Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Would you rather be Cash Rich and House Poor? Or House Rich and Cash Poor?

108 replies

rootsandwings89 · 03/10/2026 16:48

What’s more important to you? Is a big family home worth it if it eats up most of your income?

Or do you prefer to have more disposable income to enjoy holidays etc. but have a smaller home?

We are currently trying to weigh up our next house move …

OP posts:
Summer26woohoo · 04/10/2026 20:56

There's usually a happy medium though isn't there? It's not common to see people crammed into a 2 bed terrace with 3 kids whilst taking several luxury holidays a year, is it? OR to see families in mansions whilst using the food bank!

We have a 'standard' 4 bed detatched. It's in a nice area with decent size rooms and it houses 5 plus the dog comfortably, with reasonable disposable income. But it's not 'posh' or with huge gardens and a spare games room.

We could more than halve our repayments if we downsized to a 3 bed semi and be far better off financially - but we'd probably be on top of each other and two of the dc would have to share. OR we could level up, add a couple of hundred K to our mortgage and live in a huge far posher 4 bed with 'grounds' but use all our disppsable on it.

Neither of the extreme options appeal tbh.

Lovingmynewlifestyle · 04/10/2026 21:14

My everyday life is more important than my holidays. I have had some amazing holidays!
I love my large Kitchen - enough rooms for everyone and some spare, a beautiful garden. We gave up so much to have this home and I have not regretted a single time in this house. We have enough space that we can be in our own rooms if needed.

Whynottryagain · 04/10/2026 21:21

Cash rich if it was a binary choice.

Big houses have big bills and maintenance and cleaning requirements so if I had a big house but no cash I'd be too stressed to really enjoy it.

BoogieTuTu · 04/10/2026 21:24

We are house poor and following paying off debt in a few months, we will be cash rich. We did consider moving but with today’s rates, the mortgage repayments were just insane. My job is demanding and with being cash rich following debt repayment with the tune of making quite a significant saving each month. We would be able to pay off our mortgage in 7 years (we are early to mid forties) at the same time as investing and being able to live a comfortable life. We chose this over the house as the financial peace and the thought of possibly retiring in our 50’s or certainly working less in our 50’s is much more appealing.

Newusername2026 · 04/10/2026 21:30

House probably but if you are struggling to pay mortgage it might feel perilous and insecure

durdledoris · 04/10/2026 21:31

Smaller home more money - so long as it was big enough if that makes sense.

ViciousCurrentBun · 04/10/2026 21:43

We stayed with a smaller house, you have one backside that can sit in just one room at a time, that’s how I view it. Now DS has left there is zero need to downsize. We had both retired by age 56, we are not the same age. So 18 months retired together as DH has caught up. So far we have travelled round the UK and Ireland in our motor home for a total of close to 5 of those months, would have been more but MIL needed help when she was diagnosed with cancer.

My mates have bigger houses and probably nicer cushion covers. As long as you aren’t rammed in a house so it’s overcrowded what does it matter.

We are in a decent size 3 bed semi built in the 1920’s. The actual square metres of space mean it’s probably the size of a 4 bed new build.

brunettenorthern91 · 04/10/2026 21:55

It depends on your setup and exact finances.

We have a £400K home we can easily afford now without children on a combined £140K when we bought it. We have a lot of savings and a LOT of high end holidays or holidays where we don’t feel the need to hold back spending - not Michelin star dining, but if I want to sit in Italy/France with a bottle of decent wine with 2 course lunch at a local gem of a restaurant, I will… every day!😂 (We both spent our 20s grinding ourselves in our professions, so why not!)

We want kids in the next couple of years so recognised the holidays would need to pull back. Longer term 5-10 years we’d love to move from a lovely 4 bed house to a 5 bed house on a private plot.

We recently (surprisingly) shot to a £200K household income. We’ve sort of decided to have the 2 kids (hopefully!!) then see how we go here. Maybe move to a 5 bed on our estate. Perhaps LONG term look at the house with a private driveway, but wouldn’t it be great to take our kids away all the time? Go see Santa? Treat our parents? Not worry if a car breaks down? Have savings?

I’m slightly paranoid as I watched my parents lose a lot with bad investments, health issues and redundancies but I’d rather be able to sing my heart out while jogging than be breathless and running. My job is stressful enough to worry if I lost it I’d lose my house as my husbands salary wouldn’t cover it (again, I am an extreme worrier!)

DurhamDime · 04/10/2026 22:11

We’re neither in that we’re sort of both are medium.

House is fine. Enough bedrooms and bathrooms and a small but nice garden on a busy but nice enough street. Wish we had more outside space and another parking spot but would’ve pushed the mortgage into ‘cash poor’ territory.

Equally DC know they can’t have everything their wealthy friends have, but they get what matters and we have nice holidays.

Sure our house is much more ‘normal’ than some of our friends’ but I’m hugely proud it’s ours and we’re not for flashy cars or designer brands etc anyway.

Mackerelfillets · 04/10/2026 22:59

We have 3 kids so ended up with a 4 bed semi and a touring caravan on the drive for holidays. I'm glad we did it that way had lots of fun with the van.

JT12 · 05/10/2026 01:53

Definitely house rich and cash poor if you can still manage everything without falling into debt. With salary increases, promotions etc mortgages usually become more affordable and most of your relaxation and family time is spent at home. A two week holiday to me is not as valuable as the 52 weeks at home. It is all very different for individuals though as you can see from the answers here so do what works for you.

