Please or to access all these features

Philosophy/religion

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

Grumbles about the Church of England

38 replies

WhitegreeNcandle · 19/10/2026 07:13

This is one for the Christians out there. I’ve been a lifelong member of the CofE. Two small village churches over my lifetime with a brief soujourn to a city CofE where I saw a much more evangelical side.

After decades of PCC meetings and harvest suppers with dwindling volunteers I’ve had enough. There’s a particular situation in our parish right now where the Archdeacon and Diocesan Secretary offer unlimited email support to our vicar and PCC but that is just covering up such inept management it’s effectively useless.

I can’t abide how much money the Diocese takes in Parish Share that we get no support for. Why do we not have a standard program for Messy Church or toddler group. We are completely reliant on a tiny group of dwindling volunteers and there seems to be little or no support from on high. I feel the Diocese are fiddling whilst Rome burns (or paying reparations whilst roofs fall in).

I moonlight at a local Evangelical non conformist. I mostly love it (despite some of the music managing to be jazzy but theologically wishy washy). I feel it’s very much how the early church would have looked. It’s in the next town over.

im umming and aahing about this being the final straw for me. But if I resign from the PCC there will only be one other person under 75. The toddler group would close, the beetle drives won’t happen. All the things I want to see in our rural village will die a death. Can I live in my village and watch that happen? There’s plenty of other families who manage it!

anyone else had any similar thoughts?

OP posts:
oldestmumaintheworld · 19/10/2026 07:28

What are the particular things that you would like to see happen? Is yours a small Diocese? How many churches, parishes and stipendiary clergy?
Do you have a Friends group for your church?
Each Diocese has a Church Building Support Officer who is there specifically to help on the ground. Call them and ask for a visit. They will provide help. Also consider Asset Based Community Development (Google will give you pointers to people within the CofE who do this). It is very powerful and definitely works.
Alternatively take a step back for a year. Perhaps you need a period of rest and reflection. A fallow period to refresh. We all need that from time to time.

WhitegreeNcandle · 19/10/2026 07:41

It’s around 350
churches. 2 Archdeaconries. 12 Deacons.

It’s not so much the building stuff - I know there’s support there. It’s more HR stuff - not fair to go into detail in a public forum but the lack of management has appalled me. The diocese just swing it back to the pcc but in a benefice of 4 different pcc’s take different perspectives and I feel strongly the diocese should step in supporting our vicar to back the pcc’s following employment law.

I suppose I’m wondering as well if we are too far down the path to ever see a Revival without some form of church plant.

OP posts:
oldestmumaintheworld · 19/10/2026 07:50

HR can be very difficult. You will be aware that PCCs have the ultimate authority of decision making and that is difficult for Dioceses as they have very limited room in which to operate. If the issue relates to an employment matter I would ask for a phone meeting with either the Diocesan Registrar or the Chancellor's Clerk and ask for their advice as to how best to proceed. Alternatively, the main CofE website lists people to contact for specific HR support nationally.
Finally, you could consider getting outside HR support from the safeguarding team. They can often point you towards outside help to explain the law and ensure it is implemented.
I hope this helps

WhitegreeNcandle · 19/10/2026 08:20

Thanks @oldestmumaintheworld we have done most of that. It’s a very very clear HR issue that with two minutes on ACAS or government website is incredibly clear. We have one PCC refusing to do their share meaning the other 3 parishes are picking up the pieces. The diocese agree with us until they sit in front of said PCC who are extremely difficult and then they capitulate. Two years to solve an issue that will cost a couple of grand across 4 parishes. The time spent on this by vicars and archdeacons is probably worth 4 of what the actual resolution would cost.

We have a Diocesan secretary not a registrar - are they the same thing?

OP posts:
mintleavesandthyme · 19/10/2026 19:59

No advice @WhitegreeNcandlebut well done for sticking it out and giving so much. village churches are a hotbed of peopley goings on and it’s so draining.

