Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Ignoring Doctors advice

30 replies

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 20:23

My 91 year old dad had an ecg today - he is housebound but we got
him to doctors surgery today. The doctor has now reviewed it and thinks it looks worrying and wants him to go to A&E tonight by ambulance to get checked out. Dad is of sound mind and does not want to go. I am inclined to go along with this as we have spoken before about how he wants to stay at home with little intervention. He is aware that if he is having a heart attack it would be very very serious and likely fatal. He still prefers to stay at home. He is not in pain but is generally very frail. I have agreed that he does nothing tonight but will call an ambulance if he deteriorates now or going forward. He has a friend living with him who will call ambulance if needed. I live 30 miles away. Is this ok or should I more heavily persuade him to go?

OP posts:
Okwotnext · 11/11/2026 21:43

I really appreciate everyone’s comments. Thank you so much. He has spoken to another doc today who has advised there are things that can be done at home. We are having a telephone appointment to do a respect form early next week. Once the doctor was happy he fully understood the risks she said she could fully see why he didn’t want to go to hospital. I think there are some tough times ahead but dad is doing what he wants. Thanks all for your replies.

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/11/2026 21:57

A mid 80s neighbour of ours had a 2nd heart attack and was resuscitated. He told me that the after-effects were so painful (I suspect broken ribs) he wished they’d just let him die.
He did in fact die just a few months later anyway.

AnnaMagnani · 11/11/2026 22:02

I also think it's reasonable. I'm a palliative care doctor and if you have an elderly housebound patient, you should be making decisions according to what they want AND what is actually feasible for them to do.

Some patients will magically be able to attend hospital appointments or be very keen to go to hospital when they know what you are thinking, and others will be clearly able to tell you that even if the blood test show anaemia, they aren't well enough to go through the investigations suggested and think hospital sounds dreadful.

A referral to virtual ward would have made more sense as they could have done the ECG at home and made sure he was having what he needed at home.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · 11/11/2026 22:05

All the best to you and your family, @Okwotnext. Your dad sounds great, and he’s lucky to have lovely family members around him.

TheNewFinch · 12/11/2026 13:11

Okwotnext · 10/11/2026 20:23

My 91 year old dad had an ecg today - he is housebound but we got
him to doctors surgery today. The doctor has now reviewed it and thinks it looks worrying and wants him to go to A&E tonight by ambulance to get checked out. Dad is of sound mind and does not want to go. I am inclined to go along with this as we have spoken before about how he wants to stay at home with little intervention. He is aware that if he is having a heart attack it would be very very serious and likely fatal. He still prefers to stay at home. He is not in pain but is generally very frail. I have agreed that he does nothing tonight but will call an ambulance if he deteriorates now or going forward. He has a friend living with him who will call ambulance if needed. I live 30 miles away. Is this ok or should I more heavily persuade him to go?

That is fine and I guess you do not persuade him much to go, His friend is there so he would keep a check on him. Still for a safety purpose, you can keep asking for his health on call or maybe visit when passing by to know his health.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page