Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Elderly parent not wanting a fuss on a big birthday.

30 replies

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 07:22

Hi there, it’s been a difficult time with my elderly Dad since my lovely Mum sadly passed away last year. We used to have a good relationship, but as the younger child (although I’m now in my 50s!) and living close by, there appears to be an underlying tone that I should be doing more/ he should live with me and my family.
There’s been quite a few grating things that I’ve generally let slide, but more recently he had a large milestone birthday. He was very gruff with me, telling me that he wanted no fuss, and constantly told me that he would rather that it was treated as a normal day.
I offered to take him out somewhere special/ take a day off work and do something together (kids would be at school), but he had plans for the morning and we settled on a low key coffee and cake trip in the afternoon, his suggestion. We also had a meal in a restaurant (without any fuss) the weekend before, and booked up a concert for the following weekend as some nice things to do.
My sibling who lives further away (and doesn’t need to work) then decided to visit him so that he wasn’t alone on his birthday. I don’t think our plans had been shared, a lavish Afternoon Tea was planned, and I said to my Dad that it’s ok as you don’t see them often. We’d pop round with presents and cake in the evening, after work/ school.
On the day of his bday, after my sibling arrived, he sent me photos of giant bday balloons with him in them, it felt a bit like, well you haven’t made a fuss. The bday evening was quite infuriating, he kept mentioning how amazing the afternoon tea was and better than ‘your average coffee and a cake’, well yes, naturally! Our presents were thoughtful and pretty expensive, but he kept showing things my sibling had given (mid opening ours), there’s no need to compare! It was all quite strange and slightly maddening, I said nothing at the time but feel I should raise, although I may receive performative crying that the day was all too much for him. I feel that I am being manipulated and it’s not a nice feeling… next year I may buy nothing, as requested! 😆

OP posts:
Namezerchangezer · 13/11/2026 07:26

Is this a golden child sibling by any chance?

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 13/11/2026 07:26

I get how annoying it is. I care for my dad and see him daily. My sister lives further away and swans in very occasionally, and he treats her like royalty. It's the novelty factor, I guess. I'm always there so just part of the furniture.

Try not to take it personally. It doesn't really matter. It isn't a competition.

AutumnOakTree · 13/11/2026 07:33

I agree, don’t take it personally. It may be something as simple as it’s something different for him to talk about.

Do you feel more annoyed with your dad for praising your sister more, or your sister for upstaging you?

Toodarktooearly · 13/11/2026 07:38

Well your sisters a guilt ridden upstaging piece of work. Elderly parents are often unfair to the the sibling doing the lions share. I'd probably start sending her daily photos of all the stuff you do. I'd also be pleased in fact I'd cry with relief if either of my sisters did that for my dad as they barely phone him and he has been distraught on high days and holidays since we lost my mum in the summer. 💐

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 07:40

Thanks, there have been quite a few things over the years where my sibling has caused problems for my parents. I think I just feel hurt, and slightly humiliated. I hate competition, but my sibling is incredibly competitive, which my Father is aware of, so it made it all the more uncomfortable.

OP posts:
Sannabay · 13/11/2026 07:46

Oh well thing his If you can't or don't want to take him in that's ok.

If he was playing up he might have been hoping your sister would offer.

Or if he was being naughty and trying to wind you up. Just wind back the attention you give him for a few days. If that's safe for you to do so. X

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 07:46

Sorry for sp's

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 07:47

Ps sorry for your loss of your mum. Look after yourself xxx

ItsWouldHaveNotWouldOf · 13/11/2026 07:48

That's elderly parents for you. My mum had her 90th birthday this year. Kept on that she wanted no fuss. When someone suggested to her that her kids may organise a surprise party, she said "they better bloody not". So, on the day, my brother and his wife travelled to us and we (me and kids) all went out for a casual lunch. Mum kept looking round as though she was expecting more relatives to turn up, or some other surprise. She also moaned the whole time. Sometimes they're just hard to please. They go on and on about what they don't want, and when you take them at their word, they're disappointed.

Lobelia123 · 13/11/2026 08:02

The elderly can be very capricious. My sister and I have been at outs occasionally and finally had a good heart to heart and figured out what was going on. Whether conciously/with intent or not, our parents play us off against each other. When theyre with me, all they do is up how much my sister does for them, how wonderful she is, how proud they are of her etc etc - no acknowledgement or conversation about anything thats going on in my life or interest in the person whos actually with them except as a vehicle to recieve the word dump. And the inference is a kind of underlying criticism, like 'she does all this....shes so much better than you ....' etc etc! Then when she and I had a bit of a tiff, it all came out that that was HER experience too, she was also getting a gutful of how wonderful and generous I am - and in the end we were both trying to scramble to catch up when actually it was all a bit of behind the scenes manipulation. We are wise to it now so now we just nod and agree that yes Jax is wonderful, im so lucky to have this marvellous sister and youre so lucky to have her as a daughter, and move on.

