Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

How can I help my Year 10 daughter engage with homework / revision

77 replies

Divebar2021 · 20/09/2026 22:11

Gosh I don’t even know how to describe this. My DD14 is at a pretty academic girls school - it’s non selective but punches above its weight as far as exam success goes. MyDD was always middle of the bunch at primary school and although settled well at this school has never really shone academically. Her teachers all seem to like her but her results are average to below average. She had a phase of school refusal and anxieties about school which they were responsive to and she sees someone from the pastoral team once a week to discuss her issues. ( things have been much better )
At the moment we are having battles to get her to do homework. She would rather lie around on her phone so as we are now in year 10 I have become more directive. She has a composition to write for English and I’m at a loss to know how to move her forward from her “stuck” position of “ i don’t know what to write”. She was supposed to have done a plan and she has a broad idea of a story but no actually clue what happens. I told her to get on and she spent 40 minutes doing hair and make up. Gave her a bit of a talking to and left her to it for a hour or so and when I came back she’d done nothing. She doesn’t know what to write. I then sat with her for 20 minutes to brainstorm some ideas and did a kind of mind map of prompts but she wasn’t taking it seriously so I left her to it. I find it upsetting that she sees my attempts to help as a joke. After this she sat at her desk for 2 hours and produced 2 sentences. The mind map was in front of her… she knows how to string a sentence together and she’s very eloquent. I’ve told her the sentences can be rubbish but just write something and it can be edited. She goes into a spiral and becomes very passive. Both DH and I have frustration that she won’t be proactive and ask for help but will sit there. What the hell do I do? She’s not stupid but she’s failing English and maths. I’m definitely not a helicopter parent but I feel if I do not step up she is going to bomb her GCSEs. ( she had a tutor for maths last year and still failed. ) Am I missing something.

OP posts:
concertinacornflake · 21/09/2026 20:23

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 19:07

AI isn't a perfect answer but neither is a child spending hours staring into space achieving nothing. AI may help kick start her to actually do something.

It really won't.

People are absolutely deluded about AI. It's preventing kids learning more than it's helping.

concertinacornflake · 21/09/2026 20:26

XelaM · 21/09/2026 10:39

If you were on the Y11 thread of those kids who just finished their GCSEs you would know that some English teachers actually advise to use AI to help pre-prep stories etc.

GCSE exams are about working smart and being able to answer questions to the exact specification. It's not about becoming a Pulitzer prize winner.

Edited

Just because some teachers advise it doesn't make it a good idea or a genuine help.

EatenTooMuchChocolateAgain · 21/09/2026 20:41

Can you give her some sentence starter prompts? Or help her plan each paragraph? Does she respond to an incentive to crack on like let’s go out for a hot chocolate at 2pm, you’ve got 90mins to get X amount done beforehand? Does she work alongside a friend better? Can you sit down to do some tedious paperwork yourself alongside her? Is she typing or writing? Typing she can edit what she’s done to remove some of the anxiety?
If you think it’s purely laziness / phone addiction and not unmet support needs then you could tell her how frustrating older teens find it in college having to do retakes and not being able to get onto the college courses they want if they don’t pass GCSE maths and English?

Divinedownload · 21/09/2026 20:49

I don’t think saying her sentences are rubbish would help. She’s got a case of rabbit in the headlights. You can’t help her. Just hire some tutors and the rest is up to her.

I don’t help mine. It’s on them. My son passed seven this year, mainly grade 4 and 5s. My DD is in year 10 and has a maths tutor. She seems pretty motivated despite not being as academic as many of her friends.

It’s okay to be average in my house.

theonlygirl · 21/09/2026 21:05

I would try engaging with her on what she wants to do post 16 and take her now, in year 10, to some college open days (they are coming up soon) for more vocational options that might interest her. Then she can understand what GCSEs she might need to go down those paths. She goes to a very academic school where good scores will be praised and valued, and she has friends she perceives as being cleverer. Not much fun if its more of a struggle for her. Sounds to me like she has shut down and needs to see what life after school looks like. She will hopefully understand that whatever she wants to do she has to get maths and English, but it doesn't have to be a 7 - 9. Maybe if she knows there's a path for her where a 5 gets her where she wants to go, everything will seem more doable. I think it helps for some kids to see school as just a phase in their life to get through so they can get onto the good stuff.

Hoork · 21/09/2026 21:15

This won’t be a major help but maybe a small step? Could you get her some
books? My DD hated to read for many years but I just kept buying her books (that she would read one chapter of and decide she didn’t like) and one day she found a book she liked and now shes a avid reader who costs me a fortune in books! She was around your DDs age. Some TV shows like The Stranger Things have books if that might interest her? It might help her with English.

Stopsnowing · 22/09/2026 21:56

XelaM · 21/09/2026 06:56

AI is used everywhere and by the vast majority of people. It would make life easier for her to get some ideas from AI, which she should rephrase of course. What a waste of time to battle and argue with her for hours over something that she could have done with the help of AI. Even many English teachers tell kids to engage AI for help. Just don't copy and paste it word for word.

