www, I bet he would grass you up now. Kids are so honest - bless them -
skie, bad news about strawberry - but he was never going to be exactly like the old one (smell, dilapidation etc) so whatever you do size-wise must help.
Thing is, I was thinking earlier, I know you said your DD rejected the similar-but-bigger strawberry when she had her own one, but a substitute that's not exactly the same might just do at a pinch, now the other one has vanished?
If she knew how hard you've been trying for her...!