Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

What do you think of the Irish Transition Year?

38 replies

SoftIce · 27/10/2026 12:35

It is described here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Year

Basically, an optional year of electives, life skills, soft skills, work experience and no exams after Junior Cert (15). It was piloted in the 80s and then implemented nationwide in the 90s. In 2024, about 80% of pupils took it up. Those who do it tend to perform better in the Senior Leaving Cert - but that may just be due to increased maturity.

Ireland has a much lower proportion of NEETs - I wonder how much the Transition Year contributes to that. I think if it is done well, it has huge potential. I don't think it would work in England though - parents would probably consider it too much of a "doss" and people would look down on it. Or schools would use it to hot-house children for retakes or A-levels, which is not the idea.

Transition Year - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Year

OP posts:
elgreco · 28/10/2026 16:45

Re thd expense: If your kid goes to a private school, there are more trips and they get more extravagant. They dont have to go on them but if they don't go on any they can feel left out.
Irish private schools are relatively cheap compared to the uk so you dont need to be absolutely loaded to go there and therefore there will be some parents who understandably baulk at paying for a year of not really learning.

Rondayvu · 28/10/2026 17:33

Saltstrawberry · 28/10/2026 14:28

What other expenses do you save on though?
Paying €400 upfront is difficult for lots of people.

It was not really up front it was in stages to be paid by certain dates but you are saving on all school stationery and paying for the school locker as their bags are far emptier etc. I just found TY somehow cheaper than other normal years.

Rondayvu · 28/10/2026 17:35

elgreco · 28/10/2026 16:45

Re thd expense: If your kid goes to a private school, there are more trips and they get more extravagant. They dont have to go on them but if they don't go on any they can feel left out.
Irish private schools are relatively cheap compared to the uk so you dont need to be absolutely loaded to go there and therefore there will be some parents who understandably baulk at paying for a year of not really learning.

True I think the nearest private to us is about 4k a year which is little compared to the UK costs for private schooling but it is not only private schools that do TY but I do see that some schools seem to do it better than others. Ours was that amazing I wanted to go back to school myself!

Saltstrawberry · 28/10/2026 17:43

Rondayvu · 28/10/2026 17:33

It was not really up front it was in stages to be paid by certain dates but you are saving on all school stationery and paying for the school locker as their bags are far emptier etc. I just found TY somehow cheaper than other normal years.

Okay, but most stationery is provided free by the school now and lockers are about €20.

We had the option of a single payment or two payments. I found the year more expensive tbh, especially factoring in transport to work experience and also some extra clothes for work experience (their usual sportswear wasn’t suitable). There’s also a transition year ball in many schools, though of course it’s optional. Mine weren’t interested in that but some kids might be and it’s a bit more financial pressure on parents.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 28/10/2026 17:47

I think the way TY is organised is one of the biggest differences between schools and one of the key elements to consider when choosing a school. Ds1's school covered 30% of the LC curriculum. I'm pretty sure they are not allowed do that, but apparently many more academic schools do. It probably takes a lot of pressure off 5th year (the second last school year, and the 1st of 2 leaving cycle years) but kind of misses the point. The worst part was for admin reasons they had to choose their LC subjects before TY, before junior cert results and actuallly before they even sat the JC which i thought was ludicrous. There was an option of change later though. Also, because they tried to cover curriculum the classes were organised by subject choice and ability, so they were essentially segregated academically. While this is important for exam cycles i really objected to doing it for TY. They should be opening their minds and mixing with different people with different abilites. They did a lot of fun activities too and the work experience was very good for him. They have 2 work placements and one commmunity one, I thought this was excellent. My friends kid was in the other local boys school and they did F all, endless empty periods. He started not going in a few times a week and was just doing nothing at home, she said it was same difference so on balance my DS experience was much better and DS2 goes there now too. So like most things it's a brilliant idea in principle but only when applied as it is intended.

Deadringer · 28/10/2026 18:16

I think its great, all of my dc did ty, and benefited from it

Unebellejournee · 28/10/2026 21:15

DramaAlpaca · 28/10/2026 14:49

My three DC all did transition year and benefited from the extra year of gaining maturity. I think what they get out of it very much depends on the school though; some schools really half-arse it and the students end up not doing an awful lot, whereas it can be a brilliant year if planned and funded properly.

I disagree with the Leaving Certificate being the be-all and end-all though. PLC (post leaving certificate) courses are another route into university if the LC doesn't go as well as expected, and they prepare young people really well for what is expected of them at university.

I work in education and I’d agree with this.

AshCullen1894 · 28/10/2026 21:30

My son loved it and he really thrived as well. Happy Days 🎉

SomersetBrie · 28/10/2026 21:41

I did TY in the 80s!
It was not as full on as it is now, we did some work experience, a few extra sports and a few extra day trips but mainly we made a start on the leaving cert curriculum early, which was more important to me as I needed all that time to get the points I needed for university. University was points only, it didn't matter what other personal attributes you had or interests developed.

It did mean I was 18 when I got to university, whereas my new cohort who didn't have TY, quite a lot of them were 17 (too young for the bar!).

I'm in the UK now and DC 17 will be finishing school this year and he can't wait. My friend's daughter in Ireland is a couple of months older than him and has an extra year and will be 19 before she even sits her LC.
If you love school, which she does, it's great.
If you hate it, as mine does, I can't imagine making him stay there.

turkeyboots · 29/10/2026 13:46

Kids also start school later here, and doing TY means like PP says, many DC are 18 or 19 as they sit final school exams. Add in a standard 4 year degree (which can go to 5 if you do the PLC route) and often DC are 22 or 23 as they finish college. As the vast majority stay in school to 18 and go to third level, that keeps the NEET levels low.
Also as a country with next to no industrial history, education has long been valued as a way out - either out of poverty or being a more valuable emigration prospect. Its a very different background to the UK.

MargaretThursday · 29/10/2026 18:21

Saltstrawberry · 28/10/2026 14:28

What other expenses do you save on though?
Paying €400 upfront is difficult for lots of people.

Agree. And then if you've twins that's 800...

We'd have struggled finding that for dd1. We'd probably have been okay for the other two, but it certainly wouldn't have been a easy "do without question".

And the problem with that sort of thing is that often it's the people who really need it, who can't afford it - there may also be a self selection, so those who are likely to do better on the senior leaving cert are more likely to do/be able to afford the year. So it then gives it a false raise in ability, which means those who want to do better feel they have to do it...

Rondayvu · 29/10/2026 21:13

Interesting comments. I parent solo and it was just always in my mind I wanted kids to do TY as I see it as fantastic opportunity so I just forfeited a few things like a family holiday that year instead as dc were then going on the foreign trip too but I guess this was my aspiration and actually a huge factor when applying for the school they go to as lots where we are do a lottery system for TY but the one they got into it is offered as standard. Still delighted I was able to give them the opportunity though as it has definitely been invaluable here.

Weewah · 29/10/2026 22:09

MargaretThursday · 29/10/2026 18:21

Agree. And then if you've twins that's 800...

We'd have struggled finding that for dd1. We'd probably have been okay for the other two, but it certainly wouldn't have been a easy "do without question".

And the problem with that sort of thing is that often it's the people who really need it, who can't afford it - there may also be a self selection, so those who are likely to do better on the senior leaving cert are more likely to do/be able to afford the year. So it then gives it a false raise in ability, which means those who want to do better feel they have to do it...

DS will be doing TY next year. We’re pretty stretched at the moment, but I will take on some extra work to fund it. I funded his school trip this year by selling stuff on Vinted. It was a very effortless €500. I know DS’s school also has some funding available if needed.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page