Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

What do you think of the Irish Transition Year?

38 replies

SoftIce · 27/10/2026 12:35

It is described here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Year

Basically, an optional year of electives, life skills, soft skills, work experience and no exams after Junior Cert (15). It was piloted in the 80s and then implemented nationwide in the 90s. In 2024, about 80% of pupils took it up. Those who do it tend to perform better in the Senior Leaving Cert - but that may just be due to increased maturity.

Ireland has a much lower proportion of NEETs - I wonder how much the Transition Year contributes to that. I think if it is done well, it has huge potential. I don't think it would work in England though - parents would probably consider it too much of a "doss" and people would look down on it. Or schools would use it to hot-house children for retakes or A-levels, which is not the idea.

Transition Year - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Year

OP posts:
Rondayvu · 27/10/2026 12:53

It is a fantastic year for them. Mine got so much out of it between experiences and making new friends, also they get the extra year before senior cycle and exams etc to emotionally mature which I found invaluable here. Brilliant year all round and just wish to christ it was an option when I was in secondary. I do not understand not letting your child have that opportunity.

Rondayvu · 27/10/2026 12:58

Oh and it is not a 'doss' year either as they still sit their core subjects along with learning other things for example mine got a year of Japanese, did shorter courses in the likes of volcanology, archaelogy and loads more. They did two lots of work experience, drivers training, barista training - I cannot even think of half the things and also they went on a foreign trip for 4 days too.

FlatCatYellowMat · 27/10/2026 13:10

My eldest just finished his - at his school they do a full lesson load plus TY stuff - trips, extra-curriculars like learning to use a coffee machine or making a Bodrán, dancing, chicken-keeping, forensics - goodness knows what else.

I do like the little break between Junior cert and leaving cert instead of just going straight from one to the next - and the year of growing up was well worth it. A bit like a gap year, but before you decide your leaving cert subjects.

TeenToTwenties · 27/10/2026 13:12

Sounds excellent

elgreco · 27/10/2026 13:17

It can be expensive though. Having said that, if well organised, it can be a great year. They do a huge variety of activities and it is nice following the JC to not have to worry about exams.

Weewah · 27/10/2026 13:17

The Irish culture surrounding education is very different to the English equivalent, though — DS was born in England and attended primary there for several years before we moved to Ireland where he finished primary — he’s currently in Junior Cert. There’s a lot less anxiety about ‘good schools’, no real equivalent to OFSTED, and a general acceptance that most schools do a pretty good job. DS will definitely do TY, though it’s a no-brainer because, having started school in the UK, he’s much younger than almost everyone else in his year.

Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhh · 27/10/2026 13:17

I really wish they had it in my secondary school when I was growing up in Ireland. I started university at 16 and was far too young. Another year would have been hugely beneficial to me.

turkeyboots · 27/10/2026 13:17

It's a good year for most. But it doesn't often suit ND kids, the lack of structure is hard on them. It's a great opportunity to grow up a bit before the hard work of the Leaving Cert though.
But, I doubt it has anything to do with school leaving rates. The bigger driver will be that the only exam that matters is the Leaving Cert, so leaving before then means you are largely unemployable. And there are few alternatives like Btechs or NVQs here, so clawing your way through the leaving cert is, and has been for decades, the only way forward.

Rondayvu · 27/10/2026 13:19

elgreco · 27/10/2026 13:17

It can be expensive though. Having said that, if well organised, it can be a great year. They do a huge variety of activities and it is nice following the JC to not have to worry about exams.

Biggest expense was the foreign trip which was around 700euro I think but that is completely optional. I am sure it cost me no more than 400 euro for the year and that included all the other trips and days out etc.

BootstrapTime · 27/10/2026 13:29

I think it's a brilliant year. I was the first year to do it and got to do lots of things I wouldn't have had access to otherwise. Most importantly it makes you a year older for the Leaving and for starting college. They can try lots of subjects before chosing them for the Leaving too which is a benefit. I find a lot of my foreign colleagues suspect it is a waste of time and move their kids to the private Leaving Cert colleges to do 5th year straight away which I think is a mistake. I have also heard of ND kids finding the lack of structure overwhelming although I suspect my kid will love it for the novelty. I think the Irish system does a good job of a rounded education and I think TY really supports that.

Weewah · 27/10/2026 13:30

turkeyboots · 27/10/2026 13:17

It's a good year for most. But it doesn't often suit ND kids, the lack of structure is hard on them. It's a great opportunity to grow up a bit before the hard work of the Leaving Cert though.
But, I doubt it has anything to do with school leaving rates. The bigger driver will be that the only exam that matters is the Leaving Cert, so leaving before then means you are largely unemployable. And there are few alternatives like Btechs or NVQs here, so clawing your way through the leaving cert is, and has been for decades, the only way forward.

Edited

Yes to your final point.

cantalach · 27/10/2026 14:05

My son is doing it now and it has been fantastic so far. He is the type of child to join things though and is throwing himself into everything- he has signed up for a musical, sports committee, has had an outdoor education centre weekend which he loved , barista and first aid training, and loads of other workshops and events - all in the first half of this term. I can see him maturing as a result and being less dependent on what ‘the lads’ are doing.