EmotionalBlackmail · 13/11/2026 08:02

Does he have form for saying the opposite of what he wants and then being annoyed when nobody worked out what he really wanted?

Mine is forever saying things like “I don’t want to make a fuss”, “Don’t worry about me”’when the reality is is that’s exactly what she wants.

Best example was when she went into hospital as an emergency and it was all “Don't worry about me, no need to drop everything”. As it happened, medical reasons of my own meant I couldn’t get there. She was furious nobody had dropped everything to go to the hospital!

Firefliesdancing · 13/11/2026 08:18

Sorry for the loss of your mum 💐. My sister (who doesn’t have to work) used to do this, she lived 90 minutes away but when she came to see my parents, my Mum would lay the red carpet out.

My Mum didn’t want a fuss for her 60th but I still organised something at her favourite restaurant. My sister and her family complained about the location, food, service, temperature of the restaurant. I had made a mini round cake with buttercream icing and layers etc which although small (5 inches) had taken a lot of effort to make. I presented it to my Mum earlier in the day with flowers and a watch she wanted. It was out of my price league so worked a few extra shifts to get it. My sister had organised a cake that was made with miniature figures of my mum’s profession. She didn’t tell me she was doing this. It was a lovely gesture but I couldn’t help feeling upstaged as my Mum went on and on about it for months to anyone that would listen but never mentioned me. I told my sister I was making a cake and she said only make a cake enough for me, mum and dad.

Again for my Mum’s 65th she said she didn’t want anything. I got her a story album from her friends, family, flowers delivered, cake made, and a mini shopping trip and some jewellery she picked. My sister got her a mini cruise on the Med. I did offer to contribute but it was ‘her’ present.

I did talk to my Mum about how it made me feel but she just said “O don’t be silly dear your sister is just different”. My Dad passed away last year and even though we live just 20 minutes away I don’t see Mum often. She tried to make a rivalry between my children and their cousins which I put my foot down at. Don’t ignore the feeling you have it can build resentment. Talk to your Dad and go from there.

Sparkletastic · 13/11/2026 08:19

Suggest he moves in with the non working sibling and you’ll visit for the occasional lavish afternoon tea.

Mischance · 13/11/2026 08:26

Did you do anything wrong - or did you listen to what he wanted and respect his wishes?

The fact that the golden child dropped in from heaven to scatter a bit of fairy dust to make themselves feel good does not alter the fact that you did the right things. You know that - just hang on to that and let all the rest wash by you - it is not important. You were true to yourself and to his wishes.

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 08:28

Thank you, that’s all very helpful, and appreciate your advice. I think there is an element of manipulation here which isn’t pleasant. He does have ‘main character’ syndrome, similar to my sister, and loves being the centre of attention.
Since Mum sadly passed, he has been very gruff/ dismissive of my feelings, it’s very much been his loss and I’ve found ways to grieve personally and remember Mum (he kept her ashes and hasn’t interned then). I try not to upset him by talking about Mum and understand that ‘there’s no loss greater than your partner’ , as he’s told me. I think I’m in a bit of a FOG loop, I didn’t want to upset him as he explicitly told me no to fuss (and previous big milestone bdays he knows how much I like buying balloons/ banners etc and making things special). I bought a nice cake, and kept the candles/ serviettes etc on standby in case that would make him annoyed. In fact, he was loving the attention!
I think I’m a bit fearful of him now to be honest, as his gruffness makes me feel like a small child again. After dealing with him following Mum’s passing, I try to be respectful of his wishes. It did off-side me! I hope to God I don’t become old and crafty, I told my kids to tell me if I am!

OP posts:
IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 13/11/2026 08:28

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 13/11/2026 07:26

I get how annoying it is. I care for my dad and see him daily. My sister lives further away and swans in very occasionally, and he treats her like royalty. It's the novelty factor, I guess. I'm always there so just part of the furniture.

Try not to take it personally. It doesn't really matter. It isn't a competition.

Snap!!
I’m one of 4. DDad died 20 years ago.
2 of the others live abroad.
I live half a mile from DM. Remaining sibling lives 250 miles away. None of us live anywhere near where we grew up.

The others can do no wrong. Any visit they’re treated like royalty. My siblings give me a lot of “well why haven’t you done all these lovely things with DM”. They never say “thank you for keeping an eye, taking her to all the hospital visits, walking the dog, driving her places, airport lifts, keeping her company”. - whilst working full time and juggling 2 x teens.

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:30

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 08:28

Thank you, that’s all very helpful, and appreciate your advice. I think there is an element of manipulation here which isn’t pleasant. He does have ‘main character’ syndrome, similar to my sister, and loves being the centre of attention.
Since Mum sadly passed, he has been very gruff/ dismissive of my feelings, it’s very much been his loss and I’ve found ways to grieve personally and remember Mum (he kept her ashes and hasn’t interned then). I try not to upset him by talking about Mum and understand that ‘there’s no loss greater than your partner’ , as he’s told me. I think I’m in a bit of a FOG loop, I didn’t want to upset him as he explicitly told me no to fuss (and previous big milestone bdays he knows how much I like buying balloons/ banners etc and making things special). I bought a nice cake, and kept the candles/ serviettes etc on standby in case that would make him annoyed. In fact, he was loving the attention!
I think I’m a bit fearful of him now to be honest, as his gruffness makes me feel like a small child again. After dealing with him following Mum’s passing, I try to be respectful of his wishes. It did off-side me! I hope to God I don’t become old and crafty, I told my kids to tell me if I am!

