Please or to access all these features

Philosophy/religion

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

Grumbles about the Church of England

38 replies

WhitegreeNcandle · 19/10/2026 07:13

This is one for the Christians out there. I’ve been a lifelong member of the CofE. Two small village churches over my lifetime with a brief soujourn to a city CofE where I saw a much more evangelical side.

After decades of PCC meetings and harvest suppers with dwindling volunteers I’ve had enough. There’s a particular situation in our parish right now where the Archdeacon and Diocesan Secretary offer unlimited email support to our vicar and PCC but that is just covering up such inept management it’s effectively useless.

I can’t abide how much money the Diocese takes in Parish Share that we get no support for. Why do we not have a standard program for Messy Church or toddler group. We are completely reliant on a tiny group of dwindling volunteers and there seems to be little or no support from on high. I feel the Diocese are fiddling whilst Rome burns (or paying reparations whilst roofs fall in).

I moonlight at a local Evangelical non conformist. I mostly love it (despite some of the music managing to be jazzy but theologically wishy washy). I feel it’s very much how the early church would have looked. It’s in the next town over.

im umming and aahing about this being the final straw for me. But if I resign from the PCC there will only be one other person under 75. The toddler group would close, the beetle drives won’t happen. All the things I want to see in our rural village will die a death. Can I live in my village and watch that happen? There’s plenty of other families who manage it!

anyone else had any similar thoughts?

OP posts:
InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 29/10/2026 22:27

@Oakeydokemy parish is the cathedral. It’s pretty similar, the Priest deals with most things. The secretary is a paid role and that’s it really. Loads of volunteers but no legal stuff.

LancashireButterPie · 30/10/2026 08:01

DH and I went on holiday to a lovely posh hotel in the lake district last year and there was some form of vicars conference on at the same time.
I have never heard so much moaning and bitchiness in all my life, all of them complaining about how the parishioners and volunteers are so needy.
They were judgemental and completely up their own arses.
One was complaining that her church was becoming popular with the traveller community and the others were joking re how to discourage them.
I used to volunteer and honestly, I'd be horrified to think I was being criticised for my efforts.

OP, it's the ordinary parishioners who see you and appreciate your efforts, not the hierarchy.

DeafLeppard · 30/10/2026 08:27

I think there’s a real disconnect between the “corporate” church, for want of a better word, that’s all about reparations and social justice, and the real world of village parishes and benefices. I think a lot of the more corporate lot would quite like Mrs Miggins and the flower rota to be replaced by Boden wearing families who aren’t needy, have more money and fewer needs (or more PR friendly needs).

I also think that the on the ground church hasn’t figured out how to work in the modern world where people’s capacity for volunteering simply isn’t what it used to be, because far more women work.

Imupforthat · 30/10/2026 08:29

I walked away before it killed me.

Everything was landing on me as the rest of the buggers either expected me to do it or had no interest and were only there because they needed the position to justify other roles they were interested in. It turned into a full time unpaid job with less than constructive feedback including bullying which was never addressed.

The final straw for me was being hit with several difficult personal crisis’ at once and being volunteered by the vicar to do something I had already explained I couldn’t because of the above. I ended up completely losing my shit and breaking down in front of them. Not one of them ever checked on me afterwards as I entered one of the darkest periods of my life and I never heard from any of them again after stepping down.

Do not start me on Parish Share. Why yes £10k shared amongst a congregation of 3 elderly widows and 4 young families is very achievable and we wouldn’t want the Bishop to be going without a new gold hat. Hopefully that will cheer him up a bit re the historical unpleasantness of which we do not speak.

They refused to listen to any reason/financial suggestions from people who managed billion pound companies on a daily basis but accepted any old toot from a bearded bloke in a dog collar because that was obviously divinely inspired. Unsurprisingly this led to financial disaster for those daft enough to sign up to the stupid scheme but a nice promotion for beardy bloke.

And breath……

Seagulldancing · 30/10/2026 08:40

My MiL (CoW) is about to walk away after decades on PCC. At 73 shes the youngest, and everything nearly collapsed when she took 6 months after her husband died. The rest of them seem to actively put off anyone else helping, but are confused when all the young ones go off to the evangelical churches, so now take the approach of why bother.
The 4 village churches they support will be closed when they die. A sad loss of a community asset which has been there since the 15th century.

Screamingabdabz · 30/10/2026 09:01

DeafLeppard · 30/10/2026 08:27

I think there’s a real disconnect between the “corporate” church, for want of a better word, that’s all about reparations and social justice, and the real world of village parishes and benefices. I think a lot of the more corporate lot would quite like Mrs Miggins and the flower rota to be replaced by Boden wearing families who aren’t needy, have more money and fewer needs (or more PR friendly needs).

I also think that the on the ground church hasn’t figured out how to work in the modern world where people’s capacity for volunteering simply isn’t what it used to be, because far more women work.