Bloodysquirellls · 05/10/2026 01:56

I am house rich and cash poor. Would I like more cash? Absolutely! Would I give up this house. Absolutely not. I can’t really go back now and have been spoilt.

So I don’t know the answer.

DaphneDilemma · 05/10/2026 02:03

House rich here too. In my 50s and travelled extensively as a younger person, I love my home and don’t really enjoy solo travel. I take my adult DC away a couple of times a year but other than that enjoy my home, garden and hobbies.

MinLynn · 05/10/2026 02:14

“House poor” refers to spending more of your income than recommended on your house. Big house, no cash left.

It’s really important to me to be able to maintain my house properly. I wouldn’t want to be in a situation where we cannot afford paint, repair and upgrade as needed. I’m OK putting income toward that and cutting back in other areas, taking fewer holidays, etc.

ImBeeZee · 05/10/2026 07:58

We have gone cash rich, house “poor” although our house is very adequate for a family of 4 we are talking 1800 sq ft not 2500+.

We did seriously consider trading up for a bigger garden and similarly affluent friends of ours have done that - but the hassle and cost of doing that hasn’t seemed worth it. What I realised is that big house still have issues - horrible kitchens; grotty bathrooms; poor layout. And those can be expensive to fix.

BCBird · 05/10/2026 08:04

Cash rich but in a reasonable area

cartagenagina · 05/10/2026 08:07

Definitely cash rich, house poor.

ImBeeZee · 05/10/2026 08:17

Plus - this way we can afford solar panels with a big battery; two nice electric cars; efficient appliances and comfy mattresses.

Our pensions are in good shape and we are aren’t rolling in money but we are fortunate to be able to afford choices which are cost effective both for money and environmental reasons.

Not being financially stretched is an incredible luxury which I’m reminded of often on MN. When I hit perimenopause I was able to afford to go part time. And dh was able to afford a summer off work with the kids last year between jobs. We can enjoy less stressful jobs, spend more time with our children, family, friends and hobbies like a nice gym membership, good wine, super mountain bikes and camping gear.

I wouldn’t trade that for five bedrooms and a robot vacuum cleaner.

Scrambledomelette · 05/10/2026 08:47

I think if disposable income were just thrown at a lifestyle of conspicuous consumption, then that is a waste but when it looks like access to opportunity and security it is doing more heavy lifting than a home which exceeds a reasonable needs.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 05/10/2026 09:38

We’ve got an objectively big house but it’s not the dream house (double fronted, period features, massive garden etc.). We decided to stay put to have no mortgage and more financial freedom for whatever we choose. I do sometimes look wistfully on Rightmove but I am glad not to have the pressure a massive mortgage brings.

TexaSun · 05/10/2026 10:01

We moved from a small to big house. Not massive, but we have more space (4 in the house) and aren't falling over each other like we used to be.

If you can afford the mortgage, including being able to ride out the next 2 years of projected interest rate hikes, why not move to a bigger home. If it will be your forever home, or the home you will spend the most years in raising your family, I think it's a great decision.

Unless something catastrophic happens the house should increase in value. The money you put in will service the interest but also increase the share you own outright. Building equity is a good thing.

You need to work out your budget. We both work in jobs which pay above average salaries and manage to save a little every month and have a good buffer should emergencies happen (of which we've had 2 in this house) and still be ok. We manage to go on holiday, and instead of going out we spend money on nice food and cook nice family meals. Somewhat short-term financial pain i.e. we can't save like we would without kids, but in a few years both will be in state school so the childcare costs are near gone and we can maintain our current lifestyle but save a little more each month.

IcedIslandLongTea · 05/10/2026 10:01

It depends how house poor you’re talking.
A one bedroom flat for us all would be a no, siblings with a huge age gap or teens of different sex sharing would also be a no.
Not having the things I’d class as nice to haves, en suite, utility room, playroom, big garden for example I’d happily swap for more cash to enjoy life.

ArcangelaTarabotti · 05/10/2026 10:04

My house is just a base for going out and going away, so happy it’s small.

99bottlesofkombucha · 05/10/2026 10:18

Username7258 · 03/10/2026 17:02

There's a certain baseline I'd want for both which would affect my answer. There's a big difference in a stretch for a guest room that gets used once a year and a stretch so your children have enough space to get a good nights sleep and focus on homework, just as there's a big difference between having to pick the cheaper swimming lessons and spending years with no enrichment activities at all.

Yep, two of our dc share so I need another bedroom, and I’d love more living space- our kids are really good at using it all plus the garden. We cook a lot so a bigger kitchen would make us all happier and tidier. Need to understand the baseline!

lovethewaythedaygoes · 05/10/2026 10:24

Cash rich house poor. No question about it.

when me and DH bought our house we were both working full time and offered a mortgage of £600,000.

we bought a house for £250,000

i then had two children close together and one with additional needs. This meant I had to be home and had to quit my job. Money was no issue because we bought such a cheap house compared to our full time earnings.

when both my children started school we didn’t know how it would work for our additional needs child but they have settled amazing.

it meant I could go back full time and we could move house to a big detached somewhere. BUT we chose for me to work two days a week which meant we had a lovely extra amount coming in but I could be there for my children whenever and never miss a school activity, not worry about sick days, be present, not be exhausted, house immaculate and still have all the luxuries for the children such as holidays and any club they wanted to join, big birthday parties, could stretch to ‘big gifts’ for birthdays or Christmas. So I would never ever pile my money into a home at the sacrifice of experiences and being there for my children