Dd loved Be Our Guest - was always her favourite film when small so when we went this year it was our number one adr. She's 14 now but was in heaven eating lunch in the west wing!
Other favourites:
Tusker house at Animal Kingdom - character breakfast
50s Cafe at Hollywood Studios - they are all in character and tell you off for not eating veg, elbows on table etc. DD has always loved it.
Crystal Palace at Magic Kingdom for a character lunch.
Sci Fi diner at Holllywood Studios - book ADR to sit in a car.
Tapenyaki at Epcot's Japan
Also at Epcot - France, Chinese, Italian and Mexican (it's very dark inside though)
Rainforest Cafe at Animal Kingdom too
We go again next February and will have a dining plan for first time. However as we are going to US too we will have spare meal vouchers. Taking dd's friend who's never been. They are hoping for:
Cinderella's Table if at all possible - to see Belle! Never been before so will be looking first thing 180 days in advance!
Be Our Guest (again)
O'Hoano - breakfast with Stitch at one of the hotels
50's Cafe again I think at Hollywood Studios
Not sure at Epcot - maybe try for the princess meal perhaps or a character meal with Chip and Dale, although I did love the Japanese tapenyaki too.
Not quite decided at Animal Kingdom either - maybe Tusker House again for their huge breakfast or perhaps the sit down one over near the Everest ride.