the skills himself to educate the children.

In more than half of the CSPRs [R1, R3, R4, R7] professionals, including social workers, health visitors, and schools, were evidenced as possessing cultural knowledge or were reported by the CSPR to have made attempts to approach their work with cultural sensitivity.

However, attempts to work in a culturally sensitive manner did not always equate to more effective safeguarding practice, and could be suggested to have had repercussions for the safety of the children concerned.

In R7, it is recorded that children’s services had tried to keep the children within the family due to their cultural needs despite knowing it was not in their best interest.

For reference, these are the details of those R-numbered cases:

[R1] Child C suffered a serious and life-threatening knife injury from a younger sibling. [age 7]

[R2] Child AG was presented at hospital and was found to be malnourished and neglected. X-rays found bone fractures of varying ages and long-term malnutrition. [age 2 and a half]

[R3] Child G died in the care of the of his mother’s partner, The cause of death was unable to identify the cause of death, but seven fractures were identified which predated his death. [age under 1 year]

[R4] Holly was admitted to hospital with a range of health issues which were attributed to neglect, one of the health issues was deemed to be life threatening. [age 3]

[R7] The children were in the sole care of their father and suffered sexual abuse, physical abuse and neglect emerged. [Seven siblings between the ages of
6 and 14]

This keeps happening. The Victoria Climbie SW said she did not act on concerns she saw that she would have acted on if the family were white, as she put what she saw down to cultural differences.

A SW working with two gay men fostering children, later found to be sexually abusing the boys in their care, said she did not act on concerns she otherwise would have, because of fear of being homophobic. .

It’s sickening. Social workers need to treat all families the same, and act on concerns without these self interested fears of being seen as ‘ist’ or ‘phobic’ creating noise in their decision making.

Many parts of child protection are hard, but this bit is not. Let go of your sodding politics and act on what you see before you.

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:26

GeneralPeter · 12/11/2026 18:14

Are you saying that fear being considered discriminatory didn’t affect how the professionals dealt with these abuse/neglect cases, or that yes it may have done but it shouldn’t be put in reports?

Edited

I’m saying that focusing on that part of it and making it the headline dismisses the actual problem. It’s reductive and ignores a whole lot of context.

We hear the same argument about the grooming gangs, that they were never reported because of a fear of racism. That is such a tiny part of a tiny part of what happened. People did report it, people did raise concerns, police were involved, social services did investigate. What happened was, the system was so disjointed that cross agency reviews didn’t look at the whole picture. And the biggest issue wasn’t the fear of racism, it was that the girls involved were vulnerable, and were deemed as trouble, labeled as prostitutes, teenage girls who liked what was happening, were looking for attention, were just being promiscuous. But there have never been headlines anywhere about that, instead we have the “fear of racism” plastered all over it - because that a far more palatable excuse. And still, the type of vulnerable teenagers who were groomed, are treated as the problem today, because nobody has done anything about that.

notthesebeesknees · 12/11/2026 18:35

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:11

This is a good example of a very narrow set of rules for what is acceptable. A 7 & 8 year old playing unaccompanied is not necessarily a problem. In fact, I see kids of this age going about on our very “naice” middle class estate. The small park across from my house will often have kids that age playing without their parents. It was about this age I was happy with my child going out with friends round here. Plenty of children live with or are looked after grandparents, maybe that’s what was going on. Should they have been dressed better for the weather? Probably. Were they huddled in the corner freezing? Or were they doing that thing that kids do when they refuse to wear a jacket and yet seem entirely unbothered that it is freezing cold. Is there any parent out there who hasn’t had the “you have to put a jacket on” conversation with their kids?

You made an assumption based on prejudice rather than seeking out the actual facts of the case. The duty social worker wasn’t entirely wrong in this situation.

I disagree. Eight year olds playing together in a park near their home is not an issue, but children of that age being clearly and quite extremely underdressed for the weather is. That is a sign that parents are not coping. A child in a thin vest in the snow for what is presumably a prolonged period, rather than a quick scoot in the snow in the garden. That’s not normal parenting behaviour. A social workers job is based on being able to spot what is normal and what is not. SWs who take a relativist approach of ‘what is normal anyway’ should not be social workers.

I imagine the SW was not interested as they are overwhelmed and can only deal with more severe cases.

This is a long-standing issue that SWs want to dismiss signs that most everyone else would see as ‘not coping’ or ‘of concern’ as ‘lifestyle choices’. Their job is to discern what is normal and what is not.

notthesebeesknees · 12/11/2026 18:36

BoredZelda · 12/11/2026 18:17

Children are denied education for all sorts of reasons - many of them state sponsored in the name of budget cuts or inclusion. Those children don’t have a family business or way of life to fall back on. You can’t force any family to educate their children to tertiary level if they don’t want to. Just as with the rest of society, if the younger generations feel they are missing out because of a lack of education, they will change it for the generations who come after them. Or, they might decide they like how they live and continue to do that.

Conflating a way of life with abuse is very dangerous. The abuse should be dealt with, but that doesn’t mean they have to lose their heritage in order to do so.

It’s a legal responsibility to ensure children have an education.

Badbadbunny · 12/11/2026 18:45

A culture doesn't mean they don't have to abide by the laws of the land which need to apply to everyone!

Truinio · 12/11/2026 18:51

Flapjak · 12/11/2026 14:49

With all the technology now it can't be that difficult to track sites when they up and leave. I find it strange that it is accepted that girls generally no longer attend school after primary age, clearly to keep them trapped and lower their aspirations for a life of their own.

Sorry, with all what technology exactly? Do you think children’s services have access to spy satellites or something?

If a family leave a site in the middle of the night there all the technology in the world isn’t going to tell you where they’ve gone.