Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Ignoring Doctors advice

30 replies

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 20:23

My 91 year old dad had an ecg today - he is housebound but we got
him to doctors surgery today. The doctor has now reviewed it and thinks it looks worrying and wants him to go to A&E tonight by ambulance to get checked out. Dad is of sound mind and does not want to go. I am inclined to go along with this as we have spoken before about how he wants to stay at home with little intervention. He is aware that if he is having a heart attack it would be very very serious and likely fatal. He still prefers to stay at home. He is not in pain but is generally very frail. I have agreed that he does nothing tonight but will call an ambulance if he deteriorates now or going forward. He has a friend living with him who will call ambulance if needed. I live 30 miles away. Is this ok or should I more heavily persuade him to go?

OP posts:
ScaryM0nster · 10/11/2026 20:27

Sounds thoroughly reasonable.

It might be worth following up with the GP practise on whether there is an alternative, eg being referred for planned further assessment rather than A&E in the evening which is unlikely to improve his quality of life.

If he doesn’t already, this is a good wake up to make sure he’s got a clear set of wishes.

Arlanymor · 10/11/2026 20:28

If he is totally sound of mind all you can do is support him in his choices as someone who loves him. I think I would, however, insist on staying there tonight as an expression of my concern and to be on the spot if needed. Better to drive him in than wait for an ambulance if worst came to the worst. Sorry you are going through this, my father (81 next month, so a spring chicken next to your lovely dad!) has heart failure and had an operation earlier this year and the best thing was to be on the spot. I had the flexibility to do that and appreciate you may have other caring or work responsibilities that make that more difficult for you. Sending all good thoughts.

Seymour5 · 10/11/2026 20:32

If that’s what your dad wishes, I think it’s fine. DH, 80+ has had two heart surgeries, and wants no more. He also has other health issues which won’t improve. He would be saying the same as your dad.

FluffballFitz · 10/11/2026 20:35

Sounds very reasonable. Has he filled in a respect form? If not the GP can help with this.

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 20:44

Gp is calling again tomorrow. They have been very good. We will sort out the respect form as it was mentioned by doctors a few weeks ago so everything is clear. We’ve had the talks but not documented anything. Thanks for the views here. I want to give him autonomy in his choices but obviously don’t want him suffering. My brother is going tomorrow. He’s not alone tonight as has a friend who helps care for him there. She will call if anything happens. It’s difficult for me today due to children but I will be encouraging some more tests so the doctors can make him comfortable or help with symptoms.

OP posts:
JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 10/11/2026 20:44

I think it's fine.

I was at the GP's today and an elderly lady was visibly upset at the reception counter. The staff were explaining that there were no more appointments and she should go to Minor Injuries at our local hospital.

She kept saying "but I'm 90! You don't know what it's like at my age, sitting in those waiting rooms for hours! I can't manage it"

Tbh I thought she had a point.

mysittingduck · 10/11/2026 20:45

Your dad has made a good decision. Very old people have a horrible time in A and E. He's best resting at home. Yes there's a risk, but he is 91.

Periperi2025 · 10/11/2026 20:56

With all respect, you sound incredibly supportive & caring, it is not up to you to be 'inclined to go along with this' or to decide to 'give him autonomy', if he has the capacity to make his own decisions it is on you to reconcile with those decisions and respect them.

If he is declining rapidly generally due to age and frailty or on account of this recent cardiac event it may be worth having a chat with the GP about End of life care planning and what your Dad's wishes are for ceilings of care, and place of death, and get the GP to prescribe some anticipatory meidcation ready for when they are required if that is appropriate now.

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 21:03

Periperi2025 · 10/11/2026 20:56

With all respect, you sound incredibly supportive & caring, it is not up to you to be 'inclined to go along with this' or to decide to 'give him autonomy', if he has the capacity to make his own decisions it is on you to reconcile with those decisions and respect them.

If he is declining rapidly generally due to age and frailty or on account of this recent cardiac event it may be worth having a chat with the GP about End of life care planning and what your Dad's wishes are for ceilings of care, and place of death, and get the GP to prescribe some anticipatory meidcation ready for when they are required if that is appropriate now.