LlynTegid · 19/10/2026 20:02

Is there any possibility of the vicar moving or retiring in the near future? If there is, could you stick it out until then and try with the successor?

oldestmumaintheworld · 19/10/2026 21:24

No. Diocesan Registrar is different. Diocesan Secretary is the CEO , the Registrar is the legal advisor. It sounds like this is what you need.
I do appreciate how 'soft' some staff and clergy can be when faced with difficult decisions. Legal advice might be helpful.

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 28/10/2026 18:03

My mum is PCC secretary. She spends every spare minute on it. It’s completely taken over both her and my dads life. It’s all they talk about. I just don’t get the point. I’m RC and we don’t have any of that.

deplorabelle · 29/10/2026 10:00

Yep. Lifelong member of the CofE here too - been in PCCs, committees, deanery synods etc though I am not currently. I feel desperately in the doldrums even though our current church is a much wealthier town church which still gets congregations up to the hundred mark and has children in attendance most weeks.

It's a shadow of its former self though and as volunteers we feel like we are slowly being destroyed. A friend of mine has a paid role in the parish now. She's the first competent person to do the role in decades (the previous vicar having driven people away by blaming them for his mistakes and generally being a bit of a pompous dick). She has been in role less than a year and I'm already worried it will kill her.

You can't get off any rotas except by dying or reaching your 90th birthday. People keep looking at me meaningfully as a young person in the hope I'll run everything. I'm fucking 50!!

WhitegreeNcandle · 29/10/2026 13:20

deplorabelle · 29/10/2026 10:00

Yep. Lifelong member of the CofE here too - been in PCCs, committees, deanery synods etc though I am not currently. I feel desperately in the doldrums even though our current church is a much wealthier town church which still gets congregations up to the hundred mark and has children in attendance most weeks.

It's a shadow of its former self though and as volunteers we feel like we are slowly being destroyed. A friend of mine has a paid role in the parish now. She's the first competent person to do the role in decades (the previous vicar having driven people away by blaming them for his mistakes and generally being a bit of a pompous dick). She has been in role less than a year and I'm already worried it will kill her.

You can't get off any rotas except by dying or reaching your 90th birthday. People keep looking at me meaningfully as a young person in the hope I'll run everything. I'm fucking 50!!

I know! I’m 46 and am considered a youngster in our congregation!!

OP posts:
deplorabelle · 29/10/2026 13:20

Coming back to add: I hugely sympathize with your feelings of "if I leave will X thing carry on?" It's a horrendous pressure to put on volunteers.

And solidarity too for the "clergy and diocese operate in a way completely at odds with the real world" way of tackling problems. Unbelievably frustrating and a total waste of whatever expertise there might be within the congregation. (Previous vicar used to take tasks away from people who knew what they were doing and give them to astonishingly unqualified people he thought would blossom in the role. You'd then get it back to try to fix whatever ludicrous mess they made when the person inevitably left after six months)

I don't know what the solution is.

twilightcafe · 29/10/2026 15:14

It's literally a case of 'dead men's shoes' for church volunteers. In that only death will set you free from The Rota unless you can find a new sucker to take your role.

The PCC person at my local church had a nervous breakdown due to the demands of the role. She is an incredibly competent professional but the vicars acted as if she had nothing else to do but run the church.

Sannabay · 29/10/2026 15:46

It sounds like a social club.

Is the Gospel preached?.

If not why are you involved?

Sannabay · 29/10/2026 15:55

tell-me-more.org

ClaudiaWankleman · 29/10/2026 17:26

Sannabay · 29/10/2026 15:46

It sounds like a social club.

Is the Gospel preached?.

If not why are you involved?

Is the Gospel preached at the Church of England? Have you been lobotomised? Of course it is. There is just a raft of other volunteer work that goes into any Church which is the subject of this thread.

Sannabay · 29/10/2026 17:39

I can assure you X crucified is definitely Not a priority in many C of E churches.

Many preach a social gospel.

WhitegreeNcandle · 29/10/2026 19:09

Sannabay · 29/10/2026 15:55

tell-me-more.org

Yes it is and we have a pretty theologically sound vicar.

I do my bit because I believe thay Jesus is our Saviour and I want to tell people about that. I want my village to have somewhere that worships god. I run the toddler group because I want more people to know how transformational a relationship with Jesus can be.