Lol at old and crafty Op.

You won't. You're aware. X

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 13/11/2026 08:31

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 13/11/2026 08:28

Snap!!
I’m one of 4. DDad died 20 years ago.
2 of the others live abroad.
I live half a mile from DM. Remaining sibling lives 250 miles away. None of us live anywhere near where we grew up.

The others can do no wrong. Any visit they’re treated like royalty. My siblings give me a lot of “well why haven’t you done all these lovely things with DM”. They never say “thank you for keeping an eye, taking her to all the hospital visits, walking the dog, driving her places, airport lifts, keeping her company”. - whilst working full time and juggling 2 x teens.

Ha, yes! The "helpful suggestions" about stuff that I could do...

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:31

I think there's money to be made in that slogan on a tee btw

I might get one made for me.

I'll post the pic when I do. You made me smile.x

GodIhatethepatriarcy · 13/11/2026 08:33

Be the bigger person, do nothing.

MsSquiz · 13/11/2026 08:39

Maybe I’m missing something, but could you not have gone to the afternoon tea with them, to celebrate together?

Dogsceptic · 13/11/2026 08:46

Sparkletastic · 13/11/2026 08:19

Suggest he moves in with the non working sibling and you’ll visit for the occasional lavish afternoon tea.

This!

Lottapianos · 13/11/2026 08:47

I really feel for you OP. 'Manipulation' is the word I was thinking of while reading your post. It sounds like you've had many years of this kind of behaviour. It also sounds like there isn't much room for you, your feelings and your needs in your family - I can absolutely relate to this, and I know it really hurts

My mother is similar - won't ask for what she wants but expects you to be a mind reader and get it 'right'. It's exhausting and demoralising. After many years of this and a lot of therapy, I stopped trying to get it 'right' and stopped playing the game. Now I just do what I think is decent and reasonable and don't give it much more thought. As other posters have said, maybe in your father's head, your siblings is the 'golden child' and you're..... something else. It will be fulfilling some kind of need for your father if he believes this - it doesn't mean it's reality.

You tried to get it 'right', you listened to him, you were kind and generous and thoughtful. That's a lot more than he's done for you lately. You have nothing to feel guilty for x

Pherian · 13/11/2026 15:27

Thinkhappydays · 13/11/2026 07:22

Hi there, it’s been a difficult time with my elderly Dad since my lovely Mum sadly passed away last year. We used to have a good relationship, but as the younger child (although I’m now in my 50s!) and living close by, there appears to be an underlying tone that I should be doing more/ he should live with me and my family.
There’s been quite a few grating things that I’ve generally let slide, but more recently he had a large milestone birthday. He was very gruff with me, telling me that he wanted no fuss, and constantly told me that he would rather that it was treated as a normal day.
I offered to take him out somewhere special/ take a day off work and do something together (kids would be at school), but he had plans for the morning and we settled on a low key coffee and cake trip in the afternoon, his suggestion. We also had a meal in a restaurant (without any fuss) the weekend before, and booked up a concert for the following weekend as some nice things to do.
My sibling who lives further away (and doesn’t need to work) then decided to visit him so that he wasn’t alone on his birthday. I don’t think our plans had been shared, a lavish Afternoon Tea was planned, and I said to my Dad that it’s ok as you don’t see them often. We’d pop round with presents and cake in the evening, after work/ school.
On the day of his bday, after my sibling arrived, he sent me photos of giant bday balloons with him in them, it felt a bit like, well you haven’t made a fuss. The bday evening was quite infuriating, he kept mentioning how amazing the afternoon tea was and better than ‘your average coffee and a cake’, well yes, naturally! Our presents were thoughtful and pretty expensive, but he kept showing things my sibling had given (mid opening ours), there’s no need to compare! It was all quite strange and slightly maddening, I said nothing at the time but feel I should raise, although I may receive performative crying that the day was all too much for him. I feel that I am being manipulated and it’s not a nice feeling… next year I may buy nothing, as requested! 😆

He’s trying to manipulate you.

After reading your update about how his gruffness makes you feel. You don’t owe him living in your home or having continuous care provided by you. Which sounds like what he wants.

No one gets to make you feel small.

I personally would distance myself and do a lot less. I wouldn’t be taking him out for lunch or running around after him.

FelixRyark · 13/11/2026 15:51

OP this is prevalent, it’s the “what’s seldom is wonderful” sibling effect.
We have it with our only brother, golden child when he comes back from Australia. Even though other sibling and I do the lions share…Australia lands and Hallelujah! He can do no wrong.