I could also wax lyrical about the leaving certificate applied which my DD did. It was fantastic for a child who is not academic but still capable of third level. And takes that massive end of year scam pressure away from them. There are so many routes to college nowadays with tertiary degrees and plc access it’s not all dependent on that one be all or end all exam.

Rondayvu · 27/10/2026 14:15

Yes there are far more avenues now than ever and I only heard about the LCA a few years ago and it is a fantastic opportunity for those who as you say are not all that academic. Very impressed with our education system in Ireland I have to say and it is what has kept me here at least till we have gone through college.

Stowickthevast · 27/10/2026 20:34

It sounds amazing. I wish we had similar in the UK.

ThePM · 28/10/2026 06:50

It is amazing, I see it in my nephews and nieces. A nephews classmate spent a month in the same high school as his cousin abroad and had a great time.

SoftIce · 28/10/2026 07:08

Thanks for the testimonies. It really sounds amazinng.

Just to clarify: NEET = Not in education or training. It's not about school graduation rates, it's what they do afterwards. In England, 16% of 18-24 year olds are NEET, in Ireland only 8.8%. There are probably a lot of reasons for the difference but I think the TY probably contributes, the way it can focus on life skills, soft skills, volunteering and work experience at a crucial age. I think that's really beneficial for all pupils but perhaps particularly for those who have trouble with leaving their comfort zone.

I, too, wish it existed in England, but I'm very cynical about how it would work here. I wish it had also been established here in the 80s/90s, before academic snobbery really took hold. Now the snobbery is so entrenched that it probably wouldn't get off the ground.

OP posts:
SoftIce · 28/10/2026 09:07

(Sorry, NEET = Not in Education, Employment or Training)

OP posts:
Truinio · 28/10/2026 09:15

Very common in Denmark too to take a year off before gymnasium (high school). Most kids will spend this year in a residential programme doing sports or music or outdoor activities but it’s not compulsory.

Fridaysgirl17 · 28/10/2026 09:30

It's a great thing to have in our secondary schools,kids seem to thrive off it & it's a great break between junior cert straight into leaving cert,I personal didn't do it but I was older than my class due to repeating a year in primary as I had a bad accident & was off for an extended period of time,so I felt it wasn't for me but I do know a boy that it was fantastic for,he lost his mother extremely suddenly & in a traumatic way early in the school year & he was doing transition year so he had that year to process through it before having to think about exams etc,he is in his leaving cert year now & is focused, visiting colleges etc,that time really helped him & honestly I think it will help him achieve what he truly deserves in his exams.

Gealach · 28/10/2026 09:32

Transition year is great. A downside is that it can be very expensive for parents and consequently some kids may feel left out of things. But I think it offers well rounded educational opportunities, breathing space to decide priorities and means they are older doing the LC (final exams)

My Indian neighbour was absolutely horrified that his DD would be jollying about for a year but he has been pleasantly surprised by the advantages.

But I think less NEETs is more about schools with disadvantaged kids getting extra funding, having an alternative leaving cert that is more practical and schools successfully keeping kids in school. There is also a very high number of people going on to third level.

SoftIce · 28/10/2026 11:20

@Truinio What age is that? It sounds great! I know Norway has a year at "folk high school" after school (I think for 18-19 year olds?) which sounds quite fun too, though I think it is structured differently.

@Gealach Yes, there are probably many influences. Someone mentioned the LCA above, that sounds very interesting too. It seems to have one day a week of work experience (if the example timetable I saw is representative), which is spectacular. How do they source the work experience? Are employers more willing to engage with this? I know that in England, they often can't source the work experience placements for T-levels.

OP posts:
Rondayvu · 28/10/2026 11:39

I am confused as to why people are saying TY is expensive as aside from a foreign trip which is optional the rest of the year is included in the fees which are only around 400 euro for the whole year. You are saving on other expenses as it is not a full on academic year so I think it is fairly reasonable. Now mine did do the foreign trips but some didnt and nobody batted an eyelid.

Saltstrawberry · 28/10/2026 14:28

Rondayvu · 28/10/2026 11:39

I am confused as to why people are saying TY is expensive as aside from a foreign trip which is optional the rest of the year is included in the fees which are only around 400 euro for the whole year. You are saving on other expenses as it is not a full on academic year so I think it is fairly reasonable. Now mine did do the foreign trips but some didnt and nobody batted an eyelid.

What other expenses do you save on though?
Paying €400 upfront is difficult for lots of people.

Gealach · 28/10/2026 14:38

It depends on the school with the expenses: They are optional but some schools will offer more particularly if they have an affluent base (but of course not every child in the school will be affluent)

DramaAlpaca · 28/10/2026 14:49

My three DC all did transition year and benefited from the extra year of gaining maturity. I think what they get out of it very much depends on the school though; some schools really half-arse it and the students end up not doing an awful lot, whereas it can be a brilliant year if planned and funded properly.

I disagree with the Leaving Certificate being the be-all and end-all though. PLC (post leaving certificate) courses are another route into university if the LC doesn't go as well as expected, and they prepare young people really well for what is expected of them at university.