I think my wording is just a bit clumsy. I agree with you. It is his decision. It’s just I feel conflicted as he asked me to speak to doc and then relay info to him so I feel involved in the decision which I know is his. I suppose I feel guilty for not trying to change his mind but I agree it’s his decision. I sort of worry that others will think I should “make “ him go. My brother is on same page and agrees it’s up to dad. I just worry I don’t seem to be “persuading” him more. Your advice re meds etc is helpful. I’ll speak to doc tomorrow

OP posts:
MysticCatLady · 10/11/2026 21:10

Also chiming in to say that I think that the approach that you, your brother and your dad is taking is sensible and correct. He's of sound mind and doesn't want to go into hospital. You're not neglecting him but following his wishes. Hopefully the respect form can be sorted out tomorrow.

nocoolnamesleft · 10/11/2026 21:11

It sounds like he has capacity, so it is indeed his decision. I can understand why he may have made it.

Silverwombat · 10/11/2026 21:14

This sounds very reasonable. My only question would be why did he have the ECG in the first place? There's something to be said for only having tests / investigations done if you plan to act on results.

ILoveKits · 10/11/2026 21:20

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 10/11/2026 20:44

I think it's fine.

I was at the GP's today and an elderly lady was visibly upset at the reception counter. The staff were explaining that there were no more appointments and she should go to Minor Injuries at our local hospital.

She kept saying "but I'm 90! You don't know what it's like at my age, sitting in those waiting rooms for hours! I can't manage it"

Tbh I thought she had a point.

Not the point of the thread, but it amazes me that GPs, formerly family doctors, venture that they are upset because they no longer command the respect they once did.

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 21:25

Silverwombat · 10/11/2026 21:14

This sounds very reasonable. My only question would be why did he have the ECG in the first place? There's something to be said for only having tests / investigations done if you plan to act on results.

Doctor came to house a week ago as he was suffering very swollen legs. During that she did a thorough check up. She listened to his heart and said it seemed irregular. She wanted an ecg to know more. He agreed to this as she said it would help her see what was going on and it might be that he just needed to alter the pills he’s on. He takes 7 a day for various things. He also had blood tests at home then which showed he was anemic. Doc thought the heart and anaemia might be connected. He had ecg at surgery today. It’s first time he’s left house for about a year but he wanted to go. He will take treatments like tablets etc just doesn’t want much more intervention and doesn’t want to go to hospital

OP posts:
Periperi2025 · 10/11/2026 21:39

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 21:25

Doctor came to house a week ago as he was suffering very swollen legs. During that she did a thorough check up. She listened to his heart and said it seemed irregular. She wanted an ecg to know more. He agreed to this as she said it would help her see what was going on and it might be that he just needed to alter the pills he’s on. He takes 7 a day for various things. He also had blood tests at home then which showed he was anemic. Doc thought the heart and anaemia might be connected. He had ecg at surgery today. It’s first time he’s left house for about a year but he wanted to go. He will take treatments like tablets etc just doesn’t want much more intervention and doesn’t want to go to hospital

Bless him, he sounds entirely reasonable and like a very 'good' patient.

SylvanMoon · 10/11/2026 21:45

Arlanymor · 10/11/2026 20:28

If he is totally sound of mind all you can do is support him in his choices as someone who loves him. I think I would, however, insist on staying there tonight as an expression of my concern and to be on the spot if needed. Better to drive him in than wait for an ambulance if worst came to the worst. Sorry you are going through this, my father (81 next month, so a spring chicken next to your lovely dad!) has heart failure and had an operation earlier this year and the best thing was to be on the spot. I had the flexibility to do that and appreciate you may have other caring or work responsibilities that make that more difficult for you. Sending all good thoughts.

Edited

I don't think the advice from emergency services is to drive someone having a possible heart attack to A&E. They say the safest thing to do is call 999 and wait for an ambulance with paramedics who can administer emergency treatment enroute, which you as the driver will be unable to do.

Chelmew · 10/11/2026 21:57

Having spent overnights more than once in different A&E depts with my 91 yr old parent left sitting in a chair for 24 hours plus I think you have done exactly the right thing for your Dad. In my recent experience A&E depts are loud uncomfortable chaotic and not the place for a frail elderly person to spend the night.
if he gets worse his friend could call
an ambulance.

