Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Would you rather be Cash Rich and House Poor? Or House Rich and Cash Poor?

108 replies

rootsandwings89 · 03/10/2026 16:48

What’s more important to you? Is a big family home worth it if it eats up most of your income?

Or do you prefer to have more disposable income to enjoy holidays etc. but have a smaller home?

We are currently trying to weigh up our next house move …

OP posts:
Shatenoeuf · 03/10/2026 20:57

Username7258 · 03/10/2026 17:02

There's a certain baseline I'd want for both which would affect my answer. There's a big difference in a stretch for a guest room that gets used once a year and a stretch so your children have enough space to get a good nights sleep and focus on homework, just as there's a big difference between having to pick the cheaper swimming lessons and spending years with no enrichment activities at all.

This. For me theres a balance.

If "house poor" meant a small terrace, with the kids in little single bedrooms, a small garden, smaller downstairs rooms but in tidy nick & in an ok area - no prob.

If it meant being overcrowded in a tiny flat with mum &dad on a sofa bed in the living room... thats a no.

But then im not that fussed about:

  • posh cars or holidays
  • expensive beauty regimes
  • takeways & meals out
  • expensive clothes etc.

Id sacrifice a bigger house to ensure my kids got swimming & music lessons & money for decent food etc.

SwirlingAroundSleep · 03/10/2026 21:03

House rich and cash poor for us, but then again we upsized because a 3 bed with 5 children was too small no matter how organised we were and how big a garden it had. It was never meant to be 7 of us there but house sale falling through last minute meant last baby was almost 1 before we could move. We all love the space we now have and it is absolutely worth it.

Soonbbbqweather · 03/10/2026 21:38

No better feeling than owning your house mortgage free! I struggle to understand the need to buy larger houses when they're only for vanity purposes. Particularly now when no job is 100% secure no matter what employers tell their employees. We've never had to worry about increasing mortgage rates and were able to afford great holidays and hobbies for our DD because although we both worked full time, we geared our outgoings to a single lower salary. People need to learn to be comfortable with what they have rather than always wanting to keep up with the neighbours.

redskyAtNigh · 03/10/2026 21:44

We chose to buy a smaller house than we could have afforded, not because we wanted to be cash rich, but because we wanted to be able to protect against "something" happening in the future for peace of mind. If you put all your money into a house, you have very little wiggle room to cope with things that life throws at you.

ParrotPeach · 03/10/2026 21:46

It depends what you mean by it eating up most of your income. I wouldn’t prioritise a big house if it meant no days out, no foreign holidays and constant stress about money if bills increase etc.

But if I could have small scale holidays (eg a few days abroad or in the UK rather than an expensive all inclusive) and some days out, I’d happily spend a
large chunk of our wages on a nice house. We both WFH and my son is home by 3:45 so we spend more time at home than many people. So we benefit from space for office set ups and a playroom. If we were all out the house 8-6:30, it would be less worth it. And we only have one child so don’t need as much for days out, holidays or general cost of living etc.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 03/10/2026 21:48

The few people we know who retired under 60 have miscalculated. They haven’t got enough money now they are 15 years beyond that. They aren’t doing what they thought they would do. What seemed to be good savings wasn’t that good. Working is better than not having enough money. DH worked part time from 68 and it’s meant we haven’t touched his pensions which have done very well. Our savings portfolio has too and we’ve taken sums out to buy cars as it’s done very well! Holidays too. If we had needed it earlier it would not be the very healthy sum it is today. We haven’t yet downsized either. So plenty in property too!

ShanghaiDiva · 03/10/2026 21:55

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 03/10/2026 20:04

@Ponderingwindow Life changing for whom? Do you enjoy counting your money? Are you expecting a rainy day? I have huge savings but unless you spend them, they don’t change your life.

If savings provide sufficient income to give up work then they do change your life eg dh retired at 53.

MyGirlJ · 03/10/2026 22:05

Cash rich, house poor - which I suppose I am already.
Its only me and DD, there wouldn't be much point in the two of us rattling around in a big house.
I'm much happier having money in the bank for a rainy day, especially as I dont have a husband/partner to fall back on in case redundancy etc. Plus, we can go on nice holidays, days/meals out, buy clothes when we want/need to, and we can afford good food.

TurquoiseDress · 03/10/2026 22:54

Ireolu · 03/10/2026 17:13

Currently choosing to stay put now to have more disposable cash but our house is fine and next step up is 300k more and thats without stamp duty. We're good.

We’re in a similar situation re 300k plus for the next step up

Unfortunately we do need to move, we have 2 DC rapidly heading towards secondary but only in a 2 bed

We may need to become house rich (relatively speaking) cash poor but it’s a very scary prospect looking at interest rates & the state of the economy right now

HappyViewer · 03/10/2026 22:57

Somewhere in the middle.

Logsonthefire2 · 03/10/2026 22:59

We have been in both situations but in the end opted for the house.