Edited

How is this going to help prepare for exams?

MaeshoweDragon · 23/09/2026 07:43

Stopsnowing · 22/09/2026 21:56

How is this going to help prepare for exams?

For English, you use AI well before exams to create your barebones story. You make it one that fits with most of the past papers themes. You learn the keypoints of your tale and regurgitate it at every essay occasion. When you have a full timetable and hate essay subjects, it has always been a tactic to have a story in the bank as it were.

Onetimecode · 23/09/2026 08:03

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 07:31

This should be about her, not you. You need to do whatever it takes to get her motivated. So far what you have done hadn’t worked so you need to stop nagging and stressing and give her some different advice, different ideas, different solutions.

You do realise that is exactly why OP started this thread?

Badbadbunny · 23/09/2026 11:38

Onetimecode · 23/09/2026 08:03

You do realise that is exactly why OP started this thread?

Yes, but her subsequent replies have given the vibe that it's how she feels, etc., rather than the daughter.

aaahshoot · 23/09/2026 11:50

Lots of tuition companies are giving away free resources as a marketing technique and I have picked up a few bits to help my Y11 daughter. For English we got an English Sentence starters guide which might be the kind of thing your girl could use when stuck?

CostcoFanofThree · 23/09/2026 15:45

Yes 15 is a tricky age and stage. Book an appointment with an educational psychologist not a tutor.
Sounds like ADD (the non physically hyper ADHD).

Divebar2021 · 24/09/2026 14:30

aaahshoot · 23/09/2026 11:50

Lots of tuition companies are giving away free resources as a marketing technique and I have picked up a few bits to help my Y11 daughter. For English we got an English Sentence starters guide which might be the kind of thing your girl could use when stuck?

Thank you for this. This sounds useful.

OP posts:
aaahshoot · 24/09/2026 14:39

Divebar2021 · 24/09/2026 14:30

Thank you for this. This sounds useful.

if you are on Facebook have a look at e-learn English with Paul x

Sunbringer · 24/09/2026 16:51

You Can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

For creative writing tell her to do stream of consciousness for a bit. Literally write whatever pops in her head, just to get going, she’s not going to submit it, also first drafts don’t have to be perfect they can just be an attempt at anything.

Tell her you can go get a Starbucks if she just writes one out as a practice. Doesn’t have to be any good.

HighburyHope · 24/09/2026 21:42

A simple thing that helped my ADHD girl with task paralysis was what is sometimes called body doubling. It simply means being present in the room. She would achieve nothing shut away in her own room, so I would get her to bring her things into the kitchen and sit at one end of the long table while I worked or read or cooked or tidied. Not looming over her, but just quietly there.

trylearnrepeat · 29/09/2026 17:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Rocknrollstar · 29/09/2026 18:04

XelaM · 21/09/2026 06:56

AI is used everywhere and by the vast majority of people. It would make life easier for her to get some ideas from AI, which she should rephrase of course. What a waste of time to battle and argue with her for hours over something that she could have done with the help of AI. Even many English teachers tell kids to engage AI for help. Just don't copy and paste it word for word.

Edited

And how will she answer an exam question?

XelaM · 29/09/2026 18:16

Rocknrollstar · 29/09/2026 18:04

And how will she answer an exam question?

Use your imagination 🤷‍♀️

Nothing wrong with going into an exam with already prepared phrases/stories learned by heart and then adapted to the question.

Badbadbunny · 29/09/2026 19:06

Rocknrollstar · 29/09/2026 18:04

And how will she answer an exam question?

With AI "jump starting" her imagination and giving her some ideas.

No different to a parent helping with/dictating stories/essays etc. It's what we did with our son. What my parents did with me. My DS was hopeless in years 7 and 8 so we virtually had to dictate and/or plan essays/stories for him. As the terms passed, he did more and more himself and needed less and less help from us, and eventually got grades 9 in both Eng Lit and Eng Lang for GCSE and also grade 9's for Geography and History (heavy in essays and lengthy written answers).

I was the same. I remember my brother dictating creative writing stories to me and my mother dictating business letters (she was a secretary) for my English at secondary in the 70s! I ended up with grade Bs at both O level and A level in English.

The more you do, the easier it gets, the more ideas you pick up, and as others have posted, lots of people have a "bank" of pre-written stories which they tweak to fit in with the exam question for creative writing. For essays/long written answers, it's all about creating a plan, thinking of intro and conclusion, etc., which again is something you can practice. If the parent can't help, then AI is an exceptionally good alternative.

Badbadbunny · 29/09/2026 19:08

XelaM · 29/09/2026 18:16

Use your imagination 🤷‍♀️

Nothing wrong with going into an exam with already prepared phrases/stories learned by heart and then adapted to the question.

I agree, and you don't even have to learn them by heart. Just having the ideas and a rough plan will often do. It's all about getting over the initial inertia (which the OP's daughter suffers from) - once you start, the momentum builds up.

