Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Elderly parent not wanting a fuss on a big birthday.

30 replies

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 07:22

Hi there, it’s been a difficult time with my elderly Dad since my lovely Mum sadly passed away last year. We used to have a good relationship, but as the younger child (although I’m now in my 50s!) and living close by, there appears to be an underlying tone that I should be doing more/ he should live with me and my family.
There’s been quite a few grating things that I’ve generally let slide, but more recently he had a large milestone birthday. He was very gruff with me, telling me that he wanted no fuss, and constantly told me that he would rather that it was treated as a normal day.
I offered to take him out somewhere special/ take a day off work and do something together (kids would be at school), but he had plans for the morning and we settled on a low key coffee and cake trip in the afternoon, his suggestion. We also had a meal in a restaurant (without any fuss) the weekend before, and booked up a concert for the following weekend as some nice things to do.
My sibling who lives further away (and doesn’t need to work) then decided to visit him so that he wasn’t alone on his birthday. I don’t think our plans had been shared, a lavish Afternoon Tea was planned, and I said to my Dad that it’s ok as you don’t see them often. We’d pop round with presents and cake in the evening, after work/ school.
On the day of his bday, after my sibling arrived, he sent me photos of giant bday balloons with him in them, it felt a bit like, well you haven’t made a fuss. The bday evening was quite infuriating, he kept mentioning how amazing the afternoon tea was and better than ‘your average coffee and a cake’, well yes, naturally! Our presents were thoughtful and pretty expensive, but he kept showing things my sibling had given (mid opening ours), there’s no need to compare! It was all quite strange and slightly maddening, I said nothing at the time but feel I should raise, although I may receive performative crying that the day was all too much for him. I feel that I am being manipulated and it’s not a nice feeling… next year I may buy nothing, as requested! 😆

OP posts:
wisebear · 13/11/2026 16:04

I personally don’t like my dad although he’s still with my mum and we do have a relationship I mask heavily in their presence (I’m 41 they are 60s). I’m an only child too so my biggest fear is mum passing before him. The thought of having to look after him in old age makes me shudder and I understand the feeling of feeling like a little girl again being scolded ( I have a fair bit of trauma from both of them but of course we don’t discuss this because it’s never their fault blah blah blah) so I really don’t have any advice only to send you virtual hugs and I hope your situation improves however that may be x

Seagulldancing · 13/11/2026 16:06

I have much sympathy for you. My DM never wants a fuss, and then gets the hump when she doesn't get one, cause we followed her wishes! But we coordinate between us now as DM won't tell one of us that the other is organising something. Especially after the year of 2 birthday parties!

ChubbyCheeksCharlie · 13/11/2026 16:22

If someone asked me "do want to go out for a massive expensive tea and be surrounded by balloons with the whole place singing HB to you?" I would also say no. But if we went out and that just happened to happen, then I'd probably really enjoy it.
Very few (normal!) people say, "yes, please put yourself out and go to lots of expense to make me feel happy".
No. They say, "oh don't put yourself out, I don't want any bother". And they would be fine with that. But they'd also really enjoy the fancy tea.
By the way, once they get to late 80s, every birthday is a big one..! Can't be waiting another 5 years for a knees up... 😳

Northernladdette · 13/11/2026 16:34

Poor you, sometimes you can’t do right for doing wrong. Just let it go and smile sweetly 🙂

VoiceofInsanity · 14/11/2026 10:45

Don't overthink this. Your dad probably thought he didn't want a fuss, but actually enjoyed it despite himself. He would also have enjoyed what you'd originally planned. No-one was wrong here. x

New posts on this thread. Refresh page