But I also love the tradition. A great harvest supper. Neighbours who look after each other. A funeral where the whole village turns out. I want to live in a Christian society that makes these things happen so I put my money and my time where my mouth is.

OP posts:
Oakeydoke · 29/10/2026 19:15

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 28/10/2026 18:03

My mum is PCC secretary. She spends every spare minute on it. It’s completely taken over both her and my dads life. It’s all they talk about. I just don’t get the point. I’m RC and we don’t have any of that.

I’m also RC and trying to decipher all the acronyms here! It sounds like some kind of exhausting management structure, with all kind of politics at play.

Oakeydoke · 29/10/2026 19:16

WhitegreeNcandle · 29/10/2026 19:09

Yes it is and we have a pretty theologically sound vicar.

I do my bit because I believe thay Jesus is our Saviour and I want to tell people about that. I want my village to have somewhere that worships god. I run the toddler group because I want more people to know how transformational a relationship with Jesus can be.

But I also love the tradition. A great harvest supper. Neighbours who look after each other. A funeral where the whole village turns out. I want to live in a Christian society that makes these things happen so I put my money and my time where my mouth is.

Good for you, OP - I mean that sincerely. I feel the same but due to work commitments, small children and disabilities can’t ‘give’ as much as I would like at the moment. But people like you are worth your weight in gold.

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 29/10/2026 19:20

@Oakeydoke it is hard work. It makes me so glad to be RC. Where the structures are much clearer and less politics.

Oakeydoke · 29/10/2026 19:23

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 29/10/2026 19:20

@Oakeydoke it is hard work. It makes me so glad to be RC. Where the structures are much clearer and less politics.

Yes - just a priest and a few committed elderly ladies who do his laundry and choose the hymns… (if our village is anything to go by)

handmademitlove · 29/10/2026 19:23

If you have the time to give to the PCC, please do keep going. They need people with their feet firmly planted in reality! Treat it as a community volunteer role. And don't feel bad about also attending other churches. I know many people who do this, because sometimes you just need to receive and not to give!

I am, I guess, the opposite to you. I attend a local free church, but have connection with the parish church and support events / activities there as well.

khaa2091 · 29/10/2026 19:30

WhitegreeNcandle · 29/10/2026 13:20

I know! I’m 46 and am considered a youngster in our congregation!!

Yup (47 yr old), but our (excellent) rector is early thirties.......

I choose to attend the church in the village I grew up in, which is only 6 miles from where I live. I won't have anything to do with the church in my own village - is that an option for you?

I was extremely upset by the complete closure in Covid, the final straw being a return sermon on how God would forgive all those horrible health care workers who had stopped families from seeing loved ones and offering prayers for us emergency workers who did not see the error of our ways. As you can imagine, working in Covid was a difficult experience, compounded by my miscarrying on shift and only feeling able to take a single day off work. To be told that I could not appreciate the difficulties facing patients in any way failed to understand that healthcare workers are families and patients too.

deplorabelle · 29/10/2026 22:03

khaa2091 · 29/10/2026 19:30

Yup (47 yr old), but our (excellent) rector is early thirties.......

I choose to attend the church in the village I grew up in, which is only 6 miles from where I live. I won't have anything to do with the church in my own village - is that an option for you?

I was extremely upset by the complete closure in Covid, the final straw being a return sermon on how God would forgive all those horrible health care workers who had stopped families from seeing loved ones and offering prayers for us emergency workers who did not see the error of our ways. As you can imagine, working in Covid was a difficult experience, compounded by my miscarrying on shift and only feeling able to take a single day off work. To be told that I could not appreciate the difficulties facing patients in any way failed to understand that healthcare workers are families and patients too.

I'm so sorry to read about your miscarriage and at such a stressful time at work xx

InQuiresandplaceswheretheysing · 29/10/2026 22:16

I thought it was very interesting that, at the weekend, Liverpool Anglican cathedral closed. But the metropolitan stayed open. Both equally exposed to the storm. It sums up the Church of England!