BestZebbie · 02/10/2026 13:19

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 08:07

“School” simply doesn’t work for some kids so she needs to find ways to get through it as best she can. It’s hard for some parents and even teachers to understand if they were successful and enjoyed their own school years. Coping strategies are needed rather than just whingeing at them to just do it.

I remember hating English as I had no imagination and couldn’t write creative writing or poems. No amount of telling me to do it worked - obviously it wouldn’t, it was like telling a fish to climb a tree. What DID work was a different teacher telling me to plan just one generic story, he told me how to do it, told me to choose my own subject and get back to him with the plan of the core basic plot, when I was ready, whether that was a day, week or month. With the pressure off, and freedom to choose my own subject, I did it that same evening and took the plan in the next day! Then he told me to pad out the plan - turn bullet points into sentences. Again, done that evening for the next day. Then he said put the sentences together into paragraphs and add more detail, ie the senses and descriptives. I went home and finished the story that night! I was so pleased with myself. The key had been no pressure, freedom to write about what I wanted to, etc. He then gave me the best advice ever, which I passed to my son - he told me how to use that same story line for virtually any story as in exams they’re usually very open ended questions for creative writing stories, ie a story about a city at night or something like it must end with “if I knew then what I know know I wouldn’t have done it” - he gave me some pointers as to how to use the introduction and conclusion to wrap around my own story so I could reuse the bare bones of it to answer virtually any question. My confidence went through the roof! Yes, it was a “fudge” but what worked was that it was a coping strategy. It gave me confidence in myself and it opened the floodgates to other writing, just knowing I had a back up plan, but also knowing how to tweak it rather than obsessing about the detail of the question asked and getting bogged down.

The “learn one story and customise it” approach really works - I created and essentially memorised a very dramatic short story/piece of descriptive writing (that was ripped off “the diary of Anne Frank” in as much as it was about hiding while people were searching close by for me) and used it for everything requiring creative writing from Year 9 onwards. Because I had carefully included some pre-prepared stock lines which had the types of SPAG they had to see to get the higher marks, it always got an A and it required very little thought to reproduce by the time I was writing it for the fifth or sixth time in my GCSE exam.

Chinchu · 16/10/2026 13:37

Divebar2021 · 20/09/2026 22:11

Gosh I don’t even know how to describe this. My DD14 is at a pretty academic girls school - it’s non selective but punches above its weight as far as exam success goes. MyDD was always middle of the bunch at primary school and although settled well at this school has never really shone academically. Her teachers all seem to like her but her results are average to below average. She had a phase of school refusal and anxieties about school which they were responsive to and she sees someone from the pastoral team once a week to discuss her issues. ( things have been much better )
At the moment we are having battles to get her to do homework. She would rather lie around on her phone so as we are now in year 10 I have become more directive. She has a composition to write for English and I’m at a loss to know how to move her forward from her “stuck” position of “ i don’t know what to write”. She was supposed to have done a plan and she has a broad idea of a story but no actually clue what happens. I told her to get on and she spent 40 minutes doing hair and make up. Gave her a bit of a talking to and left her to it for a hour or so and when I came back she’d done nothing. She doesn’t know what to write. I then sat with her for 20 minutes to brainstorm some ideas and did a kind of mind map of prompts but she wasn’t taking it seriously so I left her to it. I find it upsetting that she sees my attempts to help as a joke. After this she sat at her desk for 2 hours and produced 2 sentences. The mind map was in front of her… she knows how to string a sentence together and she’s very eloquent. I’ve told her the sentences can be rubbish but just write something and it can be edited. She goes into a spiral and becomes very passive. Both DH and I have frustration that she won’t be proactive and ask for help but will sit there. What the hell do I do? She’s not stupid but she’s failing English and maths. I’m definitely not a helicopter parent but I feel if I do not step up she is going to bomb her GCSEs. ( she had a tutor for maths last year and still failed. ) Am I missing something.

Could you make the first step much smaller: have her describe one moment in the story aloud, then write one sentence from what she said? I’d also ask her teacher where they see the difficulty: understanding the task, generating ideas, or getting those ideas onto the page.

Animatic · 21/10/2026 12:46

OP, my son is in year5 but he also gets stuck and his hadwriting is terrible, and impending his writing. We separate creative writing from sort of writing with hand, if it makes sense. He uses voice to text softwear for creative writing and then edits grammar, punctuation, etc. It helped a lot and school fully supports this approach.

TheDevilWears · 21/10/2026 12:53

I’ve pretty much always Home Educated, so am in a somewhat different boat. Both my DDs (18 & 16) are bright, articulate, very emotionally intelligent but struggled academically. Both were diagnosed with ASD as teenagers (no surprises and both high functioning). I have used this book for maths alongside the regular GCSE texts. A complete game changer! They both went from hating and refusing maths to being excited about it. It explains a lot about maths anxiety, dyscalculia, different learning styles . With English, I encouraged online journaling about their lives for them to get used to writing and description about things they enjoy and know etc. and we worked from there …
My eldest DD did fine in her GCSEs and is at college now studying for her A Levels.

I think gentle encouragement and small goals work best.

How can I help my Year 10 daughter engage with homework / revision