Gealach · 03/10/2026 23:03

It really depends on how small the house is. We live in a very average sized 4 bed semi detached with a decent garden. My kids all have their own rooms and we have enough space. I’d love a utility room and a big shed for storage but wouldn’t give up holidays for it either.

Ineffable23 · 03/10/2026 23:04

I'm currently debating this myself. I don't really know what to think. At the moment I have a moderately sized house on a busy road without parking. The next step up wouldn't be that much of a benefit and you're probably talking about 75,000. At then the next step up to get a big benefit would probably be 150 more than my current place. I thought I knew that I wanted to do it but I'm just getting so twitchy about interest rates. I'm busy trying to work out what I can do to optimise the space I've currently got to make the most of it instead of spending all of that money. But I'm also aware that if I invest too much in this house, I will be hitting the ceiling price or maybe already am hitting the ceiling price for a small house on a busy road.

faferandom · 03/10/2026 23:12

I’ve done both. Owned a £3m
house that gobbled up cash and needed an army of trades to maintain. Struggled to find spare money for travel. Now own a small house and doing heaps of travel, ticking off bucket list trips, time & money for self - way better !

mondaytosunday · 04/10/2026 00:05

‘House poor’ is an odd idea. A smaller cheaper home doesn’t necessarily mean that. I’m probably moving next year, selling my three bed terrace (worth around £1.25m) for a smaller two bed flat closer in to central London (about £700k). I will free up some funds to help my kids. That doesn’t make me ‘house poor’ though. I’ll have a lovely home in an area I want to live in. Yes it will be smaller but I no longer need the space with one child off in their own and the other at uni and planning on going abroad for a year.
But I have had homes of 3000sq ft down to 1200sq ft with my family and I still didn’t feel poorer for having a smaller cheaper home. I love having space, but the house I have now, half the size of my last home, feels cosier.

Friendlygingercat · 04/10/2026 00:55

\i prefer the cash any time.

Aluna · 04/10/2026 18:13

It depends what you mean I’d rather be house rich - ie big house, no mortgage, lower income than higher income, small house. Small houses are stressful to live in and income is precarious. The relief of owning your house outright is enormous.

FindingMeno · 04/10/2026 18:36

Definitely cash rich.
I've lived in some right dives and I can make a lovely home pretty much anywhere.

burgerbeast · 04/10/2026 19:21

Hmmm we are somewhere in between. Teenage children now & moved when they were primary aged to a ‘family home’ which gave us a more bathrooms and a second social room which is a godsend with older kids. House meets all our needs.

However, financially we could have done a further move to a ‘dream house’ but that would put early retirement out the picture & we would have had to forego some memorable hols. I would say overall we are happy with our choice. We’ve got friends with larger houses and friends with smaller. In the bracket and area we are looking at you have to spend a LOT more money to get a not much bigger house. I do occasionally get house envy but I’m sure other people envy mine. I think just try & be happy with your lot & before you know it the kids are leaving home.

burgerbeast · 04/10/2026 19:29

I know a family who got an inheritance who are renting a small house. They burnt through the money on holidays and designer gear. I found that choice surprising, as in their shoes, I would definitely have ploughed the money into getting a house over having experiences.

Nevermind31 · 04/10/2026 19:52

Somewhere in the middle. Still need some cash, but would def go for a bigger house rather than smaller one, but once each child has a decent sized room (not a box room), a big eat in kitchen, big living room, office etc I don’t need to push beyond that…

hellofrommyothername · 04/10/2026 20:11

It’s difficult to answer in such black and white terms, but having a nice home is absolutely my highest priority for my money, especially since having children.

However they are still very little (one is 6 months and one is 2 years) and wouldn’t get much out of fancy holidays yet. In a few years that might change.

Yoonimum · 04/10/2026 20:25

The thing is that most people will interpret the bigger house as some sort of lavish, detached home when for a lot of people the choice is tiny house + cash or medium house + no cash. We opted for the latter as with a blended family we needed extra bedrooms. Even if we'd made the kids share in a tiny house there wouldn't have been loads of spare money. I enjoyed having a nicely decorated and well furnished, semi-detached home with reasonable sized garden; it was built in the 50s when build standards and room sizes were better. Kids are all grown up now and it seemed to go in a flash! We've enjoyed more foreign holidays and a newer car recently and don't regret the choice we made at all.

ILoveKits · 04/10/2026 20:39

We have a large house and plenty of disposable income. I'd compromise on the house before the income.

Retiredfromearlyyears · 04/10/2026 20:42

House Poor. Cash Rich. We only had 1 child though so didnt need to 'up the ante' house wise. We stayed put, but we did put on a small brick built sunroom ,this doubles as a little dining area. More recently we got rid of 2 large cupboards and added a 'Jack and Jill ' toilet between our 2 bedrooms as our shower room is downstairs. We have been mortgage free since I was 48 and hubby was 50. So no mortgage pressures. However it depends on your needs and wants.

Swipe left for the next trending thread