MysterOfwomanY · 10/11/2026 22:22

Death is one thing.
Something which has a major effect on QOL is another. If it was just a case of "live or die" without the "live on in a crap state" possibility, I'd be fine too with him making the call he did. Good on him for having the guts to risk it.

seahorsessky · 10/11/2026 22:53

Could you get a home visit from the GP? I know this is very unlikely. But my friend actually got one for her dad (not in my area, and the doctor sounds like the ones we had when we were kids).
But I'd do that. Try anyway. I'll never forget ours saying that home visits for kids and old people were much better than them going to AE. Sure, they don't have the equipment for scans etc. But a caring word/painkillers from a doctor you know and trust is honestly priceless.
I'm so sorry you're going through this-it's horrible.

PermanentTemporary · 11/11/2026 07:25

I am glad you are such a good daughter. I think people who report they have ‘made’ their parent go to hospital are presenting one version of events - their parent probably wanted to go tbh. Be at peace that you have supported and loved your dad and not given him another fight, the last thing he needs 💐

DemonsandMosquitoes · 11/11/2026 07:55

JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · 10/11/2026 20:44

I think it's fine.

I was at the GP's today and an elderly lady was visibly upset at the reception counter. The staff were explaining that there were no more appointments and she should go to Minor Injuries at our local hospital.

She kept saying "but I'm 90! You don't know what it's like at my age, sitting in those waiting rooms for hours! I can't manage it"

Tbh I thought she had a point.

Unfortunately the appointments are often already full of other 90 year olds, or older. The ‘age card’ holds no weight anymore. Practice nurse.

DarkLion · 11/11/2026 08:33

Hi op, I’m an elderly nurse so often lurk on these boards. Alongside a respect form I’d also reccommend an advanced directive. It’s heartbreaking having patients stuck in hospital that don’t want to be there and have been brought in against their wishes, risking them to more infections and deterioration. That isn’t to say it’s not right in some cases if a person wishes but it’s not nice when someone has pleaded they don’t want to be there.

we see often documentation on respect forms and advanced directives ‘for reversible causes in the community only’. If he absoloutely wouldn’t want to go to hospital, that might look like treatment with medications or antibiotics in the community only or treatment only from outpatient investigations. He sounds of sound mind and I wouldn’t feel guilty for feeling like you’re not pushing further. If you did try and persuade further he might feel like there’s a lack of trust and support and he might not want to broach these issues with you. It’s so important for people to have their decisions respected as they tend to lose a lot of autonomy and independence when older and supporting him with these decisions is a huge thing you can do for him ❤️

DarkLion · 11/11/2026 08:37

Oh and just to add, respect forms aren’t just a ‘dnar’ form. People can have them and still be for escalation of care but have their wishes documented. Same as when they are used for not for resus, ones filled in by the gp tend to be really good with the patients wishes, ones in hospital are normally scribbled and basic. Good ones will outline a patients wishes balancing comfort over prioritising sustaining life, what they’d wish you avoid and what is the highest ceiling of care and escalation they’d want, what’s important to them etc

Momon45 · 11/11/2026 08:44

If you do go to A&E you'll probably end up on a corridor so I'd go with what you're Dad wants to do . My son (50)recently spent 2 nights on a trolley with a suspected stroke . The lady on the next trolley was 92 also there for 2 nights . It would be the last place I'd want to go to unless it was a dire emergency.

christmaspudding43 · 11/11/2026 12:49

My mum's most recent hospital admission left her with delirium which never really resolved and marked a distinct decline generally. During that admission (when she was lucid) she completed a DNAR, she was already on palliative care only. Two weeks after discharge we had involvement from two sets of paramedics. She was lucid with the first set and was clear that she understood their course of treatment was to be taken to hospital but that she did not wish to do that. Both sets of paramedics were honest with us, not that we didn't know, about how dire things were in A&E and that it would not be a pleasant place for her.

She died 5 days later, the weekend just gone, at home. While I have a lot of regrets and trauma over the 24 hours before she died, I don't regret the decision against A&E at all.

Obviously the circumstances are different to your dad; mum was already palliative and we knew time was short, though perhaps not that short. Your choice to support your dad's decision is the right one and the brave one in many ways.