This is so true. There is a huge snob factor in the CofE and the church, as in the body of Christ, is definitely less of a priority (for some clergy) than the hob-knobbing and climbing the greasy pole. Once you’ve actually witnessed that at first hand, the appeal of volunteering to support parish ministry just makes you feel like a mug.

So it’s also true what you say, about ‘Boden wearing families’. You’ve only got to look at the misty edged images on the CofE website to see what they value. Attractive fresh-faced middle class millennials, a few token diverse faces and model grey haired people as long as they have perfect smiles, tans and a grandchild with them. Not like in our working class church where we have face-tattoo ladies, bearded bikers, scruffy chaotic families and half the congregation is obese.

I believe that the key to revival is that the whole nature of Anglican worship, book of common prayer, and liturgy needs to be updated for modern generations. We’ll fade into obscurity otherwise. Even I find it deathly tedious half the time and I’ve grown up with it. Tinkering around the edges with things like messy church isn’t going to cut it.

Or maybe the season for the CofE is just over? Maybe we just need to let it die and hand over to the evangelicals?

DeafLeppard · 30/10/2026 09:55

Screamingabdabz · 30/10/2026 09:01

This is so true. There is a huge snob factor in the CofE and the church, as in the body of Christ, is definitely less of a priority (for some clergy) than the hob-knobbing and climbing the greasy pole. Once you’ve actually witnessed that at first hand, the appeal of volunteering to support parish ministry just makes you feel like a mug.

So it’s also true what you say, about ‘Boden wearing families’. You’ve only got to look at the misty edged images on the CofE website to see what they value. Attractive fresh-faced middle class millennials, a few token diverse faces and model grey haired people as long as they have perfect smiles, tans and a grandchild with them. Not like in our working class church where we have face-tattoo ladies, bearded bikers, scruffy chaotic families and half the congregation is obese.

I believe that the key to revival is that the whole nature of Anglican worship, book of common prayer, and liturgy needs to be updated for modern generations. We’ll fade into obscurity otherwise. Even I find it deathly tedious half the time and I’ve grown up with it. Tinkering around the edges with things like messy church isn’t going to cut it.

Or maybe the season for the CofE is just over? Maybe we just need to let it die and hand over to the evangelicals?

I have the completely opposite opinion regarding updating the liturgy 😂 I hate worship bands, praise songs and the whole “Jesus is my Boyfriend” vibes from some of them, and think that BCP is brilliant! BUT I also think there should be room for all of the above, even if I think the central pillar should be liturgy rooted in centuries of theology. You don’t see the Catholics changing stuff up all the time, do you? The whole point is that the message is unchanging, and the CofE liturgy is in itself a beautiful piece of English language.

mostlydrinkstea · 30/10/2026 13:29

I’m the vicar of four parishes in a rural area. I’m really conscious that most of my congregation are too elderly and have already done their bit, to ask them to do anymore. We employ people to do the jobs that younger volunteers used to do. I realise that this is not an option for many churches but it is this or close. I’m exploring sharing my paid resource with other churches now that we have got our governance in some sort of order.

NewGrandmummy · 30/10/2026 13:36

mostlydrinkstea · 30/10/2026 13:29

I’m the vicar of four parishes in a rural area. I’m really conscious that most of my congregation are too elderly and have already done their bit, to ask them to do anymore. We employ people to do the jobs that younger volunteers used to do. I realise that this is not an option for many churches but it is this or close. I’m exploring sharing my paid resource with other churches now that we have got our governance in some sort of order.

(Waves sympathetically.)

I left parish ministry a few years ago to enter chaplaincy - best thing I ever did!

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 30/10/2026 16:28

@DeafLeppardyou are right. I’m RC but have a love of the BCP liturgy. The one think I love about the RC church is the consistency. Mass is Mass, the theology is the same, the music may be different but it’ll never be dumbed down. And you can go to a catholic church in any part of the world and it’s the same. I went to my parents middle of the road Anglican Church and had no idea what was going on!

CraftyGin · 30/10/2026 16:35

Our Parish Share is about £140k a year, and I'd say we get good use for it. Obviously there is vicar, vicarage and curate costs, which must be close to £100k. Then add on how much it we pay towards the bishop and archdeacon. After that, there is safeguarding support, DAC, training, youth support. We even get all our licenses (media etc) paid for.

If you aren't using your diocese resources, you should.

WhitegreeNcandle · 30/10/2026 20:59

CraftyGin · 30/10/2026 16:35

Our Parish Share is about £140k a year, and I'd say we get good use for it. Obviously there is vicar, vicarage and curate costs, which must be close to £100k. Then add on how much it we pay towards the bishop and archdeacon. After that, there is safeguarding support, DAC, training, youth support. We even get all our licenses (media etc) paid for.

If you aren't using your diocese resources, you should.

Must depend on the Diocese. Ours doesn’t have those resources available excepting DAC and safeguarding.

OP posts:
InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 05/11/2026 12:20

My parents former church’s parish share absolutely crippled them. It was enormous.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread